Top Ten Questions About Movies to Ask People


The Top Ten

1 The Shawshank Redemption or The Godfather

Godfather; both excellent movies and I can see why 1 would appeal more to certain people but it's really an unfair comparison, different subjects and genres - Billyv

The Shawshank Redemption. It's so well done and the performances are just terrific. - MontyPython

Very close but I prefer The Shawshank Redemption with Morgan Freeman - Ajkloth


V 7 Comments
2 Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter

Lord of the Rings. Definitely - simpsondude

Lord of the Rings - MatrixGuy

Lord of the Rings is better made, however, I like Harry Potter more. - BeatlesFan1964

Lord of the Rings. Better written. Harry Potter is just popular because... It's popular? - MaxPap

V 11 Comments
3 Inception or The Matrix

Inception because it really made me think with the open ending - Ajkloth

Inception all the way - zxm

Oh man that's tough... Inception - htoutlaws2012

The Matrix - Camaro6

V 8 Comments
4 The Lion King or Madagascar

Really depends on your mood. They are both good. If you want to see crazy and funny : Madagascar. If you want to see a more serious story : The Lion King. I personally prefer Madagascar.

I just watched The Lion King recently, and it was much more enjoyable than Madagascar. It also had a better plot. - TheFourthWorld

The Lion King hands down

Lion King - Camaro6

V 9 Comments
5 Goodfellas or Scarface

Scarface, although I do like Joe Pesci - simpsondude

Goodfellas, but very close. - htoutlaws2012

Goodfellas, just. - iliekpiez

Goodfellas. - PackFan2005

V 2 Comments
6 Tootsie or Mrs. Doubtfire

Mrs. Doubtfire, even though it wasn't nominated for Best Picture or had Dustin Hoffman and Bill Murray - simpsondude

Tootsie; much better acting, writing and supporting characters though Robin was great too - Billyv

Mrs. Doubtfire. - Luckys

Tootsie - iliekpiez

V 3 Comments
7 All Dogs Go to Heaven or Oliver & Company

Oliver & Company, but this is a nail biter at the same time, but similar however one is just too dark for its time. - htoutlaws2012

Oliver & Company. I grew up with that movie. - nintendofan126

Oliver and Company. - PackFan2005

All Dogs to Heaven - iliekpiez

8 Star Wars (1977) or Batman (1989)

star wars

Batman. - BeatlesFan1964

Duh, Star Wars. - PackFan2005

Star Wars - Camaro6

V 3 Comments
9 Finding Nemo or Shark Tale?

Finding Nemo... while Shark Tale was alright at best, Finding Nemo just holds up better overall. - htoutlaws2012

I prefer Finding Nemo for sure - Ajkloth

It's that simple Finding Nemo of course. Shark Tale sucks

Finding Nemo

V 5 Comments
10 Batman Forever or Batman and Robin?

Oh boy too terrible Batman films of the 90's ugh... I'll go with Forever, but that ain't saying much. - htoutlaws2012

Forever had Jim Carrey. Therefore, Batman Forever. - BeatlesFan1964

Batman Forever Batman and Robin sucks - Lpsgirl

Batman Forever, but is only just better - iliekpiez

V 1 Comment

The Contenders

11 Big Hero 6 or Age of Ultron?

Big Hero 6, Ultron was a major disappointment when its sandwiched between the first film, and Infinity War. - htoutlaws2012

Why compare these two? These are completely different movies. - TheFourthWorld

Big Hero 6 is a Disney animated movie.

Age of Ultron is a Marvel Action movie.

Waaay too much different. - MaxPap

Big Hero 6. - Luckys

V 3 Comments
12 Captain America: Civil War or Batman vs Superman: Dawn of Justice

Civil war! Batman vs Superman was awful! - awesomedp900

Captain America Civil War - Trollsfan536

Capitain America: Civil War

Civil War. DC sucks. - MaxPap

V 1 Comment
13 Star Wars Episode 4 or Episode 5

That's a tough one but I'll probably go with 4 - simpsondude

Episode V, for many reasons. - PackFan2005

Episode 5 not even close - 2storm

I'd have to watch it again to be sure... But I'd say for now Episode V. Had more epic scenes. - MaxPap

V 7 Comments
14 The Little Mermaid or Ponyo

Ponyo is one of my least seen of Miyazaki's films so I'll go with Little Mermaid in this case. - htoutlaws2012

The Little Mermaid - Lpsgirl

The Little Mermaid - Camaro6

Ponyo for me

V 1 Comment
15 Se7en or Silence of the Lambs

I don't like Horror movies - simpsondude

Silence of the Lambs - MatrixGuy

Silence of the Lambs. I liked it a lot better. - PackFan2005

Silence of the Lambs - 2storm

V 1 Comment
16 101 Dalmatians or 101 Dalmatians (1996)?

I'll go with the animated version, the live action ones were just the coffin of Glenn Close's career at that point. - htoutlaws2012

The original, obviously. The live action one sucked. - PackFan2005

The original. - Luckys

101 Dalmatians - iliekpiez

17 Despicable Me or Wreck-It Ralph

Both are good, but I'm a gamer, and will side with Wreck-It Ralph that should of won best animated movie in 2012 instead of that generic Pixar film Brave which is basically a Brother Bear story plot. - htoutlaws2012

Wreck-It Ralph was a bit underrated for a Disney/Pixar movie. Despicable Me is good but very overrated. The minions are annoying and now they are everywhere on Facebook.

Wreck-It Raplh was a better movie. - MaxPap

I pick despicable me. - nintendofan126

Wreck-it ralph. - Luckys

V 6 Comments
18 Surfs Up or Happy Feet

At even on this one. - htoutlaws2012

Surf's Up

Surf's Up - Trollsfan536

19 Alien or Predator?

Alien - BlazingParasol

Alien. - MaxPap

Alien - iliekpiez

20 Pulp Fiction or Fight Club

Didn't watch Fight Club, so Pulp Fiction for this one. - MaxPap

Pulp Fiction; fascinating and fun! - Billyv

Pulp Fiction, but is close - MatrixGuy

Pulp Ficiton - iliekpiez

V 2 Comments
21 Saving Private Ryan or Casablanca

Saving Private Ryan, The other one while a more famous primitive film is not really something I got into much where this war movie definitely should of won best film of that 98' or 99' year. - htoutlaws2012

Once again I didn't watch either - simpsondude

Casablanca I never watched it,but private Ryan obviously I did - Kevinsidis

22 Alien or The Thing

Despite being boring, and not as exciting as its sequel I'll still favor Alien. - htoutlaws2012

Alien - iliekpiez

The Thing. - BeatlesFan1964

23 Star Wars or 2001: A Space Odyssey

Star wars in general than yeah annihilates that one single movie instantly. - htoutlaws2012

Star Wars. No competition. - EpicJake

Hands down Star Wars. - PackFan2005

2001: A Space Odyssey - iliekpiez

24 Forrest Gump or Schindler's List

Forrest Gump I can re-watch anytime where Schindler's List is one of those very great films that I can watch few times if I'm feeling sorrow. - htoutlaws2012

You'll feel different emotions when watching Forrest Gump. Schindler's List is just depressing.

Forrest Gump. - MaxPap

Schindler's List, but these aren't the same type of movies - MatrixGuy

Schindler's List - iliekpiez

V 3 Comments
25 Angels in the Outfield or Rookie of the Year?

Two okay baseball films even on both ends. - htoutlaws2012

Rookie of the Year - iliekpiez

26 Tangled or Frozen?

Tangled holds up better than Frozen at this rate. - htoutlaws2012

Tangled all the way, I don't like Frozen.

Frozen. I don't care what you say. - Luckys

Tangled was OK, Frozen was awful. - MaxPap

V 7 Comments
27 Back to the Future or Flight of the Navigator?

Back to the Future no contest. - htoutlaws2012

Back to the Future - iliekpiez

Wayy different. Back to the Future is way better. - MaxPap

28 Spider-Man 2 or Batman Begins?

Tough But I Go With Spider-Man 2 - VideoGamefan5

Spider-Man 2 definitely. - htoutlaws2012

Spider-Man 2 - iliekpiez

Spider-Man 2 - BeatlesFan1964

29 Bambi or Dumbo?

Dumbo, Bambi has been reenacted way too much it kinda annoys me. - htoutlaws2012

Oh my that's hard so I'll say both - Lpsgirl

Bambi - PeeledBanana

Bambi - Camaro6

V 2 Comments
30 Big Hero 6 or Frozen?

The obvious choice is the former. - Therandom

Easily Big Hero 6 - htoutlaws2012

Big Hero 6 - iliekpiez

Big Hero 6. - Luckys

V 3 Comments
31 Inside Out or Zootopia?

Inside Out for its Fetish Fuel - xandermartin98

Inside Out - PeeledBanana

Zootopia - iliekpiez

Inside Out. - Luckys

V 2 Comments
32 Big Hero 6 or Wreck-It Ralph?

I liked both but Wreck-It Ralph. - MaxPap

Big Hero 6 - iliekpiez

Hero 6

Wreck-It Ralph - htoutlaws2012

V 2 Comments
33 What are Some of Your Least Favorite Movies?

Son of the Mask, Elektra, Batman and Robin, Turbo: A Power Rangers movie - iliekpiez

I was the one who commented the glitter comment.
Edit to the comment: Date movie is my worst movie ever now. I watched it and it makes glitter look like a watchable movie. - BlazingParasol

I think my least favorite movies I would have to say Seed of chucky,Norm of the north and The garbage pail kids movie - Lpsgirl

Well... this isn't a this or that question though. - htoutlaws2012

V 4 Comments
34 Mary Poppins or The Sound of Music

Mary Poppins, going based on iconic status, and Sound of Music I fought was pretty overrated being that it's a musical. - htoutlaws2012

The Sound of Music - iliekpiez

The Sound of Music - Camaro6

The Sound of Music, though I’m not a fan of either. - PackFan2005

V 2 Comments
35 Psycho or The Silence of the Lambs

The innovator of killing Psycho - htoutlaws2012

Silence of the Lambs - 2storm

Psycho - BeatlesFan1964

36 Frozen or Toy Story?

Toy Story, Frozen isn't even in that league of elite animated films. - htoutlaws2012

Toy Story of course! - TheFourthWorld

Toy Story - iliekpiez

Toy Story. - PackFan2005

V 1 Comment
37 The Angry Birds Movie or Minions?

None of the above next! - htoutlaws2012

The Angry Birds Movie - iliekpiez

None of them. They both sucks.

Minions - 2storm

V 3 Comments
38 Ghost Rider or the Amazing Spider Man

The Amazing Spider-Man - iliekpiez

The Amazing Spider-Man. - Tia-Harribel

Ghost Rider - htoutlaws2012

39 Gordy or Babe

They seem the same to me, but on the reviews let's go Babe. - htoutlaws2012

I've never seen Gordy. - nintendofan126

Babe. - PackFan2005

Babe - iliekpiez

40 Charlotte's Web (1973) or Charlotte's Web (2006)

I actually really like the remake from 2006 its very underrated. While the original also gets its due I'll go with one I actually did see than I can't say I have seen, but know there's great deal of respect for. - htoutlaws2012

Charlotte's Web (1973) - iliekpiez

The original is better. - nintendofan126

41 The Odd Life of Timothy Green or Martian Child

Both largely forgotten in the timeline they released, but I guess I'll go with the odd life. - htoutlaws2012

The Odd Life of Timothy Green - iliekpiez

42 The Great Mouse Detective or An American Tail

The Great Mouse Detective - htoutlaws2012

An American Tail - iliekpiez

43 Happy Feet or March of the Penguins

March of the Penguins - iliekpiez

At even for me. - htoutlaws2012

Happy Feet!

44 Friday the 13th or A Nightmare On Elm Street

A Nightmare On Elm Street, both are classics though. - htoutlaws2012

A Nightmare on Elm Street - iliekpiez

A Nightmare on Elm Street

A Nightmare on Elm Street. - PackFan2005

45 Friday the 13th or Halloween

Halloween - htoutlaws2012

46 Wreck-It Ralph or Frozen?

Wreck-It Ralph easily. - htoutlaws2012

Wreck-It Ralph - iliekpiez

Wreck It Ralph

Wreck It Ralph - Trollsfan536

47 Zoom or Sky High

Sky High, Underrated, and pretty entertaining for a live action Disney hidden gem from 2005. Can't say I've seen Zoom honestly. - htoutlaws2012

Sky High, one of my favourite disney live action movies. - iliekpiez

48 Lady In White or Casper?

Casper the friendly ghost. - htoutlaws2012

Casper - iliekpiez

49 Casper or Ghost?


Ghost - iliekpiez

50 Poltergeist or the Shining?


The Shining - iliekpiez

Shining - 2storm

PSearch List

Related Lists

Top Ten Questions About Bad Movies to Ask People Top Ten Questions About Animated Movies to Ask People Top Ten Questions to Ask People About Disney Movies Top Ten Questions About T. V. Shows to Ask People Top Ten This or That Questions to Ask People

List Stats

100 votes
71 listings
3 years, 350 days old

Top Remixes (8)

1. Big Hero 6 or Frozen?
2. Big Hero 6 or Wreck-It Ralph?
3. Despicable Me or Wreck-It Ralph
1. Captain America: Civil War or Batman vs Superman: Dawn of Justice
2. The Lion King or Madagascar
3. Surfs Up or Happy Feet
1. The Shawshank Redemption or The Godfather
2. Inception or The Matrix
3. Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter

View All 8

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.