Top Ten Replacement Members In Rock Bands

ameentheguitarist23
We all love the famous member line-ups in bands, but the replacements members are no less, and rather underrated. Let's show them this is not true!

The Top Ten

1 Brian Johnson for Bon Scott - AC/DC

I don't know. I like Brian Johnson, but I find myself listening to more of the Bon Scott stuff. Still, he was a very good replacement.
Edit: I've opened up to Brian more. I still prefer Bon Scott, but Brian was probably the best person they could get to fill in his shoes. - Gg2000

2 David Gilmour for Syd Barrett - Pink Floyd

I know some people prefer the Barrett stuff, but I can't imagine Pink Floyd without David Gilmour's guitar playing. He is that good. - Gg2000

3 Bruce Dickinson for Paul Di'Anno - Iron Maiden

Absolutely gobsmacked this isn't #1 or at least Top 5. - truckturner

4 Jason Newsted for Cliff Burton - Metallica
5 Justin Hayward for Denny Laine - The Moody Blues
6 Neil Peart for John Rutsey - Rush

I know it's cliche, but replacing John with Neil was the best thing they did. It transformed them musically and lyrically from just an ordinary hard rock band into one of the best prog bands of all time. - Gg2000

7 Ronnie James Dio for Ozzy Osbourne - Black Sabbath Ronnie James Dio for Ozzy Osbourne - Black Sabbath Ronnie James Dio (born Ronald James Padavona; July 10, 1942 – May 16, 2010) was an American heavy metal singer, songwriter and musician. He fronted and/or founded numerous groups including Elf, Rainbow, Black Sabbath, Dio and Heaven & Hell. He is credited with popularizing the "metal horns" hand gesture ...read more.
8 Lindsey Buckingham for Peter Green - Fleetwood Mac

Technically, it's Lindsey Buckingham for Bob Welch. Bob Welch replaced Peter Green in 1971, and he resigned in 1974. - Gg2000

9 Ron "Bumblefoot" Thal for and Buckethead and Slash - Guns N' Roses
10 Robert Trujillo for Jason Newsted - Metallica

The Contenders

11 Buckethead for Slash - Guns N' Roses
12 Dave Grohl for Chad Channing - Nirvana Dave Grohl for Chad Channing - Nirvana David Eric "Dave" Grohl is an American rock musician, multi-instrumentalist, singer, songwriter, producer and film director. He is best known as the former drummer of the hugely popular 90s grunge band Nirvana and the vocalist/guitarist for the alternative rock band Foo Fighters. He has sat behind the ...read more.
13 Ringo Starr for Pete Best - The Beatles
14 Kirk Hammett for Dave Mustaine - Metallica
15 Ron Wood for Mick Taylor - The Rolling Stones
16 Mike Mangini for Mike Portnoy - Dream Theater
17 Richard Fortus for Paul Tobias and Izzy Stradlin - Guns N' Roses
18 Mick Taylor for Brian Jones - The Rolling Stones

Definitely a good decision. Some of my favorite musical moments on Stones records are Mick T.'s guitar solos. - Gg2000

19 Steve Howe for Peter Banks - Yes
20 Stu Block for Matt Barlow - Iced Earth
21 DJ Ashba for Robin Finck - Guns N' Roses
22 Paul McCartney for Stuart Sutcliffe - The Beatles

Well, Paul already was a member of the band that was to become The Beatles. Paul and Stu were in the band together. Stu lost interest, wanting to pursue painting, and Paul (who was the more talented player) took over the bass duties. - Billyv

23 Phil Collins for Peter Gabriel - Genesis
24 Zakk Wylde for Randy Rhoads - Ozzy Osbourne
25 William DuVall for Layne Staley - Alice In Chains
26 Sammy Hagar for David Lee Roth - Van Halen
27 Matt Sorum for Steven Adler - Guns N' Roses
28 Josh Klinghoffer for John Frusciante - Red Hot Chili Peppers
29 Steve Morse for Ritchie Blackmore - Deep Purple
30 Scott Travis for Dave Holland - Judas Priest
31 Adrian Smith for Dennis Stratton - Iron Maiden
32 Richie Faulkner for K.K. Downing - Judas Priest
33 Justin Chancellor for Paul D’Amour - Tool
34 Gary Holt for Jeff Hanneman - Slayer
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top 10 Rumored Band Member Replacements that Didn't Happen Top 10 Best Replacement Rock and Metal Vocalists Top 10 Potential Replacements for the Job of Owner of the Carolina Panthers Top 10 Best Drummer Replacements Top 10 Best Guitarist Replacements

List Stats

34 listings
4 years, 132 days old

Top Remixes

1. Neil Peart for John Rutsey - Rush
2. Bruce Dickinson for Paul Di'Anno - Iron Maiden
3. Brian Johnson for Bon Scott - AC/DC
Metal_Treasure
1. Justin Hayward for Denny Laine - The Moody Blues
2. Lindsey Buckingham for Peter Green - Fleetwood Mac
3. David Gilmour for Syd Barrett - Pink Floyd
Billyv
1. Brian Johnson for Bon Scott - AC/DC
2. Jason Newsted for Cliff Burton - Metallica
3. Ron "Bumblefoot" Thal for and Buckethead and Slash - Guns N' Roses
ameentheguitarist23

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.