Top 10 Worst Moments for President's Trophy Winners

Since its inception in the 1985-86 season, the Presidents' Trophy has been awarded to the NHL franchise that finishes the regular season with the best record. But while finishing first in the regular season is a great accomplishment, it doesn't always guarantee success in the Stanley Cup playoffs.

Only eight teams have won both the Presidents' Trophy and the Stanley Cup in the same season, while most Presidents' Trophy winners have seen their dream seasons end without lifting Lord Stanley's Cup. Here are the top 10 most heartbreaking playoff disappointments for the regular-season champions.

The Top Ten
  1. Boston Bruins blow 3-1 series lead to Florida (2023)

    The Bruins set an NHL record for the most wins (65) and points (135) in a single season and were the overwhelming favorites to win the Stanley Cup. In the first round, they jumped out to a 3-1 series lead over the Florida Panthers, but then suffered three straight losses, including two 4-3 decisions in overtime. The loss would also mark the end of the careers of Patrice Bergeron and David Krejci, while the Panthers would make a run all the way to the Stanley Cup Finals.

  2. Tampa Bay Lightning swept by Columbus Blue Jackets (2019)

    The Tampa Bay Lightning tied a then-NHL record with 62 wins and were poised to add their second-ever Stanley Cup following their first in 2004. They were overwhelming favorites to beat the Columbus Blue Jackets in the first round, but in a shocking first, the Lightning became the first Presidents' Trophy winners to get swept in the opening round of the playoffs. It was also the first-ever playoff series victory for the Blue Jackets. Fortunately, Tampa Bay rebounded to win the next two Stanley Cup titles and form a mini-dynasty.

  3. Vancouver Canucks lose in Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Finals (2011)

    It was meant to be Vancouver's year in 2011 when they won 54 games (117 points) and went through the Blackhawks, Predators, and Sharks to reach the Stanley Cup Finals. They would battle the Boston Bruins and split the first six games, winning three tight games at home while getting blown out in Boston. After leading the series 3-2, the Canucks lost Game 6, and in Game 7, they got shut out by the Bruins, 4-0. In a season that saw so much promise and hope, it ended up in flames (LITERALLY, VANCOUVER FANS RIOTED AND SET PARTS OF THE CITY ON FIRE AFTERWARDS).

  4. Pittsburgh Penguins lose Game 7 overtime heartbreaker to deny them three-peat (1993)

    The two-time Stanley Cup champion Penguins were poised to make it three straight years as they battled the New York Islanders. Trailing by two goals late in Game 7, Pittsburgh rallied to tie the score and force overtime, but their dream of a three-peat was ended by New York's David Volek, who scored the series-winning goal to complete the upset.

  5. Detroit Red Wings lose in six-game Conference Finals to Colorado (1996)

    The Red Wings had won a then-NHL-record 62 games and had reached the Western Conference Finals, where they would face their soon-to-be arch-nemesis, the Colorado Avalanche, in their first season after relocating from Quebec. The Avalanche were up 3-2 in the series when the defining moment came in Game 6, as Colorado forward Claude Lemieux hit Red Wings forward Kris Draper from behind into the boards, causing injuries to his face. The Avalanche won the series and went on to win the Stanley Cup, but the Red Wings never forgave Lemieux for his hit and would get their revenge a year later.

  6. Edmonton Oilers lose Game 7 of Smythe Division Finals on own goal (1986)

    The two-time Stanley Cup champion Oilers were the inaugural Presidents' Trophy winners and were poised to win their third straight Stanley Cup title. In Game 7 of the Smythe Division Finals against the Calgary Flames, with the score tied at 2, Oilers defenseman Steve Smith, while trying to make a pass from behind his team's own net, accidentally deflected the puck off goaltender Grant Fuhr and into the net for an own goal. Edmonton was never able to score the equalizer, and their run for a three-peat ended. Though they would win the next two Stanley Cups, one has to wonder if Edmonton would've won five in a row if not for that situation.

  7. Detroit Red Wings swept in Stanley Cup Finals (1995)

    Despite a lockout-shortened season, the Red Wings claimed the Presidents' Trophy and would march to the Stanley Cup Finals, hoping to put an end to a 40-year title drought. They were overwhelming favorites to win the Stanley Cup over the New Jersey Devils, a team that lost to the New York Rangers in seven games the year before. But the Devils swept Detroit in four straight games to clinch their first Stanley Cup title.

  8. Ottawa Senators fall in Game 7 in Eastern Conference Finals to eventual Cup champs (2003)

    Ottawa had gone through the playoffs before meeting the New Jersey Devils in the Eastern Conference Finals. Down 3-1 in the series, Ottawa forced a Game 7, including an overtime winner in Game 6. In the last game, the Devils got the game-winner with 2:14 to go, ending Ottawa's dream of Stanley Cup glory.

  9. New York Rangers fall to Tampa Bay in Game 7 of Eastern Conference Finals (2015)

    Looking to redeem themselves from losing to the Kings in the previous year's Stanley Cup Finals, the Rangers won the Presidents' Trophy in 2015 and survived a five-game series against the Penguins and a tough seven-game battle with the Capitals thanks to their great goaltending of Henrik Lundqvist. New York battled Tampa Bay in the conference finals going all the way to Game 7 in Madison Square Garden, but two third period goals by the Lightning were all that was needed to end the Rangers' quest for redemption.

  10. Vancouver Canucks lose to eight-seed LA Kings, who win it all (2012)

    The Canucks once again finished with the best record in the NHL to earn the Presidents' Trophy and were looking to make another run for the Stanley Cup. They first drew the eighth-seeded Los Angeles Kings in the first round, and to everyone's surprise, Vancouver lost the first three games of the series before bowing out in Game 5. Adding insult to injury, the Kings would go 12-3 for the rest of the playoffs to become the lowest-seeded organization in any sport to win a championship.

BAdd New Item