Top Ten Most Underrated Metallica Songs After ... and Justice for All

NOTE: Songs like Don't Tread on Me and Fuel are great but not underrated.

The Top TenXW

1Shoot Me Again

The entire album (except for Frantic being liked by fans) is underrated, so you could have any Anger track replace this. - Brobusky

Heck yeah! This is one of my favorites in St. Anger. - NikBrusk

V1 Comment
2The Struggle Within

Great song, nowhere near as popular as Sandman and Sad But True though. - Brobusky

3Of Wolf and Man

HOW was this song not regarded as one of the best on The Black Album? It's amazing! - Brobusky

42 x 4

Great song buried between two of the more popular tracks on Load makes this an undiscovered gem. - Brobusky


For the most part, the entire Load album is underrated because of it being not thrash. This song is no exception. - Brobusky

6Dirty Window

St. Anger track = automatically horrible by most fans...before they even listen to the album, and it really doesn't help that Dirty Window has only been played 31 times live! - Brobusky


The best song off ReLoad (besides Fuel) in my opinion. An amazing 8 minute long epic that never gets the love it deserves. - Brobusky

8That Was Just Your Life

You want thrash? This song gives it to ya

9Poor Twisted Me

Another good song from the Load era that is extremely underrated. - Brobusky

10Bleeding Me

The Contenders

11Low Man's Lyric

Now it's actually turned into my favourite song of all time.

This is probably my favorite from Reload - Metalmaniakkk

12All Within My Hands
14Mama Said
15The Unforgiven II
16Wherever I May Roam
17Nothing Else Matters
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists