Top 10 Scariest Buffy the Vampire Slayer Episodes Season 1-4

Please don't add any episodes from season 5 and above. there for a separate list!
-Thank you

The Top Ten

1 Hush

2 Killed by Death

3 Inca Mummy Girl

4 The Puppet Show

5 Teacher's Pet

6 Nightmares

7 The Dark Age

8 The Wish

9 The Prom

10 Restless

The Contenders

11 Listening to Fear

BAdd New Item