Top 10 Battle for Dream Island (BFDI) Characters

The Top Ten

Leafy

She only took it because he upset her. After all that she's done for Fiery, he refused to let her in because of one ride, which Leafy disliked. She felt left out, and I was really disappointed when some people saw that episode and put her at the bottom of the list despite what others have done to each other. Sure, it may be, but it was out of sadness. I don't believe that Leafy initially planned to steal Dream Island. If she did plan to steal the island, she would've done it earlier, hacked the speaker box's results, or done something a bit more dramatic. But that scene just looked like she blew a fuse. I mean, I might have done the same thing, and not just me - lots of people would.
I just don't get how a little crime could make someone the worst character.
Teardrop

TD is highly intelligent and unique (due to how she can't speak). I also love the friendship she has with Gelatin, which is at the top of my relationship ranking (but I like The Blocky, Eraser, and Pen better, lol). Overall, she is pretty amazing and hasn't been up for elimination during the whole TPOT season, even though she is on a team by herself. Also, in BFDIA, she literally got voted out due to some random gang who decided to team up and vote her out, which is totally unfair.

I agree with a lot of things that this person said, especially about the unfair elimination. I don't agree that she's a perfect character, but she is definitely one of my favorites!
Bubble

Her accent is so funny! I feel so bad for her because of Blocky when he rejoined the game. This is the second reason why I hate Blocky! So mean to Bubble for no reason! What did she do to you? Explain what she did to you! Screw you, Blocky! I also felt bad for her when Pencil and Match demoted her and were stern with her. At least she stood up to that. I understand how it feels when people do that to me. It's really painful. Trust me, you do NOT want to go through that. Another example of abuse.

It really sucks that Bubble got disqualified from the second season just because she was dead. She didn't deserve it. Leafy and Flower did, though, because Leafy stole the first season's grand prize, and Flower was rude to everyone for the entire season. I don't remember Bubble having any bad intentions.
Tennis Ball

He is the best character by far. He may not be the best in Season 1, but in Seasons 2, 3, 4, and 5, he is amazing. As one of the smart ones in class, I like smart characters, but his funny and smart personality makes it unfair if I don't put him in first place.
Also, his friendship with Golf Ball is another thing that makes him my favorite character. I can't say anything else other than: TB IS THE GOAT.

Tennis Ball is an overall good, friendly, and smart character. His relationship with Golf Ball is really strong, and everyone likes him.
Puffball

She is so cute! And her voice is funny to hear! She is such a unique character because of her abilities.

Puffball is one of the best contestants. She's so cute because of her voice and her abilities.

She is so unique and cute, and her voice is amazing.
Firey

People hate him just because he won Dream Island. Just because he won the first season doesn't mean he is going to win BFB, and people are rushing to vote him off. You say he turned bland - why not give him a chance to become a good character again? And I'm talking to you, Fireafy shippers - you want Firey and Leafy to interact again, right? Then why do you want Firey eliminated early? At least give him a chance to have character development again. But don't worry, there's not a big chance that he is going to win this time. There are many more characters than there were in BFDI, so what makes you think that he is going to win again?

Why does nobody like this guy anymore? I think he should have made it into the final six instead of Woody. I'm not saying he should win the show again, just that he shouldn't be placed lower than Woody.
Anyway, Firey is a great BFB character and my sixth favorite character of all time. He deserves way more love.
Golf Ball

I am appalled by the people who hate Golf Ball. She is funny, and WOW, she was amazing with spinning the seven balls on her legs. Screw you, Snowball, I care! Brighten up a little!
Although, their conflict was funny, especially when she called his brain small. Thank goodness somebody likes her (cough cough, TB, cough cough). I ship them.
Her elimination was unfair. It should have been reversed!

Golf Ball is really hated, but she shouldn't be. If other contestants were to listen to what she had to say, they would easily have an advantage over the other players.
Her relationship with TB is something other characters (um... not to point fingers, but maybe Pencil, Match, etc.) could not maintain for long.
Woody

I feel bad for Woody, but at least he got development in BFB, especially calming Flower down. Good job! It was also funny how he was simping on TD, and she kicked him. Both of his eliminations were unfair. Why couldn't he be in BFDIA? Why?

Shy boy.
His growth from Season 1 to 3 is so good. I have to appreciate how he went from a hated scaredy-cat to a beloved character who just needs a little push to be less scared.
- DaniloTheDog

He is just great. In the first season, he was just a scaredy-cat. But in BFB, he developed and became one of my favorite characters!
Pen

When Pen got first in the ladder challenge, I immediately loved Pen. His cap is cool. If Pen doesn't win, then I'm going to panic, but he is still in the game, so GO PEN.

Pen is one of my favorite characters. He is cool and has good moments like everyone else.

The reason why I also like Pen is because I love using this object. That's why I'm rooting for him in TPOT!
Spongy

THIS BRO IS SO ROBBED, DUDE...
I get so mad knowing that Spongy will likely take way too long to get the attention he deserves, because almost every time he is on screen, he is either hated, ignored, bullied, or mocked. Spongy totally deserves more love and more friends.
If he got an arc in a future season where some characters genuinely appreciated him as a friend, I would be happy again.
My favorite character, hands down.
- DaniloTheDog

Spongy can be the oddball. He is helpful in most cases too. I didn't see him winning, but he still is strong, heavy, and fast. He's just not energetic enough, but I still like him.

The Newcomers

?
Rose

I am appalled by the people who hate Rose.
?
Sidewalky

Fantastic character throughout the whole BFDIE. I raged at the moment that he lost BFDIE to Fern that I hate and 2nd Place is all I ever get But I wouldn't mind Sticker winning after him. Sticker is only #2 in Best BFDIE Character list because of his epic scenes, and I appreciate that. But I swear Sidewalky needs to be #1 in the list. If you hate him, then you're hated. I dreamed about SIDEWALKY winning BFDIE but it did NOT come true. Fern won and I hate 2nd Place more than any rank in anything! And in the same way, He needs to be 1st in this prime list!

The Contenders

Yellow Face

Love him! He's so silly! I don't get the complaints about him "being racist" and "stealing limbs" since those scenes are very funny.

Everyone loves Yellow Face. He's an awesome character.

Yellow Face is the best because he has no arms and legs.
Rocky

He's just my favorite. Him being mindless is just so funny.
Plus, the episode where Rocky barfed in his cake is hilarious. He somehow got second-best cake! Honestly, he should have won Dream Island. It would be great to see him barf on everyone he accepts on the Island.

Rocky is just awesome. His agreeing noise is awesome, his barf is awesome, his smile is awesome. Everything about him is just awesome.
I'm surprised that he almost always comes second to Puffball in the prize competition!

Rocky is a funny character. Even though he barfs a lot, he makes me laugh. Rocky is kinda cute, I think.
Ice Cube

Ice Cube's revenge is awesome, and she is funny. I love her friendships!
Although she isn't my favorite character, people are lucky if she's their favorite. I don't know why some people hate her! WHY! Explain! Her elimination was so unfair. Geez, can't you get an AC or something? Or vote Spongy off? Thank goodness someone did. (Pin)

I love Ice Cube. She is adorable when she is tiny. She is also talking more in TPOT. Let's hope she can get improved. Of course she will. She just needs a storyline and more dialogue (with different words).
She is my favorite in TPOT. I hope she wins. If not win, at least she does not get eliminated early. Why so much hate? Go Ice Cube! You can do this! Do this for BRACELETY! (Even though I dislike her)
Lollipop

I like Lollipop because she has an epic rivalry with Barf Bag, which was pretty awesome, if you ask me. I also really feel bad for her after what happened in episode two. I swear, after I watched that, it left me heartbroken. From now on, I don't even play Find the Markers on Roblox. Overall, she's a pretty good character.

Lollipop is another character that I want to see more development for, yet she was ruined by BFB (like Gelatin). She had so much screen time after the pre-split. Her pairing with Gelatin actually goes well and still has potential to make her a normal character (like normal humans).
Pin

Pin is my absolute favorite character. I can see why some people may dislike her. She's bossy, violent in certain scenes, and could be seen as annoying to some viewers, and that's chill.
She was super entertaining to see in season 2 for me, and we really got to see what she's capable of. Her interactions with Leafy were really hilarious to watch. It was a shame seeing Coiny surpass her, but good on him.
While I think that her season 2 villain arc was her prime appearance in the series, she's just as awesome in the other seasons. By season 3, she's a lot nicer to others, getting on good terms with her previous enemies from season 1, Golf Ball and Tennis Ball, and acting friendly towards Fries, though the gesture does end up annoying him.
By season 5, Pin develops a sense of self-righteousness and integrity. She worries about ideas her team comes up with that she thinks could be impractical or risky, like when she accuses her team of cheating by trying to use glue to hold their stack of blocks together to prevent them from falling. This is a reminder that this is the same girl who drilled a hole through Book's face just to get immunity for a challenge.
She struggles when losing Coiny, but she doesn't let that hold her back, and she continues on through the show. When she gets eliminated, she acts maturely, thanking Tree for being beside her during Seasonal Shift, when the world was expected to end, and giving him her yellow token. Pin is truly amazing. Love her.
Flower

Flower is the best character in the BFDI franchise. She's beautiful, won BFB, funny, and an independent, unique character. She's much more of a standout compared to the other bland characters, and she has great development throughout the show. However, she doesn't change her whole personality, which makes her awesome!

Flower is mixed, but I think she is alright. BFB After-Split kinda ruined her, but I do see some development later on if she gets featured in more seasons.
I just wish they could develop her even more as a character since she is a popular and infamous character ever since winning the BFB.
Coiny

Coiny may not be my favorite character really, but he's a classic. Like I said, a Firey slapper never hates a character, and this is true. I really like his friendship with Pin and it's so cute, making him my second favorite Season 1 character right after Announcer. Great character!

Coiny is definitely the best TPOT contestant. I can't believe he started out ONLY slapping Firey and now has turned out to be this fun, kind, and easy-going contestant. In case you are wondering, I think he belongs with Pin, not Needy.
Pencil

Although Pencil is my favorite character, I can see why people hate her. She should stop abusing Bubble. Pencil had so much potential in BFDI. For example, she told Snowball that he shouldn't be going around killing people with his finger. Too bad she got eliminated 16th, though. It should've been Spongy. Her friendship with Match was amazing, and her alliance with Bubble and Ice Cube was fun.
This is the Pencil we need. At first, I didn't get why Pencil was eliminated first in BFB, but now I do. I still wish it were Fanny, though. I don't blame her for what happened to Match and Bubble's interactions. I blame the writers. Since when does she do these things:
1. Become a hypocrite by using a contestant to hurt people, especially when they clearly DON'T want to do it.
2. Become bossy, stern, and mean to her alliance members (especially Bubble) instead of helping them in need.
3. Demote her alliance members! Whoever thought of that deserves a big thumbs down!
Since when? The writers just ruined her, that's all. No need for hatred. This is why she is still my favorite character. The same goes for Bridgette in Total Drama. Both deserve way better. Even Dora and Spongy get more play, and they're the worst characters! Next time, before you hate, think about their past actions. Maybe they were forced to change badly. Overall, I think she is a great character and can return with Match for a new season, as long as they don't ruin them like in BFB. We need some more love for Pencil, guys.
Gelatin

Honestly, there's no joke about how Gelatin was the runner-up. He has a personality that's similar to Pen, and he's friends with TD and Lollipop, which I like.
I also like the line, "There isn't enough room up here. - That's Better," because it's hilarious and fun.

Same as Lollipop, but even better. His sassy vibes are one thing I like about him. He was amazing in BFB 30. Number 3 overall, in my opinion.

Gelatin is the all-time BEST character in BFB. He was kinda bland in BFDIA but improved a lot.
I can't believe that Flower won. Gelatin will always be my favorite character.
Blocky

Blocky is pretty cool. I love the Blocky Funny Doings International ads because they are incredibly funny and humorous.

I like Blocky because I love Blocky's Funny Doings International. Blocky's Funny Doings International makes me laugh.

He is awesome. Pranks. Blocky's Funny Doings International. How could you not like this little prankster?
Needle

SUPER UNDERRATED!!! She's not ENTIRELY my favourite, but not only that, she's stepped into a lot of challenges in BFDIA. I know you guys would probably vote for Book to win, but Book is just really getting bullied by other contestants. But remember the Needle and Pencil conversation? Maybe Pencil was right. But let's ALL congratulate Needle for being in the final 2. LET HER WIN.

Needle is the best character in my opinion. She is lucky because she is in first place on my list of favorite BFB characters. She is really nice and kind too.
Snowball

This guy is extremely underrated. Sure, he's a jerk, but he just acts so stupid and goofy that he's bound to screw things up in the stupidest ways possible. That's what makes him funny.
And who can forget the most legendary line ever said in BFDI...
"NOOO..."

He was just putting the game into his head too much, but he is nice outside of the game. I mean, he helped Rocky before the game started. I guess the game just got to him.

He's a jerk, but most of the time when he's being one, he just makes himself look like an idiot, which I find absolutely hilarious.
Fries

This guy definitely deserves to be mentioned here. He's a pretty slick guy who experienced lots of deaths during BFDIA (e.g., being kicked into an incinerator and poisoned by a bug).
Regardless, he is a pretty cool character who definitely deserves to be mentioned here.

"Get digging. The ingredients are probably underground." Best line.
Eraser

Needle is a pointless slapper, Teardrop has no character, and we know that David and Rocky are home characters. However, Eraser is next level. Maybe he was supposed to be a kid of Pen and Snowball, but that didn't really work out, NOW DID IT? All he does is copy whatever his clique does and is SUCH a follower, making him THE worst character in my opinion.

Eraser's jokes make him funny. He is number 10 overall in my opinion.
Bubble was so close to being in the Top 10, but due to Eraser, she is not there.

He's honestly a really good character in my opinion. Him joining Free Food in BFB because he heard Yellow Face say it makes me laugh.
Bomby

Needs to be 1st place. Here's a few reasons.
1: He's cool.
2: He's the true winner of BFDIA.
3: He's not a bad character.
4: He's cute.
Overall: Underrated.
He could be in 1st place for now!

He's an adorable character who took part in BFDIA.
Bomby is underrated, and he deserves to be the star of the show.
Bomby will be a top contender.