Top 10 Songs Thought to Be Too Long to Get Radio Play
Back then people thought it was too long because they had not heard Dream Theater songs yet, LOL
Wow, this practice sounds funny and sad at the same time - DJ's bathroom breaks were the best use of a song with a supposed title "In the Garden of Eden"...
It was standard practice for DJ's to put his on whenever they needed a bathroom break or "other" extended absence from the broadcast booth.
You need the full nine minutes every time. Oh, how I hate radio edits!
"Total Eclipse of the Heart" had to be shortened for radio play. Tyler did not believe that the song was radio-friendly at its full length; the song was reduced from seven minutes and two seconds to four minutes and thirty seconds." - wiki
The full song is 4:38 long, so Columbia Records issued a promo 45 with both the full version and an edited version. Almost everyone preferred the full version, and it became a #1 hit on both the pop and the country & western charts.