Top Ten Ice Cream Flavors

preachinpreach

The Top Ten

1 Cookies N' Cream

whats better than cookies and milk, well you know. COOKIES AND CREAM!

Cookies and cream is the greatest ice cream I've ever had. It's vanilla ice cream and crushed Oreo cookies mixed together. Put them in a blender and enjoy. Thanks for letting me give out my opinion.

Its tasty even as gelato! I will eat it anywhere any time just so so so tasty and yummy and a great snack for movies and parties and dessert wow I love this flavor very much.

I love cookies and cream ita my fave

698 Comments
2 Mint Chocolate Chip

Way better than pistachio! I don't know why it is tenth! It should be in first! Best flavor ever!

My personal favorite! Refreshing mint combined with Chocolate... How can you go wrong.

Mint always makes me happy. I always can count on Mint to cheer me up if I'm EVER upset

Mint chocolate chip is my favorite ice cream flavor it's so good, with that minty taste and hint of chocolate also it makes your breath smell good. Now I know mint is 2nd place but when you combine cookies and cream and mint chip its like heaven.

489 Comments
3 Chocolate

Chocolate ice cream makes me happy!

I LOVE CHOCOLATE it is the best ever it is good and tasty yummy sweet.

Milk, dark, swiss. It doesn't matter all chocolate is good. It's awesome with toppings but still great without.

I'm fat and I love chocolate ice cream I bought over five boxes of chocolate ice cream and ate it in one day it makes me forget I'm fat

370 Comments
4 Vanilla

Vanilla. The ultimate flavor of ice cream! It has this basic flavor which you are almost always in the mood for. I found this site which shows the flavors of ice cream which were bought most, and vanilla was number 1! I hope it can be number 1 on this site too!

Vanilla is the original ice cream flavor, you can find it anywhere in the world, it's worth every bite, and a crowd pleaser

Vanilla is the best flavor, it's so creamy and delicious, tastes better than chocolate in my opinion.

How can vanilla be number four for best flavor chocolate is so over powered vanilla does not over power itself

375 Comments
5 Cookie Dough

Best ice cream ever! As a kid who didn't love eating raw cookie dough and vanilla ice cream? It's the perfect combination of cookies and ice cream without having hard chunks of actual cookies.

yummy, yummy, yummy, yummy! ah... cookie dough brings back memories...

Cookie dough is sweet and delicious! Even better in
ice cream! I vote it #1!

Like, you can't even compare. Seriously? Vanilla is above Cookie Dough? Who DOESN'T like Cookie Dough? That's right, nobody. I don't really like chocolate because like some random person said in the Vanilla comments, it's too overpowering and strong and it doesn't give you that, "Ah, icecream," satisfaction that it should. Cookie Dough is that perfect balance and even includes cookie bits (*cough* read the name *cough*) and it's overall the greatest creation mankind had ever made. Thank you, Ben&Jerry's for creating this! (Yeah, I Googled it. Sue me.)

230 Comments
6 Strawberry

Strawberry ice cream is the best there's no other flavor's that I would choose its got a creamy taste with sweet strawberry's to make it better!
Everyone else in my family like different flavors but really strawberry's the best!

Strawberry ice cream is so refreshing and flavorful, but simple and timeless.
Its not that bad for you and yet maintains a flavor as good as cookie dough. Lovely!

deserve the top 3 spot, legendary - roblist

Strawberry ice cream is the best! You people who have not voted should vote for strawberry ice cream because it is so tasty. Vote for strawberry ice cream! If you want to vote for other ice cream flavors think again! So vote for strawberry ice cream now!

149 Comments
7 Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

I love chocolate chip cookie dough. It is just so delicious. The flavor is so sweet. What's better then vanilla ice cream with chunks of chocolate chip cookies dough?

I still don't understand how CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH would be less popular than cookie dough. Its like putting love into love which= MORE LOVE! All the other kinds (except for chocolate) suck compared to chocolate chip cookie dough.

Chocolate chip cookie dough is the best. Please vote. Lots of chocolate chip and cookies. M. I always eat it. Lovely.

Great flavor! - ArianaMarvelHPVine456

192 Comments
8 Rocky Road

Makes me feel so happy! The crunch of almond mixed with the creamy marshmallows! Chocolate is the perfect base

This is so good. With marshmallows and everything. It's not my favorite but still so delicious it should be illegal. I love it so much! It should be second.

Cookie's N Cream used to be my favorite, but this one is now my favorite. It taste so delicious, I love it

These people are dumb, ya'll don't have taste buds for this ice cream this is number #1

106 Comments
9 Neopolitan

When I taste this ice cream... it just gives me the chills... it's 3 in 1 who doesn't want that?!

I love having the 3 different flavours, plus chocolate, vanilla and strawberry are 3 of my favourites. - 3DG20

Great Flavor! - ArianaMarvelHPVine456

IT IS BEST FLAVORS COMBINED IN ONE FLAVOR. AWESOME!

37 Comments
10 Coffee

Coffee is really addicting

Coffee is Wowser my favorite!

Personally, I'm a caffeine addict. This flavour provides that sensation I crave, as I'm usually drinking coffee.

Well I just flipping love the coffee ice cream

87 Comments

The Newcomers

? Chocolate Deluxe

The Contenders

11 Chocolate Chip

I love chocolate chip because it's mostly vanilla, with just enough chocolate to make it perfect!

It is great in all of its simplicity

Best flavor! Move it up!

One of the most classic flavors of all time. Gotta love Chocolate Chip.

17 Comments
12 Birthday Cake

Birthday Cake is wonderful. Right up there with Butter Brickle!

Birthday cake ice cream is amazing. The kind I get is this delicious vanilla ice cream with cake frosting inside. It is DELICIOUS. I suggest you try it man it is amazing!

Uh, Hello?! Ever heard of birthday cake? Only the greatest kind of ice cream (closely behind Cheesecake) of all time. The taste has the perfect balance of sweetness and coldness.

Chocolate is overrated, as well as vanilla. Think of the flavors that actually taste good; not what everyone else picks!

Good

45 Comments
13 Mint

How is this number 5!?!?! Mint is the best of the best! It's so refreshing! Unlike chocolate, you don't have to have a glass of water after eating it. It's so good, I have to hide the Mint Ice cream, or else it will be gone the next day. Mint cheers me up when I'm upset and I eat it all year round!

Mint is good in all occasions. It gives you a sweet cool tingly feeling attractive flavor for kids and teens

It's awesome really good everyone should try mint. Love it since I was a kid. I vote number 1! It's the best. So many memories. Delicious! Love it so much!

It smell relly good

62 Comments
14 Peanut Butter Cup

Best ever, should be #1

BEAUTY

The best Ever!

I LOVE PEANUT BUTTER CUP ICE CREAM!
I am gluten free and my brothers and sister are not. So I was kind of sad because I could not have my dads secret recipe. So he bought me some peanut butter cup ice cream I ate it all up and I don't really like ice cream.

31 Comments
15 Caramel

So sweet and so tasty. No one can resist

Caramel, it is seriously amazing. Sugar and cream, nothing can go wrong

Caramel flavor is Super amazing should be higher! Haha yeah I think it's awesome aha ha

How is this 15th

47 Comments
16 Cotton Candy

OMG I WOULD DO ANYTHING FOR COTTON CANDY ITS THE BEST FLAVOR EVER
I WOULD EAT ALL THE TIME IF I COULD.
ITS EVEN BETTER IN A MILKSHAKE OR THICK-SHAKE.
MAKE SURE YOU TRY IT
YUMM YUMM

Should be number 1. Best flavor ever! Cotton candy ice cream, cotton candy flavored candy,real cotton candy is so good! - ArianaMarvelHPVine456

I love cotton candy
Xx

Yum

80 Comments
17 Butter Pecan

The best Ice cream ever

OHHH HEEL NOOO. This is the best thing ever! It should be number 1

I love it I would crap if I didn't have this

This is the best ice cream yet... I can eat this ice cream all day with no problem. One day I had bought 60 pints and ate them all in one day and didn't even throw up not even once. But then the next day my mom got mad at me because I made and mistake in her restroom...

19 Comments
18 Chocolate Peanut Butter

My mouth is starting to water already.

I'm not sure if this and 'Peanut Butter Cup' count as the same flavour. Either way, peanut butter and ice cream are a match made in heaven. - BKAllmighty

This is the best

YUMMY! This ice cream is the best. Try it! You will instantly fall in love.

6 Comments
19 Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Should totally be in the #1 spot! It is basically chocolate on chocolate, how would you not love it!

Love this flavor, Bruh!

Dude, this flavor is BOMB. BEST EVER

BEST

5 Comments
20 French Vanilla

Vanilla, except French

Vanilla: Meh.
French Vanilla: Oh, yes! - Gg2000

Always better then vanilla and will be

Tastes like vanilla... BUT BETTER

That's because it is vanilla. But it comes from France. Which means,10 times better than regular vanilla. - Finn-Mordecai-Gumball

11 Comments
21 Moose Tracks

LOVE THIS ICE CREAM SOSOSOSOSOSOSO MUCH! I have liked it ever since I was a little girl and my family and I used to go to this amazing ice cream place. I would point to it even though I didn't know what it was called! I guess I was a young girl with fantabulous taste

Can't be put into words

It's the best, no doubt about it - crazycat99

I used to eat this when I was a little kid, and that trend has continued into my young adulthood...

47 Comments
22 Cake Batter

I've only tasted this as a sample once but it tasted really good! I should've bought it when I had the chance. Vanilla's everywhere anyways... I could've bought it some other time. :/// - Misfire

I am completely in love with cake batter ice cream because it's made from batter and I love Vanilla flavor batter! The place that I would eat this flavor is at Marble Slab!

Cake batter or birthday cake, what ever you like to call it, is by far the best ice cream I have ever tasted in my entire life. Marble Slab and any other place that sell it is the place to go. Perfect perfect perfect. My sis worked at an ice cream place during the summer and I told her to tell me when they had birthay cake ice cream in, that stuff is seriously the best! - dragonfly99

I LOVE cake batter cookie dough. Who didn't love licking the bowl of cake batter after mixing it? This is perfect when topped with sprinkles. Or you can ask them to make a milkshake with it.. HEAVEN! It is the best no matter how you have it

34 Comments
23 Mango

This is the best flavour I ever tasted, it has the taste of the real mango and but I don't know where can I get them? All the shops only selling the favourite ones but not mango. Can anyone tell me where can I get mango flavour or can I order some from the company? Many thanks.

yum - Oliversky

Yumm! Why 24th? Stupid chocolate, outta the way!
MANGO! MANGO! MANGO!

Seriously though... why 24th? 1st is the true owner of this fruitastic flavour!

Mango + Ice Cream = Bliss and one happy person - ImNotEagle

40 Comments
24 Banana

I love banana

yum

This is a very weird flavor and will probably never get to the top 10, but what the heck it's an awesome flavor. Besides, chocolate ice cream is boring. Let's go unique!

I had fresh made banana ice cream at the beach and I almost died it was so good, I wish they sold it in stores

14 Comments
25 Bubble Gum

Bubblegum yum!

THIS best flavour ever! This should be at 1st place but instead it's just 35th place please plsplsplsplspls make this change.

I love bubble gum brings back so many child hood memories! Hands down bubble gum ice cream is the best! Even after your finished you still can blow a bubble while you dump your cup in trash.

Should be in the top three I love it

30 Comments
26 Double Fudge Brownie

So good?

best ice cream flavor in the world!

Yum! You can't top that! So much chocolate in one bite!

Yes

37 Comments
27 Strawberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake is my favourite cake, but I was surprised to learn that there was an actual ice cream flavour of the cake. I got a tub of the ice cream flavour and mmm... it was so good! Strawberry cheesecake is my favourite ice cream flavour, I really recommend it! - IceBearRules

it good

I had this in a gourmet shop with my friends and it was creamy and sweet with swirls of strawberry in it. There were four of us and three had that flavour. I usually don't like cheesecake, it's a bit too cheesy, but you couldn't even taste it and it was DELICIOUS

It is SO good with peanut butter

12 Comments
28 Cherry Vanilla

This is a thing? I must try it! - Misfire

Great combination of black cherry halves and smooth vanilla ice cream

Great fruity and chunky flavor of ruby cherries in velvet smooth vanilla ice cream. Also, known as Whitehouse.

It is not available any more in Federal Way, WA

29 Lemon

Hooked on lemon ice cream since I was a child.

I love lemon ice cream

This is really good in Europe.

Lemon is one of my favourite flavors of ice cream! It really tastes great! I love it! Please vote the lemon flavor! Go Lemon flavor! Lemon Rocks! Hope you love the lemon flavor too! :-bd

23 Comments
30 Brownie Batter

amazing

best ever

This is #DELICIOUS

31 M&M's

I love M&M'S flavior ice cream so much! It reminds me of my childhood if you love regular m&m's then your love M&M ice cream.

I love me some m&m ice cream every now and then but I like chocolate more

M&M are amazing. But even better in ice cream!

Yummy so yummy ohmygod.

32 Cherry

Very nice especially when it has real cherries in it. It's also great with chocolate ice cream.

The kind with big black cherries! Yum!

Muero por la cherry

33 Peppermint

I had this in chicago once. it was amazing! - tropicaljay

It lasts in your mouth and it tastes so good. In general, I love anything that's minty. It's so yummilicious, you know what I mean?

Should be available year round for those of us who love the mint flavor without the chocolate. I love it

The BEST. All year round. Hard to find one with just the right amount of mint and not too creamy.

9 Comments
34 Orange Sherbet

Extremely underrated! It's disappointing that this delicious flavour is only 41 on this list, it should be so much higher! Some other flavours that are above this are really bland or just plain nasty. Let's get this to at least 30!

I like oranges.

YES - MrZebra24

Orange sherbet is the best ever I love it it should be in the top 10 at least!

9 Comments
35 Peach

Homemade peach ice cream... yum

Peach is amazing. You have to try Peach Bellini though.

This sounds so good

36 Mint Fudge Oreo

Mint is awesome!
Fudge is awesome!
Oreos are awesome!
Combined is very very very awesome!

MINT ice cream is amazing but then you add 2 other godly ingredients... and suddenly it is to die for. this should be number 1.

When I think of mint fudge oreo, I think of an amazing oreo chip, green volcano that just oozes out the deliciousness.

Best ice cream flavor ever why isn't it in the top ten

5 Comments
37 Banana Split

I have just come to know this flavor. Loved it. It has all the flavors - chocolate, strawberry, banana, nuts.

I love this flavor it has just about every flavor. There is vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and banana

38 Pistachio

Pistachio nuts are so good anyways, but with ice cream it is heaven! Why doesn't everyone who thinks that pistachio ice cream is good, rate it good? I suppose people just think "Hmm, I don't want to vote pistachio even though it is the best... " Join me men and girls! Join the revolution to making pistachio number one!

The literal best ice cream ever!

Nutty goodness!

Green, green, pistachio

107 Comments
39 Pralines and Cream

Hands down personal favorite

My dad's favorite ice cream is Pralines and Cream and my dad doesn't really like the kinds that I like. This should really be first! - rainbowdashrules

The sweetness of the cream with the crunch of the pralines, only the best felling in the world (and in your mouth)! :)

-BossBrooks

Yummy yah! One of my favourite ice creams lots of caramel with candy coated pralines

4 Comments
40 Pumpkin

Great right after thanksgiving dinner or any time really. Try it its really good but it is only sold around the holidays

I love pumpkin for October/November and then Eggnog for December.

I like pumpkin in the fall.

Wait tell Halloween

2 Comments
41 Chocolate Vanilla Swirl

yay.

It's the best flavor ever

Mm so good!

42 Rainbow

My childhood.

This should be in the top ten. My childhood favorite.

It is a ripoff. It is just vanilla that is dyed.

Rainbow is the best! Should be in the top 10! - micahisthebest

1 Comment
43 Butterfinger

it is good

44 Heath Bar Crunch

Amazon best ever

Amaze

45 Rainbow Sherbet

My favorite baskin Robbins flavor

It's the best

THIS MUST BE HIGHER - MrZebra24

This should be #1 by the way it is the best

5 Comments
46 Toffee

The best ever!

Only 71!? Only 0.1% of people vote for this!?
The toffe tastes so sweet!

Tofee is the best ever since I ate it, it felt lilke a dream come true

47 Raspberry

Why is this not #1?

The best for sure

How can you not say this is the best?

Its completely the best flavour I taste in italy in sermione and there is the best ice-cream in the world

48 Dulce de Leche

Häagen-Dazs version of this, hands down!

! BEST ICE CREAM EVER! I mean, seriously? Chocolate? What could get better than caramel ice cream with caramel swirls? NOTHING! If you haven't had this ice cream yet you HAVE to try it.

Best ice cream flavor

It's amazing! The creamy caramel just oozes in your mouth! Awesome!

6 Comments
49 Black Raspberry

Black raspberry is the best no contest

One way to get your daily fruit allowance!

50 Hazelnut

I don't understand why this is not in the top 10. The taste is so lovely and it reminds me of the gorgeous Nutella. I know it doesn't occur in many ice cream shops but I once tried it in Italy and the flavour was ever so heavenly. If you ever come across this flavour and your not nut allergic you should certainly try it 100%.

This song is the best of these guys. It's even rambo theme song for kicking ass!

There is no better Ice Cream flavor in the entire world, than Hazelnut.

Magnum Ghana - best ice cream ever!

2 Comments
8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Best Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors Weirdest Ice Cream Flavors Top Ten Ice Cream Flavors That Go Together Top Ten Best Sodas That Can Be Turned Into Ice Cream Flavors Top Ten Breyers Ice Cream Flavors

List Stats

19,000 votes
305 listings
11 years, 348 days old

Top Remixes (149)

1. Cookies N' Cream
2. Vanilla
3. Birthday Cake
Ilyas678
1. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
2. Cookies N' Cream
3. Chocolate Chip
JoesMom3990
1. Cherry Vanilla
2. Cookies N' Cream
3. Chocolate
gymnast82

WRemix
View All 149

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.