Top 10 Best Creepypastas of All Time

booklover1
To people who don't know what a CreepyPasta is, let me explain. A CreepyPasta is a short story that is posted on the internet that is designed to unnerve and shock the reader. I looked high and low for the best of the best, and here they are. Let's begin.

The Top Ten

1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

Jeff the Killer was the first creepypasta I'd ever read, and boy was that a mistake for the first time. When I read it my mom and brother were at the park, I am almost never home alone so I took this as a chance to read something scary. Well I didn't mean horrifying, when I first read it I stood there and thought this isn't scary and then turned to Jeff Returns, that's where I started to get freaked out. I imediatly shut off the computer and ran into my bed room (taking my three dogs, two of which were very large and guard dogs) Then I turned on childrens T.V. and read some romance novel, anything to get my mind off of it. Because the more you think of it, the more it haunts you.

By far the best creepypasta I've read, the picture is pretty creepy as well... GO TO SLEEP

Jeff is the best! His story almost made me poop my pants! The picture traumatized me! I haven't been able to sleep for more than 3 months! I'm always afraid that he's in a dark area waiting for me... He's in my nightmares. I even think I've seen him once! He cut a scar into my arm that made me pass out! He must have thought I died from it! He's tots the best!

I find that this is complete bull seeing how jeff isn't real no creepypastas are real they are all fakes now I feel you should turn off your device before you spit out even more bull nobody believes he is real so just stop

Jeff the killer is one of the worst creepypastas and is not worth the hype. The story is unrealistic and very poor written.
I mean, how could he cuts his eyelids without burning his eyes? Why the hell would you cut your eyelids?! If you were not to blink, your eyes will be dried out and you could become blind.
How could your skin turn white after you got burned? Fire does not cause your skin pale!
Also, the thing that digusts me the most is this picture. The original photo was a a picture of a girl who had commited suicide, but some people edited the picture of this girl and made it to a monster! (aka this picture here)
Lastly, how could a thirteen year old child have the motivation to become insane and killing people? He is too overpowered and he could have been able to kill his own dad at the age of 13!
Conclusion: Jeff the Killer is a try hard who's story is written too fast.
P-S: "Go to sleep" is the worst catchphrase I have heard in my life. See you in hell!

400 Comments
2 BEN Drowned BEN Drowned

BEN is a figure who takes on the form of the Elegy of Emptiness statue of Link's human form in the title: The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask. The writer is terrified by this entity because it seemingly haunts the game cartridge in a way that makes the victim of this pasta feel alone, hopeless and trapped. The reason this creepypasta belongs near the top is because it is a good read, it is very believable (contains videos), it is quite lengthy, and it goes into great detail with the characters, settings and events, allowing you to paint a vivid picture in your head. I highly recommend reading this one.

The first creepypasta I ever read, and might I say the best. This thing creeped me out for a long time due to the fact I am a big legend of zelda fan. Because of that fact (and the fact I had recently beat Majora's Mask when I read this thing) it scared me even more to know it could be haunted. It is also one of the most realistic ones I've seen. In my opinion it should be the top. All thanks to Mr. Alex Hall (aka Jadusable: aka the writer of this creepypasta)

A very long but amazing story with a whole bunch of videos. - booklover1

Sorry but I have seen better creepypastas, in my 15 long years of being a fan of them - drooper

190 Comments
3 Slender Man

The ongoing series by the Marble Hornets creates an atmosphere of a documentary, making it seemingly more believable than many other creepypasta's I've seen. With well done filmwork, and a very interesting, mysterious, and unnerving story, this will leave you looking out the window, fearing something is watching you, overall, making me like Slender Man the best.

Really love this story, got me into creepypasta and is more believable than others

Really?! Jeff the killer is one of the few CreepyPastas that follow real life physics. Slenderman is not one of them.

It is Not at all scary just dumb there are better creepypastas that exist - drooper

I think Slender Man is the best creepypasta do you agree

Sorry but I have seen better creepypastas, in my 15 long years of being a fan of them - drooper

132 Comments
4 The Russian Sleep Experiment

While reading The Russian Sleep Experiment I felt myself get physically unhealthy. I grew dizzier and my breathing seemed to grow difficult, possibly as and attempt to hold back vomiting. Repeatedly I said "Oh my god. " It's literally horrifying not only the gore described but for me more some of the things said through those undergoing the experiment. I don't know if I'd recommend reading it or never reading it but it's the best creepypasta.

Not the first creepypasta I've ever read and not the last, but certainly one of the best. The descriptions of the victims are wonderfully nauseating. This is certainly worth a read if you don't want to sleep at night (or should I say, DO want to sleep... )

It is Not at all scary just dumb there are better creepypastas that exist - drooper

I love this creepypasta. It's extremely descriptive and gross, but never bores the reader. It's not as scary as some others I've read, but it's the most disturbing (tied with 'Cupcakes. ')

Give it a read! It's worth your time

109 Comments
5 Squidward's Suicide

O. O Of all the mind-numbingly creepy material I have seen and read over the years, this creepypasta disturbed me the most. They describe the scenes in this story so well, putting brain-assaulting images in your head that are difficult to remove. One of them being the picture. And, having seen many episodes of Spongebob as a kid, all those memories of our good spongey friend and his aquaintences have been pooed all over. I will never look at Spongebob and Squidward especially the same way again, and after reading this creepypasta, neither will you.

This is the first one I've ever heard, and I never read a better one ever since. Scary, yet a good quality read. - booklover1

It is Not at all scary just dumb there are better creepypastas that exist - drooper

Don't ASK WHO JOE IS - purpleyoshi98

77 Comments
6 Eyeless Jack Eyeless Jack

I LOVE Eyeless Jack :P I think he needs to be in the top ten :) I don't know why but I just love Creepypasta and all of these stories... You can thank my friend for getting me obsessed in these stories! Anyways, I really want this story to win but my choice came down to Slenderman, The Rake, and Eyeless Jack :) All of them need to be in the top ten!

My favorite creepypasta

It is Not at all scary just dumb there are better creepypastas that exist - drooper

Just my favorite creepy pasta plus is awesome

86 Comments
7 The Rake The Rake

I couldn't sleep for nights after reading this. I just kept looking at the end of my bed the hell out.

I'm so terrified after I played the game... I don't like it... I can barely sleep, screw Jeff this thing scared the living crap out of me

I love the rake

It is Not at all scary just overrated - drooper

88 Comments
8 Smile Dog Smile Dog

Imma can of him be cause he talks for slender man and he hangs people I love that stuff

It is Not at all scary just overrated - drooper

This dog is disturbed

I love this

53 Comments
9 Laughing Jack Laughing Jack

Pennywise and laughing Jack must be related some how or just a really good ship - Deathisme

Laughing Jack has always interested me more then the other Creepypasta's. I was a little disturbed when I learned he prayed on small children, but otherwise he seems like one of my favorites.

I love him like love love him - LaylaHangedLH

Most disturbing ever. Screw Jeff's fat mouth. This guy makes Penny jealous. - TriggerTrashKid

108 Comments
10 Suicidemouse.avi

It is Not at all scary - drooper

Scary As Heck That Made Me Stop Watching Micky Mouse

This is an amazing creation and a crazy video, because in all honesty, this story has a suicidal Mickey Mouse, and that's not new! Back when Walt Disney was still designing the comics, he had one artist make a sad and horrible comic of Mickey losing Minnie and making three attempts at his life which were all comically foiled. This comic strip surely inspired the idea of this creepypasta, and is slightly disturbing to realize Mickey WAS suicidal! The worst part of the true fact is the third time he tried he turned on the gas pipe in his house so he would run out of oxygen, which is exactly how Walt Disney's mother died, he had attempted to fix a gas problem and she asphyxiated a few weeks later, and this morbid death was incorporated in his comic! Walt Disney by himself with what he's done is almost just as disturbing as a fake story!

I saw this on youtube (most anmzing top ten) and so I was with a friend and I watched it with him on youtube witch if you look it up there is a animation 4 it and I all most peed my pants

18 Comments

The Contenders

11 Penpal

Amazing story that really sticks with you. My favorite so far.

It's refreshing and would be the face of creepy pastas if not for the tumblr fans that wet themselves for Jeff the killer (in more ways than fear...). That's why he is so popular... fan girls.

Jeff the killer is trash this is good

There's a reason behind why this was made into a novel. It's a masterpiece, better than most creepypastas like Jeff the Killer and Ben Drowned.

39 Comments
12 1999

What makes this creepypasta so good is not that it's scary, but just so convincing and creates a sense that this story may have happened. It really dives into the realms of disturbing and the sick, demented mind of a pedophile that creates a local channel for little kids, just so he can lure them into his house, torture them, and sacrifice them. There are a plot holes, especially when the parents of these kids that are lured into the house don't even bother that their kids are missing. But it's a well-written story with great suspense and goes into the mind of a kid watching the show, almost being lured into the house, and how his childhood was much darker than he remembered it years later.

The most well writen creepypasta.

As a kid, this gave me nightmares. Well-written, but messed up. Why do people write about children, though? Stop. But it is realistic and less cheesy than most ones I've read like the RSE and BEN drowned and Jeff the Killer, Mothers call, etc.

It's brilliant. Jeff is rubbish compared to it. Happy Apply copied this in a stupider way. It's a must read - the first one I ever read and the best. It's really convincing. Not for the faint hearted... Just remember. Never watch Channel 21.

41 Comments
13 Abandoned by Disney

That Mickey Mouse though, scared the crap out of me. - SackofCheese

Pretty creepy. Not going to lie though, I liked it better up until the very end when they went overkill on the blood.

Oh so scary at first then it wasn't scarry, " "Hey, " it said in a hushed, perverted, but perfectly executed Mickey Mouse voice, "Wanna see my head come off? "

It started to pull at its own head, working its clumsy, glove-clad fingers around its neck with clawing, impatient movements similar to a wounded man trying to pull himself free of a predator's jaws...

As it worked its digits into its neck... So much blood...

So much thick, chunky, yellow blood... " THAT was my favorite part when I first read it.

The feeling of foreboding left me unprepared for the ending. A recommended read for anyone who wants to read quintessential creepy pasta.

54 Comments
14 Psychosis

It's long but its worth a read. This is a great story to show a journey to insanity. It reminds us how fragile the human mind is. You keep on thinking again and again if he was insane or if some kind of entity was after him and that if the whole human race was really all dead... Or worse. What makes this story so amazing was the twist of the ending but you have to think a little more to realize that twist. The thought of something after him, the fear and who to trust, the story really let me experience that. Not sure with everyone else. I'm not scared of it much thanks to reading it about more than 5 times. I recommend this story. It blew me away when I read the ending. I discovered this story while going through YouTube and I'm happy I did. When I first read it... At night by the way... Around midnight. I was scared. It was written with a talented use of grammar and words too.

*spoiler? *
*spoiler :P*
*last spoiler alert*

It's funny though...
How his insanity ...more

Stuff like slender man and Jeff the killer are just bad like poorly written trash but this is some really good psychological horror that works well.

It's so creepy! The ending is insane! Why isn't this in the top 10?

The doctor read the paper the patient had scribbled on. It was barely readable, written in the shaky script of one who could not see. He wanted to smile at the man's steadfast resolve, a reminder of the human will to survive, but he knew that the patien was delusional.
After all, a sane man would have fallen for the deception long ago.
The doctor wanted to smile. He wanted to wisper words of encouragement to the delusional man. He wanted to scream, but the nerve filaments wrapped around his head and into his eyes made him do otherwise.
His body walked into the cell like a puppet, and told the patient, once more, that he was wrong, that there was nobody trying to deceive him. - RegularCrapMan

20 Comments
15 Ticci Toby Ticci Toby

This is my favorite but I just want to say something. Fangirls. The one thing that ruins a good Creepypasta story. From Jeff to Toby to Ben to everyone who is a creepypasta is ruined by fangirls. Like this comment to eradicate fangirls.

Toby is awesome

He is the best, he should be number 1

Needs to be in top five

86 Comments
16 NES Godzilla Creepypasta

This should be number one this and the Russian sleep experiment were the only creepypastas that actually scared me

It's not just a creepypasta to me, it's a novel. A story about a boy who got a shoddy copy of Godzilla: Monster of Monsters that directly involved a demon and his dead girlfriend is excellent! The images are well made and very convincing, Red is a genuinely creepy antagonist and the story was constructed superbly! Massive props to the writer for creating this masterpiece of a story! - Noah_Infinity

MELISSA

I'd read creepypastas before, but this is the creepypasta that got me into creepypastas! I find it odd that so many people didn't like the ending, because the story did such a good job of building your hatred and anger for the villain that it was really, REALLY great to see the little bastard get his comeuppance at the end! I wish I could have viewed the sequel, but either it isn't posted yet or I just can't find it anywhere.

16 Comments
17 Lavender Town Syndrome

Lavender town maybe a littlebit creepy like the ghost and others but the worst part is the song. They say it cause suicides. CREEPY! And this song has been stuck in my head for days until it stops every time I listen to it it will never get out of my head until I ethier wait until its gone or listen to some other music or watch some T.V. to get it out of my mind. Oh yea one more thing I know this is not a real creepypasta but its called creepypastaphoebia. Its where if you read a certain creepypasta you will be scared. The common ones are you can't sleep, nightmares, look everywhere, and other ones. Some are exclusive like for an example say if you read a squidwards suicide creepypasta and if you look at the photo and you ethier can't look at squidward or if you see a toy of him you use something to destroy it. And that's why I like the pokemon lavender town creepypasta.

I'm never playing Pokemon again. - TriggerTrashKid

Lavender Town is a true Creepypasta about a song in a Pokemon game. The creators of the ghost-like town wished to make the music creepier and different for said area. Little did they know that it contained low tones. Because children's/teenager's ears are less-developed than adult's, they can hear them. It took a while for people to realize, unfortunately. Realize the connection between player's suicide when they reached that part of the game, if they wore headphones or ear buds. Not every child killed themselves, though. Some developed mental health problems. As in Schizophrenia, or similar. When the connection was made, they called all the games back in and changed the music. Yet copies are all over the internet or YouTube. If you are stupid enough to listen, then try Missing Frequencies. This is an edited version, and is 10 times worse. As the song progresses, they add different layers. This is known to cause headaches within 10 seconds, so be very careful.

I'm listening to the Missing Frequencies edition right now and it's creeping me out a lot. - IceFoxPlayz

It is the most creepy one. Really!

37 Comments
18 Candle Cove

I literally want this to be a real show! - SaphireStorm

I read this before I realized that it was fictional creepypasta. When you read of it that way everything just gets loads more creepy. Oh, and when accompanied by that candle cove video on YouTube? Made it even more awesome.

It's creepy as hell I did not sleep in sunday

This story kept me up for nights after reading it! So creepy and eerie!

33 Comments
19 Normal Porn for Normal People

No no never a gain - nicoleking

Incredibly creepy and underrated... The thought of a psychotic killer posting porn to the internet sends chills up my spine. Also incredibly convincing.

This one was really good. One of my favorites. - shiftaltkey

This story is very interesting, convincing and well thought out. It was also a good combination of bizarre and unsettling, and the author did a good job at making it believable; I usually think of things featured in creepypastas as being a pile of nonsense, but I actually thought the videos were real.

30 Comments
20 Cupcakes

I would not count the story as a creepypasta - drooper

Scary has heck

Worst creepypasta of all time. - XtheXlmao

This is too gory - ElSherlock

50 Comments
21 Jane the Killer Jane the Killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

Like most creepypastas jane is good not evil but she wants revenge

Should be number 1 because of her sexiness - awesomeguy101

Jane The Killer is the best of the best and deserves to be number one because in almost every story she kills jeff and her story creeped me out but she is the best go jane if you don't agree remember this is just my opinion

She deserts more credit. She nearly kills Jeff the killer and gave birth to his child!

22 Comments
22 Borrasca

I absolutely love this one! Every second I was completely enthralled.

It's so worth the listen. Take 2 and a half hours to yourself, turn off the lights, and enjoy.

This was hands down one of my favorite creepypastas providing an amazing story that kept me hooked to the end

This creepypasta is the best one ever by the best person ever, it should be number one

4 Comments
23 Masky

I like him as a creepy pasta and I could just say ever girl out
There that likes masky always wonders what he looks like
Underneath that mask. One thing I don't like is that he is one of slenders
Goon. ( fact ) his real name is Tim

Honestly people should stop spouting the 'he isn't a creepypasta', shut up and do your research. Creepypasta is defined as horror stories on the internet, and oh wow guess what, videos are visually telling a story! Who knew? Saying that he isn't a creepypasta and Marble Hornets isn't because it's not a original and based off the slenderman, newsflash: a hell of a lot of creepypastas are based off another, like Jane the Killer! They took the authors original Slenderman work and made videos for it, and added characters to it, and is widely accepted as having the best representation of the slenderman, and if you research the slenderman most sites, Slenders' official wikia for example, will include the authors original idea and that of Marble Hornets, and since they just used all the true information on the Slenderman, it's adding onto that of the original creepypasta. Masky, and his Partner Hoodie, need to be more recognized as actual creepypastas!

Masky is a brilliant character from the channel MarbleHornets. I am actually quite scared of his character as he is shown to appear out of no where and is very aggressive. MarbleHornets was presented amazingly, seemed so real. I don't know how many times I have been jumped scared by Masky appearing around the corner in the videos. Masky also scares me as where ever he is, slenderman is sure to be close by. As well as he can easily tackle you and even kill you. The whole concept of him being anywhere anytime by him being teleported around by slenderman actually makes me paranoid and creeps me out.

Okay. I died a little from listening to his voice thing... It made me love him and not be scared of him... The funny thing is most of the voice things make me love them more than be scared of them.

14 Comments
24 The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen

How is he able to warp time? - RegularCrapMan

It's actually so creepy but very interesting

I was so curious as to what the picture in the security camera looked like that I looked it up on msn. It's freaky!

I've seen and read and listened to someone read it and man. Was I spooked by how realistic it seemed to be. God please don't tell me this is actually real!

It's a little creepy but mostly really weird and interesting. Time loops...

6 Comments
25 Herobrine

Herobrine is not really scary and he's a fun boss to beat in Minecraft but you should see 01g's videos

Herobrine should be added as the final boss mob, and use a gun as its weapon.

Ruined minecraft. - TriggerTrashKid

Badass

39 Comments
26 The Tunnel

It's a little cheesy, but it's pretty scary, especially what happens during and after the encounter of the tunnel. - booklover1

Holy crap, that was surprisingly good...

I read it, and I didn't want to go into any more abandoned tunnels. - username34

I have never heard of it.

1 Comment
27 Zalgo Zalgo

Looks so good - ElSherlock

I think he should be top 10

Zalgo is underdeveloped and thus under appreciated. Once he gets a few good pastas going for him, instead of just the short comics, he should pick up in popularity, especially since he already has a clear and menacing description, even if it doesn't explain much about him as a being.

Zalgo is Powerful interesting in hell
Zalgo island is here in Hell
Zalgo is Unstoppable in hell
Zalgo food is Bloody Death
Zalgo can't be Kill
Zalgo is Here he Here to stay

10 Comments
28 Hoodie

Personally my favorite Creepypasta/Marble Hornets character. - MikeandZoey

I love hoodie! Even though he's just a proxy, he's awesome! He stalks you, then bashes your head in with a brick. And all you see of him is glowing red eyes and a stitched closed mouth. He is epic!

I didn't know hoodies story but just by reading "He stalks you, then bashes your head in with a brick." I couldn't stop laughing. SO NOW HE ONE OF MY FAVOURITE CREEPYPASTAS!

Again, going to say this character was a great creepypasta and is actually terrifying, and yes, he is a creepypasta, because he is from an Internet based horror story, thank you very much, and creepypasta's aren't always short. Saying that they aren't creepypastas because they aren't original is so messed and wrong because they used the original idea and expanded on it and used the facts of it and made Slenderman so much more popular.

15 Comments
29 NoEndHouse

This is the REASON I WATCH CREEPYPASTAS

That was so good! But still really creepy @ the same time. Its really well written and it is something you can really call creepy! It was disturbing @ some points but that is what you should expect from a good creepypasta! The best creepypasta I have read by far! I love it!

This was an -amazing- pasta, especially compared to some of the horribly written ones ranked above it. Some typos and stilted suspense part of the way through, but really? Why the hell is this #30?!? AWESOME PASTAS ARE AWESOME.

This is something we can call as creepy. Its excellently written. Something that really gives you creeps. Plus, the subject is somewhat different. No video games or lost episodes stuff. My opinion? I ♥ it

15 Comments
30 Luna Game

I feel like the Luna game has a good concept. But it's more hilarious than it is scary. The fact that it traps your computer and forces you to keep playing is pretty good though. But the pictures that pop up several times aren't creepy until you stare at them for a while.

I hate My Little Pony but I have to say...
This story is more hilarious than it is scary

Not scary at all! Suck it, bronies!

As much hate as this comment is getting, this is not scary at all. There are so many cliches, it is unbearable! - GREATEST

LOVE

1 Comment
31 The Harbinger Experiment

WHY IS THIS ONLY AT #31! THIS SHOULD BE #1, IT'S THE BEST CREEPYPASTA EVER!

THE BEST(aside from scp)

That song sounds like 60s AC/DC lol. That song it sounds like this: oahoaaoaooahaohaoahaoaho. I learned about this on amazon prime the stuff called role play Creepypasta it’s epic. There is also an scp that I now watch. I watched all the rp Creepypasta episodes.

Long but worth it.

2 Comments
32 My Little Pony Theory

This really is a wonderfully creepy idea of what could be the basis behind an awesome show. Although it's a little heart wrenching for me to think that some of my favorite characters were based of these poor girls.

When I first saw this as a creepypasta I thought it was going to be bad but when I read it made absolutely sad because they all died in terrible ways definitely deserves to be higher it's my favorite creepypasta and I've read a ton of them

So sad, I cried. My eyes were bloodshot I cried so much. I've read a lot of creepypastas, but this wins the award for saddest.

I cried so much when I read this it is just absolutely heartbreaking how they all died and another piece of advice don't read this while listening to (Don't Fear) The Reaper it makes it worse

9 Comments
33 SlenderMan SlenderMan The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Slenderman is way better than enderman, the enderman isn't even a creepypasta. - nintendofan126

He is definitely the best. he can be invisible, if you look at him you go mentally insane, people who are near him get a sickness which causes them to vomit and hallucinate, he teleports, he can hypnotize people, he can take control of you AND SO ON.

How can anyone not like Slendy? He's faceless and anyone who sees him comes up missing without a trace and are never heard from again. And he's a supernatural being, so he can't die.

I don't get how he is not in the first place he is like the creepyest

1 Comment
34 Come Follow Me

There is no words to describe this pasta. But, lets just say I very do think this pasta should be in the top ten. I don't think I have read anything more horrifying then this story. So I think you should totally read this story, but I warn you it may give you nightmares.

A very thrilling Pokemon creepypasta. Was fun to read.

So freaky... I couldn't sleep...

I literally feel sick after reading this. I swear ill never touch a Pokemon game in my life EVER

1 Comment
35 Lost Silver

Literally, I read his story everyday - ethanlikescreepypasta

An amazing creepypasta about the inevadibility of death. It truly raises questions, not to mention has several alternate endings.

I like this one. It raises questions, and has good buildup. Also, it has lots of great symbolism. Gold dying in the ends symbolizes the death of the Gameboy Pokemon games. The number of badges increases like the number of pixels 8 first, as 8 bit. Then, it goes to 16, then 24, and so on... Those are all other multiples of eight. The increasing number also acts as a grim reminder that everything you do... Doesn't matter because someone will surpass you, and you will die. Your accomplishments don't change that, - GREATEST

I love this story so much! It deserves to be first on tip ten. It is creepy, exciting and when it ends it leaves thoughts and questions bouncing around in your head.

17 Comments
36 Hope is Lost

Hope is lost creepy pasta is where spongekiller kill everyone by death by 74

This most scariest SpongeBob SquarePants lost episode I did seen because it's under rated this well written and well spoken creepypasta lost episode this episode is scarier than Squidward's suicide. Also, Plankton got served was another scary lost episode creepypasta

The only truly creepy SpongeBob pasta.

That one creeped me out a lot

1 Comment
37 Burgrr Entries
38 The Rugrats Theory

The song dude..

This has too many plot holes - ElSherlock

Falls into theory but makes you think twice about watching kid cartoons. They can make even adults scream in fright

This theory is so fake, one hole in the theory's logic is that there have been Rugrats episodes WITHOUT Angelica. - CommentandList

3 Comments
39 Jeff the Killer vs Jane the Killer

It is a very well written story and I don't totally blame Jane for wanting to get even with Jeff. I would want revenge too if someone killed my family. However, everyone, including Jeff's family, forget what Jeff went through. They never even considered what Randy, Keith, and Troy did to him, which is what made him what he is today. And Jeff does eventually regret killing his family, especially Liu, whom he once fought to protect, so he can't be all bad.

I love this one. I always like when there is a girl version of something and they go against each other. I love how you can feel the anger of jane when you read her story. Well at least I did.

I love the story but jane do you really think that killing people jeff will get mad but still a good story its awesome

I read both there storys. I see why jane hates him. Both storys are actily around the same story in some parts. I love the story line.

8 Comments
40 Robert the Doll

This isn't a Creepypasta! This is a real doll! Don't mistake real life for fiction! - SaphireStorm

Screw Annabelle, this doll is actually horrifying.

The best one - ElSherlock

I wanna go see it at the museum - blackflower

5 Comments
41 Phineas' Suicide

I love creepypasta I love this one It is going to become number 1

Why you do this you ruined my childhood

Why did you put this in here. - SackofCheese

MY CHILDHOOD IS GONE!

7 Comments
42 Jeff is Back

It's crap - TriggerTrashKid

What the hell? Why is it right down at 114? It's a good Creepypasta In fact, I daresay it's better than the original. It makes a lot more sense, and is a lot creepier. But it's easier to get creeped out by the video, rather than by just reading it.

Fangirls are annoying... but what can I say?

This was one of the best what I don't get thought is the Jeff the killer fan girls who have crushes on him? Personaly I love the story its self so horrifying almost as good as the first

4 Comments
43 Where bad kids go

He went back to find his scarring childhood memories and found horror. This one is quite terrifying with its implications

When the Creepypasta said that's were the bad kids go, I started laughing so hard.

Love this one! It's very underrated. It's also very very short. One of my favorites.

I love this oneand its one that I have always rememberd

1 Comment
44 Anasi's Goatman Story

There are a ton of underrated creepypasta on this list, but this really surprised me to see it down so low on the list. Especially behind the tons of Jeff the Killers and Slenderman stories. This story is so well written, and feels realistic! Read it, it's worth it even though it's long.

WHAT IS GOATMAN DOING DOWN HERE! I know it's not as well known as some of the others, but I've never been scared more by a creepypasta than goatman. Plus, there isn't even gore, and it's still scary.

Almost as good as my top 3 (1999, Rap Rat and Dating Game) and pretty damn awesome. Deserves to be top 10!

I would rather stay at a Hilton with Slenderman than this thing... I am literally crying after listening to it

45 How To Play Hide And Seek Alone

Scary as hell!

This sounds like a lonly boi story

I’d never try it - blackflower

46 Jvk1166z.esp

It caused a buzz because it was a virus, or seemed to be. If you tried to load the game with the mod active, it would hang at the initial load screen for a full hour and then crash to the desktop. If you let it get that far, your install of Morrowind, along with any save files you had, would become completely corrupted. Nobody could figure out what the mod was trying to do, since it couldn't be opened in the Construction Set. Eventually, warnings were distributed not to use it if you found it, and things died down.

About a year later, in a mod board I used to frequent, someone popped up with the mod again. He said he was PMed by a lurker who deleted his account immediately after sending. He also said that the person advised him to try playing the mod through DOSbox. For some reason, this worked... sort of. The game was a bit laggy, and you couldn't get into Options, Load Game, the console, or really anything else, other than the game itself. The QuickSave and QuickLoad ...more

47 Funnymouth

One of the creepiest creepypastas I've ever read. I love how it builds up the suspense and then at the end just lets it all out. It's amazing

It's just a very good, interesting and very creepy creepypasta, definitely of of the best I've ever read.

Amazing pasta, but underrated sadly. Definitely one of my favorites. I still have nightmares about it. Should definitely be higher up on this list.

This is a amazing story definitely one of the best, it all subtle (except the end) horror

1 Comment
48 Fallout 3: Numbers Station
49 Ghost

Seriously? everyone knows this lol - XtheXlmao

50 The Story of Her Holding an Orange

Not that good but probably the scariest.

8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters Top Ten Things You Probably Didn't Know About Creepypastas

List StatsCreated 1 Jul 2011
Updated 15 Nov 2019

7,000 votes
411 listings
8 years, 160 days old

Top Remixes (69)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. BEN Drowned
3. Slender Man
Sweetdeathgirl2000
1. BEN Drowned
2. Jeff the Killer
3. Slender Man
BENDROWNED
1. Jeff the Killer
2. Squidward's Suicide
3. The Russian Sleep Experiment
Cry

WRemix
View All 69

Posts

Worst Types of People on the Internet EP-16 Season Finale
SirSkeletorThe3rd

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.