Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas

These are creepypastas that scared me the most. Its almost Halloween so lets bring some nightmares out.

The Top Ten

1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

The scariest thing about this creepy pasta is that guy's face! I mean, just look at it. That is ugly. Uh-oh, he's here! Aah. *Blood Splatter*. - MasterBeef

This Creepypasta isn't the least bit scary. It was actually pretty damn boring and painful to read. I don't see why he's so popular, so beloved, so commonly known, and well received within this fandom; he's totally and utterly terrible. Most overrated creepypasta ever. - RandomCommenter

Yeah this is creepy

Yep 100%. This guy is number 1

2 The Russian Sleep Experiment

This was the first creepypasta I EVER read! Talk about getting off to a strong start. It's like the first time I had seafood was in Maine and it makes seafood everywhere else seem subpar...It's the same thing for creepypastas. This one turned me into a creepypasta junkie and I've never stopped chasing that first high.
From the idea, the imagery, the symbolism, and the incredible plot, this isn't just creepypasta at it's best but WRITING at it's best.
There IS a short film that can be found on youtube that, while nowhere near as effective, gives a glimpse into how well this story could work as a film. By developing the character of the prisoners, their transformation into inhuman monsters has even more weight. This could be a grand slam of a horror film in the right hands

This one was so scary I didn't want to go to bed.
Everyone reading this comment, go read this creepypasta NOW! - RosalinaX

Definitely the scariest I've read

This should definitely be a movie (and a good one). - CaptainDrama

3 BEN Drowned

This creepy version of Link is not creepy at all I was not scared of it when I was in second grade

I remembered this made me paranoid for a week. I was literally scared to be alone even if the sun is out.

Favorite creepypasta can be scary to me
God that statue though

It's good, but not really scary. More like creepy. - RosalinaX

4 Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Imagine a tall figure stalking you and your friends and then dragging you away and eating you alive with his disposable mouth.

Slendermens daughter has no eyes so how can you say him and his daughter are not creepy

His name sounds like a fitness program. - RoseWeasley

How is this below Jeff the person with no brain!? Unlike most Creepypastas, this one actually scared the hell out of me! looking at the picture, I think I'm gonna have nightmares tonight!

5 Squidward's Suicide

When I first saw him it always gave me memories when I watched Nickleodeon

This is a creepy DUMB (yea I said it) lost episode from Spongebob Squarepants, And all lf my childhood I LOVED SPONGEBOB. When the creepypasta came put when I was 10 I was heartbroken, Terrified, and sad.

The photo is scary. - RosalinaX

Like it, but not scary. - Gametoon

6 1999

This is my new favorite creepypasta. Amazing story, extremely well written, so realistic, it all fits together to create the perfect creepypasta. Very long, but very worth it! If the length intimidates you, don't let it! It' amazing! 10/10.

This is creepy, but also amazing at the same time. Read it. - Gametoon

Realistic, super creepy, and very long. If you have the time, read it. - RosalinaX

Squidward suicide is nothing comparing to this.

7 Smile Dog "Smile Dog" is a story about a cursed image file. The image shows a large German Shepard or Husky dog that is smiling.

Lets find some your afraid of-Smile dod

CUTE lol is is the cutest husky I've seen... even the smile

A creepy ass pic of him is my desktop wallpaper - Creepypastafan119

I agree with this one except for the picture. Like really, what was it? - Gametoon

8 Sonic.exe

Why is he only #8? He should be above slenderman. - Kerbiman123

Nah, this is just one big clichefest. Blood, gore, satanism, all the works. The rom hack is pretty cool, though. - Gametoon

Why is this on here? Cliche after cliche after cliche with ridiculous and stupid moments and an idiotic story and main character.

This is understand creepypasta.

9 Suicide Mouse

This episode is very disturbing. I heard about this from my friend. I did not watch this, so I will tell you what my friend saw. Mickey Mouse walks across a street for 2-3 minutes. Then the screen goes black for 2 minutes, and you hear a woman screaming. And then Mickey walks across the street again, but it's a bit longer, and Mickey's face slowly molds into a psychotic smile, that takes up 2/5 of his face, larger than I could ever make on my own face, and his face is covered in scratches. This goes on for a while, then he trips over "something" and he molds into a "skeleton demon" but still keeps the scratched up face, but now has horns. This goes on for another while, then the screen goes black again, and the woman screams again for 2-3 minutes, before the scratched up face appears on the screen, because the episode is done. Very disturbing

They are scary as crap

The video was disturbing as hell. - Limeyy

The video is really disturbing. - RosalinaX

10 Ronald McDonald House

Holy hell. This was definitely the scariest one yet. Really well written too. I was seriously hoping he got out of there alive.

I have never been shaking from a creepypasta since I first read the Red Mist. This was seriously the most messed up and sickening story ever and is making me seriously want to stop reading creepypasta as a whole

This story is so unnatural and unsettling in every single way. It combines the elements of being alone, darkness, insanity, clowns, and gore. It deserves to be higher on this list.

This is by far the scariest creepypasta I have read. It combines; fear of the unknown, suspense, clowns, being trapped, and gore all into one very well written story. It should at least be in the top 5. - filmfan

The Contenders

11 Abandoned by Disney

Five Nights at Treasure Island Vibes. - Tgamez

This was TERRIFYING. Oh my gosh... The nightmares of that costume. And that Mickey Mouse voice, "Hey, wanna see my head come off? " OH my gosh.

It scares the poop out of me

I actually had a nightmare after reading this story - marynamaru

12 Lavender Town Syndrome

This pasta is actually pretty creepy. It makes it sound so real and the whole thing was sad too. It made me glad that Pokemon Blue version was the first game I ever played, not Red/Green! I recommend this pasta to any Pokemon lovers out there, definitely a good read and not too scary.

Pokemon can be scary and suicide making. Well that's it. If I'm missing something please add it on here. Well bye and good luck sleeping tonight after reading these Creepypastas. And happy halloween.

Yea this one is pretty creepy I will say but I don't know I have never actually heard the Lavender Town theme so I can't judge it much.

Haha, this is my favorite, no offense but Sonic.exe sucks laugh out loud - MoldySock

13 Funnymouth

I find this story creepy! It's definitely in my top tens.

Oh my gosh! I am still paranoid to look in the mirror to see my face look similar! - Daviddv0601

I really wish I never read it and I'm still getting over my nightmares

1 of the best I've read

14 Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv

The backstory behind this video is mind numbingly disturbing!

I've seen a picture of the original guy. It's fake, don't worry. A visitor here said they watched the whole thing, and that visitor didn't take eyeballs out. You're safe. - TeamRocket747

I hope you know that is not the full video

He was identified but I forgot his name

15 Annabelle the Doll

This isn't even a creepypasta it's a movie based in the conjuring universe - Creepypastafan119

What makes the movie scary...ITS BASED ON A TRUE STORY!

The creepypasta is real

Just watched the movie. I found it disappointing. It was too much like chucky the doll. A possess doll tries to kill a family and so on.

16 The Rake

First I see rake I'm like get this man outta here

Must be higher

Scarier then Suicide Mouse and Ben Drowned. - RosalinaX

In my opinion, The Rake is probably the scariest. Even though pretty much all Creepypastas are fake, The Rake is probably the most believable. I don't know about anyone else, but I find a hairless dog like creature scarier than some faceless tall guy in a suit. While Slenderman just stands around looking like he is upset you didn't show up to his birthday or something, The Rake mutilates you with your blood acting like a sprinkler or something, I don't even know... But in my opinion the scariest Creepypasta out there as of now.

Does the rake stalk you for years? While this is still really scary, I'd have to say that the slenderman is scarier

17 The SCP Foundation

Scp 682 stomps on everyone else

SCP Foundation is not a Creepypasta, or a part of the fandom. SCP and Pasta are completely different fandoms. - RandomCommenter

This is not A Creppypasta But It Scares People

Not a creepypasta but, I still think this is a brilliantly crafted world. Always nice knowing any second a monster of unbelievable power will wake up and destroy the world. Honestly the SCP Foundation lore is very lovecraftian. - Stalin

18 The Pocket

I should stop looking at creepypasta photos!

19 Weeping Angel

Waitaminute isn't the weeping angel from doctor who?

The weeping angel is scary even the picture she would've kill you

This one comes from doctor who but I'm not sure if it is a pasta or not Lol

Wait weren't there weeping angels in doctor who?

20 Jane the Killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

I'm a bigger fan of Jeff, but Jane is a badass too! I don't totally blame her for wanting to get even with Jeff, for I would want revenge too if someone took my family from me. But still, think of what Jeff went through.

Jane sucks, she is just another cliche killer with no depth and no motivation to kill. Jeff the killer is horrible but Jane is worse

It's just a spinoff of Jeff the Killer!

Not very scary at all. Also quite overrated, along with Jeff the Killer.

21 Eyeless Jack

Way too short and not scary at all. Also, how did he not feel his kidney get pulled out? - Gametoon

I love EJ as a character, adore his design, and find his concept a little creepy, but he is not scary. Not even in the least. He shouldn't be on this list. - RandomCommenter

Needs to be higher. - SurcaneWolf

This Is SUCH a good read. I love Jack as a character and the story itself will really make you think

22 Tails Doll

After reading this, I was like, what the hell? - Gametoon

Normally, creepypastas just make me scared at night. Not once have they given me nightmares. Except for the tails doll. That one gave me a nightmare. I don't remember the whole thing, but I do remember a few 2 second parts of it, all of which had the Tails Doll floating around on a colored background with red, glowing eyes. About the waking up in the middle of the night thing, that just happened because I had 1) gotten scared of a new creepypasta, the teddy bear 2) My friend told me that there is a 90% chance that if you wake up in the middle of the night for no reason, it's because you're being watched. Combine the 2, and you wake up in the middle of the night 4 times! - username34

So, if I ever ever ever see a red dot in the dark (which will probably be my Wii), the dot gets it with my sword. This one scares me to this day. Never ever playing a Sega Saturn game to be careful

When I read this I was checking out of my window and waking up in the middle of the night for 4-5 weeks hoping that I will live.

23 Annora Petrova

Its really great but the picture that everyone makes a big deal of isn't scary at all. Oh and can someone tell me why the picture is scary?

Hell, the scariest part of the pasta is the photo, it made me never want to sleep again

24 Penpal

I find this story much better than say Jeff the killer, one because it's written better, but mostly because it's very realistic. A teenage boy cutting his face without getting an infection somehow and dying his hair with fire is just impossible. That's why it isn't scary. Things that are closer to reality are way more scary because it could happen. Kids getting stalked by older men happens all the time and that's terrifying. The fact the story makes the main character so clueless to the things happening while the reader can make sense of it is done so well. Like when he finds the blankets and food under his house he has no idea why they're there and makes so big deal out of it. The reader on the other hand can see why they're there and it's so effective in creating a great atmosphere. The story also leaves you to connect the dots in some cases. The more and more you figure out what's going on the more you fear for the characters. The ending was definitely not a disappointment. Every ...more

I read it and even though it is a long read. It is totally worth it 10/10

I've been looking up lists of "The Best Creepypastas Ever" and am extremely surprised it took me so long to find this one on a list. It's at number 38 on the list that I found and, especially after reading a lot of the other ones, I don't understand how it could be so low on the list. I got chills big time when I read the last paragraph, it was extremely moving. The author is an excellent writer and should consider writing full novels. 10+/10 definintely the best I've read.

I am happy to announce to you that Penpal has been expanded, and a full length novel has been released! You can get it on Amazon. - GREATEST

One of my favorites, along with Psychosis. I voted Penpal, however, because even though I like Psychosis better, Penpal is terrifying because it could, and sadly has, happened. The deaths of people close to him also show how evil humans can be and the last little part about Josh teared me up. This is a beautiful story, and deserves the novel it received.

25 Mr. Widemouth

A Cool Creepypasta The Story Is Fantastic

One of the most plausible, yet still creepy stories out there. Here is a my summary of the story.

A young child with Mononucleosis was forced to stay in their current house for more than 3 weeks, and his parents gave him some in-door activities/possessions to help pass the time before they had to leave and move to a new house. During that time, he developed an "imaginary friend". This "imaginary friend" looked kind of like a Furby and had a widemouth grin. His name, like the title suggests, was Mr. Widemouth. His personality was somewhat similar to Johan Liebert, as Mr. Widemouth would continuously try to get the boy to do dangerous things, like juggling knives, or jumping off the second story of the house. One day, Mr. Widemouth told the child about this location that many other children have visited after meeting Mr. Widemouth and that the boy should come visit this place one day. The child and his family left the house, and moved to a new one. He never saw Mr. Widemouth ...more

It's decently scary (freaked my 11-year-old brother out).
But more than scary it's the best-written creepypasta ever.

Very good read.

26 Candle cove

Not Really Scary But It Gives You Some Chills

Not scary, but I do like it and it's creative. - Gametoon

Snarled even mentioned about the 1970's T.V. Show: Candle Cove.

Quite long but otherwise we'll written. Rather than paranormal this story focuses on the malicious acts of a perverted man. 10/10

27 The Harbinger Experiment

Martha! Turn off the music! - XxSEVEREDHUMANITYxX

Scariest one yet.

Very good creepy pasta. This should be in the top 5.

This should be #1

28 Super Mario 64: Damned

How is this scary? It's just a bunch of cliches. - Gametoon

This combines every cliche into a single Creepypasta, but does it right.

I read about it incredibly creepy and disturbing I may never be able look at Super Mario 64 the same way after reading this creepypasta. - egnomac

WAY scarier than I thought it would be...holy hell - Co0lk1d25

29 Red Mist

The story was pretty freaky, the picture was hellish, but the video? That was disappointing! The part where he was standing there with those bleeding eyes was creepy, but when he actually killed himself, it looked like someone drew a picture of him on a computer, and the animation when he put the gun to his head was so lame. In the story, he used a shot gun and blew his head apart. There was blood, brain matter, his eye was hanging out... But in the video, he puts a little revolver to his head, shoots himself, and then blood spatters on the screen. Then it shows a picture of squidward lying down with some really fake looking blood. Also, when the voice said "Do it! " It sounded like a ' 15 year old who has no experience with voice acting. LAAME!

The story was scary, but the episode was disappointing. In the story, he blew his head up with a shotgun. In the episode, he put a little revolver to his head, and shot himself, and there was some blood on his head... Weak! Also the animation was poor, and when the guy says "do it," it sounds like a 15 year old guy who has no experience with voice acting. LAME!

Squidward creeps me out on this one. The only thing that creeps me out on this creepypasta is the BIG BLOOD SHOT RED EYES! And the ending were HE POINTS A GUN INTO A MOUTH AND SHOOT! That's just creepy.

Remembering flashbacks of spongebob and patrick and squid ward all happy content neighbors, that episode is like getting brick to the forehead. I'm just sitting there thinking, "WH-WHY!? WHAT HAPPENED HERE?! " I can't even explain the toll this takes on your childhood happiness.

30 The Keyhole

When the guy looked into the key hole, and it was red that is when it became a creepypasta.

Its called White With Red

Ahh this did not scare me

31 Polybius

AVGN played this crap! - Tgamez

Whether this story is true or not, which I doubt, there is a chance that it could've been inspired by a similar story REALLY did happen. Back in the early 80's, there was an arcade game that was phenomenal called "Berzerk". In 1981, a man, who was only 18 years old, got a score of 16,660 points, and for some unknown reason, he died of a heart attack right after.
1 year later, another man at age 19, played the game, got in the Top 10 High Scores twice in 15 minutes, and once again, for some unknown reason, he died of a heart attack right after. To this day, nobody certainly knows what was responsible for these heart attacks. What caused these 2 young men to die of heart attacks? What's your guess?

Too hyped to be at the top score, I guess. Or they're unhealthy and fat. - TeamRocket747

Did you guys know that this is in the Simpsons?

Odd but not scary. 1/10

32 The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen

I listened to this on YouTube two times already and I liked it. I was so curious as to what "Jeremy" looked like that I looked for the picture on msn. Freaky! That's all there is to it.

You can't have a list without a disturbing security tape being in it, I like the concept of the time loops and also Jeremy is a freak

I really really liked this

33 Username 666

Let me write a full and detailed explanation of this creepypasta (don't read within 2 hours of bedtime unless you have plans to not sleep):

The video begins with the protagonist on the YouTube homepage. The protagonist then goes into the omnibox and adds 666 on the end. They get taken to a page that says "This account is suspended". Nothing scary...yet.

The protagonist then refreshes the page several times, and everything is normal up until the 13th refresh when the video thumbnails were replaced with the X and "666". It stays like this until the 20th refresh when all the letters are replaced with d's or 6s. d is the first letter in "devil", and also looks like a 6 in reverse (a little bit).

Then, at the 21st refresh, the page background changes from white to red, and on the 21st refresh it changes from red to black. This is when the suspended account notice starts changing, too. The 22nd refresh changes the page background to red and ...more - allamassal

This gave me nightmares! it's a really satanic channel.

The video makes no sense at all. It's not even scary.

My friend tried to kill my computer by looking this up and trying to make it happen. I didn't let him though. All it really is, is a virus hooked up to YouTube. Nothing paranormal. - username34

34 The Doctor

So are we talking about the doctor from doctor who or the creepypasta one because no matter what I like them both

Okay, let me get this simple. This is nightmares in a story.

Why does he want to kill him? And if he's a scientist, does he not notice that he's trying to kill him? - sdgeek2003

I hate doctors because they all turn out to kill you in MOVIES LIKE THIS PEOPLE HE IS A KILLER!

35 An Egg

Not really creepy but if u want your mind exploded this is what u want to read

36 Persuaded

Same old zombie cliche and wasn't scary at all

37 Psychosis

This, unlike the horribly overrated Jeff the Killer and Slenderman, is extremely thought provoking. Such a disturbing concept, and the ending is so well crafted the writer ought to get a medal. This and Candle Cove are easily my favorite Creepypastas.

Now this. this is horror. it doesn't attempt to make itself scary but instead relies on the readers own thoughts and insecurities to help piece together the puzzle that is Psychosis. the way the character is relatable and provokes an ideology based on his current, and maybe coincidental, circumstances makes it an infinite times better then Jeff the killer or any other knock off, cheap trash.

This is the best written creepypasta by far. It easily squashes things like red mist and lavender town syndrome, and makes slenderman seem like a children's novel.

One of the first Creepypastas I read, and still one of the best. The entire read was good, but when it all comes together at the end, it really gets you thinking. 10/10

38 Laughing Jack

I love him he is the best - LaylaHangedLH

I read the full real story and that creeped me out.

Easily my absolute favorite creepypasta. I told his story to all of my friends, and they were mortified. This one could easily be around the top three, but this isn't my list...

One of my favorites. I mean, think about it. A psycho monochrome clown who kills children and disappears into thin air when attacked. What's not to be scared of?

39 The Expressionless

Annabelle image from the conjuring made me terrified of dolls but the image of the expressionless oh god I'm horrified of manicans now and the image gave me pediophobia

I was going to vote for the rake, but when I saw this creepypasta on the list, I had to vote for it. Don't look it up or you will regret it. The way how the mannequin turned its teeth sharp was creepy.

The pic is disturbing but the pasta itself was bad. Especially the ending, it may as well said, AND THEN A SKELETON POPPED OUT! Ugh. - RedTheGremlin

Definitely beats out any other creepypasta!

40 The Grifter

Sounds VERY creepy! Now I don't want to here

about this guy

A video full of corpses, dead children, broken dolls, and other stuff.

41 Slender Man

It is already nomber 4 but it is number 40

So scary it's on here twice.

42 Ticci Toby

I think it best to not hurt him he still has a heart

If u vote for him I give u a cookie

Toby isn't scary. In fact, I feel bad for him. He was bullied for having Tourette's Syndrome, which gives you uncontrollable ticks. But that's the thing; he can't control them! So that's why I find it sad, people shouldn't dislike other people for what they can't control.

I absolutely love Ticci Toby! In my opinion Ticci Toby is the best creepypasta. It's so well written and all the details the author added make it very easy to picture exactly whats happening! If I were to be able to only listen to one creepypasta my whole life this would be the one I would listen to!

43 Seed Eater

He looks like SCP-1471

Made my brother read it he had nightmares and I thought that serves you right for watching sanjy and Craig - Helloworld

Kids! Delicious!

44 B.O.B.

Bob the builder is the scarist boi around

Bob's name means Brutal Obsence Beast

Almost as the rake but this is without hand. It's special is can run as fast as a tiger

45 Where Bad Kids Go

To Hell, I think...

I think this is about a boy who watched a show that showed bad kids dying so kids would be good and the boy as a man talked about the goriest, scariest, and even his fave moments.

Not scary at all!

The closet!

46 Normal Porn for Normal People

Never read it, but what kind of title is that? - Gametoon

1999 is more disturbing

I can't believe this isn't up higher, it's by fat the most disturbing one out there. Just... Look it up. I can't describe it any more. Just look.

So disturbing. Just look it up and just look.

47 NoEnd House

YEA! This is like This creepypasta I made up called the devil's house!

A bit long, but worth every minute.

Listen to it on YouTube by MrCreepyPasta... You'll piss yourself and not want to sleep for days.

48 Gateway of the Mind

The footage is so jarring

The human with power and without sense known as God but this thing was abandoned by God himself

The footage is creepy as hell

One of my first pastas, but the creepiness factor remains strong as ever.

49 Max and Ruby 0004

Seeing that makes me cry I love that show! I always wanted a house just like theirs... NOT ANYMORE!

My tablet completely froze after seeing this. It wouldn't turn off!

Nope nope nope nope nope nope and so many nope so scary that it kept me up all night

This one was a big nightmare... I watch it about 4 months ago and it still scared me..

50 Humans Can Lick Too

The title reminds me of a creepy commercial about an ice cream human eating himself... - VoidSense

Hey! I've seen that! Is it the commercial about Little Baby's Ice Cream? - RedTheGremlin

This is just plain creepy...

That ad was... WEIrd as carp

Heheheh I remember this one - AnonymousChick

8Load More
PSearch List