Top 10 TV Shows that Had Major Cast Changes

Ever found yourself watching your favorite show and suddenly, a beloved character is gone, replaced by someone new? It's a jarring experience, but sometimes it works out surprisingly well. Other times...not so much. Major cast changes are a gamble for any TV show, but they can also lead to unexpected twists and turns that keep things interesting.
The Top Ten
1 Family Guy Initially, Lacey Chabert provided the voice for Meg Griffin during the show's first season. However, due to scheduling conflicts, Mila Kunis replaced her from the second season onwards. This recasting has stuck, with Kunis voicing the character in all subsequent episodes.
2 The Big Bang Theory The pilot episode of The Big Bang Theory underwent some changes before reaching its final form. Initially, the character we know as Penny was named Katie and played by manda Walsh. However, audience feedback during test screenings led to a character overhaul. They recast the role with Kaley Cuoco and reshaped the character, ultimately creating the beloved Penny we know today.
3 The Office The American version of The Office faced a significant shift when Steve Carell, who brought the awkward charm of Scranton branch manager Michael Scott to life, left the show after seven seasons. His departure was followed by the introduction of several new characters including the enigmatic Robert California, played by James Spader.
4 The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air Perhaps one of the most notable recastings in sitcom history is that of Aunt Vivian Banks. Janet Hubert originally played the character for the first three seasons before being replaced by Daphne Maxwell Reid for the remaining seasons. This recasting sparked much discussion and speculation among fans.
5 Game of Thrones The sprawling epic saw several recastings throughout its run. Ed Skrein originally portrayed Daario Naharis in the third season but was replaced by Michiel Huisman in the fourth season. The Mountain was played by three different actors: Conan Stevens in Season 1, Ian Whyte in Season 2, and Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson from Season 4 onwards. Tommen Baratheon was also recast, with Callum Wharry playing the role in the first two seasons before being replaced by Dean-Charles Chapman for the rest of the series.
6 Cheers While Cheers remained largely stable in its main cast, there were notable additions rather than recastings. Kirstie Alley joined the show in its sixth season as Rebecca Howe, replacing Shelley Long's character, Diane Chambers, as the female lead. This change added a new dynamic to the series and helped maintain its popularity.
7 Rick and Morty Rick and Morty, the animated science fiction sitcom created by Justin Roiland and Dan Harmon, experienced a significant cast change when co-creator Justin Roiland, who voiced both titular characters, was fired in 2023. The show's production team announced that they would recast the roles of Rick and Morty to continue the series without Roiland. This decision marked a pivotal moment for the show, which had become iconic partly due to Roiland's unique voice work and improvisational style.
8 Grey's Anatomy This medical drama has seen numerous cast changes over its long run. Notably, the role of Dr. Ellis Grey, Meredith Grey's mother, was originally played by Kate Burton in a guest appearance before being recast with Sarah Paulson for a flashback episode. However, Burton returned to the role in later appearances.
9 Charlie's Angels The original Charlie's Angels series saw several recastings. Farrah Fawcett, one of the original angels, left after the first season and was replaced by Cheryl Ladd as Kris Munroe. Later, Shelley Hack and Tanya Roberts were brought in to replace departing angels, keeping the trio dynamic fresh throughout the series.
10 Doctor Who Doctor Who, the long-running British science fiction series, is well-known for its major cast changes, particularly in the role of the Doctor. The concept of regeneration allows the Doctor to transform into a new body, leading to different actors portraying the character over the years. This innovative approach has allowed the show to evolve continuously since its debut in 1963, with each new actor bringing their unique interpretation to the iconic Time Lord.
The Contenders
11 That 70s Show The role of Laurie Forman, Eric's older sister, was originally played by Lisa Robin Kelly. Due to personal issues, Kelly left the show and was replaced by Christina Moore in the sixth season. This recasting occurred amid the show's run, creating a noticeable change in the character's portrayal.
12 The Sopranos While The Sopranos largely retained its core cast, it did experience a significant recasting for the role of Father Phil Intintola. After being played by Michael Santoro in his first appearance, the role was recast with Paul Schulze, who continued to portray the character for the remainder of the series.

Small role to begin with and barely significant in the "first appearance," which is a pilot episode made long before the series. This isn't unusual. Cast changes and other adjustments are often made after a pilot. Another recurring character, Irina, is also played by a different actress in the pilot.

One "problem" is that marketing presents it as "episode one" while it really isn't. The series actually begins with the episode "46 Long."

The slight cast changes are less significant than some other story adjustments.

BAdd New Item