Top 10 Best Pop-Tarts Flavors

The Top TenXW

1Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon

I love brown sugar cinnamon poptarts! I'm advertising them to get more votes at school and I can't stop eating them they are AWESOME the best! I can't live without them! The first time I tried them my life was never the same again! It is now munch munch better!

Brown sugar an cinnamon became a pantry staple in our house! Coming foe a single parent (mom), single child home that was lower class for some of the time. My mom and I had to "agree" on things we purchased from the grocery store so we could better budget money! She would grab them on the way to work and I on the way to school... Now I am a 38 year old father myself with 3 children of my own that are 9,12,&14 yrs old, and the brown sugar and cinnamon tradition lives on! My wife on the other hand does like pop tarts so she complains that the kids and I take up a complete shelf for the display of the legendary Pop-tarts!

I am ten years old, I still eat poptarts, so does does my twin sister and 12 year old brother, my parents think I am just weird but they are so great, I also love wild berry, I pretend the lines are race tracks so I pretend to race someone, but brown sugar cinnamon, frosted, is still my favorite

Love of my life

V79 Comments

I'm eatting one right now

It's very very slimey (in a tasty way) the only s'more I had was a poptart and never had a actual s'more.

I love the sticky flavor of marshmallow and the worlds favorite chocolate together in 1 serving

Brown Sugar Cinnamon is AWFUL. S'mores all day, every day. (:

Could eat them literally for hours! They're awesome when toasted, and even better with milk. (:

Very good love it

V74 Comments
3Cookies & Creme

I can't eat one without eating the whole box!

My absolute favorite, I always have two in my hand. These pop tart's are great! In fact I'm eating a few of them right now. :) "go! Cookies and creme! "

It tastes like a chocolate oreo cake with scrumptious cream filling! No other pop tart could ever mount to the Cookies & Cream poptart! I eat it cold and hot, both are equally amazing! You get eat it for a sweet treat or a tasty breakfast, whatever you want!

I eat a cookies and cream every morning

V36 Comments
4Frosted Strawberry

Strawberry is the original and nothing beats the original. Every other flavor falls to the wayside. Strawberry all day everyday.

I love frosted strawberry! But cinnamon has to be my second favorite. It used to be #1, but strawberry is better! SO MUCH BETTER! The frosting on this one is better too. The frosting stuff on the cinnamon melts too quick in the toaster. Definitely better

All so good... but this fruit flavor has to be one of the best. It is had to compare sweet pop-tarts to fruit ones however.

These are the best not my number one but always a good choice definitely top five

V44 Comments
5Hot Fudge Sundae

These are delicious and I love them. I ate a box of them just yesterday! They taste like melted awesome!

Me and my best friend used to get these every morning before school from the vending machine, and they are BEAST! The best, hands down.

Hands down the best. Toasted or not. But when it's toasted the filling melts right out and makes it a million times better

I love hot fudge definitely top three best pop tarts

V27 Comments
6Chocolate Fudge

The best flavor possible for pop tarts. It does not get any better, these are simply the best pop tarts I have ever tasted. In fact, I am eating one at this very moment.

It's the best! Vitamin fortified cookie! I can't believe it isn't number one! You cinnamon people need to try this

Eating it right now and I've got to say it's really hitting the spot, I was totally craving chocolate and this definitely is doing it for me :P

My favorite! I should've bought the 16-pack instead

V9 Comments
7Chocolate Chip

Let me tell you something about Chocolate Chip Poptarts. They are most definitely the most delicious- no contest. Freckled with chocolate chips, filled with a insanely tasty fudge filling thing. I just literally eat them more than I breathe air. Screw the rest.

Are you kidding me who the heck likes brown sugar cinnamon what morons... Chocolate chip is the best. The only reason why people like the others better is because they've never had chocolate chip.

It is AMAZING! Me and my friends were looking for so long and I FINALLY found them! Our Resource Room teacher (who also like Pop Tarts) still hasn't found them. We are huge Pop Tart fans and this is the flavor that is hard to find, but tastes so good!

The best in my opinion

V25 Comments
8Cinnamon Roll

These are THE BEST without a doubt! Our Walmart in Spearfish, SD, used to sell them, but all of a sudden no longer. We can't buy them anywhere. Please engage a retailer near us so we can be happy again!

These were the best, but just disappeared from the shelves. They need to come back, I would eat them everyday if possible. they nailed the test to match a actual tat of a cinnamon roll

The flavor is unbelievable and impossible! They totally nailed the flavor!

For sure the best flavor!

V19 Comments
9Frosted Blueberry

Who voted for Brown Sugar #1?

This one is my favourite. It might have something to do with that this was one of only three flavours that the store I got them from as a kid even sold. I never tried whatever the other two were. I like most kinds but this one has always been the best. - BKAllmighty

This is one of the best flavors

This is an awesome classic favourite

V19 Comments
10Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Seriously, I can barely stand any other pop tart because this one is so much better than any of the other flavors I've had (and I've had almost all of the others). They taste delicious toasted or un-toasted, you just can't go wrong. Best flavor by far.

my favourite is frosted hot fudge but this is my second!

This was disgusting, but it was the only one I have ever eaten so this has to be my favourite. Maybe I'll try strawberry next time though!

I think cookie dough is number one pop tart!

V11 Comments

The Newcomers

?Confetti Cake

Best Flavor Ever!

?Chocolatey Strawberry
BAdd New Item

The Contenders

11Frosted Rainbow Cookie Sandwich

Ok - this one? ORGASMIC! The cream filling is literally like vanilla-icing and the fact that it isn't completely frosted provides a perfect balance between the icing-filling and chocolate-drizzle frosting! By FAR the best Pop-tart FLAVOR!

By far the best poptart I've ever had! The filling inside is amazing and creamy just like icing and the outer part complements it perfectly! If you've never tried this you're missing out! I eat at least one a day - Jesusismylove

Yep this is the best one!

They should sell this one more often it is definitely top best three pop tarts!

V6 Comments

My absolute favorite... I never make a trip to the grocery store without buying at least 2 boxes. I live off of RASPBERRY poptarts!

It is surprisingly good. By the way chocolate fudge sucks and strawberry should be #1.

This is definitiley my favorite out of ALL the pop tart flavors. even though it is artificially flavored, it tastes like raspberry. this is also one of the first flavors, it is not one of the overly sweet ones

13Wild Berry

The wild berry is extra colorful and super fruity. I love the icing colors. I thing it the best of the fruit flavors. However the quality of the outer crust has gone down over the years. Pop tarts used to taste even better.

This is the original pop tart flavor. By far, it is the best flavor. It's colors are fascinating the texture is crisp and clean.


Die hard Pop tart Consumer

They're just perfect. By far the best. Their texture and taste is unmatched. And the blue stripe seals the deal.

If you could sum up the entirety of the 90's in one pastry it would be the wild berry pop tart.

V13 Comments
14Frosted Cherry

What is this delicious pop-tart flavor handcrafted by the gods themselves doing at number 13 on this list?! I am ashamed of all of you who did not vote for this delectable treat. Eating these is like eating an orgasm.

This was my first pop tart flavor I ever tried as a kid, and they remain my favorite. These should be much higher on the list than they are right now.

Eating one right now and I was like " I wonder what the most popular pop tart flavor is. I was mad when frosted cherry was not in the top 10

As much as I love chocolate and blueberry pop tarts, cherry is #1

V17 Comments
15Ice Cream Sandwich
16Frosted Confetti Cupcake

I just ate one. So delicious! If you toast it well it's pretty much a desert. Confetti cupcake pop tarts are great.

Amazing, that's all you need to know. Its just a burst of amazingness in every bite!

These pop-tarts are the bomb when I first taste confetti cupcake this was my reaction:" it taste like cake batter" Best pop-tarts in the world, I love confetti cupcake pop-tarts. :-D

I love frosted confetti cupcake it is my favorite.

V5 Comments
17Red Velvet

The best pop tart ever hands down! Please don't keep this a limited edition. When I buy, I must buy in bulk, I mean at least 5 boxes. My friends steal them because they are so good and I can't eat just one! My favorite!

Actually the best flavor ever! Delicious red velvet outside filled with gooey, sweet, almost chewy cream cheese frosting. I've eaten three in one day, to be honest.

These area daughters favorite. So sad they are a limited edition. Hoping they will keep them on the shelf year round if sales go well. Very yummy!

I always wanted to try a red velvet pop tart but I never see them anywhere in the stores!

V8 Comments
18Vanilla Milkshake

Delicious, especially when toasted!

Please bring these back.

Viva La Vanilla Poptarts! The greatest thing to happen since the founding of America, if these aren't brought back I will die!

V6 Comments
19Blueberry Muffin

These were our new favorite. The filling inside is so creamy and they make the house smell so good when toasting. We are on our last box because I can no longer find them. I hope they will return some day.

it is clearly the best... I have never had cinnamon roll, but blueberry muffin is so good, I know that cinnamon roll can't beat it... I love BLUEBERRY MUFFIN!

A new flavor... great warm!

20Peanut Butter

Amazing the best pop tart ever. Not just for the soft peanut butter interior but also the soft buttery crust on the outside with the slight sprinkle of sugar! Most pop tarts have the crust they break off and throw away. Not with this flavor!

I love the soft peanut butter inside also how moist the crust is. I eat them for breakfast and for a snack any time of day

Wonderful! One of the very best -- and I've tried almost all flavors. Satisfying, luscious, cozy.

These are the best hands down.

V7 Comments
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Best Fruit Pop Flavors Best K-Pop Couples Best Asian Pop Artists Best K-pop Artists of 2012 Top Ten Ice Cream Flavors

List StatsUpdated 30 Nov 2015

2,000 votes
45 listings
5 years, 318 days old

Top Remixes (9)

1. Frosted Rainbow Cookie Sandwich
2. Cookies & Creme
3. Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon
1. Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon
2. Raspberry
3. Chocolate Fudge
1. S'mores
2. Cookies & Creme
3. Hot Fudge Sundae

View All 9


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.