Top Ten Strangest Five Nights at Freddy's Theories

I don't think it was Bonnie. It was most likely Freddy because they had just closed down Fredbear's Family Diner due to the bite of '83 by Golden Freddy. Also, Freddy's mask has a child's handprint on it, which is probably from him malfunctioning and biting a child. This aligns with when Phone Guy says, "The animatronics used to be able to wander around, but then there was the bite of '87. Yeah. It's amazing how a human body can live without the frontal lobe." He says this to us in FNAF 2, I think.

No. The bunny bully was the one who caused it because he planned it from him bullying Mike until he joined and said he would stop on his birthday. He does the prank then so Chris will die! Also, I don't think that people do play the game and then make theories. Only Game Theory does.

I believe that Foxy is good because, as you see in the first game, Foxy doesn't actually try to kill you. He is just in the doorway with his jaw hanging loose, which may explain the out of order sign on the curtain on his stage. I don't believe that in the second game he's trying to hug you, though.

He was already out of order when he turned old and his wires were hanging out in the second game, so his programming was obviously all messed up. If he was originally good in the first game, the messed-up programming probably just caused him to not function as he was supposed to.

Ok, so Smike once said that the Purple Guy might be an animatronic, which means he had an endoskeleton inside of him. What do you think? And the Purple Guy inside of Springtrap is not what I'm talking about. There are two different Purple Guys. I'm talking about the one with the white pupils and the phone. Or was it his animatronic hand?

Doubt it, but it's possible. Also, I am talking about William Afton, the Purple Guy. I mean Mike Afton, the Purple Guy, has an endo in him already in the form of Ennard. I do not think that he has an endo because in Silver Eyes, Twisted Ones, and Fourth Closet, he has normal skin, so he is probably not an animatronic.

I mean, I guess that would make some sense. I mean, the Endoskeleton could be Golden Foxy, and Chica was part of Fredbear's Diner until she was moved to Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria, or at least that's what I've heard before.

My friend told me his theory that the endoskeleton belonged to a Golden Foxy. Or maybe, it could be a... I actually have no idea.

There are only two proven Golden characters that performed at Freddy Fazbear's: Golden Freddy (called Fredbear) and Spring Bonnie (later called Springtrap because of the incident with Purple Guy).

So in the mini-games, purple represents shadows, correct? Such as Fazbear's in one scene. So he could just be in shadow. I mean, really, I'd be kind of concerned and not let my child anywhere near someone purple. I'd be calling an ambulance for him.

He actually isn't. As proven by FNaF 4, purple in the minigames represents shadows. It's meant to give him an "in the shadows" look. Also, in the graphic novels, he has normal skin.

This one is right! Purple Guy/William Afton isn't purple. It was revealed that Scott needed to make him a color sprite, and he's like: I have an idea. And Michael is purple.

Actually, I came up with this theory because it's the only possible place to have the game set. Will Scott Cawthon surprise us with the scene? We all love surprises.

1. Five Nights at Freddy's 4 is already out.
2. Five Nights at Freddy's 4 takes place in a house.

No. It was in C.C. Afton's room. How dumb are people today!? Do people really think a bedroom is a pizzeria?

I see JJ and Dee Dee (Balloon Girls) to Balloon Boy as best friends or sister and brother. Nothing more than that. FNaF is a horror game, so I don't have many ships for animatronics.

STOP saying that it would be "Balloon Girl." It would be the balloon, JJ, or DeeDee. Balloons don't have genders. I see JJ as his sister, and that leaves DeeDee. This can't really be canon, though. It would kind of make BB seem more human.

I honestly don't know... But it's weird.

I mean, just because they're both blue doesn't mean he's Elsa. I'm literally dying after reading this, though!

This would explain why he lets his guitar go when he leaves the stage.

May I please have evidence? I am genuinely curious about what your evidence is.

I am very ashamed to admit this, but I thought this theory was true, and everyone thought that I was crazy.

TRUE! They are hidden behind-the-scenes things. Some can be darker than the others though.

Were people living under a rock?

My god, how did you figure out that Freddy Fazbear's PIZZA was a pizzeria?

Wow, really? How on earth did you find out?

WOW! I don't know how you figured out that Freddy Fazbear's Pizza was a pizzeria.

Yeah, actually, it is not about any children going missing or anything like that, nor about getting stuffed in animatronics. The actual incident was in Aurora, Colorado, at a Chuck E. Cheese in 1993. A former employee, Nathan Dunlap, was furious about being fired five months prior to the attack. He hid in the restrooms just a couple of minutes before closing time. At 10:05 pm, he exited the restroom and shot five employees, with one survivor who played dead. He was sentenced to death, of course. This was a very sad incident.

Wow, it took you a while to figure that one out. Congrats! You passed preschool!

WHOA, that is so amazing. It's not like we all knew that before.

Nice job. *claps sarcastically*

I need to kick something. This is even stupider than any of the other theories, well, except the Bonnie is Elsa Theory. That's sad. That's a sad theory.

Okay, I love Star Wars, but this is insane! None of the other ones made me laugh, but I couldn't stop laughing at this one! Just how is this possible?

So, Foxy was a slave boy turned Jedi who turned to the Dark Side after having a nightmare about his wife dying, and was then extremely burned and needed a specialized suit to breathe? Right.

Why, just why? It's almost as if you're trying to kill me with laughter!

This has to be the weirdest FNaF theory ever. Paws down. I mean, what?! They're yellow, and that's it. No more similarities.

My hope in humanity is lost. This is by far the dumbest and funniest theory I've seen. I'm dying.

This is actually true. Funtime Foxy was made by fixing Mangle and adding some extra things for the location, and her soul just stayed in the animatronic.

Okay, essay time. Kinda. Funtime Foxy's body shape is different from fixed Mangle's body shape. So there you go.

This is true. If anyone read the novels, in The Fourth Closet, Funtime Foxy unfolds into Mangle and chases Charlie.

What the actual F? Who came up with this? Although it would be really funny if Chica's suit just opened up and you see Chester Cheetah's body. I would laugh so hard.

May I please have the evidence? This theory is by far the dumbest one on this list.

Chica opens up and you see Chester Cheeto. Help me.

What this means is that people have believed that the parrot on Mangle was a cupcake, and the eyes in BB's mouth were also a cupcake. Maybe it could be. I don't know.

For those who don't know, Carl the Cupcake is Chica's cupcake.

The lore now is kind of simple. Basically, William tested and experimented on Michael Afton after he stuffed the C.C. into Fredbear's mouth, where he was crushed by hydraulic pressure. As punishment, William placed mannequins around his house and sprayed Michael with hallucination gas to make it seem like the mannequins were actually animatronics trying to kill him. So, if Michael was the C.C. being bullied by his friends, this theory isn't entirely wrong.

This is proven by the books and the fact that the Afton House in the mini-game has the C.C. in a different room while the room we play in is Michael's. Hope this helps.

Okay, no. Animatronics can't have sexual orientations. If he hangs out in a girl's toilets, he's not looking at guys, so he's a pervert, not gay. Unless he's that guy from Mean Girls who says, OMG Danny DeVito, I love your work.

Uhm, you got any reason why Freddy is gay? I mean, people ship stuff like Freddy x Bonnie, Foxy x Freddy, Freddy x Golden Freddy, and Freddy x Tiny, and fem Springtrap x Golden Freddy, which is illegal, but it doesn't mean he's gay.

And how is this relevant? At all? Or even possible? I don't think animatronic fursuits can be sexually attracted to anything.

Let's see... Freddy is a boy. When the power is off, Freddy realizes that Mike is not sleeping and plays a song for him to sleep... Makes sense!

WHAT! I thought that Freddy was a male child, not a female adult.

Just no. And I thought Freddy was a boy child, not an adult woman.

Who is Toychica? Toy Chica is a female. I mean, she wears pink panties and has pink cheeks, and she has a curvy body. She's definitely female. So, is Toychica a male? Is this even a character?

People are draining my faith in the human race. Slowly but surely draining my faith in the human race.

Chica means a girl. Why would it be a guy? And she wears bikini-looking bottoms. Why would that be true?

The boy you see in Five Nights at Freddy's 4's mini-game, the crying boy - that's you! By the time Circus Baby's Rental and Entertainment starts, you are an adult. Not only are you supposed to fix the animatronics, but you also have another job - freeing your sister. Your father is the Purple Man, and he wanted you to free her from Circus Baby. Your sister got killed by Circus Baby. At the end of the game, you become Ennard, an animatronic formed by the others.

Here is some proof from the cutscene:

Mike: "Father. It's me, Michael. I did it. I found it. It was right where you said it would be. They were all there. They didn't recognize me at first, but then they thought I was you. And I found her. I put her back together, just like you asked me to. She's free now. But something is wrong with me. I should be dead. But I'm not. I've been living in shadows. There is only one thing left for me to do now. I'm going to come find you. I'm going to come find you."

I mean, it isn't wrong. Though, the C.C is Golden Freddy from FNaF 1. We play as Michael in FNaF 4, and it's pretty much been proven. On the FNaF 4 Is A Nightmare Theory, I commented the lore of FNaF 4.

Another true thing! Honestly, who is saying these are rumors?

Yeah, I believe it. The bite from the minigames could be him remembering what happened in his coma.

Foxy and Spider-Man might be the same person because they are both red. It can also possibly be Iron Man. I don't know yet. But there is a possibility.

I'm not sure which is funnier, the Darth Vader theory or this one.

Uh, first Bonnie is Elsa, then Foxy is Darth Vader, then Homer Simpson is Fredbear, then Chica is a Cheeto, then Freddy is Michael Afton's mom, then THIS?! Who in the world has a small enough brain to think of this?

Charlie was murdered by William, so no, it's not true.