Most Overrated Christian Rock Songs

The Top Ten

1 Love Addict - Family Force 5

Not true. Family Force 5 rocks. - GHOSTbirdnatureLOVER

Horrible compared to "Kountry Gentleman".

2 Who I Am Hates Who I've Been - Relient K

This is a great song not overrated at all - blamescott

Horrible compared to "Be My Escape".

3 Whispers In the Dark - Skillet

Skillet is Overrated asf! Red band is better

Why is this song even on this list? It's a fantastic song. The best song I've ever heard

Horrible compared to "Hero".

4 Vanilla Twilight - Owl City

Horrible compared to "Fireflies".

"Fireflies" is the best song ever. I was disappointed to hear this after everyone said it was even better than "Fireflies".

Fireflies is ten times better, still a good song but - attarj

5 He Said - Group 1 Crew

Worst song on that album. It sound nothing like them. I love "Please don't let me go" and "keys to the kingdom" by them

Horrible compared to "Please don't Let Me Go"

Why is this song so popular its not that great, Not like "Keys to the kingdom" or "walking on the stars".

Horrible Compared to "Please Don't Let Me Go".

6 Take Me As I Am - FM Static

Horrible compared to "Tonight".

7 Afterlife - Switchfoot

Good song, but I don't get why people praise it so high at Switchfoot's top-ten songs. It's actually a bad song compared to Dark Horses, Souvenirs, Dare you to Move, Meant to Live and more of their greatest hits.

Terrible Compared to "Dark Horses" and "The War Inside"

Horrible compared to "Dark Horses".

8 Breathe Into Me - Red

"Death Of Me" is good, but this song was the breakthrough hit for the band. This song is just great. Calling it "horrible" in any situations is just not true. - BillyBobJoe

Nothing Compared to "Death Of Me" and "Fight Inside"

Horrible compared to "Death Of Me"

9 One Day Too Late - Skillet

"Awake And Alive" is way better.

10 Tonight - Tobymac

City On Our Knees is way better

The Contenders

11 I Can Only Imagine - Mercyme

I love this song. My parents danced to it @ their wedding. But my dad's favorite hymn is "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God."

The song on its own merit is okay, but it's been plugged into oblivion by evangelists and preachers who rant and rave about the greatness of the song and its superiority to "Imagine" by John Lennon. I hear they're making a movie about the origin of this song, which is utterly ridiculous to me. Why not a movie about "The Hallelujah Chorus", or "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God"? Those songs at least has some historical background to it.

12 Outta My Mind - Anthem Lights

Terrible compared to "Can't Shut Up"

13 Faceless - Red

"Feed The Machine" smashes this song to pieces.

14 Missing Pages - Seventh Day Slumber
15 All About Who You Know - Petra
16 Wasted Life - Seventh Day Slumber
17 Move - Thousand Foot Krutch
18 Comatose - Skillet
BAdd New Item