Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths
Bluestar's descent into grief-struck madness is one of the most frustrating but saddening things to read in this series. She was built to be a respectable and caring leader, and that all goes crashing down which only proves (funnily enough) Bluestar's humanity. Mistakes are what makes a character so interesting to read. Bluestar has flaws, but at the end of the day she gives her life to protect her clanmates. Saying goodbye to her kits one last time as a mother, and not as a leader, or a warrior. It's breathtaking.
She is so brave and strong. Many people cried at her death. She will always have a place in many people's heart. At least she is in StarClan with Moonflower, Snowfur, Mosskit, Stonefur, Whitestorm, among many other loved ones. Many people love Bluestar, the brave leader who is loved by many, and especially loved by ThunderClan. May StarClan light her path. - Rain Bogart/Rain Shadow
I think firestar was right about keeping bluestar in camp, but she was so ambition that she risked her life to save firestar from the dogs. I think she did her best to lead the clan into success. I trust bluestar. Bluestar NEVER put herself before other cats and she did more for the clan. SHE DID NOT DESERVE TO DIE! No leader was ever better than bluestar because she showed more loyalty and compassion than firestar. My opinion: Bluestar's the best leader ever! Bluestar lead her clan to victory! More than firestar. I'm not saying that firestar is a horrible leader or anything. I just think that bluestar is a more experienced leader. I know her mate was in riverclan but she showed more loyalty to thunderclan. I flet bad for her when she had to give up her kits and see her sister get his on thunderpath. Her life was hard, at least she got to see mosskit, snowfur, moonflower, and stormtail in starclan.
I glad that oakheart's voice whispered in her head. She got to see her ...more
After everthing that happend to her... Everyone she loved was dead
and some more I forgot the name of
On top of that she had like deppression and was so confused.. then she drowned I was like OML WHY
Honestly, if I start talking about Firestar I'm going to start crying. Please read the other comments and love Firestar. He is so beautiful and brave and I seriously can't even with Firestar haters. Every time I think about his death I feel like bawling my eyes out. He is, again, so beautiful and brave. I love Firestar with all my heart and he will always have a place in my heart. How is this not the first one? At least he is in StarClan with Bluestar and Whitestorm and etc. We love you Firestar, the brave warrior who is loved by people, but mostly ThunderClan. May StarClan light his path.
Without Firestar, we wouldn't have this series. Even if you dislike him, he's most likely the character we're ALL attached to. Firestar IS the series. We saw him start off as a kittypet, Rusty. Then he proved himself to become a clan cat. Fireheart/paw would have never thought he'd gone as far enough to save the Clans when he were a kit. Without him, the Clans could have gone to chaos. He kept the peace within all five clans, and even now he continues being a legend. Every cat looks up to him, and he shaped some of the best cats in ThunderClan. Firestar's death itself wasn't as sad as some others, since he died in honor protecting his clan (well actually that makes it even sadder but shush pfft), more as the fact that he's dead now. But he will forever go on as the fire that saved the clans.
I think that Firestar is the best warrior cat ever he defeats scourge Tigerstar and Brokenstar. And if you don't like firestar I can't believe you. I truly believe that without Firestar there would be no series. And then there would be no warrior cats series and that would be sad...
Its sad how he dies he defeats Tigerstar he was a good friend to Graystripe and Ravenpaw. he was kind and gentle. he is the best warrior ever.
Honestly, I was a little mad that I had to wait for Omen of the Stars to get my Firestar - Tigerstar battle, but it was worth the wait. Tigerstar and Firestar had a long-lasting grudge, but Firestar didn't hold it because of Tigerstar's attacks on him, but on the forest, the clans, and the lake. The way Firestar died - protecting the clans from one of their oldest and most feared enemies - was so sad, but so noble. He even knew that it was his battle to fight, and he surely knew that he was going to die. He didn't sit back and let his clan fight Tigerstar for him, not even his best friend, Graystripe. He fought, and he died, but he died knowing he succeeded in his dreams and diminished his kittypet legacy. May StarClan light your path, Firestar.
Her death is quite sad. She was never my favorite character, and I think other deaths were sadder, but it was still sad. SPOILER ALERT! Strangely enough, the saddest part of this book for me was when Graystripe left ThunderClan.
Imagine it: it should be the best moment of your life, welcoming two bundles of joy- your bundles of joy into the world. Creating a family with the one you love and then you can bring up your babies. But instead you lie in agony as the medicine cat shakes their head and your mates eyes fill up with tears. Then it hits you-you aren't going to make it.
This death was just sad, because Silverstream didn't get to live with her kits and Graystripe had to lose her already. R.I.P Silverstream. Even though this death is sad, I think others are sadder, like Gray Wing.
WHY SHE HAD TO DIE! Do you know what I noticed, a lot of the deaths in the series are young, beautiful female cats like Spottedleaf (twice), Feathertail, Silverstream and many other she-cats. I mean I wouldn't mind if Millie died a painful death and I wish Feathertail was spiked, and Silverstream died of blood loss, Spottedleaf was killed by Clawface than Mapleshade. I really wish Silverstream never died. Graystripe just ditched her and want for the @!? %# Millie. This is Erin Hunter "Oh maybe I should kill off Silverstream like I did with Spottedleaf so Graystripe doesn't have to choose between her and that piece of!? $@ Millie"
Only Feathertail could call Crowpaw a stupid furball...
May you hunt with StarClan,
May your walk hold pride.
May you curl up with your mother,
May your honor thrive.
May you shine your light on kits,
May you be happy among stars.
We loved you so,
And miss you too.
But a beacon of hope still shines,
A sign that we will be together soon...
Feathertail was one of the most heroic cats I've met. The Tribe really thought it was Stormfur. It must have been hard for Stormfur and Crowpaw/feather. I wish she never died. And when Stormfur broke the news to Graystripe, Graystripe said something along the lines of "she was the most like her mother." or something like that.
Feathertail was one of my favorite cats, and she died to save some Tribe that they barely knew. She didn't deserve to die! She was so young then. At least she has Silverstream and the rest of her ancestors.
She was so young! Her and Silverstream did NOT deserve to die! We all know that her and Crowfeather/paw could never have worked out but STILL!
How is this not the SADDEST death?Honestly, if I start talking about Spottedleaf I'm going to start crying. Please read the other comments and love Spottedleaf. She is so beautiful and brave and I seriously can't even with Spottedleaf haters. Every time I think about her death I feel like bawling my eyes out. She is, again, so beautiful and brave. How cruel is it to be a victim of all the hate, wait years and years for her love, then get killed twice!? I honestly hate quote "erin Hunter" but I love Spottedleaf with all my heart and she will always have a place in my heart. How is this not the first one? At least she is in StarClan with Firestar. We love you Spottedleaf, the brave medicine cat who is loved by people, but mostly ThunderClan. May StarClan light her path.
Spottedleaf died heroically. She died trying to protect the kits. I'm writing a story on Wattpad and the main character is named after Spottedleaf. Her name is Spottedfeather.
Why did Clawface even kill Spottedleaf? Maybe to just make sure nobody would tell Bluestar or Lionheart that Clawface had stolen the kits. Spottedleaf was my favorite! I made a fanfiction on her and did a "What if Spottedleaf wasn't killed", which was super sad. I wonder if she even liked Firepaw back- now this is just making me cry T^T
This is the saddest death. I loved her so much! Sorry Firestar she died TWICE! And to all spottedleaf haters SHE WAS GREAT! she was the best medicine cat (besides leafpool I LOVE her!)
From the very beginning, she was the most loyal cat you've ever met. Her life was 100% dedicated to the warrior code, her clan, and StarClan.
She suffered so much pain after learning the truth about her parents. She was lost and wandering in the dark tunnels until Fallen Leaves found her. When she finally came back, she found it difficult to be around everyone she'd left and stayed away from for so long.
She gave her life to save Ivypool, a clanmate she barely got to know. During her dying breaths, she forgave those that had lied to her about her forbidden bloodlines and sent out a last desperate plea for forgiveness. She deserved to live longer. She definitely earned her place in StarClan.
She was fiercely loyal and protective of her Clanmates as well as the warrior code. She tried so hard to do the right thing, she thought that it would be best if Ashfur didn't cause drama for the Clans if he was in StarClan. After he died, she was horrified of what she'd done and exiled herself from her own Clan, then came back and fought the Dark Forest along with her Clanmates, with the courage of any other warrior. She sacrificed her own life for Ivypool's. She lived a hard life, learning that the first half of it was a lie the entire time, but she has recovered and forgiven all that have lied to her. She was such a noble cat... she deserved better than to be killed at the paws of a Dark Forest warrior. At least she finally got peace from her troubles and fears in StarClan.
Hollyleaf was one of the only cats who lived for the code! Even if she broke it she realized after what she has done and was scared about it, I feel bad too.
I really like to know why isn't she at the top of the page, and why oh why did erin hunter killed her?! She already "died" one time already! She was so devoted and brave and loyal! And she was on tough cat in battle, it will be super hard to beat her! Rest in peace Hollyleaf, rest in peace. With you gone my life will never be the same. Again why?! I basically died inside with her every time I read last hope.
*hating hawkfrost! *
Erin Hunter had absolutely no logical reason to kill her! she should be at the top of this page 100%. And I'll smite anyone who says otherwise! Hollyleaf shouldn't die!
*back to sobbing*
this is what would happen:
Silvermoon pads over to Mosskit. "What's wrong? why are you down here little one? Here, I'll help you into top five saddest deaths." Mosskit mewls when Oakheart comes and helps her up. Silvermoon looks down to the haters of Mosskit and sticks her tongue out. "This is where she belongs!" Silvermoon hisses. "I bet Mosskit's warrior name will be Mossheart like his father." Silvermoon meows as the other cats in top five nod in agreement.
Poor Mosskit! If she was a warrior, I'd have named her Mossfur (after her mother, of course) or Mossheart (because she was an awesome cat)
You see your mother and siblings pushing ahead before you. you have to make it you must you see your mother turn back towards you. Then it all fades away.
Hows mosskit down here her death is the saddest in warrior history its her that had one of the shortest lives but known in the books and had a whole fandom page of her growing up and living as a river clan warrior meeting her mother and her returning to her birthplace we loved her but she went to soon her death will be forever remembered and who wouldn't cry in her death scene for the T.V. series the way her small body dropped and the look on bluestars face says it all that she died we burst into tears in our room then rant how its not fair that she died yes its relevent to keep the look of bluestars depression but maybey she could have lost something else to her not mosskit
I love the cranky, old she-cat characters! Yellowfang's death was something I knew would happen before I turned the page, but I wanted her to survive!
-For those who need to refresh on the death-
In one of the forest fires for ThunderClan's territory, an elder (Forgot their name, oops.) got trapped in camp, so Yellowfang ran in to get them. She got to the elder and had to run into her den with the elder. . .I think the smoke got to her lungs and she died.
She had such a hard life. If only she lived to see the lake as a living cat. I cried when Yellowfang died. I love you so much Yellowfang. You taught Cinderpelt well.
Honestly I almost cried reading about her death. If only she had lived longer! She was a pretty noble cat, and loyal to her foster Clan.
I think it was so sad that she risked herself to go into the fire but it was the right thing to do. But when she told Firestar she loved him and wished that he was her son instead of Brokenstar and then died it was too sad.
I loved how he spoke his heart and did not listen to leopardstar because he knew what was right. If he let them die instead of him then Stormfur would be with Brook and be happy instead he would be in starclan at a young age! And for feathertail she would've died anyway and sooner! Which would have been so sad. Even though I was sad stonefur died he is now in Starclan and will always be remembered as a great warrior!
I will always remember him-- as the greatest warrior of all time, and saving his apprentice. Without him, Stormfur and Feathertail would've never made the journey to the Sun-Drown-Place, and what would that bring? Stupid Leapordstar. I was crying
Why, Leopardstar? Why would you just stand there and do nothing? Why would you tell Stonefur to do what Tigerstar had said? Good thing Tigerstar got killed.
He was born half ThunderClan and half RiverClan. He died a full RiverClan warrior. He had the fierceness of his mother and the courage and honor of his father. He was a great warrior.
I feel like Honeyfern shouldn't have died. At least she saved a helpless kit. Briarkit. Who was going to get bitten by a snake. Sometimes, I wonder what would have happened if it was Lionblaze instead of Honeyfern. Honeyfern would have survived., and Lionblaze's powers would have been revealed.
I sat, sunning myself against Berrytail. I could not believe my luck! He loved me back! And I was a warrior! I could not wait for duties to begin. Ooh and maybe me and Berrytail could have kits! What a great thought! Ahh yes I could imagine them. I watched Millie's kits playing across the clearing. Maybe she could give us some tips? Aww they were so cute! I could see Briarkit playing next to the rocks. Wait a second what was that behind her?! I jumped to my paws in an instant, racing across towards the tiny kit. Berrytail jumped up behind me, but, slower, confused at my sudden start. The snake was already arched up behind the unaware kit mouth open, poison ready. No! I jumped , knocking the kit away. I heard Berrytail's cries from behind me but it was to late now. I said a silent goodbye to my wonderful mate as I watched the snake's mouth come flying towards me. Everything went black as the venom entered my system.
Ok first I think we can all agree that Honeyfern is a hero. I mean, she gave her life away for a kit! She had always been so calm and gentile, and her heart was always in the right place. I think that Honeyfern's death is more sad then Firestar's becouse 1 she was just such a sweet cat, and 2 Firestar was a kittypet, and I won't ever be able to forget that. Once a kittypet always a kittypet. I wish Honeyfern a good life in Starclan and I hope that she will always find happiness. ( by the way it's Berrynose NOT Berrytail) (( the composer of a small opinion article about how Tigerstar is not evil is by Mountainbreeze)) (((and in a different opinion article about why Violetshine is my favorite cat I meant "why is she down here in 83 AND in 123")))
WHY isn't Honeyfern #1?! She literatly sacrificed herself for a kit! A KIT! That is like the best thing you can do for your clan! But a snake... Why did it have to be a snake to kill Honeyfern? She totally deserved to live and to be with Berrynose! But then her sister stole her man! come on people!
*looks at the way he was treated by Mistystar*
Are you frickin kidding me?!
1. She hurt her leg and could not be a warrior
2. She became a medicine cat, but medicine cats aren’t allowed to have kits
3. She had a crush on a cat (Firestar) who had no idea she loved him. STUPID TOMS
4. Her apprentice lied to her and was keeping secrets
5. Her mentor died so soon after she found happiness.
6., Yellowfang was so hard on her
7. She was kidnapped by ShadowClan Warriors to train as apprentices when they were only three moons!
8. She was killed by badgers!
R.I.P Cinderpelt. May you hunt peacefully in StarClan and May your death be avenged
-Frostwhisker, ShadowClan medicine cat
I sat, trembling, watching as Sorreltail cried out. Around this nursery, screeches and cries could be heard as the rest of ThunderClan battled ferociously. Why of all times did she have to kit now? I watched the opening, ready to react if the badgers approached. But then, my eyes turned to Sorreltail as she let out another moan. In that instant, the badger had pushed through. I saw it make a beeline for Sorreltail who was unable to move. No! I could not let innocent kits be slaughtered by badgers. Without a moment to spare, I dived towards the badger, feeling its claws rake across my pelt. And then it all went black.
She should be #1! I love her through and through. She couldn't be a warrior but that never stopped her. When I watched the Blame MAP of Cinderpelt I ALWAYS cry. It's so sad how she dies, and that's why she should be number 1!
Honestly, this was like one of the saddest deaths. A badger killed Cinderpelt, and she was ALSO protecting Sorreltail AND her kits. But does Cinderpelt really deserve that death? Her leg got crippled and then she had to become a medicine cat when she REALLY REALLY wanted to become a warrior. It almost made me cry!
It was one of the saddest deaths ever. When she died, it was so sad. It was painful to read about her getting run over by a monster. And of course it was frustrating because Thistleclaw blamed it on Bluefur.
Omg this was hands down THE saddest death in all of the extras. She was such a sweet cat who always looked at the bright side. When she died I cried for THE first time. RIP
Snowfur was such a sweet and kind cat! It broke my heart to read that part in Bluestar's prophecy. Bluestar was carrying her sister to Adderfang and his patrol, and she was telling her that it was going to be okay and that they were going to get help, but deep down, Bluestar knew her sister was dead. I CRIED!
Saddest death in the history of StarClan! I cried when she died. Tears were coming out of my eyes and I wanted to close the book so it would stop happening, but I kept it open. When it kept dragging on, I felt as if I was going to die! I was like,
"Help me StarClan! Why did you do this to me?"
If you want a book full of drama, just read Bluestar's prophecy! There you go! Snowfur was such a good character in the book! Didn't she get hit by a monster? Super sad death!
Okay ferncloud, I love ferncloud. I mean am I biased because dustpelt is my fave character, maybe, am I taking my bias in my choice of votes, absolutely not. Also I was like mad when sorreltail wasn’t on this list. She deserves to be period.
How could you Brokenstar you killed a mother of so many cats in Thunderclan. I hope you rot in hell brokenstar. Ferncloud shouldn't have died like that.
The Last Hope, p.318: ' "why is Ferncloud asleep?" Amberkit asked popping her head up. "She tired after all the fighting silly," mewed Dewkit beside her. ... "Dustpelt will wake her up" '
The kits thinking she was asleep broke my heart. Ferncloud died protecting them, she died a warriors death even though she was a queen.
I love Ferncloud! Just not her brother!I mean I get that his heart got broken but I mean going to that extent I MEAN WHAT THE HECK CREEPPPPPP! Anyway Ferncloud had a hard life so I already felt bad for her and the fact that like her mother, father, brother, and 4 of her kits died! I mean like WHAT THE WHAT! :( I also feel bad for dustpelt too so yeah.
Okay first of all, RIP Swiftpaw. I get that Longtail was his mentor and may have had a bad influence on him, but that doesn't mean he has to die! By dogs! I thought dogs were cute and fuzzy creatures until I read that part... Seriously why did he have to die?! He would've become a warrior!
He should have lived. Swiftpaw was a good apprentice and would have made a great warrior. He saved Brighthearts life, fighting dogs. He should have been Brighthearts mate! Not Cloudtail! I will just go ahead and blame it al on those dam humans who let those dogs out!
I would bet that if he became a warrior, he would be named Swiftclaw, Swiftstrike, or Swiftbreeze. And he lost his chance! It’s actually TigerKIT (he doesn’t even deserve his apprentice name!)’s fault! He
pushed Bluestar into maddening depression! I was so sad! He was so brave, and GOOD RIDDANCE TigerKIT! He matured greatly from a timid kit to a fierce fighter! I wish he hadn’t died! (TigerKIT is a disgrace to the name of tigers!)
Swiftpaw died way too young, and he seemed like a sweet cat, I really wish we had gotten to know him better. He was so heroic and brave for a cat as young as himself, trying to help him and his friends become apprentices, and in the end, sacrificing himself for Brightheart. I support Bright x Cloud, but I have a feeling that I would have supported Bright x Swift if he would’ve lived
In a sense, it wasn't just Hawkheart's fault: It was Goosefeather's as well. Goosefeather told them they had to attack. Goosefeather told them to go. Hawkheart killed Moonflower. I can't believe it! Goosefeather, sending his own littermate to her death! He probably didn't know, though.
OMG. This one I cried so hard. I just remember Moonflower saying she would do something for Bluepaw when she came back but she never did come back!
This death is so sad... I completely HATE Goosefeather after this, just bc of his stupid prophecy she had to die when her kits were only apps!
Poor Moonflower. Stormtail started not really caring about her, Snowkit, and Bluekit, then she had to be KILLED by the WindClan medicine cat. I almost cried when she died. RIP Moonflower.
He was one of my favourites at the time, but now he isn't I forgot the death details.
He died in the battle with BloodClan.
Whitestorm was so wise and brave, and a great deputy. I hate that he seemed just to be a placeholder until Firestar decided that he actually wanted Graystripe. Don’t get me wrong, I like Graystripe, but I feel like Whitestorm was just killed solely for the purpose that Graystripe could become deputy. I wished he had lived longer, he was a great and noble cat
Poor Whitestorm, getting killed like three days after he became deputy?! That’s messed up, even Redtail survived longer than that, and he had two ambitious cats trying to killed him, (Thistleclaw and Tigerstar)
Whitestorm, the noblest cat by far (all of the "good guys" are the noblest, I can't say Whitestorm is better than the rest, but I mean he was so noble! D:).
I cried when he died, but ha'd when Bone got swarmed and killed by the apprentices. And LOLOL to the person who said "Tigerbutt." I think in Warrior Cat language, it would be called "Tigerrear"...
I loved Whitestorm! He was so patient and understanding, even so noble just as an apprentice! I love him and I wish he had survived the battle, because even though he wouldn't have lived long enough to succeed Firestar as leader of ThunderClan, he would have made one of the greatest leaders ever known to the forest/lake territory.
Willowbreeze is my favourite character's mate. In my opinion, she and Crookedstar were the best ship in the history of Warriors! Stupid greencough! Why did you take Willowkit and Minnowkit too?
When Willowbreeze, Minnowkit and Willowkit died, I was crying. I miss you Willowbreeze. I love you, as if you, Graypool and I were sisters.
~Stormheart of RiverClan
Crookedstar had disfigured his face, lost both his parents, and his brother had kits with a cat from another Clan. When he met Willowbreeze, I thought things were finally going to go his way, until she died and all but one of their kits died. How horrible is that? This is by far the saddest Warrior cat death.
Okay, when Firestar died, I admit, I cried. But when I read Crookedstar’s Promise, I was BAWLING my eyes out when she wanted to name the kits and she was telling Crookedstar to be brave. And I cried even more when he confronted Mapleshade. Then, at the end of the book where he gets into a fight with Oakheart, it ends with him telling his only surviving kit that he’s her father. I’m still pretty upset that she died too after kitting Graystripe’s kits.
I LOVED her so much. Tigerstar was a great villain and definitely was wrote to make people hate him. Brindleface was an amazing mother and was related to some of my favorite characters along with being one herself, <3
HOW CAN BRINDLEFACR NOT BE IN THE TOP TEN?! Sure Firestar, Bluestar, and Spottedleaf deserve to be up there too, but they already are! For crying out loud, she was SLAUGHTERED by TigerCLAW! (Doesn't deserve star) she was my absolute favorite queen of all time and she just died like that! Poor Cloudtail too! How do you think he felt? Taken away from his mother at birth and had his foster mother killed for no reason whatsoever! I hate you Tigerclaw I hate you I hate you I hate you! Brindleface I'm so sorry this had to happen to you.P. S: Thistleclaw haters back off! He didn't train Tigerpaw to be evil. He just taught him to be strong!
I know! He doesn’t even deserve a warrior name! He deserves TigerKIT and that’s all. She’s loved her kits dearly, and the must’ve been devastated. I don’t blame Cloudtail for wanting to rip his throat out, I would take my revenge if ANYTHING KILLED MY MOTHER, TOO!
She was a caring mother. She raised Cloudtail, Ashfur, and Ferncloud. She was in camp as cats went to go investigate the dogs lurking at Snakerocks. Tigerstar killed her as bait for the dogs so they'd like the taste of cat blood, but the warriors hauled her body away before anything happened.
Okay, this was definitely the scariest death in this list. I really felt sorry for Jayfeather having to know he was drowning and not being able to do anything about it. Also tied between Cinderpelt and Swiftpaw. Swiftpaw's was so scary but imagine being trapped under ice in the frezeing water, struggling under the current with only a blind medicine cat there to save you. Awful death. RIP Flametail
I loved Flametail, he was one of the first ShadowClan cats that the books centered on and then he died and everyone was so sad. Also, the only death I literally cried about was Briarlight's. So this is my second saddest death.
Poor, poor flametail. How ever hard Jayfeather tried to save him, he just couldn’t. I truthfully hated flametail, but...the only reason I was sad of his death was because of what dawnpelt did after.
DROWNED. That is like the worst death possible in my book. They blamed Jayfeather of killing him but really it was ROCK who came and told him to go away and TOOK him away so you should be blaming rock people! Flametail you will be remembered.
I have never read the books but I have started to learn more about them. I saw lots of names a Longtail was the first I picked. I love cheetahs and Longtail reminded me of one. He's yellow and black pattern and his personality was just like a cheetah's. I was very sad about Longtail's death when I found out he was blind and died because a tree hit him. I will keep Longtail's legacy on by playing as him in animal jam. I think you should vote for Longtail. Love, Longtail fan. P.S. my user is Animalgirl0906. 🐆
All I gotta say is he is one of my favorite characters ( if not my favorite). Poor Mousefur blamed herself and that was so sad :< He lost to a kittypet (oof) lost his vision to a rabbit- A FLIPPING RABBIT- and was killed by a flipping flopping tree!? Poor Longtail went through a lot. Literally hate trees now >:C
I am totally blaming Mousefur for that. Stupid old coot. It's her fault he died. His death is the only time I ever cried over a book and I am still not over it. He was my favorite of all books of all fandoms. Also I love his personality and humor a lot. He was brave enough to stand up to Tigerclaw and saved a kitten from an owl. If he hadn't been there the Clan would have been eaten by the dogs. He went through the mountains being blind. A tree shouldn't have ended that.
I burst into tears when he died. Lots of people's first impressions on him when they read Into The Wild for the first time are "I don't like him, he tried to fight Rusty and he has a bad attitude." I feel sorry for him, because Firestar didn't trust him until later on and he didn't finish mentoring all of his apprentices, and he got his eyes scratched out! Poor Mousefur was devastated when Longtail died. DUMB TREE
I'm just pretending that he secretly got killed by Tiger Claw. Lion Heart for me just dies so stupidly.
"A great Warrior dies from injuries" Are you serious?!
Lionheart and spottedleaf never die, you think they do but they are secretly replaced by mapleshade and tigerstar and go off somewhere together and have four kits, ivytiger, honeymitten, spotstripe and brightdazzle
I love you so much lionheart and you don't deserve to die you deserve to live and be happy with spottedleaf or someone who you love
It's so sad when graypaw/stripe runs over to him and cries "You can't die, you can't! I still need you! Bluestar still needs you! "
Lionheart should be higher on this list like 10 or something
Oh why StarClan. Why did he die so early went we had not prepared yet for death? It was Graypaw that really made it. At this point ever was new cat death?!? Well no If I re read it, it’s not so bad.
Lionheart is a great warrior, he was perfect, he could never be doubted and always followed the warrior code like a real warrior should, he was a very fine temporary mentor to Firestar, and Bluestar was so sad when he died, so was Greystripe, Lionheart, I cried when you died, I would have lied, for you, Lionheart. And even worse, replacing Lionheart was that evil Tigerstar!
OH MY GOODNESS GRACIOUS STORM'S DEATH WAS SO SAD GRAY WING LOVED HER AND SHE CHOSE CLEAR SKY AS HER MATE BUT STILL AND THUNDER GREW UP WITHOUT HIS REAL FATHER AND NO MOTHER THOUGH GRAY WING WAS A GREAT FOSTER FATHER AND STILL WHERE IS GRAY WING NOW? HE DIED FROM ASTHMA AND HE ISN'T HERE? I HAVE A COMPLAINT BUT BACK TO STORM SO THIS IS WHAT SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED
Gray Wing dug through the rubble till his paws hurt. he could see a small shape moving under. "One of the kits is alive!" he yowled as he dug harder. Turtle Tail peeked over the rubble and started helping Gray Wing. He noticed a gray tail flicking under a rock. "Storm!" he yowled and dug more. Storm sat up coughing and gagging until she spit out dirt. "Let's get you and your kits to Cloud Spots and Dappled Pelt!" Gray Wing Turtle Tail and Storm raced away each carrying one of storm's three kits.
Also I gave Thunder's unnamed siblings names Thunder had a sister named Cloud and a brother named ...more
Her death was very sad, but I think I saw someone who said that they wanted her to be Thunder/Thunderstars mate, Thunder is her son, so...
I think it was really sad when storm died because she was mates with Clearsky, who was devastated and Graywing had a crush on her! She never got to name her kits too ;-;
Storm was one of my favorite cats I guess but she didn't deserve Skystar as a mate when he was in that state. If they weren't mates she would've been alive still.
Um, I was crying, yes, but WITH ANGER. So Mudclaw loyally serves Tallstar for moons and moons, shows outstanding bravery, and is overall a great deputy. So Tallstar is seriously in debt to him right? Then Tallstar REPLACES HIM WITH ONEWHISKER, saying 'I don't want any rivalry with Thunderclan when I'm gone.' Then what happens? He fights with Thunderclan just as much as Mudclaw would have. Everyone is always 'Tallstar is so wise and farsighted.' But this was stupider than Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and Jayfeather looking for the foxes as kits. I hate Tallstar, RID to him.(Rest In Despair)
When Tallstar dies he makes Onewhisker his deputy because he gets a vision that Onestar will be a fair leader and ally with Firestar. But he was wrong. I can't stand that sad look on Mudclaw's face in the manga when Onewhisker is made deputy...it looks so sad..
Tallstar was such a great warrior, learning from his mistakes and fixing them the best he could. When he died...for me, not even Firestar's death could beat his. The fact that Tallstar was sick and old was enough to make me cry because I knew that the Erins would kill him off. I was so mad that Mudclaw was acting like he was already dead, I was about ready to (if I could) stomp over to the writer's area and go 'CAN YOU KILL THIS GUY YET'! Tallstar was the best cat ever (in my opinion), and with his last breath, he did the right thing...what he always tried to do.
He is my favorite leader! He is one of the best warrior cats. Of course his death is sad. He was brave and smart. He never let the knowledge of him knowing that Firestar was Jakes son come out. I just find him really inspiring! At least he got to see the clans new home.
Ok, just to clarify, Sandstorm DOES die in Vision of Shadows, the latest book that was released in March 2016. And It's so sad! She dies as an elder on a quest to find SkyClan (yes another one) and an already threatening fox fight injury becomes deadly when she catches it on a spike and dies of blood loss. Poor Sandstorm!
I love Sandstorm so much! Her love, respect, and loyalty to her clan is heart breaking. Reading Firestars Quest is making my heart beat faster than ever because I am out if she dies after the storm where the tree falls down and mite of killed her.
Ya guys, hate to break it to us, sand storm does die. But I can't remember the book its in nor reading it. But she does die. If not in my 182 padge book I will have to find out how she died and do a scene where mint kit meets her in starclan and asks how she dies. I litterally just wrote green cough. 0-0
She was (and still is) one of my favourite first series characters. When she died in The Apprentice's Quest, I was sad, yet happy she could join Firestar in StarClan. She was so selfless, leaving to guide Alderpaw in his quest when she knew she would die...
I litteraly HATE Brokenstar! I was so happy when he died. Sorry Brokenstar lovers. I would have never cried. And yet I didn't. Please don't take this offensive it's my opinon. I agree only thing sad was his mother did not love him when she found out he was the cat with blood on his paws. AND killed him because of that.
In my opinion, one of the saddest deaths. Yes, he was evil, and he sent kits off to fight, but he did it because his mother never loved him. In fact, she killed him TWICE! He was my favorite. RIP Brokenstar.
No joke, I screamed through Forest of Secrets when he died. He deserved to die, but deaths 1 and 2 are horrifying to me.
Brokenstar was abused as a kit and never knew who his mother is. Then Yellowfang has to put him to sleep and she confesses to be his mother, this is so sad seeing a cute little kit turning evil and then having to be killed. (If you read Yellowfang's Secret you would think this is even sadder, like I do) -AmethystFøxQueen