Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths
This was by far one of the saddest deaths. When I read it, I was shocked. And then I cried. Bluestar did not deserve this. She was so brave and wise and I was so proud of her for telling Mistyfoot and Stonefur the truth. But seriously... Firestar's death may have been the saddest, but this was by far the most shocking and tragic.
SO sad! I thought she should have been able to live! Also in the background when she died Tigerclaw looked horrified which was weird because he tried to kill her before.
I think she deserves place 3.
There are SO many sad deaths from Snowkit's tragic, helpless death to Firestar's brave death, but we can all agree Bluestar's death was shocking and upsetting. She had to die so Fireheart can become Firestar, but it was so sad! It was happy too, she said goodbye to Stonefur and Mistyfoot. She had faced so much and she was about to reunite with her loved ones... but still. Her sacrafice almost brought me to tears. RIP Bluestar.
Bluestar was such a wise leader ( not when she was mentally unstable) I was happy that she told mistystar/foot and stone fur the truth.
Why? That was my first question. Erin, why? Firestar was, in my opinion, the best cat in the entire series. First, he led ThunderClan and the others clans against BloodClan, saved the forest, ya know, then he helped lead the clans on the journey to the lake, then he killed Tigerstar. And my insides are bursting with happiness as I read that bit, and then he dies. Like, what? Erin is getting lazy? Did she want ThunderClan to have a horrible leader? Bramblestar-I'm sorry- is a horrible leader. Like, come on. This was the saddest death for a reason. At least he died a hero.
Every had that feeling when you you get a test back and think you aced it, but you failed? That's what I felt when Firestar died. He had just killed Tigerstar, and then he had to die, leaving Thunderclan with Bramble as a leader (who is TERRIBLE). Sure, he killed the greatest threat to the forest, but he still died. He gave everyone of his lives to save his clan, and he went down that way. He saved the other clan time and time again, and if they kill his spirt off I'm going to hate Erin Hunter. by the way, nice dying words Firestar. "You live like a rouge, you die like a rouge", going out screaming death and in a ball of fire. R.I.P Firestar, R.I.P
Admit I'm disappointed. I'm trying to refrain from using all caps here (I think I do it too much) but WHY was no one bawling their eyes out?! Come on! Squirrelflight was actually jumping for joy at Bramble now star's forgiveness (ahhhhh). Now for the other side...I LOVE firestar! He was the under dog...cat? and made his way to the top. He made the clans better - and though he understood war was a solution, always tried peace first. I cringed for him, laughed with him, and now...cried for him. So sad! Died as he lived, awesome, and a hero.
Firestar- We met him as Rusty. We followed him into the heart of the forest. Together, side-by-side, we learned the ways of the warrior code. We fought bravely to protect our clan. We stalked through the depths of the forest. We grew with him, we learned with him, we followed in his pawsteps. From Rusty, to Firepaw, to Fireheart, to Firestar- we became a Warrior through his eyes. The first stories, THE stories, the ones that made us who we are, the ones that gave us Warriors- they are his stories. To see him die is to watch our link die- to watch ourselves die. Rusty was, and still is, and always will be- part of ME. Part of YOU. Part of everything that is Warriors. Such a sad and noble death- may Firestar live forever in the hearts of young Warriors, his memory never fade, his soul forever hunt in Starclan.
She died having Graystripe's kits... that was so sad. She died from blood loss... even sadder. This was not the saddest detah, but it certainly amongst the top. Long live Silverstream
I think Silverstream had the saddest death because she gave birth when she died of blood loss. Graystripe thought she was the only love he only had but changed his mind when he saw Millie, who was similar to Silverstream. and Graystripe and Mille had 2 kits, Blossomfall, Brairlight.
Dewdrop of Riverclan
Silver stream deserved better, greystripe left her loss to mate with a bratty kitty pet. I wish greystripe never found her so she never died.
She died giving birth to one of my faviourte characters, Feathertail. Her death was tragic. Poor Greystripe, Stormfur and Feathertail!
She and her friends were just trying to find a safer home for the clans. And poor Crowfeather. I liked them together and it was just so sad to see him grieve like that. He really did care for her so much. Feather tail died saving her friends and the Tribe WHO THEY JUST MET! It was so sad to see Stormfur so heartbroken too. He was the best brother and stayed with the Tribe to be close to her and his mate, Brooke. It was just really sad and I hated her death.
You know what I would have done? I would have shoved a spider in those horrible tribe cat's noses. Feathertail died saving their STUPID BUTTS from Sharptooth. And Crowpaw and Stormfur's reaction was just... devastating. I miss her.
This was so sad! Poor poor crowfeather & Stormfur! Crowfeather is probably like top 3 as far as warrior cats go for me, and his reaction made me feel so sad! I think it was the reaction of crowfeather and her heartbroken brother Stormfur, that really made her death so sad!
Her death was so sad! I'm a CrowLeaf shipper, but the way Crowpaw reacted was just so sad that I have to admit they were cute together. Stupid tribe cats, I hate them all! Brook's annoying, Crag's bossy, Stoneteller's rude and grumpy, Talon's just a jerk, and all the others are boring and have no story! They forced Feathertail to die, caused Crowfeather, one of my favourite characters, to be heartbroken, caused Stormfur to be sad (I mean, he sucks so I'm glad he felt something bad but like come on) and she was my favourite cat at the time! The New Prophecy killed off three of my favourite cats: Feathertail, Cinderpelt, and Hawkfrost. I hated that arc, and Feathertail's death was so sad! Crowfeather naming himself after her was soooo cute. I miss her so much! -FierceheartOfThunderClan
Why do people hate Spottedleaf? She's not a bloody Mary Sue! Here are her flaws: 1. Died young (which is not her fault), 2 Irritated easily. 2 flaws! She's not a Mary Sue! Her life was so unfair, she became a medicine cat so Thistleclaw wouldn't turn her into a stupid demon (points to Mapleshade). Mapleshade is a stupid idiot. Both Spottedleaf's deaths were sad, and Clawface and Mapleshade are stupid idiots. Mapleshade is overrated, while poor sweet Spottedleaf is so underrated! Goodbye, Spottedleaf. We'll miss you... or at least the good people who understand Warriors will...
Spottedleaf, how just how? When she died in the great battle with dark her last words were "This was never going to happen, we cannot journey together, I'm so sorry" she says that to Firestar when she's about to die, poor her, why did anyone even kill her spirit of, the poor died twice and when she was so young
This poor cat was killed TWICE. So, sure, I don't like the idea of SpottedxFire but Spottedleaf was kind, gentle and selfless and did not deserve any of this. She died forever saving Sandstorm, because she stilled cared about Firestar. this is just.. devastating
She is so kind. Even if Mapleshade killed her if Spottedleaf could talk to Mapleshade she would be kind to Mapleshade and understand her problems and whatever. I was so sad that she died. I wish starclan was real so that Spottedleaf would be more blessed.
- Crystalpool the medicine cat of thunderclan
Mosskit died nearly after he was born. If he survived and got a bad name I would be furious. He should be named Mossheart because of how kind he is. He forgave his mother for leaving him out in the cold with Oakheart.
- Crystalpool the medicine cat of thunderclan
Mosskit did not deserve any of this. I think Erin was lazy again. If she lived, I think she should have been called Mosstuft. Long live Mosskit!
I hate Bluestar for this. She brought her kits out into the frozen forest, and then acted like she was the one suffering them most from it. But Mosskit suffered the most, knowing her mom brought her out into the forest and leading her to her death. I personaly think her death was super sad, and that she should get a new chance like Cinderpelt.
I love Mosskit! My fave dead kits of all time (some are young apprentices, still kits)
10 Shrewpaw (still a kit when died), 9 Minnowkit. 8 Willowkit, 7
Look, I love Hollyleaf, and her death was so sad I couldn't help but cry. Her death is the fourth saddest in the series for me next to Badgerfang, Briarlight, and Ferncloud. She didn't deserve to die! And all for stupid Ivypoop. Ivypoop should've died instead, what good is she? She just lived to become a whiny brat in AvoS when Hollyleaf could've became a legendary leader of ThunderClan! Hawkfrost should've killed Ivypoop instead. I love Hollyleaf! I hate that she killed Ashfur, but she's interesting, kind beautiful, badass, sassy, and I love her so much. I hate Hawkfrost for killing her. I miss her so much! R.I.P Hollyleaf, may you forever hunt well in StarClan. -FierceheartOfThunderClan
I cried when she fake died. And then when she really died, gosh, tears. It was just so sad. And she saved her best friend ivypool. I just loved her and miss you so much.
Her death was the perfect finnish to her redemption! Gosh, I hated her so much, then she comes back BOOM and I actually LIKE HER? And then BOOM she's dead! So sad. The Erins really mess with my heart.
I love Hollyleaf so much. My absolute favorite character. I cried when her fake death happened, and I cried when she actually died. She isn't mentioned in StarClan or The Dark Forest, and I wonder if she was punished for killing Ashfur.
Why is Yellowfang's death #8? It was so sad and sudden when the forest fire happened and Yellowfang was trapped in the camp. She also had such a sad life and she did not deserve to die especially because of how bad everybody treated her. Sure, she is a bit bossy and all, but that just makes it more sad and tragic when she dies. Now Silverstream, seriously? Sure it was kind of sad but we only knew her for 2 books and we knew Yellowfang for much more. When you think about it, Yellowfang also served aa very important role, she became the next medicine cat of thunder clan when Spottedleaf did not have an apprentice. But Silverstream or Feathertail, or Hollyleaf, or Spottedleaf all were put into the story to add a little more entertainment, some of them did not succeed though. There is just too much forbidden love, but Yellowfang accepted it, but nobody else did. I do not want to put any unnecessary hate in anybody's favorite character, but I got to say it's hard not to hate them. So I ...more
Yellowfang didn't deserve to die. She actually accepted Russetfur and Boulder, she had powers she couldn't speak of, and she nearly killed Firepaw, and lay down and accepted that her time had come when Firepaw pinned her. She was undoubtedly one of the most iconic characters, and even Tigerstar admits that do cat deserves to go up in flames. I felt a sinkhole going into my stomach, and actually cried when she died. She didn't deserve this!
She lived such a sad life with Brokenstar accusing her of killing kits. I guess that he didn't know that she was his dad, but its no excuse. When Yellowfang came to Thunderclan she was an outcast. She died to save for Bramblekit from the fire. She died to save the son of TIGERSTAR! You will live forever in the stars, Yellowfang. All the tears I cried for you are your amazing memories.
Soooooo sad! Her last moments were a confession to a cat who already knew! Oh yellowfang, you lived your life as best as you could - you did the right thing killing your son (why am I talking in 2nd person? haha) and with a mate like ragged star?! Pffft he's got nothing on you! You made the world more beautiful, you helped Fireheart, and gave cinderpelt her life back, your presence was missed in thunderClan, and in my life (as a reader).
This was SAD. Such a beautiful sacrifice, who cares that he's half clan! His last moments contained the purity of the warrior code, and the actions of a leader. I applaud you Stonefur, I was horrified at you death, but I hope you know, it was NOT in vain. Rest peacefully.
Stonefur, I LOVE you, but you're not one of my favorite characters. However, this death was so... Hold on, my house is currently flooding with my tears. Okay, where were we?
He knew that Tigerstar wouldn't let him win but he did it anyway, Leopardstar should of done something about it, she lost a great deputy that day.
He had such a sad death. Stupid tigerstar had to have someone kill him. It's partly leopardstar's fault, she joined tigerstar in tigerclan.
I was devastated, when I found out how Cinderpelt died. At least she was instantly recreated into Cinderheart. But still. I feel terrible for Leafpool. She's gone through so much already. Cinderpelt, and all of the other medicine cats that have died or are still alive are the best cats I could name. She died so young, and I HATE badger's. They deserve to eat death berries, for what they've done the Cinderpelt, and how they badly injured all the other cats. Curse you badger's. Badger's are a piece of crowfood to me. -Whiteleaf-
This was so sad, she had so much unfinished business...I cried. Why did she have to die so early? Leafpool needed her, she spends every second thinking about how much she wants to apologize to her, and making sure cinder heart has the life she deserves. Firestar needs her, he was so sad when she died and yellowfang needs her, you could tell she was struggling when it came time to handle cinderheart...I was glad when she sepperated from cinderheart and is able to reconnect with yellowfamg and later on Leafpool,
Run free cinderpelt, live the life you've always wanted, and that you deserve!
Cinderpelt just had a crazy life. This makes me hate Tigerstar even more. She got crippled by a monster that was supposed to be a trap for Bluestar. She dreamed of becoming a warrior and had to become a medicine cat. Then Yellowfang died from a fire in their camp. Cinderpelt had to tell Fireheart, her crush, that another cat liked him. She could never have kits and she knew how she was going to die. SO SAD.
Hello, I am only on the 1st book and I did some research about Cinderpelt. When I found out what her life was like, I burst into tears. Falling in love, but can't be with him. Wants to be a rebellious warrior, but gets injured by a monster. Man, do I hate TIGERSTAR. Tells her crush another she cat likes him. Dies. DIES. I want to hate the author for doing that. But, at least she was reincarnated!
She had just given birth to her kit! Snowfur, I admit, should of maybe been a little more careful though, but this death took me by surprise! I was so sad!
Snow's death was honestly so sad. She just wanted to get out and stretch her legs and she got hit by a monster! Poor Snow! She even had a kit back at camp, a young one at that!-Fallen from before StarClan
It was the saddest death for me. And it caused so much too. Snowfur died so:
Thistleclaw turned violent.
So Tigerstar turned evil.
So Tigerstar went to the dark forest.
So Hawkfrost went to the dark forest and Brambleclaw was born.
So Ivypool went to train in the dark forest.
So the clans learnt about the great battle.
Now, I may be wrong about some of that I'm a little rusty but you get my point.
Snowfur does help Mosskit, but I honestly wish she was back since Bluestar would do better with her living. Also she would be a great Thunderclan deputy
Swiftpaw. Oh, Swiftpaw. I know he was supposed to have his warrior name by now, but Bluestar, I'm sorry to say this, but Bluestar, no matter what you need to give an apprentice his warrior name when they are ready no matter what. If not, this might happen. You try to prove yourself to become a warrior, and die. I'm sorry. I wish I could have gone with him to heal him back to health. He died fighting, which is one of the most saddest and bravest thing to die of. Especially to dogs. Dogs the worst. -Whiteleaf-
I've loved Swiftpaw since he was first apprenticed in Fire and Ice. So what he was a bit of a jerk to Firefart? No one cares about that dumb Gary Stu anyways. Swiftpaw DIED for his best friend. I don't care that he was disobeying his leader, he did it for a good reason, and I entirely blame Bluestar for his death and Brightheart's injuries. I just love him so much! He's arrogant and rebellious towards his leader and enemies, but he's kind, gentle, and caring towards his friends. I felt so bad when Cloudtail was made a warrior before him! Cloudtail SUCKS! I love Swiftpaw, and I hardcore ship him with Brightheart. R.I.P my beautiful baby Swiftpaw. -FierceheartOfThunderClan
Swiftpaw did not deserve to die. I think Erin was just too lazy to make him a warrior. I think he would have made an excellent warrior and his name would have been Swiftleap. Why did you kill him? Come on.
Don't get me started with swiftpaw, I blame his death on bluestar for not letting him become a warrior, I begged for him to show signs in starclan to firestar.
I started crying when she died. It was so unexpected and tragic, and poor Berrynose grieved her so much after. I'm not saying her death was worthless though, because she did save Briarlight. Even though she was later crippled... She and Berrynose would have been such a great pair and Honeyfern had a great influence on him. (He was a little arrogant, hence the suffix; nose.) She had such a beautiful name too. We will miss you Honeyfern!
Honestly, how much of a pointless death was this? Not saying that Honeyfern is bad, but this death was really unfortunate, poor Honeyfern... I wasn't a fan of hers, but she deserved so much better rather than getting killed off just for Hollyleaf to fed Leafpool the deathberries. A pretty poor excuse for an innocent character. Even worse by dying when she was pregnant, that's way worse to think about. Pretty much that's the only time I really felt sympathy for Berrynose; before he went with Poppyfrost, to which I don't really like them much. It's not them being as a couple, it's just how fast Berrynose moved on with somebody else. At least with Graystripe and Millie they had the time together to think about things, Berrynose seemed like he just moved on for the sake of her sister... I guess Berrynose loved Poppyfrost more but, eh, It could've had some moments like Graystripe and Millie did in the manga series.
I sat, sunning myself against Berrytail. I could not believe my luck! He loved me back! And I was a warrior! I could not wait for duties to begin. Ooh and maybe me and Berrytail could have kits! What a great thought! Ahh yes I could imagine them. I watched Millie's kits playing across the clearing. Maybe she could give us some tips? Aww they were so cute! I could see Briarkit playing next to the rocks. Wait a second what was that behind her?! I jumped to my paws in an instant, racing across towards the tiny kit. Berrytail jumped up behind me, but, slower, confused at my sudden start. The snake was already arched up behind the unaware kit mouth open, poison ready. No! I jumped , knocking the kit away. I heard Berrytail's cries from behind me but it was to late now. I said a silent goodbye to my wonderful mate as I watched the snake's mouth come flying towards me. Everything went black as the venom entered my system.
Addisyn00 you got the story a little wrong no hate (I literally just read her death last night)
Honeyfern was on the basking rocks with her mate (they were basically mates) Berrynose and Lionblaze. She saw a snake slithering up to Briarkit, and jumped forward to push Briarkit out of the way just in time, but not fast enough to save herself. The snake bit her on the shoulder, and she died in pain with all her family watching.
I think this death was SO SAD! Honeyfern was so young, and she sacrificed herself. And what really made it even sadder was Honeyfern shouting, "Help! Help me, please! My blood is on fire! "
I mean come on WHY FERNCLOUD. She was the best. Her death was really sad I cried. She left Dustpelt and all of her kits. And half of her kits died which was really sad. The sweets part was that Dustpelt took a piece of her bedding and put in his nest so he can have her scent with him.
She was such a kind mother and she had a good influence on Dustpelt; they were so sweet together! I was both shocked and sad when Brokenstar killed her. She lost Hollykit and Larchkit on the journey too... Other than that, and a few other things, she had a pretty great life; that didn't make me any less sad to see her die though. :(
Stupid Brokenstar. He stayed behind after the Dark Forest Battle in the Last Hope was over and grabbed Ferncloud (sweet, gentle Ferncloud) by the neck, snapping her neck and killing her. Yellowfang bit down into his own neck, killing him, because she was so mad her own son could do that. But Dustpelt and her full grown kits were crushed. May the heavens guide your spirit across the stars forever, Ferncloud. Rest. Your life's work is done.
She didn't live for longer than Sandstorm, Graystripe, Dustpelt, etc. Cats can have up to five litters a year, she only had three litters ever. Her death was so sad, she was protecting the kits! Brokenstar I hate you.
I cried so much when she died. I felt so bad for Bluestar and Snowfur. She shouldn't have gone to destroy the herbs, someone else should have. Goosefeather shouldn't have even told them about that part of the vision. It's kind of his fault.
-Snowfeather of RiverClan
I think that this is definitely goosefeathers fault he was the one who sent them to the windclan camp. she never deserved to die. she was basically killed by her brother. I never really cry that much but I cried whne snowfur and moonflower died. I was reading at night and I cried so much because bluestar swore not to lose anyone again but I kept thinking about snowfur and how she lost her even though that comes later in the book
Moonflower had such motherly love with Bluepaw(star) and Snowpaw(fur). I cried when she died because I knew that her kits would never see her again! The scene before the battle also made is 100% worse because it was sooo sweet. She was helping her kits go to sleep, and Bluepaw was thinking about how much she loved her!
I wonder how a medicine cat can't feel sorry for killing an innocent cat's mother. She was so young, so emotional, and Eagleheart didn't even look like he regret his actions! I get it, she was destroying the medicine supply, but really? The warrior code says you don't need to kill to be a good warrior. And he isn't even a warrior!
I just really don't like Eagleheart. He has the nerve to taunt the poor, young warrior at a gathering, too! Killing an innocent apprenyince's mother and not even feeling sorry. What a medicine cat he is.
Okay, Everyone who has read at least the first series of Warrior Cats should know how Whitestorm died. Bone, I want you gone forever, and to never be remembered. The one who killed Whitestorm. Whitestorm was a bit old, but he still had a job to do. He was wise, and a great warrior. I could have saved him, ya know. I'm a medicine cat, and I wish I could save every cat. -Whiteleaf-
One of the greatest deputy's ever and he had waited so long for it! But he was quite old and but still didn't deserve to die in battle!
Whitestorm was just the best. I loved him. Bones, the cat who killed him, death was kind of funny though. He got killed by a swarm of apprentices.
this cat was so nice and he respected Firestar without getting angry at him for being deputy. when Graystripe was like ''Firestar..'' and you didn't realize what he meant before Firestar screamed ''white storm, no!'' I cried and my mom thought someone wasn't nice or something. I wish I could bring back this cat.
It is always so sad to see kits mothers die. Especially when they are still apprentices. I didn't like Ashfur later on in the series but it was still really sad. Brindleface was a good mother to Cloudtail, Ashfur, and Ferncloud.
Brindleface was a great mother to Cloudtail, Ashfur, and Ferncloud! She cared for Cloudtail as his own mother would have an even though he became very evil, it was so sad to see Ashfur so heartbroken after his mother's death... These are the things that get to me; when a mother with kits get killed and the kit(s) are left confused and stricken. So sad...
She was a caring mother. She raised Cloudtail, Ashfur, and Ferncloud. She was in camp as cats went to go investigate the dogs lurking at Snakerocks. Tigerstar killed her as bait for the dogs so they'd like the taste of cat blood, but the warriors hauled her body away before anything happened.
Brindleface was a great mother. Her children had to have her die when they were only apprentices! That was so sad. I almost cried when I read that Cloudtail found her dead. Stupid Tigerclaw/star! I hate him! Brindleface had done nothing to deserve what she got from him.
I didn't really know who Willobreeze was until I read Crookedstar's Promise. I mean she got stolen from her home by Windclan, THEN got stolen back from Riverclan. Then she died after having her kits. Also two of her kits died with her.
I feel so bad for Willow! Poor girl was taken from RiverClan, and then taken back TO RiverClan when she just then got comfortable with WindClan! And then she died a day after birthing her kits?! So much pain...-Fallen from before StarClan
Okay, when Firestar died, I admit, I cried. But when I read Crookedstar's Promise, I was BAWLING my eyes out when she wanted to name the kits and she was telling Crookedstar to be brave. And I cried even more when he confronted Mapleshade. Then, at the end of the book where he gets into a fight with Oakheart, it ends with him telling his only surviving kit that he's her father. I'm still pretty upset that she died too after kitting Graystripe's kits.
I rarely cry when warrior cat die but I did when Willowbreeze did. The author makes everyone die but Willowbreeze (and Crookedstar) didn't deserve it.
Is it just me or does anyone else think cats can have phobias? If so, FlameTail woul have aquaphobia (Fear of drowning) His death would be like this from his point of view.
He was plunged into dark, freezing water. It burnt his lungs as he swallowed mouthful to mouthful. He could hear muffled shrieks coming from the surface, as a shape leaped into the water after him.
JayFeather. But something was different. Instead of his eyes glazed with light, frosty blue, they were like normal eyes. And he could SEE him. But... Isn't JayFeather blind? Then, a hairless cat appeared beside JayFeather.
"It's not your time. Leave him." the cat said.
Then the world turned black.
OMG, I had nightmare from this death. He was trapped under the ice, and he was lead out on to the ice from by his sister. He should always be a part of shadowclan's memory, and never have to fear water again.
Okay, this was definitely the scariest death in this list. I really felt sorry for Jayfeather having to know he was drowning and not being able to do anything about it. Also tied between Cinderpelt and Swiftpaw. Swiftpaw's was so scary but imagine being trapped under ice in the frezeing water, struggling under the current with only a blind medicine cat there to save you. Awful death. RIP Flametail
This is what happens when you head onto the ice. Dawnpelt blamed Jayfeather for this but Jayfeather was sad because he could not save Flametail! Awww
Longtail might of not welcomed Fireheart but he is still really awesome. He also kind of had a sad life. First his only "friends" betrayed him. Then he blind by a dumb rabbit. Last of all he got killed by a TREE.
I am totally blaming Mousefur for that. Stupid old coot. It's her fault he died. His death is the only time I ever cried over a book and I am still not over it. He was my favorite of all books of all fandoms. Also I love his personality and humor a lot. He was brave enough to stand up to Tigerclaw and saved a kitten from an owl. If he hadn't been there the Clan would have been eaten by the dogs. He went through the mountains being blind. A tree shouldn't have ended that.
Ugh. I hate how un noticed Longtail's death went. He is an amazing cat! He was arrogant and rude but he changed! Which is the best part about him. I personally think Longtail is one of the most relatable warrior cat characters- ever. His death was COMPLETELY shadowed by Briarlight's injury. I mean come on people. At least she LIVED, even though she's a big Mary Sue. Poor Longtail. I was so sad when he died.
Longtail is really an underrated character. His two best "friends" betrayed him. His apprentice died of dogs (TIGERSTAR I'm LOOKING AT YOU). And he became blind for good bc of a STUPID RABBIT. He also died because of Mousefur even though they liked each other. I think Longtail has an awesome role in the Warrior Cats series. Also for people reading this you might wanna check out the Longtail MAP. It's really good.
-FerretTail of RC
Lionheart was one of my favorites characters when book 1 started. I was so excited to see how his life would play out, how he would be there when his kits were apprentices. But then, he was killed. This poor man didn't even get to see his kits made apprentices. Cinderpelt and Brackenfur were even made apprentices early! Man I hate the old ShadowClan, they killed both Lionheart and Spottedleaf in cold blood and then tried to steal Frostfur and Lionheart's kits! Lionheart will forever be remembered as a great deputy.-Fallen from before StarClan
When lionheart died I was in such a state. He was such a good deputy. I blame tigerstar for helping shadow clan come to thunderclan.
Such a loveable and courageous character, and so loyal to his clan. There should be more cats like him. I was so sad when he died.
Lionheart was my favourite character from the start. His death made me, along with greystripe, completely and utterly depressed. Why couldn't have bluestar died, Lionheart become leader and let him have a nice, peaceful death, leaving the clan to fireheart and being even better than he already was. He'll stay in my heart forever. Also, when I started power of three, I thought, after the cinderpaw thing, maybe lionblaze could be a reincarnation of Lionheart. Sadly not. -Wildheart
where do I start? this is just an amazing cat who did everything he could to make sure his clan was safe. even tho sandgorse wasn't nice to him, he still grieved and promised to avenge him even tho there was nothing to avenge. he blamed himself fo everything and I felt so bad for him when he sat alone and reena said that the reason sparrow had more friends than him was because sparrow was ''a good cat unlike him''. if I could, I would've slapped her in the face like will smith.
Tallstar was the best leader ever in my opinion. At first, I wasn't sad, but when I read tallstar's revenge, I thought differently. Especially with the whole jake thing. He didn't even get to be in starclan with Jake, and colour only make the journey there with him. Very sad death, but not as sad as lionheart's death, I'd say drawn at second with yellowfang
Tallstar was such a great warrior, learning from his mistakes and fixing them the best he could. When he died...for me, not even Firestar's death could beat his. The fact that Tallstar was sick and old was enough to make me cry because I knew that the Erins would kill him off. I was so mad that Mudclaw was acting like he was already dead, I was about ready to (if I could) stomp over to the writer's area and go 'CAN YOU KILL THIS GUY YET'! Tallstar was the best cat ever (in my opinion), and with his last breath, he did the right thing...what he always tried to do.
Noble Tallstar and his peaceful leadership. He was leader for long, and I didn't expect him to end it as soon as they got to the lake! He didn't even get to see his clan's new home. I agreed with Barkface, when Onewhisker and Mudclaw were fighting over leadership. When Mudclaw and Hawkfrost attacked Onewhisker and Windclan, I wondered how Tallstar felt, watching a decision he made almost destroy his clan he lead and fought for so long to protect.
Just look at the picture. When he tells Flintfang what a good mentor he is and how he wants to be named after him I start wailing. STUPID, DAMNING, *insert swear word here* BROKENSTAR! I wish that Badgerfang got the same opportunity as the other cats to live longer asn be an apprentice at six moons like *voice breaking and tears start* everyone else. *Starts wailing* *screams out the window* BADGERFANG!
Yellowfang's Secret - Yellowfang's Secret
He was braver than Brokenstar ever gave him credit for. He fought so hard, at such a young age. All he wanted was for his mother & leader to be proud of him. When he died, he just wanted Flintfang to know how great of a mentor he was. I love him so much.
RIP Badgerfang. Rejoice with your mentor & parents in the stars. We still love you.
I saw Badgerpaw up there but I had to find Badgerfang because he is warrior, no matter how young. He didn't deserve to die. When I read that part in the book I just like gasped. He was much to young to go. He was a Warrior, and a good one at that.
I was so sad when I read The Smallest Warrior in code of the clans. Reading Badgerfang say he hoped brokenstar and his mom were proud of him made me start to cry. It was to much reading the whole thing.
I Hate you Brokenstar!
I really wish she chose gray wing. he liked her for who she was, but clear sky only liked her because of her look. when clear sky disowned thunder I felt an urge to just pick him up and tell him that if he wasn't a good father for him, I would slap him to StarClan. ahh nvm he didn't know what StarClan was yet. but storm is just so nice and deserved better than clear sky.
I really loved Storm. She was so kind to Gray Wing. I was actually kind of sad that she fell in love with Clear Sky. It was Clear Sky's fault that she died. He drove her away and THEN rejected his own kit.
Storm was a great cat. She was beautiful, brave, and clever. I was disappointed when she chose Clearsky over Graywing, but...
It was so horrible and sad when she and her two (I think two) kits got crushed in the debris. And then poor Thunder was left motherless, and then if it couldn't get any worse, rejected by his father! Poor Storm...
Storm was really nice, and I don't think that she should have chose Clear Sky over Gray Wing. Then again, Gray Wing wouldn't have missed Turtle Tail as much if they both had become mates. But still, she should have lived longer and watch Thunder grow up into the great leader of ThunderClan!
I have two reasons for this.
#1: Brokenstar should've lived for WAY LONGER. Can you imagine how iconic it would've been for Tigerstar to serve as a deputy beside Brokenstar, then there'd be an actually long fight when Tigerstar tried to kill him.
#2: Yellowfang went through life-long trauma after poisoning Brokenstar, her own son! Brokenstar didn't even know that until his last moments of his life. Everything I'd read just collapsed infront of my eyes when I read this, and I actually cried.
I hate brokenstar but I voted him because of how he died. Like wouldn't it be kind of sad if your mother poisoned you? and he didn't even believe Yellowfang was his mother so it is not that sad.
I don't like brokenstar, dear goodness NO, but his death was tragic. Not tragic in the way that he as a character died, but tragic in the concept that yellow can't poisoned her own son for the good of the clan. That was really sad.
Fun fact: Brokenstar is higher than Badgerfang here because everyone is "What?!?!? He was evil" or "His mother killed him!1!1! Bad bad Yellow fang!1!1". Half of my friends do that. I know, he was abused and stuff, but can anyone remember Crookedstar? Don't vote here.