Top 10 Best Five Nights at Freddy's Fan Games

Your nights survived at Freddy's were just the beginning. After the lights went out and the screams faded, a whole other side of the fandom took over. One filled with fan games that are honestly so good, they could freak you out even more than the originals.

These aren't just lazy copies with recycled jumpscares. We're talking full-blown, custom-built nightmares with new animatronics, twisted lore, original mechanics, and enough atmosphere to make your spine consider early retirement. Some take what worked in the main games and run wild with it. Others just do their own terrifying thing. Either way, you're getting games made by fans who clearly know their Freddy from their Fazbear.

Now it's your turn to pick which ones deserve more love. Vote for the fan games you think are top tier. Scary, smart, stylish, whatever makes them stick in your brain at 3 in the morning.

The Top Ten

  1. Five Nights at Candy's

    Although it's not my favorite fan game, the storyline is SO good that you should try it. It's really good. I love that this game mentions Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria, and the death screen has the closing newspaper for Freddy Fazbear's Pizza.

    Sorry for the horrible grammar. I'm a fast typer. One more thing, there should be a FNAC (Five Nights at Candy's) 4. I don't know what you would do for it, but it would be amazing, and I bet it would skyrocket in popularity.

    - Random person on the internet

    I really love how this game has grown into the best FNaF fan game franchise. The easter egg of Markiplier in this game is super creative.

  2. The Joy of Creation: Reborn

    This game gives a new aspect to the FNAF franchise, even if it is not part of the original games. It is the best fan-made game by far because it lets you explore more of the area!

    Overall, it is the best horror/adventure game I've played in a while. Not including any FNAF, of course.

    I think people are getting this game mixed up with The Joy of Creation: Story Mode. Remember, TJOC: Reborn is the one where you free-roam around the attic, basement, or woods, and TJOC: Story Mode is the one with the five different rooms (bedroom, living room, office, etc). Try not to get confused between the two!

  3. One Night at Flumpty's

    I guess Jonochrome, the developer of this game, is so crazy. I mean, look at the characters and rooms. Does the office look disgusting? Still, I like this game.

    Although the door and light system is taken from the original Five Nights at Freddy's, the game is original with an egg and his friends running after you.

    This fan game is amazing but gross, and the jump scare noises are... interesting.

  4. One Night at Flumpty's 2

    Amazing game, probably the best office gameplay in any "Five Nights at Freddy's" style game ever. It is definitely my favorite "Five Nights at Freddy's" style game.

    Welcome one and all to Flumpty Bumpty's. If your lights are out, you're safe (or are you?). If your lights are on, they'll come find you and rip you into a brand new face.

    It's original and very good and fun playing. It's less stressful than FNaF 2, but it's very chill when you are in the final hours of the night. It also has Hard Boiled mode, which is similar to Golden Freddy mode from Five Nights at Freddy's 2.

    It's the BEST FNAF game ever.

  5. The Joy of Creation: Story Mode

    This is by far the most well-made FNAF fan game I have ever come across. The quality and graphics are good in themselves, but while playing, you get a sense of pure dread that really only the first FNAF game has given me.

    The story is phenomenal, and the fact that each night is different makes it so it never ceases to be terrifying. It totally deserves to be way higher on the list.

    Calling this a "fan game" is an insult. Not only does it have awesome game mechanics, lighting, and models/textures, but it also has a very unique atmosphere. The story itself was somewhat meta, yet serious.

    I can't put into words how much I praise Nikson for creating this masterpiece.

  6. Five Nights at the Chum Bucket

    This game has a 3D office. Although they did trip up with the jump scares, it is still a well-designed game.

  7. Five Nights at Wario's 3

    You just get stuck in an abandoned mansion and survive against creepy ghosts of Wario, Waluigi, Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, Ashley, and DK. (Not counting Peach as she does not appear in-game and only appears in the second picture of the first cutscene.)

    At the end, the guy in the Wario Man costume comes all the way to apologize to the ghosts for what he had done. Great game!

    The designs are just creepy. I'm surprised Nintendo didn't take the game down.

    You are in a house. You can switch rooms. Very original.

  8. Five Nights at F***boy's 2

    Very humorous, and it is the best game in the series.

  9. Dayshift at Freddy's

    Honestly, for as funny as it was, and as tear-jerking as it was in the end, I'm surprised it isn't higher on the list! This game was phenomenal! Especially DSAF 2, which didn't follow the rule of "sequels being worse than the original."

    The same goes for DSAF 3 as well, but I really wished that *SPOILERS* Jack had his soul back so he could be with his family. That's really the only complaint, though.

    I'm surprised to see this game, or series, so far down. The first game was hilarious. The second one was funny as well but really drew you in with its story. The third one was just an amazing experience and is definitely a tearjerker. Thus, it should be higher up on the list.

  10. Dayshift at Freddy's 3

    11. The Newcomers
  11. ?

    JR's

  12. ?

    Dayshift at Freddy's 2

    13. The Contenders

  13. Five Nights at the Krusty Krab

    Who doesn't like SpongeBob and FNAF combined?

  14. Five Nights at Fina's

  15. Popgoes

    Really good game with unique mechanics, compelling lore, and entertaining gameplay. Popgoes deserves a proper promotion.

    Very creative and has my second favorite office mechanics. It's a shame there isn't a second entry in the series.

    Great plot and a personal favorite. The weasel's out to hunt!

  16. Five Nights at Wario's 2

    Here are two facts. 1. The place where you do surveillance is a place that burned down, maybe 20 years ago, by Bowser, and then he died in the fire. 2. The Phone Guy, Richard McRoy, actually locked the player (Thomas Taylor) in the building to become bait for the ghosts. Richard McRoy is actually a villain.

    I never really tried this game myself, but from the gameplay, it does look pretty good.

  17. Five Nights at Wario's

    I think it's great and has good potential. Not to mention, I like the Mario franchise.

    I saw Wario at my door and left immediately. It's way better and scarier than the original FNAF.

  18. Five Nights at Treasure Island

    Just a great one. It's a mix between Abandoned by Disney, the creepypasta, and FNAF. I LOVE the concept of shutting off a camera, and I'm excited for Treasure Island: The Abandoned Resort.

    I love the game and its concept. This should be at number one, not at fifteen. Anyway, I love this game to my heart.

    It is one of, if not THE FIRST, fan games ever for FNAF. It was very unique in gameplay and has even more unique (almost) sequels. It is highly well-known. Show more love. It's being remade anyway. #please?

    I love the fact that its inspiration was the creepypasta "Abandoned by Disney."

  19. Five Nights at F***boy's 3

  20. Five Nights at VenturianTale

  21. Bonnie Simulator 2

  22. Those Nights at Rachel's

    Even if the game came out more than a few months ago (I think it's been out for 2 years, but I am not sure), it is a pretty well-made game. The game is based on Unreal Engine 4, which makes the models, the lighting, and basically everything look excellent.

    This takes place at a restaurant called Doug and Rachel's. With another restaurant comes another Phone Guy, but he can't really act, although his performance is great. This game makes you spin around two monitors and different hallways.

    You also have to walk to a backstage area that is near the office and close curtains to stop an animatronic from coming out of the open curtains and jumpscaring you. The creator also made The Joy of Creation, The Joy of Creation: Reborn, and The Joy of Creation: Story Mode. I highly recommend it.

  23. Five Nights at Funland

  24. Five Nights at F***boy's

    Original concept. I do not have much to say about this, though.

  25. Super FNaF

    Super FNAF is a great time. The story is incredibly well done, and the music is excellent. The gameplay is decent, but everything else is perfect. Easily one of my favorites along with the FNAC series, The Joy of Creation, Wario's 3/Origins, and Popgoes.

    The game was so good, and the endings were awesome. I like the little secrets in there.

  26. Five Nights at Candy's 3

    This game is easily the best game in the entirety of the Five Nights at Candy's trilogy. This game has more content than the first two games, the plot gets intense as you progress through the game, and the final boss on the last night is easily the hardest and most challenging final boss in any FNAF fan game (main games not included) I have ever seen from watching the whole trilogy on YouTube. The last boss really is a pain in the butt. Overall, this game is easily the best one in the trilogy, and it's probably the second best in the trilogy, only to the first game.

    Solid gameplay. It was unique with the tape recorder and the flashlight, it definitely had the best narrative out of all of these games, and a lot of the characters' stories and motives were revealed. Great minigames.

  27. Final Nights

    This game shares the characters from the original series Five Nights at Freddy's. These characters, Fredbear and Spring Bonnie, were hidden in the deep lore of the game.

    One of the best games I have ever played. Do not let anyone tell you otherwise.

8Load More
PSearch List