Best Race Horses of All TimeWho are the best race horses of all time? It's hard to choose.
I understand the Man O War debate, but Turcotte did run Secretariat with weights during training and still set record times, not many people know that. His times and records are undisputable, he's the only horse to ever get faster times from start to finish at the Kentucky Derby. And while MOW was awesome and a beast, I do not think ANY horse could have beaten Secretariat at that Belmont race.
The fastest horse on dirt from 1 3/16 to 1 5/8 miles in history.
Secretariat holds the STILL STANDING fastest recorded times in the world on dirt all the way from 1 3/16 to 1 5/8 miles in HISTORY and is just 0.2 seconds off the current 1 1/8 mile world record. He NEVER lost a race that was not caused by ill health (x2), unprepared replacement for other horse in long distance race (x1), severe interference (x1) or unfair disqualification (x1). Excluding these factors, he won his remaining 16 races all by handsome margins of multiple lengths, never a photo finish. Under healthy and fair conditions he would beat ANY horse put against him, not by a nose but by a margin of lengths.
" He won the triple crown in record time FOR ALL THREE RACES! He won by a distance of 32 lengths and his whole career he was shrouded in doubt because of the way he ran, everyone thought he was a bold ruler colt that would break down and not go all the way, they also thought that some of his health problems would destroy him. He came from a lady who had almost no experience in horse racing and rose to be an amazing horse who syndicated for a record-breaking 6 million dollars. Secretariat won horse of the year and had the heart and soul of a champion, he knew he was the best.
The wins are unlikely to be matched by any horse again. As a 3YO, he won from 7 furlongs to 13 on dirt, slop and turf, defeating 3 future Hall of Famers, 13 World, track or stakes record setting horses, and setting no fewer than 7 stakes, 5 track and two world records, including all three Triple Crown records (marks which have stood for 40 years now). He was capable of remarkable versatility in his running style, running around horses, through horses or on the lead the whole way. He nearly set a track record as a 2YO in an 8.5 furlong race (one fifth of a second off mark). His losses, while unfortunate, mostly came as a result of his handlers' desire to let the country see the horse race before his retirement mandated by the breeding syndicate. He was generally such a sound healthy horse that they made a couple of mistakes with him, but that shouldn't take away from his absolutely remarkable performances when healthy and properly trained.
Undefeated in 21 starts if it weren't for a bad restart by the guy with the starting gun. He was facing the wrong direction after a restart when the starting gun went off (only race he ever lost, and t was only 6 furlongs and he lost by a head after spotting everyone 10 lengths. Also raced back in the day when many factors affected the times so they are not comparable to modern day times. If you factor it all in, Man o' War had the fast times of all and never ran a bad race.
In fact the only 1 he lost might have been the fastest any race horse has ever gone considering it was the only one he ever had to give it his all (of course, factoring in the heavier shoes, deeper tracks, etc).
For me, the only real way to compare and judge competitors from different eras in any athletic discipline is in how dominant they were. And in that, Man O' War has no competition. He nearly made a mockery of the sport, and all his latest "races" were really just speed exhibitions, as by then, no one wanted to send their best horses out to be so dominated. And all of that was with some of the highest handicap weights ever assigned. He was retired at 3, because had he raced another year, he likely would've been sent to post with even higher weight assignments - the highest assigned weights of any race horse in history to this day.
People really need to do their homework before just voting for a name they recognize. MOW was killing the competition so bad that the jockey club started forcing him to carry more weight. He was carrying on average 32 pounds more than the other horses and he was still beating them so badly that it actually became hard for him to find anyone that was willing to race. It became so ridiculous that in his fourth year of racing the jockey club wanted him to add more weight. His owner thought that was to dangerous and retired him because he was scared he would get hurt. N'ough said, I love Secretariat but I'm sorry MOW would beat the brakes off of him.
MOW was absolutely the greatest horse since Eclipse (1764). Even having Seabiscuit in the top 50 all-time shows this is about general popularity from movies than from facts. And contrary to the movie, War Admiral was not much bigger than Seabiscuit. Native Dancer and Secretariat would be tied at # 2 in a legitimate poll. Native Dancer won 21 of 22 and only lost the Kentucky Derby because of a poor ride. He sired Raise a Native who in turn sired almost half the horses alive today through his sons and and was damsire of Northern Dancer, the # one sire of the last 75 years. Native Dancer sired most of the half not from sons of RaN
Forget the American nonsense, all races on flat dirt tracks against rubbish opposition means nothing. The obsession with timing is also complete nonsense. Frankel is the best horse I've ever seen in 45 years
Not a horse in the classic sense, more a unnatural force of nature. On the rundown to the stalls I would get chills, and by the time he was being loaded I'd start to hear white noise...that's the sound of pure electricity...it hung in the air wherever the horse raced. You could slice the atmosphere with a knife, it was so thick with electricity. No other horse has ever given me these types of sensations. When he ran it was pure adrenaline. The air was thick with that too. He exuded it, and the other horse's felt it, they all knew who was boss before they even went into the stalls, they could smell it and sense it. Frankel was, is and will always be the king of all Alpha's.
Frankel, much more than just a undefeated European champion, the best thoroughbred to ever set foot to a racetrack throughout the history of the thoroughbred. At his peak, rated a remarkable 147, a rating which has never been repeated, nor never will. His 2000 Guineas win was right up there with the best of his performance's, going hard out from start to finish and still making everything else look extremely ordinary, two furlong's out, Frankel was an amazing 15 length's clear, an achievement no one will ever see a thoroughbred perform again. Frankel had it all, a 100% perfect record, 14/14, which could have went at least 100/100 had his connection's decide to keep the equine champion going. Yes, Phar Lap's, Melbourne Cup win's and other major win's were quite impressive, but the level of horse's he faced would have been no where near the quality of horses Frankel destroyed easily. Yes, the famous Seabiscuit story was an amazing, unlikely fairytale, but to call him the best ever? No. ...more
Been watching the greats for best part of last 50 years and Frankie has at the time of writing won 12 from 12 (10 group 1's) and has plenty scope as he goes now to the Juddmonte and up to 10 furlongs - can't ever recall seeing ANYTHING quite as good as this fella at the mile and the great thing is he really does appear to be getting even better - They make movies about the great horses in Hollywood and its plain to see how they exaggerate performances etc for dramatic effect, hope I'm still around to see what a director will do to attempt to improve the perfection that is FRANKEL!
I like character and am most impressed when a horse or person is challenged that they take on that challenge. Any horse or person that does this is in my mind a REAL CHAMPION. That is why I need to choose Seabiscuit.
Seabiscuit, I think should be the number 1 horse that ever lived because unlike most of these horses in this list, they are born naturally big. Seabiscuit was the underdog before he showed the world what he was really made of. Despite of his smaller size compared to his rivals in his time, he was asked to run with heavier loads but still managed to run in record time, now imagine if he carries less weight. Wooh. At the end of the day, even without the size or the handsomeness of what secretariat has, he still is one of the greatest that ever lived and that is because the horse has heart and his not willing to back down from any competition.
Speed alone doesn't make the greatest horse. Courage and intelligence should count, too. Also, in considering Seabiscuit's winning times for races versus other horses winning times at the same distance, you have to consider he won a lot of handicap races where he was carrying heavier weight than horses who might have faster times in other races. Seabiscuit was also very smart. He had to relearn things in ways horses who were expected to win from 2 years old never had to. At 2, he was used to boost confidence in other horses, taught to always pull up so the other could win. He had to learn a totally different way of doing things then, so he could win races at all. He also learned an unfamiliar starting method just to race War Admiral. Stats on paper are never a complete story.
Seabiscuit won the heart of the nation. He ran past most racehorses retirement age with weights higher than most horses ever run with. I think the most seabiscuit ran with was 133 lbs or something around there. Secretariats highest weight was only 126 lbs. Seabiscuit also taunted his opponents letting them catch up then speeding away from them again. If Seabiscuit had better opponents he would have just gone faster. I would love to see a race between Seabiscuit, who never backed down, and Secretariat, who set multiple still standing track records. I don't know who would win. All I'm saying is no one ever saw Seabiscuit run against a horse he couldn't beat.
Zenyatta is probably the greatest horse ever... She was so great that she never ran a whole race to her potential but won everyone but one... Check her times her last mile in the breeders cup faster than the because winner fastest last mile in because history fastest quarter mile in history of the b cup. 17 plus hands has a stride second to none no horse has ever gained ground on her gives a world class horse 5 lengths with 300 yds to go n catches him... No other horse alive can run her down... And if I'm wrong prove it... If you had every great horse alive at the quarter pole tied coming for home... I'm sure you would not leave her out... Why? Cause you know why!
Zenyatta had a human quality about her. She was an amazing race horse. I've never seen a horse behind 3 lengths with a furlong to go and win the race after kicking into the highest of gears. Zenyatta winning the Breeders Cup Classic in 2009 was the equivalent of the New England Patriots' Adam Vinatieri winning the 2002 Super Bowl with a field goal on the last play of the game. Even better possibly? Zenyatta running down St. Trinians in the 2010 Vanity. Simply Amazing. If not for jockey error, Zenyatta would have also won the 2010 Classic, and gone 20-20 all time. Mike Smith shook her loose, inexplicably, 2 seconds too late. She beats Blame going away if he plays that race right. Still, one of the best ever!
She should be second on list. I'm not even into horses or racing but honestly followed ONLY while this female ROCKET was out laying the smack down to anybody who dared get near her. The ONLY reason she ever lost was all Mike Smith's fault, he even owned up to it and other jockeys just kept mouths shut because that knew there hasn't been a horse like her ever. Nobody even touches her times today! Her personality was amazing, I mean she actually danced for the cameras and crowds. She's at WORST top 5 all time, these others are just big names everybody knows THE Z TRAIN IS#2 FOR SURE
I love Zenyatta! She never failed to entertain us. Her personality made millions fall in love with her. I follow her now as a broodmare and I have to say she's just a great mother. She has two striking colts and a beautiful filly. Can't wait to see them on the track. Cozmic One is two and so is Rachel Alexandra's colt, Jess's Dream. We never had the chance to see a Rachel vs. Zenyatta, but maybe we will have the honor to see these two regally bred colts square off on the track.
Phar Lap should be nr 1. He must be the best racehorse of all times. He died way to soon, and I get depressed just to think about it. There is no doubt in my mind that he would have beaten any other racehorse, even the great Secretariat. He was taller than any other racehorse, and had to endure the extra weigt they put on him. He also won 37 of 51 races. So just imagine what he could do if he was still here. It just hurts my heart that he ran twice as many races that any racehorse do today before retirement. They pushed him too hard. The horse Towering Inferno that played Phar lap in the film, died of lightning, he was also nicknamed Bobby, just like Phar Lap. And that Pharlap in Thai means Light from the sky, is just spookey. That the horse who played him in the movie died by lightning. This is not just a coinsidence.
Glad Lys Gracieux won the 2019 Cox Plate to put some perspective on things. Lys was class but some argue Almond Eye is better. Winx winning four Cox Plates was great but Lys Gracieux highlights the differences in class from different areas.
Now lets talk about Phar Lap. Simply goes against Americas best on dirt versus turf by boat and wins easy under sufferance in record or near record time at the time and going wide. Phar Lap is so far ahead of Frankel and co it does not matter a is a true challenger to the likes of Secretariat. Genuine freak and some say who so both horses race the best of all time!
Very few horses ever have their name liveth forever more. Pegasus was the great winged stallion in Greek mythology. Greco-Roman poets wrote about the ascent of Pegasus to heaven after his birth, and his subsequent obeisance to Zeus, king of the gods, who instructed him to bring lightning and thunder from Olympus. One could then say that thousands of years later that the lightning would strike, and strike hard in the world of Thoroughbred racing. In the Thai language the word "Phar Lap" translated to English means "lightning". Pegasus lives on; and so does Phar Lap in the hearts and eyes of many.
He crushed all opposition south of the equator on every type of surface from sprints to 2 1/4 miles. His win in the AJC Plate as a 3yo was his Secretariat moment. At one stage he led by 30 lens, bettering every track record beyond a mile before easing down to win by ten and smashing the Australasian record for the distance by over 6 seconds. He endured extraordinary and well documented challenges to race the best the North America could put against him when racing on dirt for the first time, first up, dropping to last in the early stages, circling the field to lead before set a new track record when winning the Agua Caliente. He ran 2f in under 23 seconds during that surge. Legendary jockeys Willie Carson and Eddy Arcaro were there on the day and were effusive in their praise - the greatest horse they'd seen. The cotton wool champions of today could never match his range and toughness.
The reason that I think that she was the greatest ever racehorse was not only the fact that she won 25 races from 25 starts but the fact that she raced 24 of them over 5/6 furlongs. Followed horse racing for the last 50 yrs and although a lot of horses have had a long sequence of wins, none has won 25 and more importantly those that did win most of their races were from 1mile to 1and a half miles - no sprinter other than Black Caviar has had more than 10 consecutive wins over the shorter distances, somehow they managed to have one or more off days but B.C. always, always found a way to win
Hard to compare her against middle distance and beyond but definitely the greatest sprinter ever. Had a cruising speed that was untouchable in the jurisdiction that breeds and races the worlds fastest sprinters of this era. Did stretch to 7 furlongs but it would be debatable that she could have repelled the stamina of Frankel at that distance. It surely would have been a race to remember if they met and is a big shame as both were in their physical prime at the same point in time. Unfortunately they were on different sides of the planet certainly Frankel's connections had no financial incentive to travel and as it turned out Black Caviar didn't seem to cope well with her trip to England anyway although she still managed to win. Unfortunately due to circumstances Europeans never got to see her awesome ability because if you compared her to some of the recent dominating performances of Australian sprinters that went to Royal Ascot then they would have witnessed her winning by a very big ...more
Won on straight tracks, turning tracks, left handed, right handed, all over Australia and travelled to the other side of the world to win at Royal Ascot, when she injured herself in the run. All time Australasian Group1 wins record holder. World's highest rated horse and highest rated sprinter. Beat world's 2nd highest rated sprinter 6 out of 6 times. Track record holder at Australia's premier track and fastest ever 200m sectional. Defeated 50+ individual Group1 winners and remained unbeaten. 25 starts for 25 wins incl. 15 Grp1 wins (14 open class against colts/fillies/mares), 7 Group2 wins and 2 Stakes race wins for $7.9 million in stakemoney. Champion.
I saw her race three times live and each time I was on the fence at the winning post. Watching her coming down the straight is a memory I will never forget and it was all so easy to her. Each time she gapped her rivals in the blink of an eye, and always whilst just being ridden hands and heels the whip never touched her big, beautiful arse.
The others on this list are magnificent, but Ruffian was my heart. I honestly believe she could have given the others on this list beaten many of them outright, if not given them a run for their money. We never saw this filly's bottom.. She was leaving Foolish Pleasure behind even as the break occurred. Zenyatta could not have caught her simply because Z is a closer, and at the top of the stretch Ruffian's jockey Jacinto Vasquez would have turned Ruffian loose to run just as Zenyatta was getting started. And look no further than Secetariat's trainer, Lucien Lauren, who said "As God is my judge she might be better than Secretariat. That man had to reason to lie.
Why do people take a great horse and put her 7th!? Ruffian was the greatest horse at under a mile. Maybe even the greatest ever. She could sprint or stay and would beat anyone and everyone they threw at her. But on that fateful day she would face a colt for the first time in her life. At the start she banged her left shoulder on the starting gate and swerved hard on her right foot. But despite any pain she kept running and in a few strides she was dead even with Foolish Pleasure. After a brisk three furlongs a flock of birds flew in front of them and the great filly's ankle snapped. But she kept running pulverizing her sesamoids ripping the bone through her skin until finally after 100 yards she stopped. After 8 hours of trying to save Ruffian's life, she was finally put to rest. Her final resting place is in the infield at Belmont Park, with her nose pointed towards the finish line.
That match race broke my heart and changed the way I viewed horse racing. I love the horses, especially when you see one like Ruffian who ran for the love of it.
Ruffian was this once in a lifetime horse..not just for me, for everyone. Mystical, dark, black except for a little around her delicate nose, she was a monster on the track. Ruffian had sprinter speed, even moreso than regular sprinters, but could take it a mile and a half, yet she was wrapped up in a show horse's body. A horse like this comes along only once in a lifetime, I was old enough to watch her tragic race, yet young enough to mourn her for decades. Have we had other very good female racers? Absolutely. But, for example, Zenyatta could not catch Ruffian, and Rachel would not be able to keep up with her. She was not around long enough to set long win records, hers stopped much too early. One of my wishes would be to bring her back to us, but we who truly LOVED this magnificent horse will hopefully see her again. As far as the match race goes, which any knowing horse racing fan would agree was a very bad idea, she was already putting her competitor down; he was already getting ...more
By far better than frankel won at 1 mile 1 furlongs won 1965 Epsom derby on the bridle and beat the best ever fiel ever in the 1965 arc by 6 lengths could have been 20 but crossed over the track in the final furlong second home was diatome winner of the 65 French derby and he beat the third by 8 lengths I have been watching horse racing for over 50 years and have seen most of the brilliant horses in that time great horses that where fantastic...but sea bird11 peerless no question!
Sea Bird was the pre eminent racehorse in Europe in the 20th century. He won the Epsom Derby and Prix de l'arc de Triomphe on the bridle , the only horse ever to do this. He was so good that he was never extended so no-one knows just how good he was. I have seen all the great racehorses of the past 50 years, but Sea Bird is the only one who sent shivers up and down my spine. Many people consider him ' Champion of Champions'.
Won his races with ease and when he won the Prix de l'arc de Triomphe it was probably the best ever field, which he strode away from.
I saw Sea Bird win the Epsom Derby in 1965 and his performance was simply mindblowing. He won the most prestigious Derby in the world in a common canter and 11 of the horses who finished behind him won 15 races between them during the remainder of that season. 'Champion of Champions' is a fitting title for this equine superstar.
I understand the sentiment of those who think it's not right to put Barbaro on a best racehorse list. For obvious reasons I agree. But those people 1) didn't see him win the Kentucky Derby in one of the best fields in a very long time. Such a natural! Such ease! No sweat - literally. No foam at the mouth. Just a stroll in the park. He was amazing! I would have bet the farm on his winning the triple crown. In fact, after the Derby, I turned to a friend and said, "It would take something catastrophic to keep this horse from running away with the next two races. He loved to run, and it was so easy for him. So sad.
Understood that his career was curious short, but his KD was one of the greatest and strongest ever run. His second half split was crazy. His career leading up to that day was impressive as anything and thinking for a second that hea wouldn't have won the Preakness had he not been cut off and had to slow up and misstep, then you aren't being realistic. That was a very strong field at both as well as the Florida Derby. He is more than "a feel good story", he was a beast and he was a machine.
Barbaro was an ok race horse, but not in the top 20 or maybe even top 50. There are so many other deserving race horses like the #9 Zenyatta. No offense to Barbaro lovers- but the only reason Barbaro is relevant is because he won the Kentucky, and died on the track. Only one great accomplishment is his life.
Barbaro was a GOOD horse but did not accomplished much to be rank number 8.. it's ridiculous and an insult to racing and other greats to put Barbaro at number 8... ghost Zapper, holy bull at 3 just like barbaro, would had beaten Barbaro very easily.. this horse does not belong in the top 100
Interesting breeding which shouldn't have produced a horse of this higher calibre. He was a terrifically physically impressive specimen who oozed power and apparently he was not "molly-coddled" as a youngster. A horse who looked his best when galloping up the hill at Newmarket in '71.
Not at his best when suffering his only defeat in 18 races. Beat the strongest post war Guineas field and proved classy enough to win a King George over a trip beyond his best. Multiple group 1 winner certainly the greatest 1m -1m2f turf horse
Lots of talk about Frankel being the greatest but has not beaten the quality that the Brigadier beat and Frankel's four year old campaign has been brilliant but not tested him in the Arc for E.G. brigadier still my number one! Nijinsky a close second.
Best mile and mile and a quarter hordr. Would beat Frankel up a stick. Frankel beat the same 6/7 Horses throught his career. The Brigadier beat horses like Mill Reef My Deallow Scottish Rifle Parnell Dahlia. etc. All who went on to win Classic and Group Races.
To have sea the stars in this position tells me how completely stupid this list is. Secretariat deserves his place at no. 1 due to his speed records, to hold the triple crown, break all the records and still hold the Belmont stakes record 40 years on! Unbelievable. But sea the stars has done something that no horse has ever done and many have tried. The Guinness, derby and arc in the same season as well as 3 10 furlong group 1s every month for 6 months. The 2 times he was pushed he broke race and track records for the distance. He always done enough but I have no doubt the better the opposition the faster this colt could go. For me a very close second to secretariat.
A truly impeccable 3yo campaign from 1m to 1.4m he beat everything with a touch of class could of won a triple crown had he ran in the st leger, a devastating turn of foot and a cruising speed of a jet. Kinane sat on some terrific horses I. E high chaparral, rock of Gibraltar, Galileo, montjeu, hawk wing and many more his C. V as a jockey was amazing he won many of group 1s all around the world yet there was no doubt in his mind that the star was the best horse he'd ever seen or sat on, as Kim McGrath said when he hit the front in the arc "PERFECTION IN EQUINE FORM' THE GREATEST EVER
2000 Guineas over 1 mile, Epsom Derby & Arc de Triomphe over 1 1/2 miles, Eclipse & Irish Champion Stakes and York International Stakes over 1 1/4 miles all Group 1 races won over 6 months. Wow!
Incredible horse.. Only ever did enough and whatever pushed him he would stick his head out... Against anything... The horse I think he would have had trouble against would be franked over a mile... Any distance after that no competition
Last triple crown winner that is always underrated. Perfect horse physically. Graceful andpowerful, affirmed is overlooked when it comes to experts. His battles with alydar are classic. The greatest rivallry in racing history. Affirmed is my no 7 horse
Won more Grade 1 races than any other horse, 22 for 29 lifetime racing against Alydar, Seattle Slew and Spectacular Bid! If you exclude Affirmed from your top ten list you lose credibility in my opinion.
Affirmed when he retired was a horse they knew could set world records. Affirmed broke hroses Hart's there will to ever race again. He is right up along side Secratairat.
Magnificent horse. Won the triple crown races under increasing stretch pressure like no other winner ever endured. Too much heart to allow Alydar to get his nose in front!
The "Wonder Filly", who is one of the only fillies to ever have been compared to the great Ruffian. Her 20 1/4 length win in the Oaks was impressive, but her win in the Preakness against the boys was something else entirely. Her time at the Mother Goose Stakes was less than a second slower than the record set by Secretariat. She recently ran against the best boys in the country at Woodbine, and she became the first filly to ever win that race. She also set a track and course record. Calvin Borel, who ran Mine That Bird to victory in the 2009 Kentucky Derby and gave up his Preakness ride to jockey Rachel instead, says that she is "The best horse he has ever ridden. " His list of horses whom he had jockeyed is impressive, to say the least.
I think this horse deserves recognition. The race between her and Curlin was one of the best and thrilling races I have ever seen. She should have ran against the boys in the Kentucky Derbyshire. You never know, she had the potential to beat the boys.
A win in the Kentucky Oaks, two weeks later defeats colts in the Preakness Stakes...!
Great filly.. but not a top 25 horse. Only one great season. Maybe a top 70 horse, but not 25
To put Seattle Slew below Zenyatta is a joke to the world of horse racing. The zenyaheads are out, obviously! Slew was the only undeafeated Triple Crown winner, he did it with ease, he beat another Triple Crown winner in a race, and this horse is one of the few horses that changed racing forever by being an incredible stallion when he was retired. His life still lives on today, in my mare, in many horses and I rather doubt that it will ever die out. He was a beautiful horse, despite when young being called Baby Huey, a 17, 500 bargain of the history of racing. He beat quality horses as well, and unlike Zenyata she only raced male horses twice and lost once to them. A fine mare, but nowhere above the incredible Seattle Slew. TD
What makes Seattle Slew the greatest was the ability to reproduce champions. Affirmed is listed #13 and Seattle Slew defeated him twice and is listed #15.
How can they possibly rank the great Seattle Slew this low? He was the ONLY undefeated Triple Crown winner (up until last year) and as a breeding sire can arguably be deemed the greatest of all time, bar none. This list is complete BS--Slew should be ranked either #1 (if you also include passing on his talent to his get--no one else even comes close) or at the very least #2 if you are only comparing what each horse did on the racetrack.
I remember the news brimming with Seattle Slew's victory. It seemed that everyone was excited that so much attention was given to a horse and a race somewhere across the country. For a moment, we all felt we were back in some 1940's Mickey Rooney movie (The Black Stallion). And it was also the year my son, Jason Byron, was born. How can I not remember and not vote for Seattle Slew as my favorite?
Citation is number 1 folks. The greatest horse of the 20th Century. 27 for 29 as a 3 year old, speaks for itself. Won the Jersey Stakes by 11 lengths in the midst of the Triple Crown. The Pimlico Special was a walk-over - no one else would take him on. Ran on 10 different tracks. To quote Andy Cannon, "If you went to Citation's grave today, and played a bugle, the call to the post; Citation would break out of the ground and beat everything else around". A LOT of folks still feel that that's true. Citation was the winner of the computer simulated race between the greats. There's no doubt about it - he's number one!
Please do your thoroughbred horse racing history. Citation is second to none. S. Fitzsimmons said that Citation was the greatest horse that he ever saw - and he saw Man 'O War. Citation won the Sysonby Stakes mid week, run at a mile; then went on to win the Jockey Club Gold Cup that same week-end, then run at 2 miles. Citation beats Secretariat, any track, any distance, any day.
He won the Sysomby Mile as a three year old against the best older sprinters in the country. The three days later he won the Jockey Club Gold Cup at two miles against the best older distance horses in the country. No one has done that before or since. As a three year old he started 20 times and won 19. Man o War started 11 times and won all 11. Secratariat started 12 times and won 9.
Citation is number ONE without a doubt. His races across country and the outstanding way he won them, not to mention the computer simulated race between him and all the other great ones, he comes out on top! I love to watch DVD's they have of his triumphs!
,Unfortunately there are too many Americans voting who simply don't appreciate what the National is.
It is the ultimate test over the ultimate jumps over the ultimate distance.
To win it once is incredible, to win it twice is phenomenal, to win it thrice is verging on impossible, throw in a Scottish national in the same year & its other two appearances also being in the top 4 finishes, is simply one of the most outrageous achievements which anybody has ever heard of.
I mean I get that Secretariat was a phenomenally quick horse and has hammered records that have stood for years, and still holds those records today...but the Belmont is only a 12f race.
The Grand National, to put into perspective for people who don't know. Is a National Hunt Steeplechase, which is two laps of the track & over 30 fences, the field is usually around 50 horses, but has been as many as 66 before, the fastest time which has ever been run is just under 9 minutes, the race is just ...more
Greatest Horse of all time with the biggest heart, and in my opinion it's like Sprinters or Marathon Runners - Flat or Distance Horses - Jumpers over Distance are the Bravest and the fittest horses of the lot, especially ones that win over 4m 4f! Take a look at the National in which he beat Crisp @ Red Rum "1973" Grand National: Enough said, no need to bore with times, tracks, excuses for losing or not being unbeaten. Takes a true Class horse to come back after a taste of defeat to beat the best in the greatest test of horse racing... 3 times!
Red Rum should be called the greatest racehorse of all time, as he won the hardest, most challenging race that exists THREE TIMES. Incredible.
I believe it is unfair to place all these great flat horses with this ultimately fantastic horse. Red rum raced in one of the biggest races of all time over FENCES such as BEACHERS BROOK and the CHAIR before they were reduced in height and now after the reduction the still stand taller than me 5ft 2" if you ask any Brit even non horsey ones who red rum is they will know. I think red rum is the best horse over fences definitely. However I agree secretariat is the best horse ever
Undoubtedly the greatest steeplechaser of all time and he ran against top class chasers. Broke their hearts. I am sure he made a mockery of the handicap system. To rate Red Rum above this horse is nonsense. Arkle would have made him look like a Selling plater. Alan.
Arkle is the best race horse that ever came and went no horse could touch him if he wasnt carring extra weight no horse could have touched him. all these americans can say what they want about racing on the dirt and flat but when it came to jumps Arkle is the only one
This must be an American site, what with all those Yankee horses at the top. If Arkle hadn't been shackled with more weight than the rest no other horse would have got near him. 24th on this list is laughable, and so is Brigadier Gerard's placing.
Arkle may never have carried 13 stone but he often had to give up to 42 lbs to the opposition and he still beat them by a distance. Mill House was considered the best steeplechaser of all time then along came Arkle and broke his heart. Without doubt,Arkle was the best steeplechaser ever. Des
Probably the greatest Derby winner of all time and would have been a great stallion at stud had it not been for the scum that killed this fantastic horse. May they rot in hell.
His Derby win in 1981 ranks alongside Frankel's 2'000 Guineas win as a wonderful spectacle. Truly mesmorising. A great advertisement for our sport.
Still holds biggest winning margin in the Derby by some distance joke of a position
He should be in the top ten great horse with the success of winning the Irish derby
21st Century Seabiscuit. It's his unlikely story that makes him extra special. I used to wish that he had won the Triple Crown but then I wouldn't be enjoying him two years later. Moreover, I will have gotten to see him race in person three more times in my own backyard.
A $10,500 investment earns over $12M (and counting) on the track before stud. Marvelously ridiculous. I ranked him with LA Sports legends Magic Johnson, Marcus Allen, Kobe Bryant and Fernando Valenzuela as an athlete who brought hope, real excitement and prestige to Greater LA as well as the world.
Considering the high caliber of his competition, his ability on all surfaces and versatility in racing style being able to win on the lead or come from behind - he should certainly be in the top ten! All time leading money earner in North America means he excelled in the big races.
Sure not the greatest, but he is still racing and winning. Look at his last race! The Dubi gold world cup. So dominate and fast. Wait until this season is over. Will win the Breeders Classic and be horse of the year. Looks like American Pharoah of last year. Physically and mentally the best horse running in the world today.
California Chrome is the greatest horse ever. He is a true champion. Chrome brought awareness to fans who knew nothing at all about the races. He's truly the people's horse. I love Chrome and everything he stands for. His owners and trainers are also awesome.
Winx is a great barometer horse. She is a freak. I have never seen a horse win races so comfortably. Her stride rate is freakish. Maybe she is a modern day sea biscuit version but she is a freak. She regularly finishes off the last 4 furlongs at unheard of speeds easily with consistently. In this regard I think she could beat Frankel. In fact Winx could sit on Frankel and go past him such was her sustained burst. Its interesting because Black Caviar would beat Frankel for sure up to 1200 at least. Winx would beat Frankel probably 1800 and beyond. Having said all this Phar Lap is a different level of freak compared to Winx. Winx is an all time great but pedestrian compared to what Phar Lap pulled off!
A good horse no doubt but not the best. The class of opposition she beat was generally moderate. She never travelled overseas and in her final race today an ordinary horse from Japan, Kruger, got close to her. This horse wouldn't have gotten within cooee of Frankel, Sea Bird or the mighty Ribot. And what about Kincsem, unbeaten in 54 races. And Kincsem "TRAVELLED" unlike Winx. I am confident Winx would have met her Waterloo had she gone to Ascot to face Enable. Des
Just have a look at the distances she has won over, plus the caliber of her opposition. End of story or the beginning of her story. Watch what she does to her opposition. I would hate to own a champion racehorse and run it against her. I am so glad to be able to say I have seen her.
Winx has won 19 Group 1's. 30 horses have ran second or third to her 24 have won group one's. She IS beating great racehorses. She IS the greatest in Australia and no matter how many champions come along in my lifetime, from my eyes, in my life there all in winx's shadow. A true champion.
I watched him when he won the Arkansas Derby and every race after that. And when I saw him run I just knew that this was the horse to do it. He runs so flawlessly that you can't take your eyes off him. I know he's no Secretariat and I wasn't around during that time. But to me he gives you that hope like Secretariat did. And that's all that matters. Winning the triple crown only seemed like a pipe dream. But when he won, it looked like he won it with ease. He turned that dream into reality. Then he won the Breeders Cup Classic in record time. And I cried when he crossed the finish line. I never had that much emotion for any racehorse. Thank you Pharoah you gave me hope and I hope one day that I will be able to meet you. I think he deserves a rank because he turned non horse fans into racehorse fans. If that makes sense.
Three years ago American Pharoah won not the Triple Crown, but the Grand Slam of horse racing. I feel that some people overlook that saying that the horses he was up against were not as good as those previous Triple Crown winners raced against. But the same could be said about any other racehorse, that he/she won just because the other horses weren't that good. What makes Pharoah special is that he wasn't those other horses that could not continue racing after the strain of the Triple Crown and his owners and trainer felt that he had the strength to continue. He won the Grand Slam, the only horse to EVER do so which is why I think he is definitely as good as Secretariat and any other racehorse ranked higher than him. Personally, he is my favorite racehorse of all time, not just because of his impeccable career but because of his loving disposition, public appeal, and simply the way he won his races. I am so grateful that I was alive to watch him change the racing industry, and show ...more
No where near as talented as Secretariat, or Man O' War, but was a winner. He was an amazing racehorse. But he had a winner mentality. Won all 4 races, putting up an amazing time in the Belmont race. This horse is definitely better than Arrogate because Arrogate never even ran in an of the Triple Crown races. The Arrogate fans need to calm down, he barely beat an old California Chrome. Also, California Chrome injured himself before another time him and Arrogate faced off, and that is why he lost that one. Arrogate also doesn't have the best competition. American Pharoah went right into breeding after the Breeder's Classic, so he never faced off against Arrogate. But we all know American Pharoah would come out on top. American Pharoah is the best horse with Zenyatta of the post 2000's so far.
There are not many horses that come around like him. One of the most unique strides of a horse ever, and he used it to his advantage over the others. He was able to conserve energy and eat up tremendous amounts of ground in the mean time. He came within half a length of sweeping the Triple Crown along with the Travers and Breeders Cup Classic. Still, winning the Triple Crown and the Breeders Cup Classic may well stand the test of time. He will always be one of the most popular of all time great horses with that very unique and kind demeanor that he had towards people.
Did a term paper that included Omaha. He was a great racer and the research proved it.
Wonderful runner, totally underestimated by most.
Pharlap will never be matched
The most successful cheltenham gold cup winner winning it 5 times and the only horse to win the two nost prestigious steeplechases in the same year something that will never be beaten.
His record speaks for itself. His sheer courage got him around Aintree to win. He was a not a natural jumper of the huge pre-war fences in the Grand National.
It's a list made by americans for americans. Ok The big Red Secretariat can be on the first position. But I don't find for example in the list the italian Nearco, unbeaten on all distances in 14 races at 2 and 3 years old, and considered the best brreding sire of the 20th century. Fr remind, it was Northern Dancer's grandfather!
I think he was a true force of nature, capable of destroy the unlucky challengers in any race, over any distance and, above all, in any moment of the race. And the last one is the one that makes a racehorse a champion (Tesio said)
He should be up there in the top 5, He has won in all kind of distance and in turf/dirt. He won the biggest race in uk and France (twice). He is truly one of a kind.
Second greatest horse in the history of thoroughbred racing behind Sea Bird II. Ribot was unbeaten in 16 races stretching over three seasons.