Worst Undertale Ships

Sometimes there are things in Undertale that make me want to cry. Ships in general. The reason being most are non canon, or really lightly implied. REMEMBER THIS IS OPINIONATED

You can disagree with me if you like, though.

The Top Ten

1 Fontcest (Sans and Papyrus)

Just Why! Why the heck would people ever want to ship these two?!? It's disgusting! There brothers for God's sake! No one should like this ship!? Why would you have deep feelings for your own sibling That kind of way! Yeah they love each other but in a family way! This ship is just.. BELH!

Why would you have feelings for your own sibling? They're brothers. They already love each other as a family. Nobody wants this kind of ship, it's just, WEIRD!

Yeah this ship is kinda weird,they are brothers! And stop with the gay ones


V 19 Comments
2 Soriel (Sans and Toriel)

Why? A goat and a skeleton? No.

Why is this ship even a thing

First of all, the age difference. Second of all, that's it.

I don't find much wrong apart from the ages of the two. While I would rather them be friends, it still would mostly make sense.
Also, the creator of this makes bad points. - rhysterrabbit

What I ship this I don't know why

V 15 Comments
3 Chasriel (Chara and Asriel)

It would be extremely cute if they were friends. But no. They're siblings. Even if Chara was adopted, Chara and Asriel became siblings. - rhysterrabbit

What the - ElSherlock

Their relationship might have been abusive, and people ship that even though Chara forced Asriel into killing people and manipulated him. Like what?!

Um... Honestly I am more into Chans (actually my favorite ship), the reason why is because they both are my favourite and it does make sense! Well Chara x Asriel? Nope!

V 4 Comments
4 Frans (Frisk and Sans)

I... like Frans...
You'll probably think I'm weird but come on! When does it say Sans' age?
Yea, he's probably quite a bit older but I know that a lot of people's favourite character is Sans, so why not ship him with the main character? Unless you did the genocide route, in which case, Frans is just wrong...

Sans is at least 18, and the game makes us assume Frisk is just a child, so that is pedophilia. And do not even try to say it is an alternate universe where Frisk is older. - LittleAwesomeApple

This should be at least 2nd considering it,

1) Sucks

2) Has absolutely NO chemistry

3) And the most important one, SANS IS IN HIS EARLY 20S AND FRISK IS LIKE 10!


I think this is a good ship unless you think about the ages...
Otherwise NO

Frisk is probably like 10 and sans is probably 20 or something if u still ship this FIGHT ME

V 11 Comments
5 Asgriel (Asgore and Asriel)

This is a never should be shipped and burn to the ground

There, family, it doesn't even MAKE SENCE! - UFEdgygirl12

... what has undertale ships got to IT GOT TO THIS

Makes sense. If I was a dad! Ikd also date my son (this is a joke by the way)

V 8 Comments
6 Ghostcest (Mettaton and Napstablook)


This is a thing? - rhysterrabbit

Idc if they're cousins. I'd understand if they were ANIMALS, like warriors, but these aren't the clans. This is considered incest. DON'T LET BLUEBERRYCHEERIOS KNOW THIS EXISTS! - Darktail_of_FireClan

Mettaton and nabstablook are practically opposites, except for the music thing, but they’re cousins so that’s why I’d say this ship sucks

7 Papyton (Papyrus and Mettaton)

They have nothing in common and they don't know each other. Mettaton is straight

Papyrus is TOO MUCH for Mettaton. The only good thing about this ship (even though it's apparently very popular) are the comics in which Sans beats up Mettaton for flirting with his brother. - Yendks

I don't know, but have you seen the pictures of their child? Super cute and impossible, but I don't know what monsters can do.

Don't make the cinnamon roll Papyrus gay! Also, Metta doesn't even interact with Papyrus that much. Papyrus didn't even call at the end of MTT's battle. Also, it's hard to imagine either of them in a relationship at all.

V 5 Comments
8 Monsterdyne (Monster Kid and Undyne)

Everyone has their idols but the person you idolize doesn't want to date you - Maya159610

Monster kid only idolized her. Like if you idolized a football player it doesn't mean you love them. - Darktail_of_FireClan

On Monster Kid’s side? Yeah, I could see them having kind of a crush on her. That kind of stuff happens.

But adults having feelings for children is gross and it promotes pedophilia.

9 Charisk (Chara and Frisk)

I mean the relationship between them could be very toxic and since they are siblings but if they weren't siblings the relationship wouldn't work because well...let just say the relationship between them is toxic

Number 1!


By my earlier comment I meant INCEST. - Darktail_of_FireClan

V 4 Comments
10 Papdyne (Papyrus and Undyne)

Uh... I hecking love this ship. So why is it bad? If you think Papyrus is in the friendzone, I don't blame you. He is. But their canon platonic relationship could easily evolve into romance over time. Also I sorta think he likes her in canon. She mentors him and really, really loves him. I think it might take a few years, but this could really BE something. I legitimately believe the only reason it's so hated is cause it interrupts Alphyne. And yes, I can see that being a blow-up spot. But calm down, and just give it a chance.

Undyne is wayyy too rough for Papyrus. - rhysterrabbit

If Undyne was anything but a mentor to Papyrus. She would be a mother lol.

If it werent for alphys I would ship this but sorry I ship alphys x undyne instead, its not bad, there's just way better monsters for undyne - Maya159610

V 1 Comment

The Newcomers

? Sancest (AU sans x AU sans)
? Gasans (Gaster and Sans)


The Contenders

11 Flans (Sans and Flowey)

"Sans is a smiley trashbag" - rhysterrabbit

I don’t even know...

Ok..fandom,did you forget something? No? Well I'll remind you...You do realise that Sans hates Flowey and Flowey hates Sans...So...WHY DA FALLIIIP DO YOU SHIP ZHEM TOGHEZER!


12 Gasgore (W D Gaster and Asgore)

I find it hard to believe more than ten people ship this - sansundertale

Gaster is basically an easter egg, and asgore is the king, this would never work out - Maya159610

Oh, what now. - rhysterrabbit

I am utterly disappointed in this fandom. - Darktail_of_FireClan

V 1 Comment
13 Alphyne (Alphys and Undyne)

It's canon, so I think it's fine.

All the weeaboos will agree. At least I do.

14 Sansby (SANS X GRILLBY)

Sansby can go die in a hole -.-" - UFEdgygirl12

Sansby is like the worst thing ever, (I do respect gayness) but sansby is a noo

15 Tosriel (Asriel and Toriel)

They are cute together

Oh my god... - Willowfur

The person that said they’re cute together, I feel like you’re confused. Asriel is Toriel’s SON. I’m simply going to give you the benefit of the doubt on that one, but shipping a mom with her son is... wow

16 Salphys (Sans and Alphys)

They barely have anything in common - rhysterrabbit

This is used a lot by homophobes! I hate this ship because it interferes with canon!
PS: Darktail yeah I made that comment on charisk!

17 Undyrus (Undyne and Papyrus)

Eh... I ship Alphyne more. - Willowfur

18 ToriGore (Asgore and Toriel)

I think Dr. Alphys added this to the list. - tacoperson

It’s goat mom and goat dad

I don't see how people would survive shipping a goat mama who hates her ex. IT'S CALLED AN EX FOR A REASON, GODDAMMIT

19 Flowriel (Flowey and Asriel)

It's like dating a mirror.
Flowey and Asriel are the same person. - rhysterrabbit



20 Nyehctar (Papyrus and Flowey)

Not only is Flowey technically a child and Papyrus an adult, their friendship wasn’t even real. He was just manipulating him to get human SOULs.

21 Torigorepapans (Toriel/Asgore/Papyrus/Sans)

How does this even work? - LittleAwesomeApple

22 Alphyton (Alphys and Mettaton)

1. Weird
2. It is shown in the game that MTT is more busy with his life than with Alphys
3. Ew
4. I know Mettaton EX's legs may be thicc but Alphys will still like Undyne more. That sounded weird. - tacoperson

Abusive relationship - rhysterrabbit

23 Sansariel (Sans and Asriel)
24 Asrister (Asriel/Gaster)
25 Torisk (Frisk and Toriel)

NO. - Willowfur

Sans x Frisk would work if they grew older. This wouldn't work ever. Who even made this? - rhysterrabbit

She sees them as her own kid. While whether or not they see her as their mother is up to the player, it’s still a child x adult ship.

26 Friskriel (Frisk and Asriel)

Incest. Plus this makes no sense. - Darktail_of_FireClan

This I so lovely it works

27 Torister (Toriel/Gaster)


28 Chasans (Chara and Sans)
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Best Star Trek Ships Top Ten Most Famous Ships of All Time Top 10 Boku No Hero Academia Ships Top Ten Best The Lion Guard Ships Top 10 Riverdale Ships

List Stats

200 votes
30 listings
1 year, 221 days old

Top Remixes

1. Fontcest (Sans and Papyrus)
2. Flans (Sans and Flowey)
3. Soriel (Sans and Toriel)
1. Fontcest (Sans and Papyrus)
2. Chasriel (Chara and Asriel)
3. Papyton (Papyrus and Mettaton)
1. Soriel (Sans and Toriel)
2. Chasriel (Chara and Asriel)
3. Fontcest (Sans and Papyrus)


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.