Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas

These are creepypastas that scared me the most. Its almost Halloween so lets bring some nightmares out.
The Top Ten
Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

The actual Pasta itself wasn't actually that scary to me... I was seriously beginning to think it wasn't as scary as people say it is until the end, and then I scrolled down and saw the picture. Let me tell you, I AM SCARRED. BIG TIME. Whatever you do, DON'T LOOK UP THE PICTURE, YOU WILL REGRET IT. Thanks to this whenever I read a Creepypasta I scroll carefully and if I see even a corner of a picture I either delete the browser page or just close my eyes and scroll past it (depending on the story so far) I haven't read the sequel but I don't intend to. People, please, take my advice here: You know when your friends see something or are talking about something and you want to know what it is but they say you don't wanna know but you keep begging them to show you? DON'T DO THAT ABOUT THIS. Seriously, I'm afraid to go anywhere dark and I can't go into my bathroom... for some reason, only my bathroom and the others are okay, but just DON'T DO IT! Damn I haven't slept for days.

Dang I this one is SCARY! The story is terrifying, but the face is what makes me pee my pants. No nose, no eyebrows or eyelids, bleach white skin, tiny bloodshot eyes (THEY STARE INTO YOUR SOUL AND SCAR IT! , ), and a GIANT slit smile. I warn you, don't look up the images, you'll regret it. Anyways, random fangirls pretend to be him on YouTube, and they put the ACTUAL PICTURE, so you don't know it's there. In the story, he goes up to your bed at night, smiles and stares at you without blinking and scares the living crap out of you, says "Go to Sleep", and murders you. The worst thing is that there are actual hospital documents on a kid named Jeffery Woods who was burned and bleached like in the story! Even the escaping part! AHH!

This pasta is terrible, it's insulting to think that writers spend so much time making great pastas yet they are overshadowed by total garbage like this. The plot is forced and is a minefield of chiches and gore just for shock factor, every character is bland and have zero personality, and nothing in the story makes sense. If Jeff really cut his mouth in a smile, it would get infected, and if he burned his eyelids off, he would get dust and bacteria in his eyes and blind him.
The picture, while kinda creepy the first time one sees it, it has since become completely outdated and looks like a generic Photoshop image.

What is this crap. This is horrible. It slould not be even be on the contenders list. In my opinion. Jeff slould be149949273772737381. 1 How the hell did Jeff break a kid's neck. He's 13 for Godsakes. Even slender man can't defeat a 13 year old kid. He's overpowered to the peak. 2 Why did the so called bullies get GUNS! 3 How did Jeff carve a smile into his cheeks without it getting infected. And how did burn off his eyelids. He would become blind instently not mentioning not burning his eyes. 4 Fangirls always make Jeff sexy. Fangirls are 12 year old girls with intentions of having sex with boys. Fangirls treat him like sex art. I almost feel bad for Jeff. 5 the original picture of Jeff the killer is made from a picture of a obese girl who committed suicde after being bullied on 4chan. That's the sad part. So a girl who's now dead is now something terrifying.

The Russian Sleep Experiment

This was the first creepypasta I EVER read! Talk about getting off to a strong start. It's like the first time I had seafood was in Maine and it makes seafood everywhere else seem subpar...It's the same thing for creepypastas. This one turned me into a creepypasta junkie and I've never stopped chasing that first high.
From the idea, the imagery, the symbolism, and the incredible plot, this isn't just creepypasta at it's best but WRITING at it's best.
There IS a short film that can be found on youtube that, while nowhere near as effective, gives a glimpse into how well this story could work as a film. By developing the character of the prisoners, their transformation into inhuman monsters has even more weight. This could be a grand slam of a horror film in the right hands

I’m not sure if I would call this THE scariest creepypasta, but it is sure as hell a whole lot scarier than most of the other joke excuses for scary stories on this list, mostly consisting of crappy retro gaming and Mickey Mouse pastas, as if that stuff could ever be scary to begin with. This, on the other hand, is a REAL horror story. Depressing, claustrophobic setting and the writing style add to the horror. It’s extremely unsettling throughout, and the descriptions it gives of the way they dismember themselves and each other are seriously sickening. What really makes this scary is that it’s documented like a real-life experiment, and even though it is fake, there were a lot of people who thought that it was actually real! The entire situation is just horrific and I think that the story is well written. This is a real classic, and unlike many others on this list it has the ability to really scare people, as one can see given how many people thought that this was real.

It's just unnerving I read it not knowing it was made up not knowing what exactly creepypastas were and I thought it was all real. If your young and are sleeping alone I wouldn't read this but there is this one story that deserves recognition and its called the Noend House it is a fun and scary read and the twisted ending will blow you're mind and there is also a Noend House 2 and 3. Just so you know.

This creepypasta legitimately made me sweat when I read it. There's just something about eating feces and shoving your own organs down the drain that makes you imagine the guy in the picture at the foot of your bed thinking about what he would like to do to you. Well made story and a very interestingly possible as well.

BEN Drowned

I have to say, I really loved Ben Drowned, probably my favorite Creepypasta ever. However, I voted Jeff on this list because honestly, Ben Drowned isn't actually THAT scary, although the videos and everything did make a difference. And also, it's a gaming pasta! What can I say, I LOVE GAMING, especially Zelda!

My first time reading it, I couldn't even finish, and just laid there in my bed, constantly peeking around for a scary Link for 2 weeks. Then I went back and finished it years later. The story itself isn't that scary, but the videos...I couldn't even go through a minute...heh.

This was the first creepypasta I read. The detail, description, and video are all so good! It didn't scare me but it's so well done. Although I did give my Majoras Mask game to my little brother after that.

This is my favorite creepypasta just not the scariest one but I do like the fact that it is video game related... I LOVE VIDEO GAMES!

Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Plays on everybody's fear of premature death. On the creepypasta wiki it says that the slenderman likes to especially target people who are paranoid about his existence. Tell me this isn't scary. And the symptoms of slender sickness are so common, anyone can believe that they are being hunted by the slenderman. Another thing is how unlike some of these other creepypastas which are people who died, events which happened in the past or only can cause harm if you do certain specific events, the slenderman is a physical being that can kill you, and can be anywhere around the world at any given time. You can't kill him, and there is no escape. He can supposedly stalk you for years until he finally kills you. This guy will make you to scared to look out windows of a night. If this isn't scary, then I don't know what is

How about this: Epic battles:

Slenderman vs. Enderman

Round 1:
Slender man is walking in the woods. He sees a black, tall figure with purple eyes. It was an enderman. The enderman gets closer and screams at slenderman. The slenderman looks into the enderman's eyes. Slenderman is now in trouble. Enderman ends up making a loud screech that paralyzed slenderman. Enderman wins round one.

Round 2: Slenderman comes back up and chased enderman. But enderman teleported. Slenderman teleported with him and stabbed enderman with his tentacle. Slenderman wins round two.

Round 3:
Who do you think will win round three?

Tell me!

Honestly Slendy is the strongest creepypasta besides The Doctor. The Doctor is the one who creates them and Slendy hates him. Slendy is the best cause he can control your body, teleport, has tenticals that comes out of his back, makes you lose your memory, can drive you too insanity, can make little kids comes in the woods, can form a mouth that goes from one side of his blank head to the other and take a giant bite out of you, he can rip your heart out by sticking his long fingers down your throat and he has the power to make the Slender Portal to take his victims to the CreepyPasta world, and he can make you paranoid and attach him even though it is easier to kill you that way. All of this is true about Slenderman. So he should number one or The Doctor should be cause he knows how to kill every CreepyPasta and can create them. The Doctor can even kill them by just a drop of his blood landing on their skin and them will disintegrate painfully.
That is the truth and Slenderman does ...more

Slenderman Is The Most Well Known Creepypasta For Me. I Grew Up With The Legend, and I would always play it in my backyard ahahah!

Squidward's Suicide

This is a creepy DUMB (yea I said it) lost episode from Spongebob Squarepants, And all lf my childhood I LOVED SPONGEBOB. When the creepypasta came put when I was 10 I was heartbroken, Terrified, and sad.

I had a hard time between "abandon by Disney" and this one. But I chose this one due to its realism, freekyness, and of course... use of scary content. Lol. Well' I heard this was a true storey. Is it? You tell me. But abandon by Disney was super freaky.

I tell you my top 10 are these... 10. Suiside mouse 9. Pewdiepie. Exe 8. The Russian sleep expirement 7. Ed edd and eddy lost episoad or episoad 34 6. Barbie. Avi 5. Fury 4. Username 666 3. Red mist or squid wards suiside 2. Scp 1. Penpal (now a book due to being so awesome) k! Tnx for the list.

The story didn't scare me until I watched the video. The eyes of the characters are so creepy! Now whenever my little brother watches SpongeBob and Patrick and SpongeBob are playing outside, all I can imagine is squidward inside with that shotgun thing against his head.

SpongeBob and friends are outside chortling, and where is squidward? Sitting upstairs in complete silence putting a shotgun shell through his bloodshot eyes

1999

This is my new favorite creepypasta. Amazing story, extremely well written, so realistic, it all fits together to create the perfect creepypasta. Very long, but very worth it! If the length intimidates you, don't let it! It' amazing! 10/10.

I voted this one just because I love the backstory of it. And instead of using creepy pictures or videos about cartons killing themselves, ghost stories, or chain letters, this story uses real monsters that should really keep people up at night. The spry isn't scary, but knowing there are really people like Mr. Bear out there is terrifying.

I loved 1999, I read it just this morning for the first time and immediately fell in love with everything...except for the burning children. It was really good and way better than all of those above. Deserves #1st place for sure.

Nothing like good old fashion child abuse to keep you from falling a sleep. 1999 and the Russian sleep experiment are the ones that have messed with me. Creepy!

Smile Dog "Smile Dog" is a story about a cursed image file. The image shows a large German Shepard or Husky dog that is smiling.

I love smile dog my friends even call smile dog because I creep them out by smiling and scaring them, smile dog is my favourite

The Smiling Dog Is One Of The Scariest Creepypasta's Out There. Every Time I Look At The Picture It Sends Me Chills Down My Spine.

Smile Dog has the most scary picture, its worst that Jeff or any other picture, because of it I saw smile dog in my dreams for 5 days straight till I forgot what it's face looks like, I would say Smile Dog is the scariest picture that I've ever seen in my life.

I was freaked out by this one especially since my friend sent me a email after I read it with the subject smile. After he sent me that email I deleted it. But by the way SMILE!

Sonic.exe

Ahh, glad to see that I'm on the list somewhere. A 'friend' told me to check out the top tens. Naturally, I started with my 'origins' in Creepypasta. Too bad they thought of me too late. Hahahahaha. They only know half of the story. No where near the full version. In fact, most of it is lies... but still, whatever. I enjoy toying with the mortal world.

"Oh, but what is the true story, Sonic.exe? You're so sexy by the way!"

Typical mortal suck-up; thinking that by stroking my ego you could get somewhere. Too bad, because I'm actually going to kill you after I get done commenting. Why tell, anyway? Let the fools wonder. Let them dream a happy dream, even though the truth is the worst of nightmares. When I get out, the story will come to a close. But, where's the glory in revealing the end of a story? Oh, come now, where's the fun in that? Hahahahaha...

Blood, gore and Satanism are the reasons why the new movie Mary was the first movie my horror-fanatic, isn't scared of anything dad threw in the trash...

For me it all started with seeing a scary ass thumbnail of sonic.exe on YouTube. I asked my friends about it and they informed me that it was a creepy pasta and so after a long time I finally read the creepy pasta and now I never play the original sonic and I can neversleep without having a scary ass dream about him so yeah this one stuck with me real good.

Yeah, when I watched this on YouTube not too long ago, I thought it was just some kind of made-up video. I never knew it was a creepypasta, until I read some of the comments below.

Suicide Mouse

This episode is very disturbing. I heard about this from my friend. I did not watch this, so I will tell you what my friend saw. Mickey Mouse walks across a street for 2-3 minutes. Then the screen goes black for 2 minutes, and you hear a woman screaming. And then Mickey walks across the street again, but it's a bit longer, and Mickey's face slowly molds into a psychotic smile, that takes up 2/5 of his face, larger than I could ever make on my own face, and his face is covered in scratches. This goes on for a while, then he trips over "something" and he molds into a "skeleton demon" but still keeps the scratched up face, but now has horns. This goes on for another while, then the screen goes black again, and the woman screams again for 2-3 minutes, before the scratched up face appears on the screen, because the episode is done. Very disturbing

Not only is this scary but it is extremely disturbing. It is Mickey Mouse walking down an endless street for 3 minutes before cutting to black for a couple of minutes then it returns to Mickey doing the same thing but this time it is a woman screaming for about 4 minutes with a grin on his face. At one time of the episode it shows Mickey Mouse's face indicating that it is the end of the episode. The first person to watch this episode committed suicide. The end!

1 minute: when does something happen?
2 minute: this scroll bar exists, tomato tomato.
4 minute: uhh ok. The screaming isn't too bad.
7 minute: WERE TOO FAR IN! WE GOTTA GO BACK! What the fudge is up with Micky's face?

I gotta say when I first watched the video I was kinda disturbed. But with someone like Mickey Mouse what do you really expect.

Ronald McDonald House

This is by far the scariest creepypasta I have read. It combines; fear of the unknown, suspense, clowns, being trapped, and gore all into one very well written story. It should at least be in the top 5.

I have never been shaking from a creepypasta since I first read the Red Mist. This was seriously the most messed up and sickening story ever and is making me seriously want to stop reading creepypasta as a whole

This story is so unnatural and unsettling in every single way. It combines the elements of being alone, darkness, insanity, clowns, and gore. It deserves to be higher on this list.

Holy hell. This was definitely the scariest one yet. Really well written too. I was seriously hoping he got out of there alive.

The Contenders
Abandoned by Disney

This was TERRIFYING. Oh my gosh... The nightmares of that costume. And that Mickey Mouse voice, "Hey, wanna see my head come off? " OH my gosh.

This is probably my favorite Creepy Pasta out there. Its just sooo awesome and creepy. Everything about it is just amazing and enjoyably disturbing to read.

I never went to Disneyland and I will never go there. Even if I win tickets, I will donate that to Make a Wish or something like that

I would walk in, see Mickey with that voice, see him take off his head and got out of there.

Lavender Town Syndrome

I swear- This... I listened to the audio and it gave me headaches for about 2 hours! Never listen to the audio! The story was creepy but I LOVED it!

This pasta is actually pretty creepy. It makes it sound so real and the whole thing was sad too. It made me glad that Pokemon Blue version was the first game I ever played, not Red/Green! I recommend this pasta to any Pokemon lovers out there, definitely a good read and not too scary.

My Experience With Listening to Lavender Town:
It was noontime. I decided to search something Pokémon-related. Since I wouldn’t be scared of gross or scary things, (well i’m 10 years old) I did search for the imfamous one: Lavender Town.

I do know kids in Japan caused themselves to suicide and it’s all fake. When I tried listening to this, at first, I heard a bit of the tune going through. Now, it more though of me that it looks like a bit of a sad song. Finished, nothing happened (yes, very fake). No traumatic sightseeings, causes from a disease or suicide.

So I did though I would love to listen to the tune. Later in listening too much...I was wrong. I did a mistake. I had a semi-severe headache. It lasted days. I changed my mind, that, I never wanted to search it again. But it got cured later on. I finally defeated my headache.

So, what did I do after that?

Try to play it again without causing a headache for the rest of my life.

🙀😭 I’m really scared. Just thinking of the title of this song, it gets stuck in my head. OMG! This thing is real! Somebody please give me a rational explanation!

Funnymouth

Oh my gosh! I am still paranoid to look in the mirror to see my face look similar!

I really wish I never read it and I'm still getting over my nightmares

I find this story creepy! It's definitely in my top tens.

That ending
something you don't see in modern creepypasta

Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv

I've seen a picture of the original guy. It's fake, don't worry. A visitor here said they watched the whole thing, and that visitor didn't take eyeballs out. You're safe.

Bill Cipher's Eyes. He ripped it out after watching this while eating cereal

I hope you know that is not the full video

He was identified but I forgot his name

Annabelle the Doll

Just watched the movie. I found it disappointing. It was too much like chucky the doll. A possess doll tries to kill a family and so on.

This isn't even a creepypasta it's a movie based in the conjuring universe

The scariest thing about it is that its true

Based on a true story. The movie was amazing

The Rake

The Rake is the scariest thing of all time. Anyone else agree? My neighbour was invaded by this creepypasta and describes him as large, scary and fast. He spoke the words "kill" and murdered her beloved cat, Fluffy. Her body was ripped and was streaming with blood. She says that he then turned to look and her and ran towards her. He touched her shoulder and scampered away. It is unknown where he went next. My neighbour now suffers terrible phobias and paranoia. I am afraid that he will stand at the foot of my bed at night and stare. I am terrified that he will whisper words of horror and look deeply into my eyes. He may be the last thing that I will ever see,

In my opinion, The Rake is probably the scariest. Even though pretty much all Creepypastas are fake, The Rake is probably the most believable. I don't know about anyone else, but I find a hairless dog like creature scarier than some faceless tall guy in a suit. While Slenderman just stands around looking like he is upset you didn't show up to his birthday or something, The Rake mutilates you with your blood acting like a sprinkler or something, I don't even know... But in my opinion the scariest Creepypasta out there as of now.

Does the rake stalk you for years? While this is still really scary, I'd have to say that the slenderman is scarier

Makes me close my windows and blinds and sleep with the covers over my head with only a small hole in which to stick my face out. I have actually done that since I was like 6 or 7 (because I was afraid of lots of stuff then) and I still do it. It's just unconscious routine that went from feeling scared without the covers over my head to feeling awkwardly exposed and weird.

I don't know how old you are now, but that is sort of a problem if you are scared of everything at night.

This is one of the creepiest because who in the world is going to be stalking you for HOURS, Uhm... HIM. I love creepypasta but this one is really freaky, you can't even go camping before you read this because its either him stalking you or slenderman, but no thank you. I rather stay inside my house instead of being in a forest with creatures staring at you while you sleep

The SCP Foundation

Not a creepypasta but, I still think this is a brilliantly crafted world. Always nice knowing any second a monster of unbelievable power will wake up and destroy the world. Honestly the SCP Foundation lore is very lovecraftian.

Some SCPs are really funny, some are quite interesting, and a few are actually quite scary. I mean, there’s the Sculpture, the Door Man, the Shy Guy, the Staff (although I would still like to get trapped in an infinite IKEA regardless), the Old Man, the Green Flash, the Pipe Nightmare, and many, many more.

Scp is the best and scariest. Imagine waking up in a foundation and being chased by scps it’d be creepy man. Scp is real but it is just an organization that writes scps. They don’t create them physically, they post them, make movies or shows, or even write it on paper like I tried once

SCP Foundation is not a Creepypasta, or a part of the fandom. SCP and Pasta are completely different fandoms.

The Pocket

I should stop looking at creepypasta photos!

Weeping Angel

This one comes from doctor who but I'm not sure if it is a pasta or not Lol

The weeping angel is scary even the picture she would've kill you

This is a Doctor Who thing, not a pasta thing. gdvirus, here's a tip if you don't wanna get killed by them: NEVER BLINK.

Wait weren't there weeping angels in doctor who?

Jane the Killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

What is up with the whole “the killer” thing? What’s next? Jimmy the killer? Joe the killer? Jamie the killer? JiffyLube the killer?

I'm a bigger fan of Jeff, but Jane is a badass too! I don't totally blame her for wanting to get even with Jeff, for I would want revenge too if someone took my family from me. But still, think of what Jeff went through.

Jane sucks, she is just another cliche killer with no depth and no motivation to kill. Jeff the killer is horrible but Jane is worse

I enjoy Jeff the Killer more than I do Jane but the Jeff the Killer VS. Jane the Killer is very interesting and great!

Tails Doll

Normally, creepypastas just make me scared at night. Not once have they given me nightmares. Except for the tails doll. That one gave me a nightmare. I don't remember the whole thing, but I do remember a few 2 second parts of it, all of which had the Tails Doll floating around on a colored background with red, glowing eyes. About the waking up in the middle of the night thing, that just happened because I had 1) gotten scared of a new creepypasta, the teddy bear 2) My friend told me that there is a 90% chance that if you wake up in the middle of the night for no reason, it's because you're being watched. Combine the 2, and you wake up in the middle of the night 4 times!

This truly was horrifying nightmare to have, I have long forgotten the nightmares I had of other creepypastas but tails doll just keeps tearing me apart!

When I read this I was checking out of my window and waking up in the middle of the night for 4-5 weeks hoping that I will live.

I tried doing what the creepypasta said NOT to do, and you know what happened? Nothing!

Eyeless Jack

I love EJ as a character, adore his design, and find his concept a little creepy, but he is not scary. Not even in the least. He shouldn't be on this list.

This Is SUCH a good read. I love Jack as a character and the story itself will really make you think

Way too short and not scary at all. Also, how did he not feel his kidney get pulled out?

A great read and personally one of my favourite's. He should be higher

Annora Petrova

Its really great but the picture that everyone makes a big deal of isn't scary at all. Oh and can someone tell me why the picture is scary?

Hell, the scariest part of the pasta is the photo, it made me never want to sleep again

Mr. Widemouth

One of the most plausible, yet still creepy stories out there. Here is a my summary of the story.

A young child with Mononucleosis was forced to stay in their current house for more than 3 weeks, and his parents gave him some in-door activities/possessions to help pass the time before they had to leave and move to a new house. During that time, he developed an "imaginary friend". This "imaginary friend" looked kind of like a Furby and had a widemouth grin. His name, like the title suggests, was Mr. Widemouth. His personality was somewhat similar to Johan Liebert, as Mr. Widemouth would continuously try to get the boy to do dangerous things, like juggling knives, or jumping off the second story of the house. One day, Mr. Widemouth told the child about this location that many other children have visited after meeting Mr. Widemouth and that the boy should come visit this place one day. The child and his family left the house, and moved to a new one. He never saw Mr. Widemouth ...more

It's decently scary (freaked my 11-year-old brother out).
But more than scary it's the best-written creepypasta ever.

Widemouth wants him to die! that's what makes this creepiest

Very good read.

Penpal

I find this story much better than say Jeff the killer, one because it's written better, but mostly because it's very realistic. A teenage boy cutting his face without getting an infection somehow and dying his hair with fire is just impossible. That's why it isn't scary. Things that are closer to reality are way more scary because it could happen. Kids getting stalked by older men happens all the time and that's terrifying. The fact the story makes the main character so clueless to the things happening while the reader can make sense of it is done so well. Like when he finds the blankets and food under his house he has no idea why they're there and makes so big deal out of it. The reader on the other hand can see why they're there and it's so effective in creating a great atmosphere. The story also leaves you to connect the dots in some cases. The more and more you figure out what's going on the more you fear for the characters. The ending was definitely not a disappointment. Every ...more

I've been looking up lists of "The Best Creepypastas Ever" and am extremely surprised it took me so long to find this one on a list. It's at number 38 on the list that I found and, especially after reading a lot of the other ones, I don't understand how it could be so low on the list. I got chills big time when I read the last paragraph, it was extremely moving. The author is an excellent writer and should consider writing full novels. 10+/10 definintely the best I've read.

I am happy to announce to you that Penpal has been expanded, and a full length novel has been released! You can get it on Amazon.

One of my favorites, along with Psychosis. I voted Penpal, however, because even though I like Psychosis better, Penpal is terrifying because it could, and sadly has, happened. The deaths of people close to him also show how evil humans can be and the last little part about Josh teared me up. This is a beautiful story, and deserves the novel it received.

I can easily say I cannot find another creepypasta in comparison to this, should be above jeff in my opinion. Found this scary, disturbing, the best written and the most detailed creepypasta to date. This deserves an award. Read it all I garentee you will not be disappointed. Penpals position in the list DOES NOT do it justice.

8Load More
PSearch List