Top 10 Non-Political Examples of Voters Getting It Wrong

HenchmanNo2
We like to think of voting as the best way to come to a decision that is desirable to the majority of people. A tool to make sure we make the right decision. But that's not always the case. Whether because of confusing options, poor turnout, sampling issues, or an uninformed voting population, the popular decision can be the wrong one.

Here are some examples of when voting went awry.

The Top Ten

1 Peyton Hillis voted onto the cover of Madden NFL 12

Given the Madden Curse, this was probably a good thing for the other players in the poll, but it's a bit of a joke that we know about a player because they were voted onto the cover of the most popular NFL video game instead of them being voted onto the cover because they were popular. Thank you highly motivated Cleveland fans. - HenchmanNo2

2 American Idol voters crown Kris Allen as the next American Idol

Sure, American Idol voters usually get it wrong. It's almost a curse to win the show given the success of contestants who don't come out victorious in that final week of voting. And yet this one seemed like such a no brainer.

Allen who has gone on to do who knows what and I don't even care enough to look it up, beat out Adam Lambert about who Cowell said "Over the entire season, you've been one of the best, most original contestants we've ever had on the show. The hope and whole idea of a show like this is to find a worldwide star, and I truly believe we've found that in you", and about who Allen said upon winning "Adam deserved this". - HenchmanNo2

Adam Lambert was the best and I was shocked. - Metal_Treasure

3 Yao Ming voted starting center in the 2011 NBA All Star game

Being voted starting center in his rookie year over Shaquille O'Neal, who was the reigning MVP, was bad. But not as bad as Yao's final appearance.

Because of the NBA's online all star voting process and Yao's national icon status in China, in 2011, Yao was voted onto the All Star team for an eight time despite playing only 5 games that season and averaging 10 points per game. - HenchmanNo2

4 Shakespeare in Love awarded Best Picture by Academy votes

There aren't many movies as impactful as Shakespeare in Love. The history, the gut wrenching performances, the immersion so intense it caused people to have flashbacks, arguably the greatest film director of all time, the greatest actor of his generation at the pinnacle of his success,... Oh, wait... I'm thinking of Saving Private Ryan, the movie Shakespeare beat out for Best Picture in 1999. - HenchmanNo2

5 Boring black and white idea receives most votes to be the new Nebraska state license plate design

Again in 2011, the state of Nebraska used an online poll to determine which of four designs people most wanted to be used on the state's new license plates. CollegeHumor.com users caught wind of it and flooded the poll with votes for what they believed was the worst of the four choices. After the poll concluded and the worst design won, the state removed the votes it attributed to CollegeHumor users which changed the results. - HenchmanNo2

6 Steely Dan's Two Against Nature wins the Grammy for Album of the Year

Anybody heard this album? How about Radiohead's Kid A or Eminem's The Marshal Mathers LP, two of the albums that were nominated that year and lost. - HenchmanNo2

7 Sepp Blatter voted President of FIFA for a fifth term

Apparently even Blatter didn't agree with this one as he resigned 4 days after the vote took place. - HenchmanNo2

8 The Texas House of Representatives voted in favor of a resolution commending the Boston Strangler for service to "his country, his state and his community"

To demonstrate that legislators often pass bills and resolutions without reading or understanding them, Rep. Tom Moore sponsored this resolution commending Albert de Salvo for "his noted activities and unconventional techniques involving population control and applied psychology". - HenchmanNo2

9 "Hitler Did Nothing Wrong" beat out "Gushing Granny", "Fapple", and "Diabeetus" in a vote to name a new apple version of Mountain Dew

"Fapple" would have sold SO well. A mistake indeed. - keycha1n

Gushing Granny... That's so funny! - Turkeyasylum

10 Yasser Arafat awarded the Nobel Peace Prize

His supporters hail him as a freedom fighter and his opponents label him as a terrorist, neither of which are shining examples of peace. - HenchmanNo2

The Contenders

11 Grammy 1989: Metallica lost out to Jethro Tull in the Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance category

I didn't know there was a similar problem between Paul Simon and Stevie Wonder, and that it was actually a Paul Simon quote. It's really cool and I understand why Lars liked it. - Metal_Treasure

Lars Ulrich even stole that line, since 15 years before that, Paul Simon thanked Stevie Wonder for not putting out an album that year.

Even Ian Anderson, the lead singer/flute player of Jethro Tull, thought the voters had this wrong.

The award was named "Grammy's 10 Biggest Upsets" in Entertainment Weekly‍‍ '​‍s.
In 1992 Metallica won a Grammy and Lars Ulrich of Metallica commented "We wanna thank Jethro Tull for not putting out an album this year". - Metal_Treasure

12 Fans of "The Simpsons" voted in favor of "Nedna" (i.e. for Ned Flanders and Edna Krabappel to become romantically involved/get married)
13 Crash awarded Best Picture by Academy votes
14 Zootopia awarded Best Animated Feature Film by Academy votes

It did not deserve to beat out "Kubo and the Two Strings" or even "Moana". But like "Crash" before it, the Academy gave the award to the 90 minute social justice lecture.

15 Brave awarded Best Animated Feature Film by Academy votes

Yay third-wave feminism clouding the Academy's judgement

16 American Idol voters crown Taylor Hicks as the next American Idol

To be fair, his obligatory first single that's indirectly about the experience of winning "American Idol" itself (every winner had that unspoken requirement) did get the Weird Al treatment, and we all know an artist has made it when Weird Al at least asks to parody their song. Incidentally, Taylor's song was "Do I Make You Proud" and Al's parody was "Do I Creep You Out".

"Who? " Exactly. Meanwhile, that season of "American Idol" wasn't the last we saw or heard from Kellie Pickler, Katharine McPhee, or Chris Daughtry.

17 How Green Was My Valley awarded Best Animated Feature Film by Academy votes

It was up against no less than "Citizen Kane", and it's not like we say something great is "the 'How Green Was My Valley' of (games, books, even modern movies)"

18 Kettle Cooked Wasabi Ginger won a voting contest for a new Lay's potato chip flavor

Wasabi and ginger belong on rice and fish (that's what sushi technically is), not potatoes an grease.

Bacon Cheddar Mac should've won

19 Bayonetta won the Smash Ballot/voted into "Super Smash Bros"
20 "Three Gays of the Condo" (episode of "The Simpsons") awarded an Emmy over "Jurassic Bark" ("Futurama" episode)

Another case where looking "progessive" took precedence over all else

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Kids Shows That Are Bad Examples for Kids Top 10 Examples of Irony Best Example Songs of All Time Top 10 Examples of Bad Parenting in Cartoons & Animated Movies Top 10 Examples of Good Shows vs. Bad Shows

List Stats

20 listings
3 years, 41 days old

Top Remixes

1. Yao Ming voted starting center in the 2011 NBA All Star game
2. Boring black and white idea receives most votes to be the new Nebraska state license plate design
3. American Idol voters crown Kris Allen as the next American Idol
HenchmanNo2
1. Peyton Hillis voted onto the cover of Madden NFL 12
2. Shakespeare in Love awarded Best Picture by Academy votes
3. American Idol voters crown Kris Allen as the next American Idol
htoutlaws2012

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P