Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Annabelle the Doll

Just watched the movie. I found it disappointing. It was too much like chucky the doll. A possess doll tries to kill a family and so on.

The scariest thing about it is that its true

This is not a creepypasta

Ah! Shes scary

V 3 Comments
22 Eyeless Jack Eyeless Jack

This Is SUCH a good read. I love Jack as a character and the story itself will really make you think

I love reading the story again and again because not only was a friend of mine in a cult similar to the story but I ALSO HAVE A FRIEND NAMED JACK

He eats your kidneys for God's sake!

A great read and personally one of my favourite's. He should be higher

V 6 Comments
23 Annora Petrova

Its really great but the picture that everyone makes a big deal of isn't scary at all. Oh and can someone tell me why the picture is scary?

Hell, the scariest part of the pasta is the photo, it made me never want to sleep again

24 The SCP Foundation

Ahh its scary Because it seems real but if it wasntits not scary like a thing like the weeping angels that if you don't look at it it kills you its kind of a copy but the detail was good so a goo read I would say but not scary

25 Mr. Widemouth

One of the most plausible, yet still creepy stories out there. Here is a my summary of the story.

A young child with Mononucleosis was forced to stay in their current house for more than 3 weeks, and his parents gave him some in-door activities/possessions to help pass the time before they had to leave and move to a new house. During that time, he developed an "imaginary friend". This "imaginary friend" looked kind of like a Furby and had a widemouth grin. His name, like the title suggests, was Mr. Widemouth. His personality was somewhat similar to Johan Liebert, as Mr. Widemouth would continuously try to get the boy to do dangerous things, like juggling knives, or jumping off the second story of the house. One day, Mr. Widemouth told the child about this location that many other children have visited after meeting Mr. Widemouth and that the boy should come visit this place one day. The child and his family left the house, and moved to a new one. He never saw Mr. Widemouth ...more

It's decently scary (freaked my 11-year-old brother out).
But more than scary it's the best-written creepypasta ever.

Very good read.

Widemouth wants him to die! that's what makes this creepiest

V 4 Comments
26 Red Mist

The story was pretty freaky, the picture was hellish, but the video? That was disappointing! The part where he was standing there with those bleeding eyes was creepy, but when he actually killed himself, it looked like someone drew a picture of him on a computer, and the animation when he put the gun to his head was so lame. In the story, he used a shot gun and blew his head apart. There was blood, brain matter, his eye was hanging out... But in the video, he puts a little revolver to his head, shoots himself, and then blood spatters on the screen. Then it shows a picture of squidward lying down with some really fake looking blood. Also, when the voice said "Do it! " It sounded like a ' 15 year old who has no experience with voice acting. LAAME!

The story was scary, but the episode was disappointing. In the story, he blew his head up with a shotgun. In the episode, he put a little revolver to his head, and shot himself, and there was some blood on his head... Weak! Also the animation was poor, and when the guy says "do it," it sounds like a 15 year old guy who has no experience with voice acting. LAME!

Squidward creeps me out on this one. The only thing that creeps me out on this creepypasta is the BIG BLOOD SHOT RED EYES! And the ending were HE POINTS A GUN INTO A MOUTH AND SHOOT! That's just creepy.

This is just another title for Squidward's Suicide

V 5 Comments
27 Penpal

I've been looking up lists of "The Best Creepypastas Ever" and am extremely surprised it took me so long to find this one on a list. It's at number 38 on the list that I found and, especially after reading a lot of the other ones, I don't understand how it could be so low on the list. I got chills big time when I read the last paragraph, it was extremely moving. The author is an excellent writer and should consider writing full novels. 10+/10 definintely the best I've read.

I am happy to announce to you that Penpal has been expanded, and a full length novel has been released! You can get it on Amazon. - GREATEST

I think the only reason this is so far down is people don't have the patience to read it all. But absolutely worth it

I have read a lot of creepy pastas, but this one takes the cake for me. It's so well written, it should be made into a movie!

I am seriously pissed at how overrated creepypastas like Jeff the killer, the rake, and slenderman are. This masterpiece should be number one

V 8 Comments
28 Candle cove

Quite long but otherwise we'll written. Rather than paranormal this story focuses on the malicious acts of a perverted man. 10/10

V 1 Comment
29 Super Mario 64: Damned

I read about it incredibly creepy and disturbing I may never be able look at Super Mario 64 the same way after reading this creepypasta. - egnomac

This combines every cliche into a single Creepypasta, but does it right.

V 1 Comment
30 The Harbinger Experiment

Very good creepy pasta. This should be in the top 5.

This one scared the hell out of me!

V 3 Comments
31 Bloody Painter

I also hate the fangirl comments screw them I hate fangirls but I love his story

Good creepyypasta, though the fangirl comments here ALMOST made me unable to take him seriously anymore... - FireWasp2004

Ummm... Don't exactly agree with the first "fangirlish" comment... He's supposed to be a terrifying mass murderer that uses blood for paint. I don't think being called "cute" would be taken very lightly. Anyways, the bloody painter is an AMAZING story, a long with jeff, Ben, EJ, LJ, ticci toby, clockwork, masky, hoodie, slenderman, etc. Definitely worth the read.

V 3 Comments
32 Dr. Smiley

I love his shark teeth I like to call him jaws and whenever I read the story the theme goes on in my head

He is great. And a great character.

V 1 Comment
33 The Keyhole

When the guy looked into the key hole, and it was red that is when it became a creepypasta.

V 2 Comments
34 Persuaded

Same old zombie cliche and wasn't scary at all

35 Laughing Jack

Easily my absolute favorite creepypasta. I told his story to all of my friends, and they were mortified. This one could easily be around the top three, but this isn't my list...

One of my favorites. I mean, think about it. A psycho monochrome clown who kills children and disappears into thin air when attacked. What's not to be scared of?

It's obvious this creepypasta is FAKE. First of all, how could someone disappear in a puff of smoke? Second of all, how could the narrator post the creepypasta from a MENTAL HOSPITAL?!

He is the best and went through the most pain

V 12 Comments
36 The Expressionless

I was going to vote for the rake, but when I saw this creepypasta on the list, I had to vote for it. Don't look it up or you will regret it. The way how the mannequin turned its teeth sharp was creepy.

Definitely beats out any other creepypasta!

The pasta itself is only about 6 out of 10 but the picture is downright disturbing

It's a pretty good pasta, but the thing that made me uncomfortable was the picture.don't dare look it up

37 An Egg

Not really creepy but if u want your mind exploded this is what u want to read

38 Psychosis

This, unlike the horribly overrated Jeff the Killer and Slenderman, is extremely thought provoking. Such a disturbing concept, and the ending is so well crafted the writer ought to get a medal. This and Candle Cove are easily my favorite Creepypastas.

This is the best written creepypasta by far. It easily squashes things like red mist and lavender town syndrome, and makes slenderman seem like a children's novel.

One of the first Creepypastas I read, and still one of the best. The entire read was good, but when it all comes together at the end, it really gets you thinking. 10/10

Shocked to see this so low. Way underrated

V 13 Comments
39 Bloody Mary

This isn't a creepy pasta, it's an urban legend - VoidSense

V 4 Comments

This is a REALLY scary one. The picture gave me nightmares! - LedZepp81

You people are such idiots. That picture was a band advertisement on 4chan!

This gave me SO. MANY. NIGHTMARES. Scary as hell!

This is one of the most unnerving Creepypastas I've ever heard. What's really unnerving- the picture of the murder victim. It should be in the top ten, without a doubt.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Scariest Movies of All Time Best CreepyPastas Ever Top Ten Scariest Things Ever Top Ten Scariest Video Games Scariest Songs Ever Written

List StatsUpdated 18 Aug 2017

1,000 votes
159 listings
3 years, 295 days old

Top Remixes (27)

1. Slenderman
2. Jeff the Killer
3. The Rake
1. The Grifter
2. The Angel Statue
3. The Keyhole
1. Annora Petrova
2. Cupcakes
3. Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv

View All 27


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.