Top Ten Questions About Metallica to Ask Users of TheTopTens

Songsta41

The Top TenXW

1Ride the Lightning or Master of Puppets?

Ride the lightning by far. Fade to black is such a feeling and overall perfect song, I wish every song could be like that. For whom the bell tolls is also an insane song. Really, every single song on the album never fails to leave me mesmerized. Master of Puppets is amazing too, but not to nearly the same extent. - Songsta41

Ride the Lightning. Not even close. Master of Puppets bores the he'll out of me. (Especially the title track)

Such a close one, but for being true, powerful thrash, MOP - gemcloben

Ride the Lighting. - Mumbizz01

V2 Comments
2Dave Mustaine or Kirk Hammett?

I prefer Dave, he's got a very unique style of guitar solos that's hard to beat. He's also an insane songwriter. I would wish he was in Metallica if that didn't mean Megadeth wouldn't exist. - Songsta41

I would say Kirk Hammet, he's responsible for my favorite guitar solo in existence.
One - CastlevaniaFanboy128

V2 Comments
3St Anger or Lulu?

Can't see why everyone loves the title track from St. Anger. It's repetitive and boring. Both albums are equally bad. - IronSabbathPriest

Hey, at least the title cut for St Anger was decent. - MrQuaz680

St anger has an actual good song - gemcloben

V3 Comments
4Robert Trujillo or Jason Newsted?

I like Trujillo more. I don't know what it is about him, I just do. - Songsta41

Trujillo. A really unique and underrated player, but newsted is just pretty simple. - gemcloben

V1 Comment
5Death Magnetic or Kill Em All?

Kill Em All, really no contest. Death Magnetic is just an average album to me, poor production let me down. Whilst Kill Em All has a really raw and powerful sound, as well as being the best vocal album in my opinion. - IronSabbathPriest

I prefer their most recent album. It's got some really great songs. Not to say Kill em All doesn't, that's a fantastic album, but James's voice is a bit too raw. - Songsta41

Kill em All. Seek and Destroy just wrecks everything on Death Magnetic. - MrQuaz680

V3 Comments
6If they could cover any one song what would it be?

I wonder what it would be like if they covered "lowa" (song) by slipknot - Mumbizz01

V4 Comments
7What's your favorite cover by Metallica?

Turn the Page by Bob Seger. That's now one of my favorite songs of all time. I would say Am I Evil, but I like the Diamond Head version better. - Songsta41

Stone Cold Crazy by Queen. I like both versions of the song but I like Metallica's version better. - MrQuaz680

V3 Comments
8Black Album or And Justice for All?

...And Justice for all only had one (no pun intended) song that sticks out in my mind while Black more - MrQuaz680

And justice for all bring a whole new (yet equally heavy) sound to Metallica. - gemcloben

Black Album, it's actually my second favourite by them. - Mumbizz01

I'd go with the Black Album - CastlevaniaFanboy128

V1 Comment
9Load or Reload?

The first part of Load is actually pretty awesome. Whilst Reload only has two songs on it that I really like. - IronSabbathPriest

V4 Comments
10If you could make any one Metallica song disappear off the face of the Earth, which one would it be?

Mama Said, cause it is a country song. - MrQuaz680

Fade to black distracts fans from real thrash - gemcloben

Distracts? People who want real thrash just don't have to listen to this. Besides, I'm surprised you didn't say Nothing Else Matters by that logic. - Songsta41

V3 Comments

The Contenders

11For Whom the Bell Tolls or Master of Puppets?
12Kill 'Em All or Master of Puppets?
13What Metallica song do you think people need to stop obsessing over?
14Damage Inc. or Dyers Eve?
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

P