Top Ten Video Games With the Creepiest Storylines

The Top Ten

1 BioShock
2 The Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask

The moon is gonna squash us

You can't get much more scary than this.

3 Eternal Darkness
4 Amnesia: The Dark Descent
5 Cho Aniki

Ha ha!
This is weirdest storyline ever!

6 Hong Kong 97
7 Earthbound
8 Mother 3
9 Metroid Fusion
10 Dark Souls

The Contenders

11 Metroid Prime Trilogy
12 Resident Evil Trilogy
13 Drake of the 99 Dragons
14 Half-Life
15 Doom
16 Five Nights at Freddy's

Basically, 5 kids go missing in a pizzeria without a trace. They possess animatronics and they want revenge. They think you are responsible for their deaths so they attempt to murder you. Soon, it's shown that someone who worked there lured them into a backroom and killed them. He stuffed them into animatronics suits so he wouldn't be caught by the cops. They were noted dead, bodies never found.

17 Cave Story
18 Super Paper Mario

The world is about to end, and it's up to you, your girlfriend, your brother, and your arch nemesis to save it. - Synchronocity

19 Beyond Good and Evil
20 The White Chamber
21 Wario Land 4

The heck is wario? - XxSEVEREDHUMANITYxX

22 Resident Evil 4
23 Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
24 Zelda: Wand Of Gamelon

I mean, some of these games aren't that scary by themselves; it's when you dig deeper that the true horror comes. But fact that this is higher than The Walking Dead, Slender, and The Binding of Isaac deeply amuses me. - Synchronocity

25 The Last Of Us
8Load More
PSearch List