Most Overrated Guitarists


The Contenders: Page 2

21 Dimebag Darrel

Nobody could playing Dimebag riffs like Dimebag. His phrasing was second to none and his rhythm riffs were more difficult to play than most people's solos. Not saying he was the best ever but not overrated for sure.

What the hell? When I searched for this list the LAST man I thought would be on the list is Dimebag Darrel! I love Pantera, and not to mention the way he died. I remember watching the footage of the club/bar they were playing at and just watching him fall. I was so shocked when I found out he was shot in the middle of a show. It's pretty sad that someone thinks the Dimebag is "Overrated", He's anything but.

Why do people alway say Dimebag was a "guitar-god"? I don't understand why he's considered to be a legend, he doesn't bring anything interesting to the table except for a really good rhythm feel and decent technique. Then again, I don't even like Pantera, maybe I'm a little bit prejudiced because their music annoys me in general.

He is worshiped too much. I never found him to be as good as people make him put to be

V 7 Comments
22 John Petrucci John Petrucci John Peter Petrucci is an American guitarist, composer and producer. He is best known as a founding member of the progressive metal band Dream Theater.

Overrated, john is the most technical and skilled guitarist, he is not overrated, in fact, he deserves more recognition.

How dare you! That is an insult to decent guitar players, saying Petrucci is overrated.

He used to incredible back in the early 90s, but the last 10 years has been nothing but boring, generic, cheese metal. Shame.

23 Prince Prince Prince Rogers Nelson (June 7, 1958 - April 21st, 2016) was an American musician, best known for being one of the most popular and influential artists from the 80s, with songs such as "Purple Rain", "Little Red Corvette", "1999", and "When Doves Cry" .

Prince is incredible! If anything, he's very much underrated! And considering the amount of instruments he plays, it's amazing!

One of the most influential guitarists of the 80"s and beyond... Enough said...

Prince could never be overrated, only underrated.
The most influential guitarist of the 80's and beyond.

This guy seems way overrated after he died. no one would stop playing Purple Rain after he died.

V 1 Comment
24 Tony Iommi Tony Iommi Anthony Frank "Tony" Iommi is an English guitarist, songwriter and producer. Best known as lead guitarist and founding member of the pioneering heavy metal band Black Sabbath, he has been the band's sole continual member and primary composer.

I wanna kill the guy who put the father of metal here!

He was so into music when his finger was cut off, he switched hands and played with his right hand and not his left. Most guitarists wouldn't have the courage to do that even if they wouldn't be as good as when he was a lefty. Respect to Tony. - Plonderss

Got to give this guitarist some respect, he's one of the pioneers of metal.

He lost his touch

V 4 Comments
25 Liam Gallagher Liam Gallagher William John Paul "Liam" Gallagher is an English musician, singer, and songwriter. He rose to fame as the lead singer of the rock band Oasis, and later as the singer of Beady Eye.

Few basic chords, awful strumming, bad player all round

Same as his brother Noel... But crikey, what a chav he is! No wonder all the townies in their trackies look up to him.

Can he even play guitar? he isn't even a good singer. his talent is limited to his 164 IQ. and sometimes some backing vocals and tambourine. that's it - zxm

V 1 Comment
26 Zakk Wylde Zakk Wylde Zakk Wylde is an American musician, singer, songwriter, multi-instrumentalist and occasional actor who is best known as the former guitarist for Ozzy Osbourne, and founder of the heavy metal band Black Label Society.

He's definitely lost his sense of creativity in his solos and riffs.

I can't stand his tone... That terrible blasty sound with tons of gain and then the endless wah... Definitely overrated

He's really weird looking with the beard and mustache, BRING BACK THE OLD 1980S ZAKK WYLDE!

Raping three notes for eight minutes. That's all how stupid wreslter makes his sound.

V 1 Comment
27 Eric Clapton Eric Clapton Eric Patrick Clapton is an English rock and blues guitarist, singer and songwriter. He is the only three-time inductee to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame: once as a solo artist and separately as a member of the Yardbirds and Cream. He has also been a member of Derek and the Dominos.

Clapton is one of the best guitarists there has ever been. Listen to 'Why does love got to be so sad' live at the Guillmore, then if you still think he's over rated go to the doctors because you need to have your ears checked.

If he's overrated, then its for a good reason. He's the second best guitar player after Hendrix. - BrianScott01

Hasn't really been able to top cream since he went solo.

Wake me up when he's done playing! What a lame ass duck.

V 4 Comments
28 Joe Bonamassa Joe Bonamassa Joe Bonamassa is an American blues rock guitarist, singer and songwriter. When he was only 12 years old, Bonamassa opened for B.B. King. He was born 8th May 1977. He is known to be one of the greatest blues guitarists ever.

Bonamassa is a technician shredder, not a bluesman. We get it, he can play fast. If you wanna see why I believe he is an overrated player look up the video of Bonamassa, Derek Trucks, and Billy Gibbons playing Freddie Kings "Going Down" at the RR Hall of Fame inductions. Derek (who is of my favorite guitarists) gives very subtle yet strong phrases when plays. After he finishes, Bonamassa completely overplays and misses the entire point of the blues, which is a shame because it could have been fantastic.

How is this ridiculous fake blues wannabe not the number one most over rated guitarist in history is just beyond me. He as blues by numbers, he's a 70's blues rock jukebox, who looks like a complete dork, has the most embarrassing fake stage moves ever, and has nothing whatsoever to say with his music.
He wouldn't know the blues if it hit him in the face.
His PR people work 24hrs a day to get his ugly mug in every guitar mag every single month, pushing some chap product or other. Give it a rest and get a proper job.

That rich white boy wouldn't know the blues if it fell on him. Great bluesmen don't own 900 guitars and. 1000 amps.

29 Ritchie Blackmore Ritchie Blackmore Richard Hugh "Ritchie" Blackmore is an English guitarist and songwriter, best known for his work in the hard rock/metal bands Deep Purple and Rainbow. He was ranked number 16 on Guitar World's "100 Greatest Metal Guitarists of All Time" in 2004, and number 50 in Rolling Stone magazine's list of the more. V 1 Comment
30 Yngwie Malmsteen Yngwie Malmsteen Yngwie Johan Malmsteen is a Swedish guitarist, songwriter and bandleader who was born on June 30th, 1963, in Stockholm, Sweden. He was known for his neoclassical metal playing style back in the 1980s.

Ok he is a really good guitarist but far from a Guitar Icon or Guitar hero like everyone claims.

V 1 Comment
31 Bo Diddley
32 Chuck Berry Chuck Berry Charles Edward Anderson "Chuck" Berry is an American guitarist, singer and songwriter, and one of the pioneers of rock and roll music.

Chuck is a pioneer of early Rock and Roll. He kind seems as if he'd be underrated though.

Why is this guy not at number one? In a list of OVERRATED guitarists Chuck Berry is easily the top choice. He's been praised non-stop for 50 years for basically one song. He's for some reason listed amongst the greatest musicians of all time when his music was outdated 40 years ago. He's given much more credit than he deserves. I think that's the definition of overrated.

The man had one song and its not even that good. Chuck Berry is the definition of overrated. He receives almost universal praise for what is a very standard song. Not that he isn't talented but calling him the king of rock and roll takes things a little too far.

By far the worst lead guitar player of all time... Recently played in a casino and played most of his solos in the wrong key..

V 3 Comments
33 Hideto Matsumoto

like everyone is just recognizing only him, a great one but it is very annoying if he is the only one - ronluna

34 Robert Johnson Robert Johnson

Are you kidding me? Robert was so good, people actually believed he sold his soul to the devil.

I believe it was Keith Richards who said, "it sounded like two people playing",when he first heard this guy.

Yeah, sold his sold to the devil, and still sucked!

V 1 Comment
35 Brian May Brian May Brian Harold May is an English musician, singer, songwriter and astrophysicist, best known as the lead guitarist of the rock band Queen.

Somebody needs to clean their diaper out... It's full of crap.
Brian May is God's gift to the guitar in technique, melody, phrasing, tone, etc.
What the hell more can you ask of the man... Sheer genius.

I saw him live he's good not great. And everyone thinks he's amazing for bohemian rhapsody it's a 20 second solo get over it. His solos some are good but even the good ones are to short. I don't hate brian may I like Him I just don't understand how everyone calls him underrated when people call slash overrated and people think he's better than slash seriously brian May would never be able to write solos like sweet child o mine november rain godfather theme double talking jive and estranged.

He's unrated in my opinion his clean solos are amazing and no one recognises that.

I'm probably going to get the downvote blues for this but I've heard both live in studio from Brian and his guitar work always feels lacking, this is coming from somebody who has all of the Queen albums, but he is a nice man.

V 3 Comments
36 Paul Gilbert Paul Gilbert

That Gilbert appears on this list is shocking. He talent is almost without parallel among rock guitarists. Listen to "Scarified, " then listen to "GVRO, " then listen to "Green-Tinted Sixties Mind. " This guy does it all. Somebody owes readers of this list an explanation.

Paul Gilbert is a musical genius and incredible guitar player.

V 1 Comment
37 Orianthi
38 Cliff Burton Cliff Burton Clifford Lee "Cliff" Burton (February 10th 1962 - September 27th 1986) was an American musician, best known as the second bass guitarist for the American thrash metal band Metallica, recording three studio albums. He died in 1986 after getting crushed by a tour bus in Copenhagen whilst promoting Metallica's more.

Shows how much people know about guitar. Cliff Burton is a bassist, idiots.

Yeah he was an overrated guitar player as he did not play guitar. He played the bass and he was a good bassist.

Are you kidding me? First of all, he's a bassist and not a guitarist. Second, he basically almost played the lead guitar in their songs, he wrote riffs and bass lines. Listen to Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets and listen carefully to his bass lines and amazing rhythm. - Plonderss

Can we get him to number 1?

V 6 Comments
39 Mick Thompson

Mick Thompson is not overrated! He did one of the best guitar solos and riffs with slipknot... Personally his performance at the 1st album of slipknot for me sounds very cheesy but his performance in the album all hope is gone... He did one of the best solos and riffs ever! - nooreldeen

40 Pete Townshend Pete Townshend Peter Dennis Blandford "Pete" Townshend is an English musician, singer, songwriter, and multi-instrumentalist, best known as the lead guitarist and songwriter for the rock band The Who .

Townshend should not be on this list. A completely different style than other guitarists from his era. Not "technically" great like Clapton or Beck and he and The Who played in a more "freestyle' manner when in concert. Pioneered the use of guitar feedback and his influence on hard rock and heavy metal can't be underestimated. Moon and Townshend were perfect for each other.

Should be at the top of the list. Townsend sucks big time.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Most Overrated Rock Guitarists Best Guitarists Ever Best Metal Guitarists Most Overrated Actors/Actresses Most Overrated Rappers of All Time

List StatsUpdated 22 Feb 2017

2,000 votes
58 listings
8 years, 278 days old

Top Remixes (7)

1. Slash
2. Synyster Gates
3. Dave Mustaine
1. Kirk Hammett
2. Kurt Cobain
3. Angus Young
1. Jimmy Page
2. Kurt Cobain
3. John Mayer

View All 7


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.