Top 10 Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths

I CRIED, Bluestar was an amazing leader
her last words
"Fire can save the Clan... You never understood, did you? Not even when I gave you your apprentice name, Firepaw. And I doubted it myself when fire raged through our camp. Yet I see the truth now. Fireheart, you are the fire to save ThunderClan. You will be a great leader. One of the greatest the forest has ever known. You would have the warmth of fire to protect the Clan and the fierceness to defend it. You will be Firestar, the light of ThunderClan."
-Bluestar-
goodbye Bluestar, my favorite leader...

It's so sad how BlueStar does she's been through the hardest things first her mother dying second her sister dying and her child dying,TigerClaw her deputy turned and friend to kill her it's rough. And I also love her character development she's kind ,loyal brave and all the best quality I couldn't of thought of anyone better to be the leader

Bluestar was one of my favourite cats. She was so kind and so brave. Her death is just one of the saddest deaths. I slammed the book shut and vried. Bluestar was heartbroken when she found out that Tigerstar tried to kill her. She tought no one in her clan was loyal. WHen the clan ran to hide form the dog pack Bluestar felt guilty and ran to svae Firestar. She jumped into the side og the pack leader nad both her and the dog fell down in the gorge.

"You will have the warmth of fire to protect the Clan and the fierceness to defend it. You will be Firestar, the light of ThunderClan."
-Bluestar_

"Fire can save the Clan... You never understood, did you? Not even when I gave you your apprentice name, Firepaw. And I doubted it myself, when fire raged through our camp. Yet I see the truth now. Fireheart, you are the fire to save ThunderClan. You will be a great leader. One of the greatest the forest has ever known. You would have the warmth of fire to protect the Clan and the fierceness to defend it. You will be Firestar, the light of ThunderClan."

-Bluestar-

It's so annoying that the author decided to kill him! Like, why?! He did so many things for the clans and deserved to live so much longer. I was also mad that Bramblestar was the next leader. I just hate Bramblestar! He is a horrible leader compared to Firestar.

Firestar- We met him as Rusty. We followed him into the heart of the forest. Together, side-by-side, we learned the ways of the warrior code. We fought bravely to protect our clan. We stalked through the depths of the forest. We grew with him, we learned with him, we followed in his pawsteps. From Rusty, to Firepaw, to Fireheart, to Firestar- we became a Warrior through his eyes. The first stories, THE stories, the ones that made us who we are, the ones that gave us Warriors- they are his stories. To see him die is to watch our link die- to watch ourselves die. Rusty was, and still is, and always will be- part of ME. Part of YOU. Part of everything that is Warriors. Such a sad and noble death- may Firestar live forever in the hearts of young Warriors, his memory never fade, his soul forever hunt in Starclan.

Why did he have to die? I love this character and everything he did, he was the best cat in the entire series, Erin, why? How could you do this to everybody that loves and cares about Firestar/Rusty? And he shouldn't have died, it only took away one of his lives, and he is a lot like Bluestar (former leader of ThunderClan) And Tigerstar should die, I really don't like that he wounded Firestar, why did it have to kill him? Just why? Bramblestar is the not the best leader in the series, and why did so many good cats have to die? This was the saddest death of all of them.
1. He killed a villain
2. He was a hero
3. He did everything he could for the clan and he dies?
4. He was in the first book
5. He was very loyal to his clan
6. He was wounded by a evil spirit
7. A tree fell on him
8. He was a perfect leader
9. It was the saddest death
10. He was by far the best cat in the series
And this is why it was the saddest death of all, he was the best character ...more

Why? That was my first question. Erin, why? Firestar was, in my opinion, the best cat in the entire series. First, he led ThunderClan and the others clans against BloodClan, saved the forest, ya know, then he helped lead the clans on the journey to the lake, then he killed Tigerstar. And my insides are bursting with happiness as I read that bit, and then he dies. Like, what? Erin is getting lazy? Did she want ThunderClan to have a horrible leader? Bramblestar-I'm sorry- is a horrible leader. Like, come on. This was the saddest death for a reason. At least he died a hero.

It was so sad when that kind, gentle silver stream died! The reason why she died becuase something went wrong when she was giving birth. Well it was too much blood loss when she was giving birth. Her kits were feathertail and stormfur, also gray stripes kits.

Silver stream, you were beautiful and so amazing, I can't even say goodbye to you.. you are one of the saddest deaths ever..You will have an amazing place in star clan and the biggest place in my heart

Silverstream was always my favorite ever since she saved Graystripe(My favorite before Ss) and she had this sass that Fireheart and Graystripe couldn't get. That was before (sniffs up and cries) She died. Her kits were amazing and one of the two became a Prophecy, I mean that is sweet, but you know the Prophecy kit Feathertail was my favorite after that but... (Them tears are real) She died too. See this family was amazing, without these two she-cats Warriors wouldn't be the thing it is today, without the cats I'm talking about there would be no Tribe, there would be no Graystripe, there would be no... Well you get it, but I miss Silver all the same, she was truly an amazing cat. I hope her and Graystripe have fun in Starclan together.

I got really excited when I found out she was having kits in forest of secrets. But then I was practically drowning in tears when she died! She didn't deserve it at all! Her last words were telling Graystripe that she loved him. I cried so much! She was a very kind and beautiful cat, she broke the code, and that's all. Even though the Warrior Code tells you can't have a mate in a different clan, she didn't deserve to die! Couldn't she at least stay alive to raise her kits? I miss Silverstream a lot. So does Graystripe and a lot of other people and cats. Thumbs up if you agree with me. :(

She was such an amazing character that died by sacrificing her life heroically for IvypooL (who is equally amazing!). The scene after her death was so sweet, when she makes peace with her life and then finally goes to StarClan.

Hollyleaf
Leafpool's Wish - The Last Hope
She was smart, loyal & brave.
She trained harder than the other apprentices & cared for her family & Clan more than anyone could know.
She was more upset than ever when she realized her birth, her existence, was against the warrior code. That was when she fell apart. She killed Ashfur in an attempt to protect her brothers. She than attempted to kill her own mother. She then fled.
After some time in the tunnels, however, she regained her strength.
She fought hard in the Great Battle, & died saving Ivypool.
She forgave Leafpool & Squirrelflight when she died.
RIP, strong Hollyleaf. We still miss you so much.
Rejoice with your mother, grandparents, & mate in the stars.

Hollyleaf is my absolute favorite character! She has my kind of personality. Stubborn, short temper, and curious of whats going on around her. Her brother, Lionblaze, is like my brother. Stubborn, proud, and a show off! Since I have read Warriors, Hollyleaf has been my favorite character and is still today. I was sad when she died and would have loved if she was still alive today. At least she is with Fallen Leaves in Starclan. She is my absolute favorite character and will always be even though she will not appear again in the series. I will miss her and will always remember about her forever! She is my number 1 cat and will always be! FOREVER!

She was a wonderful character! She deserved to be Bramblestar's deputy it if wasn't for Hawkfrost. Plus, it's obvious Bramble was going to choose her if she lived. Besides, she showed the Warrior Code and StarClan more respect and was one of the most forgiving and loyal cats I have read about in the series. When she found out she was replaced, she didn't fuss like her replacement probably would've, she forgave her biological mother as well as her foster one, as well as both her fathers (Crow and Bramble) and tried to make amends even though there were big downs. She never gave up, and she came back. She did all of those things that I said above, as well as did EVERYTHING in her will and power to help. She trained cats in the tunnels and rescued them when they fell in. She even saved Ivypool from Hawkfrost, causing her undoing. She did all of those things, went through so much to return to ThunderClan to see her friends and family again...only to die a second time.

Mosskit, every picture I see of BlueStar standing next to Mosskit as she died or Mosskit death, I just tear. That kit was just innocent, she wasn't ment to be left in the snow, it was all BlueStar's fault! Why would a mother kill her own kit by leaving it in the snow! Mosskit was a purrfect kit.(get it?) She was the best kit to me, a pretty, cute and, you get it

We don't know much about Mosskit, but we know she died from frostbite or freezing to death. She was an innocent kit and just couldn't make it!
by the way Twitchtail and I guess Crystalpool, I don't want to be rude or anything, but when you say 'mother power' what do you friggin mean? It was freezing snow and Bluefur (Bluestar) had probably been walking for hours, carrying 3 kits. She didn't leave Mosskit on purpose with Oakheart, simply I see it that she didn't have enough energy and strength. She put her down and probably was buried in snow and Bluefur couldn't go back for her then. Also, I read on a wiki, she died from hypothermia. Yet I agree with Crystalpool, I think her warrior name could of been Mossheart or maybe Mossflick as a snowflake or something. Also, I love how she appeared at Bluestar's leader ceremony as somewhere she says: "I understand. But I miss you" She probably reunited with family in StarClan
-Witheredpaw

Moss kit, how do I even say my feelings for you? They are so much stronger than words I can even explain it, my feeling s for Moss Kit are something I can't even translate into English or any language

Twitchtail-
Poor Mosskit, the kit was left out in the snow to die because Bluestar wouldn't keep going...she should have mother power. The power to keep going for her kits. You know, the power the thunderclan Queens had to protect their kits in the last book of the fourth series

I love Feathertail! She helped Crowpaw and showed him the bright side. I hate how everyone cheered when she died (the tribe). Only Brook was sorrowful because she loved Stormfur. Feathertil is one great cat, rest in peace Feathertail :)

I'm so sorry you died. Al least you saved the Tribe. They were happy but later what did they do? NOTHING to honor her except a grave.

Feathertail, honestly why did you have to leave? She's one of my favorite characters, and she didn't deserve to die. When I first started the series, I already decided she was gonna be one of my favourites! Even though she sacrificed herself to save the tribe and Crowfeather (Crowpaw at the time), I still think it was a big loss. I slammed the book on the floor when I saw the part when she died, but for some reason I read it over and over again? I really think Crowfeather and Feathertail would of been a great couple. I also felt sad for Stormfur and Crowfeather. Even though Crowfeather has Leafpool (basically Nightcloud too) I think he still misses her everyday, and will never forget the horrifying moment when she crashed through the roof the cave and joined the ranks of StarClan. Stormfur probably misses her too, but brother love and a crush love is different. Now I can't go without repeating her last words to Crowfeather which were: "Think you have nine lives do you? I saved you ...more

I wish you didn't die, Feathertail! I'm happy you saved Crowfeather and the Tribe, though. The Tribe just celebrated after Sharptooth was gone. They didn't care for Feathertail! Only Brook was thoughtful because Feathertail was Stormfur's sister. I cried during her death, she was so kind and brave. Run free in StarClan, my dear friend. May StarClan light your path 🙂. - Featherbreeze, the Riverclan medicine cat

She is my favorite cat ever in this series and always would be. Think it this way- if it weren't for her, Firestar would have died. She has the personality I wish to gain. She has the soul of a true hero.

She was killed by an idiot and I don't care if Clawface was forced to do it, ooh I know what you could've done one, you should run away and never come back because he can't kill you if he cannot see/find you, or if you could ask "are you a madicine cat?" And then she could answer "yes" and like everyone knows medicine cats can go through other cat's territories and Ravensong, you are so correct! Mapleshade and Clawface are both stupid idiots and they should die (well, I know Clawface dies but does Mapleshade? I'm guessing yes) and she was young too, I wish someone had said "hey idiot don't you dare touch Spottedleaf or I will kill you and I will right now!" That would be awesome and then Spottedleaf gets to live at least another book, and if she doesn't I will go over there and start a vendetta (like the kind where someone from a murdered person's family goes and kills the murderer) And even though I'm not from her family I would gladly kill the murderers myself-Snowpaw the ...more

Spottedleaf is one of my favorite medicine cats. Stop saying she's too old for Firestar because it's actually not true! 6 moons till her apprentice ship, let's say one year of training, then about four moons of being a medicine cat since the books states she's young, Spottedleaf was just around two years old while Firestar was six moons old! They only have 1 year and 4 moons between them. SO stop saying she's too old for him, cause she's not. That being said, Spottedleaf was one of the most caring, gentle, and selfless cats ever. She died saving Sandstorm because she didn't want Firestar to be sad...I can't even begin to imagine how much she loved him!

Why do people hate Spottedleaf? She's not a bloody Mary Sue! Here are her flaws: 1. Died young (which is not her fault), 2 Irritated easily. 2 flaws! She's not a Mary Sue! Her life was so unfair, she became a medicine cat so Thistleclaw wouldn't turn her into a stupid demon (points to Mapleshade). Mapleshade is a stupid idiot. Both Spottedleaf's deaths were sad, and Clawface and Mapleshade are stupid idiots. Mapleshade is overrated, while poor sweet Spottedleaf is so underrated! Goodbye, Spottedleaf. We'll miss you... or at least the good people who understand Warriors will...
-Ravensong

Yellowfang. Honestly, I don't know who is more sadder than her death. Yellowfang had her heart torn inbetween the Clans and her own son. But, that story is for a different. Me, I'm thinking Yellowfang should have died a more hero death, but this is what the book tells us. Yellowfang died of smoke annihilation, and she was left there until Fireheart found her. Even her last words will make me cry. She said to Fireheart, "I wish you'd been my son, but I could not have borne a cat like you." Rest in peace Yellowfang. You deserve it. The grumpy, impatiant, cranky elder, and also, the most loyal cat you could meet was dead. Yellowfang. -Creekglade (Limpcreek)

I agree with Creekglade and heaps of other people. I can't explain how dreadful her death was. She is one of my favourite characters too, so it didn't help. Although she's a bit snappy and impatient, I like that about her! And it sure isn't a bad thing. When I was reading, my heart was racing and I didn't know what was gonna happen next. I thought she was dead when Fireheart had got every cat away from the fire, but as everyone knows Fireheart, he was going back to save her no matter what. She played a big role in Fireheart's life. And her last words were... strong.
"I wish you'd been my son, but I could not of borne a cat like you" I felt like crying. You can normally tell irl when someone means what they say, but Yellowfang meant them. She did care for Fireheart like her son. She had such a bad past, not just having to live in ShadowClan but Raggedstar died and everyone thought she stole kits and was a murderer and a traitor. She was misunderstood, but after she met Fireheart her ...more

It was her time, but I wished she could've stayed with us much longer. She was truly the best med cat, so wise and even though she was bad-tempered, she was truly a good cat.

Why is Yellowfang's death #8? It was so sad and sudden when the forest fire happened and Yellowfang was trapped in the camp. She also had such a sad life and she did not deserve to die especially because of how bad everybody treated her. Sure, she is a bit bossy and all, but that just makes it more sad and tragic when she dies. Now Silverstream, seriously? Sure it was kind of sad but we only knew her for 2 books and we knew Yellowfang for much more. When you think about it, Yellowfang also served aa very important role, she became the next medicine cat of thunder clan when Spottedleaf did not have an apprentice. But Silverstream or Feathertail, or Hollyleaf, or Spottedleaf all were put into the story to add a little more entertainment, some of them did not succeed though. There is just too much forbidden love, but Yellowfang accepted it, but nobody else did. I do not want to put any unnecessary hate in anybody's favorite character, but I got to say it's hard not to hate them. So I ...more

Now Stonefur isn't my favorite character but his death was harsh. He did a good thing protecting Featherpaw and Stormpaw, it was brave. But did he think was gonna happen? He was right in front of the treacherous Tigerstar and dumb Leopardstar. Even though Blackfoot/Blackstar killed him, it was an order from the leaders. I forgive Blackfoot because he regretted everything bad he had done. But still, if he hadn't protected the apprentices, both of them would of died or one of them.
-Witheredpaw

Have you guys ever thought of it this way. Without Stonefur, the clans wouldn't exist. He saved featherpaw and stormpaw and featherpaw was a prophecy cat and died for the tribe and in dawn of the clans you can see that the tribe becomes the clans so if feathertail had died earlier, then the tribe wouldn't exist and the clans wouldn't exist

Stonefur did a very brave thing. He protected apprentices and he sacrificed himself so Stormpaw and Featherpaw would survive. I do like Blackstar but I will never forgive him for killing Stonefur. Rip Stonefur you brave soul.

NOOO! I slammed the book shut when he died ngl. He is my 2nd favorite cat! His death showed so much courage, love, bravery and nobleness. I think I would've been terrified but he held his head high. And the fact that he was nearly starved and wounded and STILL managed to fight Darktail off was epic. I was furious at Blackstar/foot when he came in and killed him. (I forgave him over time though) at least he saved his sister and the apps. R.I.p Stonefur we love you!

Swiftpaw had a sudden death, and along came bright hearts bad injuries, but at least bright heart survived. Sadly, Swiftpaw died. He was just about to become a warrior which is super sad because he just ventured out to snake rocks (if I remember correctly) and got killed brutally by some dogs that got loose as we know because of the prologue. I think that he should've got his warrior name about the day before and at least he'd die bravely with a warrior name, and which I were to name him, he'd be Swiftheart. Also, random fact, it's funny he got mentored bu long tail, for long tail is also his half brother.

Not true about Bluestar! It was not her fault at all! I understand she was going through depression, but it doesn't mean you can blame it on her! So Stonefur4ever, you should just shut up. It was Swiftpaw s fault. He's the one who had the idea, and brightheart wouldn't have lost half of her face! So shut up!

SPOILERS!

Poor, poor swiftpaw! Here is a list on why his death was awfully depressing!

1. He was so younger he had a bright future ahead of him!

2. He died trying to PROVE he could be a warrior but never got the chance to be one!

3. I shipped BrightxSwift! They would have been cute! - I still love CloudxBright tho!

4. He would have made an amazing warrior!

5. He died because of Bluestars stupid mental issues!

Poor swiftpaw. All he wanted was to be a warrior and serve his clan. I was a lil vexed that he drug Brightheart into it but oh well. Bluestar made tOO MANY stupid decisions when she was sick-minded or whatever she was. I wish she said sorry to everyone she hurt during it.

That's so sad, she died at a young age and she did it to save her sister and she wouldn't have just left her with the adder, and she got bitten herself. I would have tried to run away after I saved my sister and she was only a kit, that's so sad and her siblings, they must be really sad at the loss of they're sister and if they don't care I hate them because she was only a poor kit that wanted to save her sister, and who put the adder there? Or did it just come out of no where? And she was only a kit (I'm sorry that I keep repeating this but its too shocking) and she was too young to know what to do and in the end she gave up her life for she knew it was right-Snowpaw the ThunderClan apprentice

I felt so sad when she died! then I felt angry at Berrynose. I felt so bad for him right when Honeyfern died, but then he disappeared from the scene and when you next see him he's totally over it, its like he doesn't even remember her!

Its just so sad that honeyfern didn't get a chance to mate with berrynose ad have kits of their own and her mother and father (sorreltail and brackenfur) only had two daughters left!

Honestly, how much of a pointless death was this? Not saying that Honeyfern is bad, but this death was really unfortunate, poor Honeyfern... I wasn't a fan of hers, but she deserved so much better rather than getting killed off just for Hollyleaf to fed Leafpool the deathberries. A pretty poor excuse for an innocent character. Even worse by dying when she was pregnant, that's way worse to think about. Pretty much that's the only time I really felt sympathy for Berrynose; before he went with Poppyfrost, to which I don't really like them much. It's not them being as a couple, it's just how fast Berrynose moved on with somebody else. At least with Graystripe and Millie they had the time together to think about things, Berrynose seemed like he just moved on for the sake of her sister... I guess Berrynose loved Poppyfrost more but, eh, It could've had some moments like Graystripe and Millie did in the manga series.

May be long- And SPOILERS!

why...
Why...
WHY!
She was such a warm-hearted, lovely She-cat and went through so much. I mean her former mentor Went evil (Darkstripe), her brother went evil, several of her kits died...I mean her life wasn't easy! And yet she kept going and for the kits that lived she loved so much. And I just hate it when people get angry and hateful at her because she had a decent amount of kits...but seriously?! How many kits lived?! And just cause she had a lot - a lot of kits Dosen't mean she didn't still help her clan! I mean a clan DOES need kits anyhow. But anyways...I nearly cried when Dustpelt put some of her fur (or was it her nest? Can Never remember! Lol) in his nest so he could still smell her even though she was gone.

Stupid Brokenstar. He stayed behind after the Dark Forest Battle in the Last Hope was over and grabbed Ferncloud (sweet, gentle Ferncloud) by the neck, snapping her neck and killing her. Yellowfang bit down into his own neck, killing him, because she was so mad her own son could do that. But Dustpelt and her full grown kits were crushed. May the heavens guide your spirit across the stars forever, Ferncloud. Rest. Your life's work is done.

Okay first of all, Ferncloud didn't have 'too many kits' she only had like three litters, you probably think that is a lot, and it kinda is, but her first litter, Shrewpaw died, second one lark-kit and hollykit died, and in the other one, later on in the books, icepaw(forgot what her warrior name became) and fox leap both died. I hate you Brokenstar! You are called because of your broken heart! I also love Yellowfang she killed Brokenstar twice for being a monster and killing Ferncloud! I really cried so much when Ferncloud died, she was one of my favorite characters...

I mean come on WHY FERNCLOUD. She was the best. Her death was really sad I cried. She left Dustpelt and all of her kits. And half of her kits died which was really sad. The sweets part was that Dustpelt took a piece of her bedding and put in his nest so he can have her scent with him.

Since Tigerstar's plan to kill Bluestar backfired and instead ended up with Cinderpaw(pelt) getting crippled, she had to end up as a medicine cat, which was against StarClan's 'destiny' for her, and because of that she had to die!? Her death was so sad, and then when StarClan made Cinderheart her reincarnation that just made so much unnecessary drama in The Forgotten Warrior. Cinderpelt was an amazing cat that's life was ruined and because of threat had to die one of warriors saddest deaths.

Cinderpelt was a medicine cat after Yellowfang, who died in a fire, but told firestar to save his own life. Cinderpelt was killed by a badger trying to defend Sorreltail and her own kits. I also feel terrible for leafpool, who has already been through so much, but then has this terrible thing happen to her which is Cinderpelt die, and then she becomes medicine cat.

I loved Cinderpelt so much because as an apprentice she was so curious and always got into trouble (Sometimes!) and she would have been a brilliant warrior. I love how Cinderheart gives Cinderpelt a chance to become a warrior.

I was devastated, when I found out how Cinderpelt died. At least she was instantly recreated into Cinderheart. But still. I feel terrible for Leafpool. She's gone through so much already. Cinderpelt, and all of the other medicine cats that have died or are still alive are the best cats I could name. She died so young, and I HATE badger's. They deserve to eat death berries, for what they've done the Cinderpelt, and how they badly injured all the other cats. Curse you badger's. Badger's are a piece of crowfood to me. -Whiteleaf-

I wonder how a medicine cat can't feel sorry for killing an innocent cat's mother. She was so young, so emotional, and Eagleheart didn't even look like he regret his actions! I get it, she was destroying the medicine supply, but really? The warrior code says you don't need to kill to be a good warrior. And he isn't even a warrior!

I just really don't like Eagleheart. He has the nerve to taunt the poor, young warrior at a gathering, too! Killing an innocent apprenyince's mother and not even feeling sorry. What a medicine cat he is.

Oh, how I hate Hawkheart! Moonflower was such an amazing shecat! Gentle, kind and caring.

First of all, Moonflower probably felt nervous about her kits going outside so early in their lives. But did she stop them? No! She wanted her kits to live life to the fullest, and experience the most they could! Secondly, she was brave and strong. Moonflower let her kits do things at their own will, and she fought against WindClan like a true warrior, to help protect her Clan and the cats she loved!

Bluepaw and Snowpaw should have never had to lose their mother so soon! I almost cried on my way home from school reading it. And then Bluefur lost Snowfur leaving just her and Whitekit. And then she had to give up her kits to become leader. I guess all this tragedy formed her into the strong noble leader she was but I believe she should have never lost Moonflower, not when she was so young it just breaks my heart at her reaction.

Can't relate. I never liked her, was sad for bluestar though :( but...the attack was unjustified! Hawkheart was just following orders! And I don't blame goosefeather- poor guy lives with constant T.M.I !

Willow breeze was amazing to see in the story and I guess they just had to die. Willow breeze was amazing and I loved them the most after Feather Tail

I was absolutely shocked when she died like I knew it was gonna happen but I didn't want it to happen that way. I felt super upset that two of her and Crookedstars kits got called at the ranks of star clan. I still grieve for her and their two kits who died

Okay, when Firestar died, I admit, I cried. But when I read Crookedstar's Promise, I was BAWLING my eyes out when she wanted to name the kits and she was telling Crookedstar to be brave. And I cried even more when he confronted Mapleshade. Then, at the end of the book where he gets into a fight with Oakheart, it ends with him telling his only surviving kit that he's her father. I'm still pretty upset that she died too after kitting Graystripe's kits.

I forgot about that death! SAD SAD SAD! Although this was sad, I think Mosskit's death was so so sad as well, because Bluestar already lost, like EVERYTHING, and right then was a really bad time, because she was giving up her other kits. But I can't believe had bad Crookedstar had it. Why is it always the great leaders who have horrible lives?

May be loooong-
Spoilers


Whitestorm...oh Whitestorm. You were such a loyal , noble cat. And his life wasn't easy either! I mean he lost his mother at an alarmingly young age, his father basically fathered Tigerstar instead of him and attempted to shove Bluestar away from him, and his aunt (like a mother) went cray cray and he couldn't do anything about it no matter how hard he tried. And when he went to battle Bloodclan, he knew very well he was to die. Because he knew Graystripe was ment or be deputy not him. Yet the fluffy white tom went anyhow and when he did he fought the life out of him. And he even told Firestar that Graystripe was ment to be deputy, which reassured Firestar and the rest of the clan. So I say this, as I try not to cry R.I.p Whitestorm, you shall be missed.

Twitchtail-
If I'm honest I'm not sure why Bluestar didn't make him Deputy as Whitestorm was probably way better at being leader than Firestar. I actually found it very depressing when he died because he was a beautiful tom. I guess he was getting old so the Erin's wanted to kill him off. It hit me hard when I read about Whitepaw (Whitewing) in the second series.

Okay, Everyone who has read at least the first series of Warrior Cats should know how Whitestorm died. Bone, I want you gone forever, and to never be remembered. The one who killed Whitestorm. Whitestorm was a bit old, but he still had a job to do. He was wise, and a great warrior. I could have saved him, ya know. I'm a medicine cat, and I wish I could save every cat. -Whiteleaf-

Poor Whitestorm! He was such a sweet cat. I hate Bone for killing him! He would have been a great leader, so much better than Bramblestar.

Brindleface was a very mother-like she-cat and she was super kind and friendly! Stupid murderous Tigerstar had to rock up and kill her, just so the dogs could get a taste of cat blood. I know this isn't about Tigerstar but how many friggin cats has he killed?
Runningwind, Redtail, Oakheart, Gorsepaw, Brindleface
He indirectly killed: Swiftpaw, Bluestar, and technically Graypool. What I'm tryna say is Brindleface didn't really desreve to die. Shes innocent!
-Witheredpaw

It is always so sad to see kits mothers die. Especially when they are still apprentices. I didn't like Ashfur later on in the series but it was still really sad. Brindleface was a good mother to Cloudtail, Ashfur, and Ferncloud.

She was a caring mother. She raised Cloudtail, Ashfur, and Ferncloud. She was in camp as cats went to go investigate the dogs lurking at Snakerocks. Tigerstar killed her as bait for the dogs so they'd like the taste of cat blood, but the warriors hauled her body away before anything happened.

Brindleface was such a sweet, wonderful character. She was always loving and understanding. Her death was very sad. She was part of Tigerstar's plan to destroy Thunderclan with the dog pack, which also led to Bluestar's death. Brindleface a was a great cat and she won't be forgotten.

He drowned when he fell through ice. I was very sad when he died I was so happy to have a ShadowClan cat that respected ThunderClan. I'm not saying that ShadowClan always mistreats ThunderClan. But then Flametail died and Jayfeather didn't save him my heart sunk. I just miss him so much

Twitchtail-
When Flametail died being trapped under the ice, it was definitely one of the the cruelest ways to die. It was really annoying that Rock told Jayfeather to let go. I always thought Flametail would have been a great medicine cat to shadowclan after Littlecloud because he had the proper Shadowclan attitude toward Thunderclan.

Is it just me or does anyone else think cats can have phobias? If so, FlameTail woul have aquaphobia (Fear of drowning) His death would be like this from his point of view.

He was plunged into dark, freezing water. It burnt his lungs as he swallowed mouthful to mouthful. He could hear muffled shrieks coming from the surface, as a shape leaped into the water after him.
JayFeather. But something was different. Instead of his eyes glazed with light, frosty blue, they were like normal eyes. And he could SEE him. But... Isn't JayFeather blind? Then, a hairless cat appeared beside JayFeather.
"It's not your time. Leave him." the cat said.
Then the world turned black.

Okay, this was definitely the scariest death in this list. I really felt sorry for Jayfeather having to know he was drowning and not being able to do anything about it. Also tied between Cinderpelt and Swiftpaw. Swiftpaw's was so scary but imagine being trapped under ice in the frezeing water, struggling under the current with only a blind medicine cat there to save you. Awful death. RIP Flametail

He was a great mentor and would have been a great deputy if only he had more time to shine. How dare they kill him. At least he died doing what he loved defending his clan.

Lionheart was one of my favorites characters when book 1 started. I was so excited to see how his life would play out, how he would be there when his kits were apprentices. But then, he was killed. This poor man didn't even get to see his kits made apprentices. Cinderpelt and Brackenfur were even made apprentices early! Man I hate the old ShadowClan, they killed both Lionheart and Spottedleaf in cold blood and then tried to steal Frostfur and Lionheart's kits! Lionheart will forever be remembered as a great deputy.-Fallen from before StarClan

I loved Lionheart from the very beginning. He was a patient, hardworking warrior and an amazing mentor to Graypaw. I was so happy when he became deputy, and I cried when he died.
—Elmfoot

Such a loveable and courageous character, and so loyal to his clan. There should be more cats like him. I was so sad when he died.

Just look at the picture. When he tells Flintfang what a good mentor he is and how he wants to be named after him I start wailing. STUPID, DAMNING, *insert swear word here* BROKENSTAR! I wish that Badgerfang got the same opportunity as the other cats to live longer asn be an apprentice at six moons like *voice breaking and tears start* everyone else. *Starts wailing* *screams out the window* BADGERFANG!

Badgerfang
Yellowfang's Secret - Yellowfang's Secret
He was braver than Brokenstar ever gave him credit for. He fought so hard, at such a young age. All he wanted was for his mother & leader to be proud of him. When he died, he just wanted Flintfang to know how great of a mentor he was. I love him so much.
RIP Badgerfang. Rejoice with your mentor & parents in the stars. We still love you.

I saw Badgerpaw up there but I had to find Badgerfang because he is warrior, no matter how young. He didn't deserve to die. When I read that part in the book I just like gasped. He was much to young to go. He was a Warrior, and a good one at that.

He was way to young, but he didn't argue or run, he stayed in that battle and he fought, but because of his age, he was to weak and he failed. As well as Yellowfang and Sorreltail, this cat should be reborn!

Why did Longtail died? I feel like instead of Brambleclaw (now Star) Firestar should have made him deputy! Longstar, leader of ThunderClan. Only if the dumb rabbit hadn't blinded him! I mean like, that's horrible Erin, HORRIBLE! Why couldn't Briarlight be the one who died, and Longtail be the one who survived? THIS SHOULD BE DEATH 1! That's all I have to say. (Bows, then runs of stage and starts crying)

I am totally blaming Mousefur for that. Stupid old coot. It's her fault he died. His death is the only time I ever cried over a book and I am still not over it. He was my favorite of all books of all fandoms. Also I love his personality and humor a lot. He was brave enough to stand up to Tigerclaw and saved a kitten from an owl. If he hadn't been there the Clan would have been eaten by the dogs. He went through the mountains being blind. A tree shouldn't have ended that.

Ugh. I hate how un noticed Longtail's death went. He is an amazing cat! He was arrogant and rude but he changed! Which is the best part about him. I personally think Longtail is one of the most relatable warrior cat characters- ever. His death was COMPLETELY shadowed by Briarlight's injury. I mean come on people. At least she LIVED, even though she's a big Mary Sue. Poor Longtail. I was so sad when he died.

Longtail might of not welcomed Fireheart but he is still really awesome. He also kind of had a sad life. First his only "friends" betrayed him. Then he blind by a dumb rabbit. Last of all he got killed by a TREE.

Storm had a very sad death, crushed by a building that was being torn down by some two-legs. Now that I've read this, it makes me feel so bad at what we've done, because we are the two-legs. Grey wing loved storm, but storms mate was clear sky. She went to live alone. While she went, she got pregnant and she gave birth in a building. Soon after her kist were born, the building they were living in was being torn down. Storm did not survive, and neither did two of her kits. Though one of her kits survived, and his name was thunder. Storms death was both sad for grey wing and clear sky.

It's so sad that storm was crushed under a building! And by a airplane!?!? Why did the wing have to crush her and her kits!? at least thunder survived to be thunderstar first leader of thunderclan

It's sad. She didn't have to die but dum Clear Sky stole her from poor Grey Wing (who is my favourite cat) and because he was horrible she went away then, died

I really wish she chose gray wing. he liked her for who she was, but clear sky only liked her because of her look. when clear sky disowned thunder I felt an urge to just pick him up and tell him that if he wasn't a good father for him, I would slap him to StarClan. ahh nvm he didn't know what StarClan was yet. but storm is just so nice and deserved better than clear sky.

I honestly love Yellowfang, and I would 100 percent if she hadn't chosen to give up her kits. I think, if Yellowfang has supported him and Wishkit and Hopekit had lived, he would be great. It's not his fault.

I have two reasons for this.
#1: Brokenstar should've lived for WAY LONGER. Can you imagine how iconic it would've been for Tigerstar to serve as a deputy beside Brokenstar, then there'd be an actually long fight when Tigerstar tried to kill him.
#2: Yellowfang went through life-long trauma after poisoning Brokenstar, her own son! Brokenstar didn't even know that until his last moments of his life. Everything I'd read just collapsed infront of my eyes when I read this, and I actually cried.

I hate brokenstar but I voted him because of how he died. Like wouldn't it be kind of sad if your mother poisoned you? and he didn't even believe Yellowfang was his mother so it is not that sad.

I don't like brokenstar, dear goodness NO, but his death was tragic. Not tragic in the way that he as a character died, but tragic in the concept that yellow can't poisoned her own son for the good of the clan. That was really sad.

Spoilers and may be lengthy-

I know we didn't get much info on him during the first book but we still saw how much he ment to the clan! As the clan was grief- stricken when they were informed of his death. And he was obviously a great mentor as Dustpaw was heartbroken when he heard his mentor had fallen. Bluestar showed her grief on his death mentioning how he was a great warrior and deputy. But luckily the Erin's gave us more! In Retails Debt we saw Retails side of the story! He had been manipulated by Tigerstar as had many others, but the noble Tortoiseshell tom managed to get past it and make his own decisions wiTHOUT Tigerstar. And when Tigerstar killed him REDTAIL BEGGED sunstar to let him go back and save Thunderclan from him. But when he was informed that Fire paw would he seems to accept it and even believe in the former kiTtyPet. And Redtail was honest enough to thank Firestar and even gave him a life.

At first, I thought what Ravenpaw said is not true. But then, after the treachery of Tigerclaw, I believed him. That's when I started to hate him more than any cat.

honestly I don't know what to write. I haven't read the super edition, but he seems like a nice and helpful cat to me. I wish I knew him better.

Redtail was one of the bravest warrior in the entire clan. I can't believe he died from a rock fall. One day he decided to go hunting. He went with Fireheart, Brambelpaw, Sandstorm, and Bluestar. He was just about to seek his teeth into a vole under a very rocky hill. Suddenly, a bolder stared to roll down the hill. Redtail turned to run but it was to late. He was squashed under the weight of the bolder. Fireheart, and Sandstorm came running. Bluestar couldn't believe what she saw when she finally got to Redtail. They went back to camp with Redtail's body. When Bluestar told the clan that Graystripe would be deputy next. The clan started to sit in vigil for Redtail. Graysripe was not to thrilled to be deputy. First of all he hadn't had an apprentice yet. The next day Bluestar told the clan that Graystripe would be the mentor of Cloudpaw. Redtail looked down from starclan. He was sad to see Graystripe was deputy. He knew Graystripe was not the right choice. Starclan sent a sign to ...more