Best Spider-Man Actors

The Top Ten
1 Tobey Maguire Tobias Vincent "Tobey" Maguire is an American actor and film producer who gained recognition for his film roles in Pleasantville, The Cider House Rules, Wonder Boys, Spider-Man, Seabiscuit, Spider-Man 2, The Good German, Spider-Man 3, Brothers, and The Great Gatsby. He was nominated for the Screen Actors Guild and Golden Globe Awards and received two Saturn Awards, including one for Best Actor. Newer... read more

Tobey was really the only live action Spider-Man who came close to nailing both Peter Parker AND Spider-Man. He was perfect as Peter, both acting and appearance wise, but could’ve been a little better with the quip delivery under the mask. Nitpicking aside, Tobey’s the best live action Spider-Man

He is the best then Andrew Garfield And THEN... Tom Holland

Toby Maguire is THE spider-man

2 Tom Holland Thomas Stanley "Tom" Holland is an English actor and dancer. Holland is known for playing Spider-Man in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and starring in the 2012 film The Impossible. He started his career in 2008 when he played the lead role named Billy Elliot in Billy Elliot The Musical on Broadway in ...read more.

How is Tom in third he's the perfect Peter! He's got the looks, the voice, he does his own stunts, he's not 30! He's the perfect Spider-Man! He's not cheesy like Toby or not as much as a cry baby like Andrew!

Tom is the actual perfect Peter Parker. This should be obvious as he is the most like the comics!

He’s waay better than Andrew. He looks more like Peter Parker, his character makes a little bit more sense. He at least did the performances perfectly. Andrew just looks a little bland, it’s just that I felt like TASM gets too boring and dull. So yeah, I think Tom Holland is better.

Too bad he's out of the MCU now. At least we'll still see him...

3 Andrew Garfield Andrew Russell Garfield is a British-American actor. Born in Los Angeles, California and raised in Epsom, Surrey, Garfield began his career on the UK stage and in television productions. He's best known for The Amazing Spider-Man films, and The Social Network (a film about the founding of Facebook), in 2021 he returned as Spider-Man in Spider-Man No Way Home. Garfield intentionally said he wasn't in the movie, claiming that the leaked footage was "photoshop" and that he wasn't the "werewolf", however, when the movie was released said claims ended up being proven false. Proving that he was lying probably as part of a Non-Disclosure Agreement thing most likely.

He grew up loving spider-man and wished for one day playing his comic book idol.

My name is Rafe, I am bald, I am gay, I am an Exorcist, I like Taco Bell bathroom, I am an Andrew stan!

There's only 2 items!

Are you kidding me?

4 Christopher Daniel Barnes
5 Josh Keaton
6 Paul Soles
7 Rino Romano
8 Neil Patrick Harris Neil Patrick Harris is an American actor, writer, producer, comedian, magician, and singer. He is known primarily for his comedy roles on television and his dramatic and musical stage roles.
9 Alistair Abell
10 Benjamin Diskin
The Contenders
11 Yuri Lowenthal

How’s Yuri not way higher? I gotta say he’s become my favorite Spider-Man voice. He has the quip delivery of Tom Holland with the sense of vulnerability of Tobey Maguire. Should easily be in the top 3 in my opinion.

12 Quinton Flynn
13 Drake Bell Jared Drake Bell is an American actor, voice actor, and musician. Born in Newport Beach, California, he began his career as an actor in the early 1990s at the age of five with his first televised appearance on Home Improvement.

Drake and josh!

14 Jake Johnson
15 Dan Gilvezan
16 Tom Kenny Thomas James Kenny is an American actor and comedian known for his long-running role as the title character in the SpongeBob SquarePants TV series and films. Kenny has voiced many other characters including Heffer Wolfe in Rocko's Modern Life, the Ice King in Adventure Time, the Mayor in The Powerpuff Girls, Dog in CatDog, and Spyro from the Spyro the Dragon franchise. His live-action work includes the comedies The Edge and Mr. Show.

Woah, SpongeBob voiced Spider-Man? Who knew?

17 Dane DeHaan

My favorite actor aka my idol!

18 Shameik Moore
19 Nicholas Hammond
BAdd New Item