Top Ten Best Singer/Songwritersredwings5
The Top Ten
Is obviously the greatest singer/"songwriter" of all time. Bob Dylan actually wrote his songs, and didn't rely on other people to create them. I honestly have no idea how Josh Groban is even on this list!
Should clearly be first. Josh Groban the greatest singer-songwriter of ALL time? You are all patently complete morons.
Why Bob Dylan?
Because there was no other artist that has performed this consistently over the course of over 50 years? I will generously ignore his "Reborn Period" in the 80's and even during that time he wrote "good mainstream music", it just wasn't anything extraordinary or interesting. The only two artists who rival his songwriting are obviously Lennon and McCartney. But neither of them performed this consistently. Lennon died too soon (Roll On John), but even he had a bad period and McCartney just wasn't the same after the Beatles breakup.
Because Dylan keeps reinventing himself over the years, moving from Pretest Folk singer to Rockstar, back to Folk, to Country, to Blues, to Gospel and then even to some kind of music style, just to release a Sinatra cover album and move to a more jazzy style? Yes, the Beatles music was more diverse and Dylan never touched the really freaky stuff (Looking at you I Am The Walrus), but the Beatles were just ...more
DYLAN BY A LANDSLIDE.
#2/#3 Mccartney said "Dylan was OUR (Beatles) idol"
#4 Simon said "I really admired Dylan"
#5 Springsteen said "Dylan is the father of my country"
#8 Elton John "I was inspired by Bob Dylan"
#9 Neil Young "It's a great honor to compared to Dylan"
I often wonder people's knowledge on songwriting and what do they base their songwriting on. John Lennon is the greatest songwriter ever and wins by a country mile, no one comes close to him not even Dylan. He made the Beatles in to prophets and took them foreward. Maccartney's greatness shined through only when he was led. Every other songwriter were limited and predictable. Lennon was much more diverse and had more in his locker. I get so fed up hearing about Dylan being a songwriter, he was not, he used music to convey his poetry. He basically was a protest writer and became an icon with that movement. I don't understand why the music industry is obsessed with him. What else did he have... Nothing... He was envious of Lennon's Intellect and pulling power. Some of Dylan's songs lacked chorus and bridge. Hie version of Norwegian wood was a joke and his Christmas album was embarrassing. In the 80's he produced nothing. Lennon was more prolific and consistent with lyrics and melody. So ...more
Hey dude dd369 you don't know anything about song writing and a Lennon hater. What is the question, song writer. One song that kills Dylan... Imagine, It is sung all around the world. Dylan a genius don't make me laugh, it shows you are limited, you can't even spell genius. Song writing is not just lyrics. If Lennon wanted he could easy write like Dylan but he was to advanced and much more diverse. Dylan's songs didn't exactly touch people's inner self like Lennon's did. What did he do in the 80's, nothing, he is a joke, didn't know what faith to follow and kept chaining. Musically, lyrics, singing Lennon wins easy. Dylan's word play was predictable, Lennon's word play was much more clever. Dylan had to write a whole verse to make a point, Lennon could do this with few words, Lennon was a superior human being. You can back to me with anything you like and I promise you I will counteract it.
Oh and Lennon never changed? There is a good case for placing Lennon ahead of Dylan as a songwriter but your argument is way off base on many points. Furthermore, Dylan wrote many more songs, and I'd venture to say Lennon may have given him the crown. The Beatles adored him. Also, since John was killed in 1980, Dylan was much more prolific in that decade. - Billyv
I tell you that; if you however have chance to ask Bob Dylan(one of the most genious when it comes to write masterpieces) that logically who's the best songwriter ever?.. The answer my friend is (blowin' in the wind :-p :-)) ; there's no problem with me but I think John Lennon is 1 or 2 bottom better than me... :_) - dd369
Strawberry Fields Forever, God, Mother, Imagine, A Day In The Life, Happiness Is A Warm Gun, In My Life, Help!, Across The Universe, Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds, Norwegian Wood, I Am The Walrus, Dear Prudence, Julia, Tomorrow Never Knows, Woman, Jealous Guy, Look At Me, Isolation, If I Fell, Ticket To Ride, Watching The Wheels, Beautiful Boy, Just Like Starting Over, and SO MANY MORE... John Lennon is the GREATEST SONGWRITER EVERV 53 Comments
The most successful singer/songwriter of all time! it's in the Guinness book of world records! and of course he was the other half of the famous songwriting duo Lennon/McCartney, he should be here it's so obvious
Paul is considered to be in the greatest writing duet of all time (Lennon-McCartney). He was also part of the biggest band of all time and he is the world's most successful artist. Why is Paul all the way down here? HOW DOES JOSH GROBAN EVEN BEAT PAUL?!
Yesterday is the most covered song of all time.
He was part of the biggest band of all time.
That band is among the biggest overall musical acts of all time.
Had the most successful solo career of all the
Half of the greatest songwriting partnerships.
Why is he all the way down here?
He is literally in the Guiness Book of World Records as the best Songwriter. Guys, get it together.V 39 Comments
The quality of work produced by Simon has been outstanding for over 50 years, many of his songs having become timeless standards. His body of work now stands comparison with any of the world's great composers or poets throughout history. His lyrics are exceptional, poetic, moving and profound, and his melodies have shaped the development of popular music in the post 1960 world. His work consistently has something interesting to say about the human condition, and has at its heart a love for mankind.
Yes Paul Simon what a fine body of work as a solo artist, with Art Garfunkel and other great musicians. Bridge Over Troubled Water one of the greatest songs ever - right at the very top with Danny Boy! Because Art Garfunkel had the lead on Bridge Over Troubled Water I did not realise how great a singer Paul is until I saw him on YouTube with David Crosby and Graham Nash on stage together singing George Harrison's Here Comes The Sun - now that is as good as it gets! What a combo and beautiful guitar playing by Paul too. Been a fan since about 1975! Rock on!
VERY, VERY, VERY WELL PUT! Love Paul Simon's VERY IMPORTANT body of work! Beautiful marriages of melody and lyric! Poignant subject matter throughout his wonderful carrier!
However he still needs to be ranked behind McCartney, Lennon and Dylan... I know it SUCKS... But the completion was fierce! Just look at these composers (including Simon)... AND they were ALL from the same ERA! What a magical period in popular song! - frank
Always loved his songs for the catchy tunes through my 57 years of life. Went back and, WOW, the lyrics. No I mean WOW, the lyrics!V 4 Comments
I hate the fact that everywhere I see the top songwriter list, I see Bob Dylan. Now I'm a Dylan fan. But this whole Dylan is the greatest thing is pissing me off. I like "Blowing in the Wind." I like "The Times They Are a Changing." I like "Tambourine Man," but I don't know what the hell it means. And I love "The Hurricane." But what are his top songs? Why are they the greatest ever?
Every time I see one of these lists, people expect me to believe that these Dylan songs are superior to "The River? " "Darkness on the Edge of Town? " "Stolen Car? " "Born in the USA? " "My Hometown? " "Nebraska? " "Reason to Believe? " or any regular old Springsteen song?
We're just supposed to believe that Dylan is the greatest?
Anybody who's a music lover, probably loves Dylan. I do too. But anybody who's ever tried to write a song, knows who he or she is trying to copy.
This Dylan = number1 is just ridiculous.
Springsteen has released 17 studio albums, and 2 compilations of songs that were unreleased. That is a hell of a lot more of what some of these singers ahead of him have done. Bruce's songs have meaning in them, just listen to "Atlantic City" "The River" "Born To Run". Not everyone has heard of him he is very underrated in this generation, that's probably why he's so far down the list
I've gone through dozens of list of this nature and this guy is in the top 10 on all of them. Seriously just read the words to any of his stiff from the 70's and 80's. Deep songs about normal everyday problems. Other than Bob Dylan I don't know who would be a better contender for best singer songwriter in the history of modern music
Love all his music have a nice voiceV 6 Comments
Pink Floyd became the biggest rock band of all time because
1. The inspiration of Syd Barrett
2. The guitar work of David Gilmour
And 3. The brilliant songwriting of Roger Waters
Actually, the Beatles are the biggest one. They made it all possible. - waldo
Roger Waters wrote entire legendary albums like The Dark side of the Moon and The Wall
I like Bob, John and Paul more, but I can't believe how low Roger is! Gotta vote him up, he deserves it. - Donut
Just listen Echoes and Shine on you crazy diamondV 13 Comments
He is good song writer and singer, he should be in the top 10 list.. I didn't like the singer in number 1 list.. Maybe some people who vote to him maybe a teenager or young and he's famous at this time that is why he is in the no. 1 in the list.. For me I will vote for the vocalist and song writer of 60s 70s 80s and 90s because the song that they write are beautiful and meaningful than the songs the are come famous for now.. I'm 24 years old but I like the song from the past than now.. Philippines
Freddie Mercury is an amazing singer, and a superb songwriter. His songs are all original, and he can write all kinds of genres from hard rock to ballads to opera. He wrote Bohemain Rhapsody, one of the greatest songs ever; We Are The Champions, one of the greatest anthems ever, etc. Not to mention how he wrote Crazy Little Thing Called Love in about 10 minutes in a bathtub with a guitar, because he couldn't play the guitar well and is limited to a few chords. Such talents are rare in this world. Freddie Mercury should one of the greatest - if not THE greatest - singer/songwriter ever.
Bohemian Rhapsody, Don't Stop Me Now, Somebody to Love, Crazy Little Thing Called Love, Princes of the Universe, Killer Queen, We Are the Champions... should I go on? Freddie undoubtedly wrote some of the most iconic songs ever. Brian May, John Deacon and Roger Taylor also wrote some iconic songs.
Dylan is the first, who can't even sing a note? Ridiculous.V 18 Comments
Great to see Neil crack the top 20. What I like about this top twenty, with the exception of Groban, is that the people on it are not only great songwriters but have also influenced other great songwriters in most cases. No flash in the pans on this list. Aside from the inexplicable Groban error, good list.
Neil Young is the closest to Bob Dylan anyone will ever come. He's still light years behind but he definitely deserves a higher spot
Yes, should be higher but honestly, he's a lot higher on this list than he is on some of the others. One has him behind Nick Jonas, for crying out loud.
Neil Young was born rocking and he still makes his cherished old black guitar make sounds inexplicable- almost unworldly.V 6 Comments
Greatest pop musician/songwriter of all time. You can pick his voice & his songs anywhere at any time. He's 71 AND HE'S STILL PERFORMING! In fact, he's going to embark on a 3 year world tour!
Absolutely! His wealth of songs is EXTRAORDINARY! Sure Bernie wrote the lyrics but then Elton composed the whole within 30 minutes... AMAZING!
The melody is far more important to me than the lyrics. If I don't like the melody, it doesn't matter how good the lyrics are, I won't like the song & Elton John writes the best melodies ever.
Elton John has now embarked on his 3 YEAR world tour!V 14 Comments
Yep, so true, his songwriting skills are sublime, (Roamer? One? The unforgiven trilogy? , I don't know where to start :S ) - Psykosauron
Hear songs like one, Fade To Black, Enter Sandman, UnForgiven, The Day That Never Comes, Master Of Puppets. And you will know that he is the best lyrics writer with deep meanings inside his mind - nooreldeen
No no no, james should be in the top 10 he's a kick ass singer and a great songwriter you people should know better than to put james at 11
Of course, Lennon, McCartney, Mercury and all the other legends are made great music and define their generations' music. But Hetfield's touch on my life is undeniable. Every word he has written touched so many people in many ways. Thank you Papa Het for awesome memories, for all the headbangs.. please keep bless us with your beautiful music! 🤘 - BekoT.V 4 Comments
Billy Joel is great! My favorite songs that he made are Piano Man, Angry Young Man, The Entertainer, Say Goodbye to Hollywood, We didn't Start the Fire, Honesty, My Life, Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway.
I don't know what you posters ages are but Billy Joel wrote and performed some of the greatest songs ever. He also wrote many songs for other singers.
He's amazing! Harmonica, piano, and singing! He has made so Many amazing songs that have lasted through time. He is the piano man.
A lot worse than Elton John.V 4 Comments
Why isn't he in the Top 10? Just listen to his songwriting on albums like Tommy, Who's Next, Quadrophenia, and The Who Sell Out. This list is an insult!
He's one of many very good writers but there are dozens that are/were much better - Billyv
Inspired the rock opera, and he's currently ranked 16th.
Baba O'Riley, Won't Get Fooled Again, My Generation, I Can See For Miles (first metal song), and having written well more than 100 songs for band's. And where is Mick Jagger/Keith Richard? They should be at least, 5.
Quadrophenia. Need I say more?V 4 Comments
Very meticulous songwriter and still a good live performer even in his late seventies. Really researched the Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald to the point where everything in the song is pretty much accurate. Also did great ballads like Beautiful, If You Could Read My Mind, and Early Morning Rain.
Yes! Thanks to whoever added him to this list. Very underappreciated artist - Billyv
Should be on the top ten list.
If people listened to his earliest few albums before he went mainstream pop, they would
probably agree with Dylan that he is one of the best ever.
Also what happened to Neil Diamond who wrote more hit songs than anyone except
Lennon and McCartney.
In the best most influential band in the world, The Beatles, George Harrison deserves #1 instead of 17. He was the best songwriter of the Beatles, and equally as good a singer as Lennon and McCartney, George has had many influential songs including Something, While My Guitar Gently Weeps, My Sweet Lord, Isn't it a pity, Apple Scruffs, What is Life, and many more. Something, written by Harrison, has been sung by hundreds of musicians after him, and he IS still the most influential Beatle, in the most influential band, in the most influential era of music
Very underrated, he wrote many of the beatles' best songs including Something, While My Guitar Gently Weeps, Here Comes The Sun, If I needed someone, Taxman... he was a really talented man.
Hard to believe some people vote thumbs down on comments like this - then again it's not so hard, the world's full of people who don't understand brilliance - Billyv
I believe that George's songwriting ability was often unappreciated during the time of the Beatles! Don't forget that it was George who wrote Here Comes The Sun, Something, While My Guitar Gently Weeps, Taxman, I Need You, etc.
He deserved top 10. He’s not quite as good as Lennon and McCartney at both singing and songwriting, but he’s close. He’s also the best guitarist of all time. That’s what made the Beatles is the balance of each of the 4 being the absolute best in their specific field, and all being equal overall.V 7 Comments
He is simply one of the creates songwriters of all time, he established a genre and became the voice of an entire generation. He voiced all the angst that covered teenagers he accomplished many things in his life. Kurt Cobain is amazing.
Kurt doesn't deserve 17th. He was one of the most original songwriters ever. Every single one of Nirvanas songs as proof - Danielsun182
Nobody can write a song like Kurt! RIP. Find me one songwriter better than Kurt Cobain (Kurdt Kobain). What did he ask to be rememberd as?
What he was best at! Writing songs! Vote for him! Or else...
When I first heard lithium I thought it was just random nonsense but after finding out lithium is an antidepressant I made so much more sense. He wrote other great songs like old age which didn't even make an album which shows how talented he is.V 22 Comments
Yes, Dylan is a Master songwriter, and George, Paul and John, to, but Jackson gets my vote for having the most diverse body of work. His lyrics are profound, hopeful, personal, and politically and emotionally aware. His singing and arrangements are beautiful. His guitar and piano playing are great. His personal and humanitarian ethics are top notch. He is Number One and it is strange that he does not get the recognition that he deserves.
Jackson Browne is among a handful of top singer-songwriters. To look at those ranked above Jackson Browne reveals that at least someone does not understand what it means to be a singer-songwriter. His body of work is extensive and widely recognized. Further, there are very few more influential singer-songwriters who have influenced the careers of other singer-songwriters. Browne certainly influenced Glen Frey and Don Henley, as well as Warren Zevon, Bonnie Raitt, JD Souther, among others.
Speaking of "Running on Empty", that album is one of the most amazing live albums ever. Listen to how tight his band is--it sounds like they're in the studio! Another accomplishment of Browne's was co-writing the Eagles song "Take It Easy" with Glenn Frey. Yes, I've heard that he and Hannah had a problem or two. We're voting for songwriters, though, not choir boys.
JB is the prophet of the age, the poet of the century, he writes the most beautiful lyrics ever + he cares about the planetV 19 Comments
The more I listen the more it grows on my - the perfect lyrics and the harmonies.
The greatest living poet and singer songwriter of the last 50 years and still performing to vast worldwide audiences
Obvious top 10 material right here. It is disgusting that talentless losers like Bon Jovi are ahead of him.
Cohen. Is. The. Number. One.V 6 Comments
He did write most of his songs and if you say he didn't, then go do some research. Here are just some of the songs written by him entirely: Smooth Criminal, Beat It, Billie Jean, Earth Song, Will You Be There, Speechless, Don't Stop 'Til You Get Enough, Bad, The Way You Make Me Feel, Wanna Be Startin' Something, Workin' Day and Night, Morphine, I Just Can't Stop Loving You, Do You Know Where Your Children Are, Much Too Soon, Stranger in Moscow, D.S., Who Is It and Another Part of Me. He wrote 4 out of 9 songs on Thriller and 9 out of 11 songs on Bad. Not to mention, he co-wrote songs like: Black or White (only the rap part wasn't written by him), Remember the Time, Ghosts, Unbreakable, You Rock My World, Hollywood Tonight, Xscape, Love Never Felt So Good, Keep the Faith, Is It Scary, Scream, Tabloid Junkie, Break of Dawn, Whatever Happens, Dangerous and Blood on the Dance Floor. Sure, he has hit songs that weren't written by him, such as: You Are Not Alone, Thriller and Man in the ...more
Michael created a depth to his songs like no other. He sang with true emotion and feelings providing the listener with a connection to him personally. He meant what he sang and I love him for that. He was believable with the songs that he wrote and as a singer. love him xo mj - love4mjj
Someone said "Michael just writes, but Dylan is an intellectual thinker and is the most creative songwriter on earth". ARE YOU INSAANE! You OBVIOUSLY DON'T have intelligence if you think THAT! Listen, Michael wrote songs that touched the MASSES AND CHANGED OUR POINT OF VIEW OF THIS WHOLE WORLD FOR BETTER OR WORST! I mean we're talking Billie Jean, Wanna be starting something, Dirty Diana, Heal the World, Keep the Faith, Tabloid Junkie, D.S. , Is it Scary, Earth Song, Little Susie. And he's written some of the BEST and MOST BEAUTIFUL AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL music I have EVER HEARD such as Childhood, Stranger in Moscow, and Scared of the Moon. And the EMOTION HE BRINGS to those songs when he sings them is out of this UNIVERSE! I mean don't get me wrong I think Bob Dylan IS a TREMENDOUS songwriter undoubtably one of the GREATEST EVER But I say Michael is either tied or over him!
Should be in top 3. He's a genius. Come on guys.V 23 Comments
This guy has been turning out awesome music since he was a teenager in Them. He is as fresh and relevant now as he was almost 50 years ago. Nobody sounds like him and nobody writes like him-Brown Eyed Girl, Jackie Wilson Said, Queen of the Slipstream, Have I Told You Lately, etc. Check out the number of films that have used his music.
Listen to the multitude of music this man has produced it's pure poetry about everyday life.
How Van Morrison isn't in the top 10 of all time is just a mystery. I think because of his quiet, away from the public lifestyle and his refusal to try and write "Top 40 BS" songs, he is under appreciated in todays world of over the top electronic, rap and bland pop music. It's a damn shame.
His music is original, beautiful and has such depth.
Should be higher.
Also where is Sting?
Once again you idiots know nothing! Joni is one of the five greatest songwriters of all time! To have her way back here behind Kelly Clarkson, Taylor Swift, Shakira, whore Madonna, and Bryan Adams, are you on crack! Taylor dreams that she's Joni at night! Go ask Prince, Herbie Hancock, Morrissey, Tori Amos, Alanis, James Taylor, Crosby Stills Nash Young, Robert Plant, and many others from that era who the best female songwriter and guitarist ever was. They'll tell you its Joni, period. Most of the artists I just named have written songs about her. Zep's "Going to California" is an ode to Joni. But she's an artist's artist so she gets overlooked for pop crap.
Blue is an all time classic, and my secound favorite album(my first is blood on the tracks). she incoporated jazz into her later recordings. she deserves top 10, 5 or even 3. trust me, I listen mostly to singer songwriters, and she's amoung the very best - RecklessGreed
That's what I like about this list. You finally see people like Lightfoot, Taylor, Petty, Van Morrison, and Denver get their due. People who have established that they are among the all time great songwriters, and not a bunch of people who have just had a hit or two. With maybe a couple exceptions, this is a very intelligent top twenty.
He #1 with me he should at least be top 50 On this list hard to believe
Running Down a Dream, American Girl, Breakdown, Free Fallin, Last Dance with Mary Jane
Almost 60 & got a NEW 2disc CD out-it's great-did you guys forget him just cause he's softspoken? -
! I miss him so much already!V 4 Comments
My all-time favorite. This list is a breath of fresh air compared to the crappy songwriters list Top Tens has out. Seriously, go visit that site if you want to see rankings that will make you puke.
This man is very understated.
Not only does he play beautiful guitar but he writes lyrics that are loved and sung by everybody. - Metalman173
He's the best. Haven't heard his new album yet. Have seen him twice live, go see him if you haven't, you'll be in for a treat.
I saw him live in a solo performance in a small old theater with great acoustics. Perfect setting, perfect art. - Billyv
The best singer songwriter of all - nobody matches his lyrics and melodiesV 1 Comment
Good to see a list that gives Denver his due. Maybe his songs don't have any deep, dark meanings to them, but that's not who the man was. He wrote simple, heart touching melodies. I've heard that the melody and words to Annie's Song came to him in fifteen minutes while he was riding up a ski lift. That is a talented man with a special gift. Not a bad actor, either, if you've ever seen Oh God with he and George Burns.
An exceptional talent in both singing and writing! I can't think of better love songs than "For You", "Never a Doubt" and "Perhaps Love".
A simply brilliant songwriter
John Denver OWNED the 70s. Love to see JD on this list. His songs reflected his deep convictions. He was ahead of his time. A genius singer songwriter.
You can tell a real good songwriter by how many others want to do his or her songs. Aretha Franklin, the Osmonds, the Beatles, James Taylor, the Drifters, the Everly Brothers, Steve Lawrence, and Grand Funk Railroad are just a few of the many and diverse artists who have recorded Carloe King songs. In this category, I believe Ms. King can only be matched by Bob Dylan and the Beatles, or possibly Buddy Holly.
I'm not saying this list is sexist, but why is the top 20 all male? Women have their fair share of experience in songwriting. - 445956
My sister turns 50 and can sing all her songs
-Life on Mars
-Ashes to Ashes
-Wild Eyed Boy From Freecloud
-Loving the Alien
-The Man Who Sold The World
-Lady Grinning Soul
-Oh You Pretty Things
-Rock n Roll Suicide
-All The Young Dudes
What is wrong with people? David Bowie is clearly one of the best, he should be at least top ten.
The fact that Bowie is so low on this list makes the entire list irrelevant. Ridiculous
Better than Bob Dylan, Paul McCartney, John Lennon and everyone on the top 77... He's the best song-writer of all timeV 5 Comments
Some of the best roadhouse songs ever and Scorsese loves them!
Really underrated as a song writer
I like Jim Morrison but if you look at the top ten it's really pretty legitimate except for Josh Groban. I don't know that I'd put Morrison in there over anyone currently there. And you still have Neil Young and Carole King outside the top twenty as well. I guess there are just a lot of really good songwriters. Also, I do believe Buddy Holly should be in here somewhere.
How is Jim Morrison not in the top 10? Like I don't get it. He should totally be up there with Michael Jackson, Bob Dylan, and John Lennon. His lyrics were absolutely incredible and The Doors were one of the best bands of all time!
Please fix the bug in the website and put him back to #1
What is Jim doing way down here? He deserves to be in the top 5!
Ed Sheeran really knows how to write a good song. I think some people don't really appreciate what he has achieved at such a young age. Plus, Ed Sheeran has also written songs for other major artists. I feel that a lot of artists get a lot of accreditation for just being around for a long time however I feel that there are other artists, such as Ed Sheeran, that have had a bigger impact and will have a bigger impact in years to come. Personlly the only person that I feel can sing Ed's songs with enough emotion, passion and meaning is the man himself. He has written numerous of songs that have more meaning and depth than any of the artists that are higher up than him on this list. For me some of his Ed Sheeran's deeper cuts such as Sunburn and Autumn Leaves have so much depth to them. Ed Sheeran really knows how to write a love song and touch the hear. You feel as if every verse is directed to you.
His lyrics and vocals are beyond amazing. He is easily a greater songwriter than those higher such as Taylor Swift. In this generation it seems like great songwriters are dying out but Sheeran is bringing back that singer songwriter style with his amazing love songs and sometimes even hip/hop tracks.
I enjoy Ed Sheeran a lot, but how is he higher up the list than Prince, Bono, and Bob Marley? Sheeran isn't quite a classic artist yet.
How in gods good name is Ed Sheeran (who I respect) above Van Morrison, Joni Mitchell, and Tom Petty... among others - pos_vanV 11 Comments
To have the huge success they have and play to some of the largest crowds ever amassed without main stream radio pushing them down your throats and not glamorized in mainstream press. That is truly remarkable if you ask me.
Should be a lot higher on the list than 59! One of the greatest lyricist for a very long time. definitely needs to be in the top 10 of all time.
Surely should be in top 5, write some of the best songs ever made, I'm suprised he's not in here already
Noel Gallagher is, undisputedly, one of the best songwriters in music history. UNDISPUTEDLY. But I'm not even gonna argue about this, this chart is clearly not a thing to take too serious since Noel Gallagher is here at 78th while above there are people like Avril Lavigne, Beyoncé, Taylor Swift, etc. Like, what? Nothing against these artists, but people should get a musical culture and get to know who Noel Gallagher is. - sethcarmichael
The fact that he wrote "Don't Look Back In Anger" and "Wonderwall" should at least put him up in the top 5. (Also even his b-sides are godlike so...)V 7 Comments
This guy is a literal angel from the sky
A Singer/Songwriter with few peers. There are few like her that writing is like breathing.
She's lower than Taylor Swift. Huh? Taylor could not write deep songs with such great lyrics as Stevie. Stevie's songs are Masterpieces and will always and forever be classics. Have to mention some. Dreams, Gold Dust Woman, Rhiannon, Outside the Rain, Sara and I could keep going. Song writing so much more meaning and depth and sheer powerfulness than anything T.S. could ever write. People need listening skills.
Awesome - solo and with fm...
For sure this list is waked, 178 and so far not a single blues artist; Muddy Waters had some songs that were pure blues poetry, same for many others of the genre. Amy Winehouse in the list, why, 'cause she died in the last ten years? Prince, yes belongs on the list, but not for dance choro, multi-instrumentalist (impressive, yes but this list is about songwriting). Bruno Mars, let's see in ten years how many of his songs people can remember.
Another proof that Bob Seger is the most underrated singer/song-writer/ musician of all times. As a song writer, he is UNIQUE! There's no explainable way for BSeger not to be in the top 25 song writers. It really discredits the visions of those making a list like this one.
Something is definitely wrong with Seger being this low.
One of the greatest songwritersV 1 Comment
I can't believe that Jim Croce is below Beyonce, Taylor Swift or Madonna... His songs were and will be eternal, he is one of the best songwriters of all time, he doesn't deserve the top 58, he deserves to be in the top 10 or even top 15 or 20 but not below!
Makes you wonder just how many more great songs he would have written had he lived longer. Songs like Time in a Bottle, Operator, I Got a Name, and I'll Have to Say I Love You in a Song are gorgeous, and Croce had a great sense of humor with songs like Roller Derby Queen, Rapid Roy, and of course Leroy Brown...
Are you people serious? Jim Croce sang about the common man, his hits are timeless and his voice is one of a kind. Very few are better than him
My man from San Diego... I was born half year after his death, but love all of his songs. Playing along with the guitar is so nice.V 2 Comments
The #1 songwriter of all time has to be either Costello or Mark Knopfler (who isn't even on the list, for shame! ). Both put an incredible amount of thought into their songs, and it shows. - martinsjh
How this prolific genius is not in the top 10 I don't know. Who the hell is Josh Groban?
This man is multi talented and made Fleetwood Mac much more than what they could of become. Tusk was a very important album for that band. Not just Rumours. Rumours catapulted them. Tusk was a fresh start after the craziness that surrounded Rumours it was time for a change. Tusk was it. Lindsey Buckingham is unique.
This is way too high. Ahead of Robert Plant and Barry Gibb? Sorry, no.
Bullets with butterfly wings
Stand Inside Your Love
And tons of deep cuts
Very surprised, he was not (yet) on the list...
The 'heart' from Pink Floyd...
Lemon Robert's lyrics are poetic and beautiful he should be on top along with Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Carole King, Paul McCartney and Freddie Mercury.
Stairway to Heaven is one of the greatest songs ever written.
What bring him up
Hauntingly beautiful songs. Complex yet subtle melodies.
Always underrated - but then he likely likes it that way...
Related ListsTop 10 Greatest Female Singer/Songwriters of All Time Top Ten Most Talented Singer/Songwriters Top Ten Canadian Singer/Songwriters Top 10 Songs On The Singer/Songwriters Collection by Time Life Top Ten Best Singer/Songwriter Albums
11 years, 17 days old
Top Remixes (27)
2. Leonard Cohen
3. Bruce Springsteen
2. Bruce Dickinson
3. Freddie Mercury
2. James Taylor
3. Jackson Browne
View All 27