Best CreepyPastas Ever


The Contenders: Page 4

61 The Seedeater

Creepypasta deserves more over rated and don't dare put this creepypasta with fan made stuff like Jeff the killer nor slenderman because, Jeff the killer isn't creepy anymore it could be for some people think it is he just a serial killer that is a human this Seedeater isn't human it's like a Karasu. Also, why isn't the strider is at the top list it deserves more than Seedeater this creepypasta still scare me.

The seedeater eats kids! Need I say more.

It's a good creepypasta but very underappreciated

The Seedeater is almost as scary as ABD e-e

V 6 Comments
62 The Strangest Security Tape I've Ever Seen

It's actually so creepy but very interesting

I was so curious as to what the picture in the security camera looked like that I looked it up on msn. It's freaky!

I've seen and read and listened to someone read it and man. Was I spooked by how realistic it seemed to be. God please don't tell me this is actually real!

It's a little creepy but mostly really weird and interesting. Time loops...

One of the most well-written, creepiest, sci-fi themed creepypastas ever!

V 5 Comments
63 Kingdom Hearts: Cathedral Glitch
64 The Story of Her Holding an Orange

Not that good but probably the scariest.

65 Spongebob Bootleg Episode

Screw that picture! Don't look at it unless you plan on not sleeping!

The only thing creepy about this is the picture. The ending of the story said if you stare into it long enough, you'll see SpongeBob blink. I never want to see that picture again. - booklover1

Damn that picture! Ugh, couldn't sleep for NIGHTS after looking at this picture!

Lmao guys chill the picture is a gif - TheEvilAlpaca

V 13 Comments
66 Emma

This one is slightly different to your average Creepy pasta.

V 1 Comment
67 SCP-173 aka The Sculptor

Even though he isn't my favorite, I am terrified of him. every time you blink he gets closer and closer until he is close enough to snap your neck. He has short limbs and his eyes are just two holes in his head.

This creature should be in the top 10. This is actually more creepy.

68 Gateway of the Mind

This creepypasta is one of the few ones that send shivers down my spine. Maybe it's the reason I am born in religious household? Maybe is the fact that this could actually be something? Anyways, I am not religious anymore but this story is one of the most creepiest I know. It got me thinking and disturbed by the image of getting all the senses away from you... You cannot hear, see, smell, feel or taste anything. That's horrifying. And the last line made the Gateway of the mind.
Please read it if you haven't, it's a lovely short story.

This Creepypasta Could Exist! And It's Terrifying, A Man Hears The Devils Telling Him About Hell and The End Of The World

Really creepy and one of the first and most disturbing I've read. It deseves to be in the top 10

V 1 Comment
69 Ed, Edd n Eddy: The Lost Episode

"Shudder" I could barely get to sleep after reading this. The scariest part is were Johnny (with his eyes missing) crawls out from Sarah's sofa and begins to devour her head.

This is a creepypasta its about the characters killing each other

I wasn't impressed at all by this creepypasta it wasn't that good in my opinion

70 The Truth About Giygas

Please tell me that ist not the thing about the babies

V 1 Comment
71 Jeff the Killer vs Jane the Killer

It is a very well written story and I don't totally blame Jane for wanting to get even with Jeff. I would want revenge too if someone killed my family. However, everyone, including Jeff's family, forget what Jeff went through. They never even considered what Randy, Keith, and Troy did to him, which is what made him what he is today. And Jeff does eventually regret killing his family, especially Liu, whom he once fought to protect, so he can't be all bad.

I love this one. I always like when there is a girl version of something and they go against each other. I love how you can feel the anger of jane when you read her story. Well at least I did.

I love the story but jane do you really think that killing people jeff will get mad but still a good story its awesome

JEFF LOSES because HE SUCK - Andyman234

V 8 Comments
72 The Midnight Man
73 Max And Ruby 0004

This is by far the creepiest thing I have ever read in my whole life. I didn't sleep that night. I had to watch funny cats because I'm soiling myself at the thought of it. Do NOT read it alone in the house at night... Ever...

Ok, I watch the max and ruby 004 video. And I had to with my closet lights on and if it didn't work I had to sleep with my mom. I'm warning you, don't read or watch this at night alone in your house. help me please



74 The Showers

The Showers is so good because it is so creative and well-written. It manages to make you uncomfortable without excessive gore. It is rather long, but it is worth a read.

It should be number one. People only know the mainstream creepypastas, but this has the best story ever. - Gruunge

The teacher is a certain critics Favorite character.

I loved it

V 1 Comment
75 Hetalia 23.5

I love hetalia and I love italy so it very heartbreaking but its still one of the best creepypastas I've read

I couldn't watch Hetalia for MONTHS after I read this. I couldn't belive the rest of Axis turned on Italy like that... :(

V 2 Comments

ALL the BLEED IS BEDDER then the generic that you all are reading? Jeff, Jane, Hoodie, Masky, Slendy, Ravioli ravioli they killed my famiouli, come on dude its generic as hell look at like even more lets see nice kid gets bullied once fights back they get angry and then fight back he turns into a psychotic killer blood, blood, blood. Then lost episodes, found it, got it for free, ohhh cheep, well next period.

V 1 Comment
77 The Scariest Video Game Ever

This one gets you be the throat and strangles you it's so creepy... until the awesome ending. - booklover1

I was laughing so hard at this, the twist at the end was hilarious.

I really like this one, the ending was just, wow. - bestgamer

I can't believe I was pacman all along

V 6 Comments

I saw a particular picture of him 2 times. The first, it started to rain and I freaked out thinking that it was him walking around. The second, while I was doing my homework and the others were asleep, I clearly heard someone toying with some keys.

It makes me feel bad for brvr I mean he has been alone in the dark unable to die or be hurt so I feel bad for the poor little guy

Every time I see the image, I hear noises.


79 Pinkamena

Great read! In my opinion it needs to be in the top 10.

V 2 Comments
80 The Crawlspace
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top Ten Pokemon Creepypastas Top Ten Things You Probably Didn't Know About Creepypastas

List Stats

6,000 votes
377 listings
6 years, 165 days old

Top Remixes (65)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. BEN Drowned
3. Slender Man
1. Jeff the Killer
2. Squidward's Suicide
3. The Russian Sleep Experiment
1. Jeff the Killer
2. Jeff is Back
3. Lost Silver

View All 65


Worst Types of People on the Internet EP-16 Season Finale
WonkeyDude98 (Mini) Analysis: Squidward's Suicide
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.