Favorite Milkshake Flavors

The Top Ten
1 Oreo Cookies and Cream

Yum yum... All I have to say! It's creamy, rich, and a great sweet treat on a hot summer night! Love! Go out and get one! They are amazing! It's the best and delicious and great and awesome and amazing and special and way better than boring old CHOCOLATE! Go and eat (or make one using ice cream, milk, and oreos... And a blender) one!

I love oreos cookies and cream
I have never had it in a milkshake but it sounds really nice
Might try it myself actually
I think it is much better than chocolate because its chocolate and cream!

Best milkshake flavor ever! Vanilla and chocolate and cookies and cream all in one! Way better than just vanilla or chocolate!

2 Chocolate

Chocolate is the most amazing flavor I have ever tasted and when I get a milkshake I only ever get a chocolate one. My favorite! If I ever find anyone drinking a different simple and plain milkshake I get angry.

Yum, fab. Tasty, Good, Great, Delicious, tastes like heaven, Better than everything I have ever tasted, fantastic, delish, mouth watering, scrumptious, toothsome, succulent, Finger-licking good flavour I don't know what else to say

I have never liked chocolate. I think that it is definitely the worst flavour for a milkshake (of any flavour). I would much prefer a lime or banana milkshake instead.

3 Vanilla

Dude...Vanilla is the best flavor! It is just so rich, creamy and tasty. Also, I love the taste of Vanilla flavored things so this was easy. Also, in chocolate milkshakes, they usually put WAY too much syrup into it. But vanilla is so good, I can't describe it in just words. It is sweet, but not too sweet and kinda light. Chocolate milkshakes aren't amazing, but they are good. Vanilla, you really can't screw up. I say that chocolate should be number 3, but Vanilla should be number 1 without a doubt. There is a certain taste to vanilla that I really can't put my finger on, but I love it so much.

I'm sick of everyone thinking of vanilla as the "plain" milkshake flavor, just because it's a similar color as milk. For the record, milk and vanilla are two very different flavors that taste INCREDIBLE together. Just saying.

I love vanilla! It belongs in the number 1 spot not chocolate! Well I would be OK if vanilla was in 2nd place but still! It is amazing!

4 Strawberry

I heart Strawberry! Yumm, I grew up on strawberry and it would always be my reward when I did something good or got a great grade in something when I was younger!
I Love Strawberry and it beats chocalte any day. I have found my love! :) That Strawberry is great and I loved the fresh strawbery!

It is the greatest flavor ever. It doesn't matter how I'm feeling after I have a strawberry milkshake it makes me feel so happy.

Simply amazing with its strong fruity flavor. Even more elegant when whipped in vanilla ice cream um!

5 Banana

Banana! The best flavour there is! Yay for bananas! Bananas are healthier than chocolate, and who can turn down the irresistible yellow hue and alluring fragrance of an ice cold banana shake? Exactly! Nobody!

Not a plain stupid milkshake like chocolate vanilla or strawberry! This is the best simple plain flavor out there! Refreshing tasty and who doesn't like bananas! Maybe mix it with strawberry!

Bananas are absolutely the best! If you haven't tried banana flavoured milkshake before, you should like right now! Try adding oreos to banana milkshakes - tastes even better!

6 Caramel

I haven't ever had Caramel but only because I've never seen it on a menu. I think I'd like it

I love caramel everything I don't know why some people done?

Caramel is the best milkshake flavor by far! I love it!

7 Cappuccino

You can't top a coffee milkshake, argument over.

I don't usually drink coffee but it sounds good.

"Best milkshake out there?

8 Mint Chocolate Double Fudge

I love chocolate. When its twice the fudge, it is soo rich! Combined with mint.. heaven.. The best ever..

Mint chocolate double fudge is my favorite. Because of the way all the flavors combine

Something different to what I normally get but still delicious!

9 Peppermint

I like peppermint just like any other mint. It has a fresh taste in your mouth. Better than boring and bland vanilla!

Did you know this is the most popular flavor in the state I live in?

Go get it at Shake Shack

10 Mint Chocolate Chip

Omg, this is my absolutely positively favorite flavor in the entire world! If you have never had mint chocolate chip (which I would find pretty unbelieveable), try it right away. It's an must! Love all you mint chocolate chip lovers!

Mint chocolate chip is way better than chocolate which is boring and gross, better than plain old vanilla, and I like strawberry though, but I like this better!

It's so minty good and sweet with the chocolate chips it makes me feel like I'm in a Bolivian rainforest with my shades and my dog, Rodney.

The Contenders
11 Black and White

Vanilla and Chocolate! Each are great on they're own but put them together and your mind might get blown!

White chocolate and Hershey's chocolate, can't go wrong.

12 Coconut

Never heard of this flavour before
Where can you get it?

The best! So creamy and tropical!

Were do I buy it?

13 Lemon

Best summer flavor!.. Lemon and vanilla add just the right amount of sweetness. Especially if you like citrus but do not want sherbet. Be creative and add chopped basil or mint...sort of like a mojito shake

People often describe lemon as "sour" but with milk, it's the exact right a,out of sweet, with a tiny kick.

Amazing taste! Sweet with a little tinge of zest.

14 Cheesecake

I love cheesecake

15 Chocolate Covered Strawberry

These milk shakes are delicious!

16 Strawberry and Banana

Best thing ever made on earth are these fruits. then add them together with a delicious ice cream and blend it up with a bit of milk and chocolate syrup and Jesus shall arrive in your mouth

Two best plain flavors combined!

17 Bubblegum
18 Birthday Cake

Birthday cake!

More like the best thing ever!

It is better than cake!

19 Raspberry

Hooray for Raspberry. Yummy and underrated. Why no Lemon on this list. I think Lemon is a fab taste. Like Lemon meringue pie.

It's actually REALLY good. The thing is, people are too shy to try new flavours. Jaffa and raspberry are my two favourite flavour milkshakes and they're REALLY good when you add lots of icecream.

20 Lime

Lime is the absolute best shake I have ever had and I would cast all my votes for Lime. So wish that you would bring this best refreshing treat back again!

Oops should read heaven in a glass 2 pint jug, refreshing, moreish and addictive. So where in the world can I get it?

The absolute best flavour in my opinion! This is the one that I always order.

21 Cookie Dough

Just think of cookie dough and icecream together!
It's the most amazing thing you can EVER have!

This is better than chocolate.

I love cookie dough and if I didn't have it I would die this coming from 50 year old

22 Smores
23 Chocolate Chip Mint

Two of my favourite flavors combined. Chocolate is already delicious. Plus mint.. much better than vanilla. Vanilla is so bland and flavourless! Yuck!

It's like having Thin Mints and ice cream in the same delicious shake!

24 Marshmallow

Toast the marshmallow goodness. Put vanilla ice cream and your marshmallows, and 1/4 cup of milk, into the blender. Blend until smooth. Add a healthy swirl of chocolate happiness. It's like having a pillow fight with marshmallows in your mouth, combined with ice cream, chocolate, and marshmallows. What do you think it tastes like? Happiness, love, and joy. But if you add just one Oreo to this mix, you will own a milkshake of the Olympic gods themselves. It's something to be reckoned with. Mmm, it's creating happiness even now.

Never had marshmallow shake but marshmallow toppings in shakes are awesome! yes!

It's the best ever. Marshmallow milkshake to the rescue! !

25 Mixed Berry
8Load More
PSearch List