Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths
Firestar's death may be the saddest, but Bluestar's is by far the most shocking and tragic of them all. It's so happy and sad at the same time when she reconciles with her kits and it's heart-warming to realize she wasn't crazy. I'm not usually emotionally, but I was so angry and shocked at this death I was about to yeet the book into the trash can. Bluestar is truly one of a kind and has likely made the most sacrifices of anyone in the series. She gave up her whole family life in order to protect her clan from cats like Thistleclaw and Tigerstar. Bluestar also went through being betrayed by one of her most trusted comrades. Bluestar is one of the toughest animals I've read about, physically and mentally. If anyone went through what Bluestar went through, they probably wouldn't be able to handle it and just end it all. Bluestar, may you live with eternal peace and happiness with your family and friends up in StarClan, we miss you.
I love Bluestar and I can't seem to find a OC that matches her. But I can say, that she was a brave and noble leader. Even tho she has had a lot of stress and heart break, in her final moments she realized that her Clan was in safe paws with Firestar, and always would be until HIS final moments. It took real courage for her to protect Fireheart from that dog, even tho he had broken her trust. She could have just left him there, but instead she sacrificed her own life to save his, because she finally realized that he truly was the fire that would save the Clan.
Bluestar's descent into grief-struck madness is one of the most frustrating but saddening things to read in this series. She was built to be a respectable and caring leader, and that all goes crashing down which only proves (funnily enough) Bluestar's humanity. Mistakes are what makes a character so interesting to read. Bluestar has flaws, but at the end of the day she gives her life to protect her clanmates. Saying goodbye to her kits one last time as a mother, and not as a leader, or a warrior. It's breathtaking.
Bluestar is my all-time favorite character. It broke my heart to read about her dying. Her last words made me burst into tears. It made me even sadder because she was depressed and didn’t deserve all of this. If Tigerstar never attempted to kill her, she would not be the depressed cat she is.
When I was reading his death, it broke my heart. He died for his clan, like the great leader before him, Bluestar. He was noble, mighty, and kind. Protecting his clan was instinct, and he sacrificed his LIFE for his clan. He wanted them to thrive, live. His death, and Bluestars' hit me the hardest. Like an actual blow to the stomach, or more theoretically, my mental emotions. He knew his clan would be okay. He fought for them, but it was time for him to go. He led his clan through many challenges and died for it facing one. I'd say that's as brave as you get. Erin Hunter made great progress in showing Firestar's personality and beliefs. StarClan made him great, they helped him, because no Warrior cat can get off without some sort of help. Even Tigerstar/caw needed Scourge, even though Scourge ended up killing Tigerstar/claw.
I mean, what else do you want me to say. This was the cat who started it all off. One of the most loveable, relatable, respected, and good-hearted characters I have ever had the pleasure to read about. When Firestar died, it was so tragic and depressing. We all knew it was going to happen, but when it did, we were all still shocked because Firestar seemed immortal. His arc from kittypet to clan leader is one of the best character arcs in Warriors and it's just so sad to see it end. Firestar is the true main character of the entire series and has affected so many people in the series and has affected us, the readers in many positive ways. Without Firestar, there is no Warriors, without Warriors, Erin Hunter is nothing. I know Firestar is fictional, but may he continue to live in peace and prosperity with his loved ones and clanmates up in StarClan. Firestar, you a legend, you have impacted me in so many ways, and you are my favorite character in the entire series, nothing will ever ...more
Honestly, if I start talking about Firestar I'm going to start crying. Please read the other comments and love Firestar. He is so beautiful and brave and I seriously can't even with Firestar haters. Every time I think about his death I feel like bawling my eyes out. He is, again, so beautiful and brave. I love Firestar with all my heart and he will always have a place in my heart. How is this not the first one? At least he is in StarClan with Bluestar and Whitestorm and etc. We love you Firestar, the brave warrior who is loved by people, but mostly ThunderClan. May StarClan light his path.
When Firestar died in The Last Hope I was so sad, (SPOILER ALERT) that he died from a tree, yet he killed Tigerstar. He started out as a kitty pet named Rusty, then he became a warrior, and eventually leader, without Firestar this series wouldn't exist.
Silverstream... I felt like crying when she died. I didn't get to know her too well but I still wanted to cry. She didn't deserve to die. Rest in peace Silverstream.
Her death is quite sad. She was never my favorite character, and I think other deaths were sadder, but it was still sad. SPOILER ALERT! Strangely enough, the saddest part of this book for me was when Graystripe left ThunderClan.
SILVERSTREAM WAS NEVER A BRAT. SHE AND FEATHERTAIL SHOULD HAVE DIED TOGETHER. SILVERSTREAM was beautiful, kind, and caring. She would have been an amazing mother. And poor, poor, poor Graystripe! SILVERSTREAM died, FEATHERTAIL died, and STORMFUR LEFT! Honestly, I just want Graystripe and Stormfur to die and live with Feathertail and Silverstream in the ranks of StarClan.
WHY SHE HAD TO DIE! Do you know what I noticed, a lot of the deaths in the series are young, beautiful female cats like Spottedleaf (twice), Feathertail, Silverstream and many other she-cats. I mean I wouldn't mind if Millie died a painful death and I wish Feathertail was spiked, and Silverstream died of blood loss, Spottedleaf was killed by Clawface than Mapleshade. I really wish Silverstream never died. Graystripe just ditched her and want for the @!? %# Millie. This is Erin Hunter "Oh maybe I should kill off Silverstream like I did with Spottedleaf so Graystripe doesn't have to choose between her and that piece of!? $@ Millie"
Feathertail, Feathertail, Feathertail. Sweet, sweet Feathertail. She was so loving to Crowpaw that she died for him selflessly! She was a hero to the Tribe of Rushing Water, to CrowFEATHER, and honestly to the four clans! If Sharptooth were still alive when the clans traveled to the lake territories, how many cats would Sharptooth have killed? And would Sharptooth have settled in the lake territories? Feathertail was too amazing. She was a true hero.
Feathertail was a beautiful selfless cat. She loved Crowfeather and didn't mind his grouchy nature, and she sacrificed herself for cats she had just met.
Only Feathertail could call Crowpaw a stupid furball...
May you hunt with StarClan,
May your walk hold pride.
May you curl up with your mother,
May your honor thrive.
May you shine your light on kits,
May you be happy among stars.
We loved you so,
And miss you too.
But a beacon of hope still shines,
A sign that we will be together soon...
Feathertail was one of the most heroic cats I've met. The Tribe really thought it was Stormfur. It must have been hard for Stormfur and Crowpaw/feather. I wish she never died. And when Stormfur broke the news to Graystripe, Graystripe said something along the lines of "she was the most like her mother." or something like that.
Spottedleaf shouldn't have died. Erin hunter was just like "Oh maybe I should kill off Spottedleaf so that Fireheart doesn't have to choose between her and that hunk of trash, Sandstorm!" I support Graystripe strongly for killing clawface.
How is this not the SADDEST death?Honestly, if I start talking about Spottedleaf I'm going to start crying. Please read the other comments and love Spottedleaf. She is so beautiful and brave and I seriously can't even with Spottedleaf haters. Every time I think about her death I feel like bawling my eyes out. She is, again, so beautiful and brave. How cruel is it to be a victim of all the hate, wait years and years for her love, then get killed twice!? I honestly hate quote "erin Hunter" but I love Spottedleaf with all my heart and she will always have a place in my heart. How is this not the first one? At least she is in StarClan with Firestar. We love you Spottedleaf, the brave medicine cat who is loved by people, but mostly ThunderClan. May StarClan light her path.
I literally don't know how to describe Spottedleaf's death! I mean it's so sad if I was Firestar... (Sorry I'm a hopeless romantic) Firestar loved her with all of his heart during his 9 lives, and Spottedleaf gave her own last life to save Sandstorm.
Her first death wasn't as sad, cause I didn't know her that well. However her death in Last Hope was so heart- breaking, that part where Firestar is crying over her fading body made my heart break and I started crying.
Mosskits death was sad, just sad, she was young, she barley even got to open her eyes! it was feezing cold and, I just wish she could have had a better life.
LMFAOOOOOOOOO someones talking about some rumor about them being apart of the royal italian unit. It was sad but.. I just CAn't with that comment. This is probably the character I would cry the LEAST about.
I think I cried more at Bluestars death because she was my favorite cat and I was so sad to see her die, but Id have to say this death was the saddest. Mostly because Mosskit was so young and it was all because of Thistleclaw! But most of all.. SHE didn't HAVE A COOL DEATH LIKE BLUESTAR! She just died in the cold! What kind of death is that? If she was old enough to talk, then she shouldve been able to pick herself up by her bootstraps and soldier through it! But there is more to her. After all she is my third favorite cat. There is a conspirisy behind her. Mosskit is somehow connected to the Royal Italian army infantry unit called the Binary Division from WW2!
this is what would happen:
Silvermoon pads over to Mosskit. "What's wrong? why are you down here little one? Here, I'll help you into top five saddest deaths." Mosskit mewls when Oakheart comes and helps her up. Silvermoon looks down to the haters of Mosskit and sticks her tongue out. "This is where she belongs!" Silvermoon hisses. "I bet Mosskit's warrior name will be Mossheart like his father." Silvermoon meows as the other cats in top five nod in agreement.
Hollyleaf is one of my favraite characters, I don't have a fave character. but her death... it just tore me apart, shredded me... she gave her very own life to save Ivypool, another one of my faves, I think she is brave loyal, anyhting that you can ask for. I think that Hollyleaf defintly deserved to end up in StarClan, who cares if she killed Ashfur, even when I figured it out, it changed NOTHING in my mind about her, she is still awesome. I also am defintly connected to the one thing, she shouldent have had to live such a long part of her life in dark, cold and lonely tunnels, although I do thank Fallen Leaves to be with her. I think Hollyleafs death was very sad, I felt very connected to her, she is very much like me.
From the very beginning, she was the most loyal cat you've ever met. Her life was 100% dedicated to the warrior code, her clan, and StarClan.
She suffered so much pain after learning the truth about her parents. She was lost and wandering in the dark tunnels until Fallen Leaves found her. When she finally came back, she found it difficult to be around everyone she'd left and stayed away from for so long.
She gave her life to save Ivypool, a clanmate she barely got to know. During her dying breaths, she forgave those that had lied to her about her forbidden bloodlines and sent out a last desperate plea for forgiveness. She deserved to live longer. She definitely earned her place in StarClan.
Hollyleaf is the most noble warriors cat you could ever meet, from the start she wanted to be accepted. she was torn apart when she found out about he real mother and father, so that made her more determined to be a better warrior. Hollyleaf was just misunderstood, I feel as if she should have lived longer, rip, hollyleaf
hollyleaf is one of my favourite characters, from the very beginning, Hollyleaf is the most noble warriors cat you ever met, she was fiercely loyal and protective of her Clanmates as well was the warrior code.
In my opinion, nothing, absolutely nothing can be as heart wrenching as Yellowfang's death. She had the saddest life ever: She trained as a warrior and had Raggedpelt as her mate but ended up in the path of a medicine cat because of some stupid connection she had with StarClan. She ended up having Raggedpelt's kits and only one kit survived. She named the kit Brokenkit after how she felt when she gave him away. The young kit was mistreated by his foster mother and foster brothers/sister. He ended up being of the most evil cats in the history of warriors, and killed his own father; Yellowfang's mate, so that he could be leader. Yellowfang was the only cat who even bothered standing up towards him, which later got her accused and exiled from the Clan she gave all of her loyalty to. She was eventually accepted into ThunderClan and trained her own apprentice there, but than killed his own blinded son in order to save the forest. I'll never forget what how she told Firestar that it will be ...more
Ok, remember when I said that Mossfall would have been Thunderclan’s best medicine cat? Yeah, no. YELLOWFANG, SPOTTEDLEAF, CINDERPELT, AND LEAFPOOL WERE ALL TO AWESOME! Yellowfang. An amazing mentor, medicine cat, and honestly, a loving mother. She would have been an amazing mother to her two kits that died. And what resilience would a cat need to have mercy, kindness, and love to Brokenstar? Sorry to all of the Brokenstar lovers, I liked him too. But my point is, I was almost in tears when Yellowfang died! That sadness and guilt when she confessed everything about Brokenstar to Fireheart! And I felt sooo bad for her when she was nervous if STARCLAN would accept her! Rest In Peace, Yellowfang.
I love the cranky, old she-cat characters! Yellowfang's death was something I knew would happen before I turned the page, but I wanted her to survive!
-For those who need to refresh on the death-
In one of the forest fires for ThunderClan's territory, an elder (Forgot their name, oops.) got trapped in camp, so Yellowfang ran in to get them. She got to the elder and had to run into her den with the elder. . .I think the smoke got to her lungs and she died.
Seastream padded over to Yellowfang*
Seastream: do not blame yourself Yellowfang, u were a great medicine cat.
Yellowfang: but I broken the Code and cursed the Clans with the birth of Brokenstar.
Seastream: I know. I too know what it is like, to have kits whose birth goes against the Code. But it should not change your thoughts about urself.
Yellowfang: I know its just... I can't stop blaming myself for it.
Seastream: u don't have to blame urself for it anymore. Brokenstar is gone now.
Yellowfang: he wouldn't have been here in the first place had it not been for me
Seastream pressed comforting against Yellowfang*
I loved how he spoke his heart and did not listen to leopardstar because he knew what was right. If he let them die instead of him then Stormfur would be with Brook and be happy instead he would be in starclan at a young age! And for feathertail she would've died anyway and sooner! Which would have been so sad. Even though I was sad stonefur died he is now in Starclan and will always be remembered as a great warrior!
He was so brave and noble! Like he gave his own life to save the apprentices and I'm pretty sure he would have beaten Darkstripe if Blackclaw hadn't jumped in
How is he NOT saddest?! I mean, he was killed for not killing his own apprentice! He had a choice! He could've lived, but he chose not to because he wouldn't do what wasn't right! He was all starved and stuff when he had to fight Darkstripe, but he STILL beat him up, so then NO NO NO, that wasn't the end, Tigerstar ordered Blackfoot to help kill him! And this was in front of everyone, even Leopardstar, and no one did anything! Firestar and Graystripe couldn't do anything, or else they would've been killed too! And with Blackfoot's help, they held him down and killed him! They cut open his throat in front everyone, including two skinny, scared apprentices! And no one even mourned his death, except that Leopardstar did quickly so no one would see, and Mistyfoot saw her dead brother and ran to mourn him while they were trying to get away! SAD!
I will always remember him-- as the greatest warrior of all time, and saving his apprentice. Without him, Stormfur and Feathertail would've never made the journey to the Sun-Drown-Place, and what would that bring? Stupid Leapordstar. I was crying
It's honestly so sad. Cinderpelt wanted to be and because of Tigerstar, she couldn't so she had to be a medicine cat. This also meant she couldn't mate. When she got in that argument with Leafpool, her whole life technically flashed before her eyes and she mentally broke down. It's even sadder since Leafpool and Cinderpelt were close and loved each other almost like family. Even worse, she knew she would die but was okay with it, that takes lots of courage. Cinderpelt's death was an integral part of Leafpool running away as well as coming back. Without Cinderpelt, most of the Warriors story would change. Any time a cat dies in the series it is tragic, but to lose someone as important and loved as Cinderpelt as just an extreme loss.
1. She hurt her leg and could not be a warrior
2. She became a medicine cat, but medicine cats aren’t allowed to have kits
3. She had a crush on a cat (Firestar) who had no idea she loved him. STUPID TOMS
4. Her apprentice lied to her and was keeping secrets
5. Her mentor died so soon after she found happiness.
6., Yellowfang was so hard on her
7. She was kidnapped by ShadowClan Warriors to train as apprentices when they were only three moons!
8. She was killed by badgers!
R.I.P Cinderpelt. May you hunt peacefully in StarClan and May your death be avenged
-Frostwhisker, ShadowClan medicine cat
Cinderpelt deserved to live. She couldn't become a warrior. She wasn't allowed to have kits. She had a crush on Firestar but he never relized it, AND she wasn't allowed to have a mate. Her mentor died so suddenly. Her apprentice was keeping secrets from her. After all she had been through, she was killed by a stupid badger.
I sat, trembling, watching as Sorreltail cried out. Around this nursery, screeches and cries could be heard as the rest of ThunderClan battled ferociously. Why of all times did she have to kit now? I watched the opening, ready to react if the badgers approached. But then, my eyes turned to Sorreltail as she let out another moan. In that instant, the badger had pushed through. I saw it make a beeline for Sorreltail who was unable to move. No! I could not let innocent kits be slaughtered by badgers. Without a moment to spare, I dived towards the badger, feeling its claws rake across my pelt. And then it all went black.
It was the saddest death for me. And it caused so much too. Snowfur died so:
Thistleclaw turned violent.
So Tigerstar turned evil.
So Tigerstar went to the dark forest.
So Hawkfrost went to the dark forest and Brambleclaw was born.
So Ivypool went to train in the dark forest.
So the clans learnt about the great battle.
Now, I may be wrong about some of that I’m a little rusty but you get my point.
When Snowfur got hit by a monster, I burst into tears, she didn't deserve to die, she as to young and had a kit named Whitekit, when Bluefur told Whitekit that Snowfur died, it broke my heart how Whitekit reacted.
It was one of the saddest deaths ever. When she died, it was so sad. It was painful to read about her getting run over by a monster. And of course it was frustrating because Thistleclaw blamed it on Bluefur.
Omg this was hands down THE saddest death in all of the extras. She was such a sweet cat who always looked at the bright side. When she died I cried for THE first time. RIP
I feel like Honeyfern shouldn't have died. At least she saved a helpless kit. Briarkit. Who was going to get bitten by a snake. Sometimes, I wonder what would have happened if it was Lionblaze instead of Honeyfern. Honeyfern would have survived., and Lionblaze's powers would have been revealed.
I sat, sunning myself against Berrytail. I could not believe my luck! He loved me back! And I was a warrior! I could not wait for duties to begin. Ooh and maybe me and Berrytail could have kits! What a great thought! Ahh yes I could imagine them. I watched Millie's kits playing across the clearing. Maybe she could give us some tips? Aww they were so cute! I could see Briarkit playing next to the rocks. Wait a second what was that behind her?! I jumped to my paws in an instant, racing across towards the tiny kit. Berrytail jumped up behind me, but, slower, confused at my sudden start. The snake was already arched up behind the unaware kit mouth open, poison ready. No! I jumped , knocking the kit away. I heard Berrytail's cries from behind me but it was to late now. I said a silent goodbye to my wonderful mate as I watched the snake's mouth come flying towards me. Everything went black as the venom entered my system.
Ok first I think we can all agree that Honeyfern is a hero. I mean, she gave her life away for a kit! She had always been so calm and gentile, and her heart was always in the right place. I think that Honeyfern's death is more sad then Firestar's becouse 1 she was just such a sweet cat, and 2 Firestar was a kittypet, and I won't ever be able to forget that. Once a kittypet always a kittypet. I wish Honeyfern a good life in Starclan and I hope that she will always find happiness. ( by the way it's Berrynose NOT Berrytail) (( the composer of a small opinion article about how Tigerstar is not evil is by Mountainbreeze)) (((and in a different opinion article about why Violetshine is my favorite cat I meant "why is she down here in 83 AND in 123")))
Honestly, how much of a pointless death was this? Not saying that Honeyfern is bad, but this death was really unfortunate, poor Honeyfern... I wasn't a fan of hers, but she deserved so much better rather than getting killed off just for Hollyleaf to fed Leafpool the deathberries. A pretty poor excuse for an innocent character. Even worse by dying when she was pregnant, that's way worse to think about. Pretty much that's the only time I really felt sympathy for Berrynose; before he went with Poppyfrost, to which I don't really like them much. It's not them being as a couple, it's just how fast Berrynose moved on with somebody else. At least with Graystripe and Millie they had the time together to think about things, Berrynose seemed like he just moved on for the sake of her sister... I guess Berrynose loved Poppyfrost more but, eh, It could've had some moments like Graystripe and Millie did in the manga series.
What makes Swiftpaw's death even sadder that his death have been avoided if Bluestar wasn't so stubborn and if Swiftpaw was thinking straight. I thought dogs were cute and furry friends! Okay, I hate swiftpaw.
What makes Swiftpaw's death even sadder was that his death could have been avoided if Bluestar wasn't so stubborn and if Swiftpaw was thinking straight. Brightheart was there too and got permanently scarred, but Swiftpaw had it worse.
I thought dogs were cute and furry friends! But they're EVIL. He was only an apprentice! Sure he told about Brokentail(doesn't deserve star) and was rude like Longtail but it wasn't his fault! he just learned from his mentor and is an apprentice who is still learning how to control his mouth! RIP Swiftpaw... :(
~Sugarstar from SugarClan
Okay first of all, RIP Swiftpaw. I get that Longtail was his mentor and may have had a bad influence on him, but that doesn't mean he has to die! By dogs! I thought dogs were cute and fuzzy creatures until I read that part... Seriously why did he have to die?! He would've become a warrior!
Yeah, she may have lived for a long time (approximately 4 arcs.) and was a literal kit cloning machine. But she was a caring mother and made Dustpelt a sweeter cat. Ferncloud helped Leafpool's kits and sacrificed herself to defend those tiny little lives.
Seastorm sat next to Ferncloud as they watched over the lake*
Seastorm: I know what it's like just know.
Ferncloud: what whats like?
Seastorm: to have a litter of kits, and not get to be there for them. U get to watch them grow up, but it's not the same.
Ferncloud gave a wistful sigh*
Ferncloud: it's not the same at all.
Okay ferncloud, I love ferncloud. I mean am I biased because dustpelt is my fave character, maybe, am I taking my bias in my choice of votes, absolutely not. Also I was like mad when sorreltail wasn’t on this list. She deserves to be period.
How could you Brokenstar you killed a mother of so many cats in Thunderclan. I hope you rot in hell brokenstar. Ferncloud shouldn't have died like that.
In a sense, it wasn't just Hawkheart's fault: It was Goosefeather's as well. Goosefeather told them they had to attack. Goosefeather told them to go. Hawkheart killed Moonflower. I can't believe it! Goosefeather, sending his own littermate to her death! He probably didn't know, though.
OMG. This one I cried so hard. I just remember Moonflower saying she would do something for Bluepaw when she came back but she never did come back!
This death is so sad... I completely HATE Goosefeather after this, just bc of his stupid prophecy she had to die when her kits were only apps!
Poor Moonflower. Stormtail started not really caring about her, Snowkit, and Bluekit, then she had to be KILLED by the WindClan medicine cat. I almost cried when she died. RIP Moonflower.
I love Whitestorm! He deserved to be leader. And let’s get a weird meme-type thing for you.
Whitestorm: Graystripe is meant to be your deputy... that is why I died.
Firestar: Graystripe will be the new deputy of Thunderclan!
Leafpool: Firestar, Firestar, I received a sign!
Leafpool: Brambleclaw is destinies to be the deputy of Thunderclan.
Whitestorm was such a great cat. I just loved him, and it was tragic when he died. Why do they have to axe all my favourite characters?
He was one of my favourites at the time, but now he isn't I forgot the death details.
He died in the battle with BloodClan.
Whitestorm was so wise and brave, and a great deputy. I hate that he seemed just to be a placeholder until Firestar decided that he actually wanted Graystripe. Don’t get me wrong, I like Graystripe, but I feel like Whitestorm was just killed solely for the purpose that Graystripe could become deputy. I wished he had lived longer, he was a great and noble cat
A mean, seriously Crookedstar lost every thing[ in Crookedstars promise] and now he lost Willowbreeze... they were the perfect couple! Willow X Crooked forever!
Crookedstar had disfigured his face, lost both his parents, and his brother had kits with a cat from another Clan. When he met Willowbreeze, I thought things were finally going to go his way, until she died and all but one of their kits died. How horrible is that? This is by far the saddest Warrior cat death.
I cryed and had to stop reading! It was so sad. (Three days later I started reading it again) but still. I hate Mappleshade, if it wasn't for her Willowbreeze, Willowkit, and Minnowkitwould all be still alive and Silverstream would have a mother and littermates. Not only that but Crookedstar would have a mate and daughters, maby even more kits, but no! Mappleshade had to kill them.
I cried and cried when she died and I don't cryer easily it takes a lot to make me cry it just made me burst into tears when I heard her say, " Oh, my precious love," and then she DIED! It was terrible and I just want to kill Mapleshade and Crookedstar DIDN'T deserve that! He was devastated!
Brindleface just plain didn't deserve to die... there's another reason for me to hate Tigerstar... I also don't understand why you people think Tigerstar even DESERVED to be on the saddest warrior cat deaths, because he DIDN"T. y is warriors so sad...
I LOVED her so much. Tigerstar was a great villain and definitely was wrote to make people hate him. Brindleface was an amazing mother and was related to some of my favorite characters along with being one herself, <3
HOW CAN BRINDLEFACR NOT BE IN THE TOP TEN?! Sure Firestar, Bluestar, and Spottedleaf deserve to be up there too, but they already are! For crying out loud, she was SLAUGHTERED by TigerCLAW! (Doesn't deserve star) she was my absolute favorite queen of all time and she just died like that! Poor Cloudtail too! How do you think he felt? Taken away from his mother at birth and had his foster mother killed for no reason whatsoever! I hate you Tigerclaw I hate you I hate you I hate you! Brindleface I'm so sorry this had to happen to you.P. S: Thistleclaw haters back off! He didn't train Tigerpaw to be evil. He just taught him to be strong!
I know! He doesn’t even deserve a warrior name! He deserves TigerKIT and that’s all. She’s loved her kits dearly, and the must’ve been devastated. I don’t blame Cloudtail for wanting to rip his throat out, I would take my revenge if ANYTHING KILLED MY MOTHER, TOO!
Is it just me or does anyone else think cats can have phobias? If so, FlameTail woul have aquaphobia (Fear of drowning) His death would be like this from his point of view.
He was plunged into dark, freezing water. It burnt his lungs as he swallowed mouthful to mouthful. He could hear muffled shrieks coming from the surface, as a shape leaped into the water after him.
JayFeather. But something was different. Instead of his eyes glazed with light, frosty blue, they were like normal eyes. And he could SEE him. But... Isn't JayFeather blind? Then, a hairless cat appeared beside JayFeather.
"It's not your time. Leave him." the cat said.
Then the world turned black.
Okay, this was definitely the scariest death in this list. I really felt sorry for Jayfeather having to know he was drowning and not being able to do anything about it. Also tied between Cinderpelt and Swiftpaw. Swiftpaw's was so scary but imagine being trapped under ice in the frezeing water, struggling under the current with only a blind medicine cat there to save you. Awful death. RIP Flametail
Willowfern: Flametail, wait up!
Flametail: sorry Willowfern. It's just I'm so eager to give the prophecy today!
Willowfern: I am too! But could u PLEASE slow down a bit? There are more stones in this bit of Starclan than I prefer.
Side note- I put Willowfern for this one, because like Flametail, she was med cat apprentice who died before becoming a fill med.
It's so sad how he drowned with only a BLIND medicine cat with him... that's why you should have at least 3 cats in each group that leaves... and for whoever's comment was first YOUR NOT ALONE! like EVERY cat has SOME type of phobia!
It's SO WEIRD!
~ Sugarstar from SugarClan
I have never read the books but I have started to learn more about them. I saw lots of names a Longtail was the first I picked. I love cheetahs and Longtail reminded me of one. He's yellow and black pattern and his personality was just like a cheetah's. I was very sad about Longtail's death when I found out he was blind and died because a tree hit him. I will keep Longtail's legacy on by playing as him in animal jam. I think you should vote for Longtail. Love, Longtail fan. P.S. my user is Animalgirl0906. 🐆
All I gotta say is he is one of my favorite characters ( if not my favorite). Poor Mousefur blamed herself and that was so sad :< He lost to a kittypet (oof) lost his vision to a rabbit- A FLIPPING RABBIT- and was killed by a flipping flopping tree!? Poor Longtail went through a lot. Literally hate trees now >:C
I am totally blaming Mousefur for that. Stupid old coot. It's her fault he died. His death is the only time I ever cried over a book and I am still not over it. He was my favorite of all books of all fandoms. Also I love his personality and humor a lot. He was brave enough to stand up to Tigerclaw and saved a kitten from an owl. If he hadn't been there the Clan would have been eaten by the dogs. He went through the mountains being blind. A tree shouldn't have ended that.
I burst into tears when he died. Lots of people's first impressions on him when they read Into The Wild for the first time are "I don't like him, he tried to fight Rusty and he has a bad attitude." I feel sorry for him, because Firestar didn't trust him until later on and he didn't finish mentoring all of his apprentices, and he got his eyes scratched out! Poor Mousefur was devastated when Longtail died. DUMB TREE
I'm just pretending that he secretly got killed by Tiger Claw. Lion Heart for me just dies so stupidly.
"A great Warrior dies from injuries" Are you serious?!
He was the PERFECT warrior and so kind to! I was so miserable when he died! I hope he's happy hunting in StarClan :D
~ Sugarstar from SugarClan
Lionheart and spottedleaf never die, you think they do but they are secretly replaced by mapleshade and tigerstar and go off somewhere together and have four kits, ivytiger, honeymitten, spotstripe and brightdazzle
I love you so much lionheart and you don't deserve to die you deserve to live and be happy with spottedleaf or someone who you love
It's so sad when graypaw/stripe runs over to him and cries "You can't die, you can't! I still need you! Bluestar still needs you! "
Lionheart should be higher on this list like 10 or something
Lionheart is a great warrior, he was perfect, he could never be doubted and always followed the warrior code like a real warrior should, he was a very fine temporary mentor to Firestar, and Bluestar was so sad when he died, so was Greystripe, Lionheart, I cried when you died, I would have lied, for you, Lionheart. And even worse, replacing Lionheart was that evil Tigerstar!
Um, When Tallstar dies he makes Onewhisker his deputy because he gets a vision that Onestar will be a fair leader and ally with Firestar. I love Tallstar but I was mad and sad, Tallstar was such a great warrior.
Um, I was crying, yes, but WITH ANGER. So Mudclaw loyally serves Tallstar for moons and moons, shows outstanding bravery, and is overall a great deputy. So Tallstar is seriously in debt to him right? Then Tallstar REPLACES HIM WITH ONEWHISKER, saying 'I don't want any rivalry with Thunderclan when I'm gone.' Then what happens? He fights with Thunderclan just as much as Mudclaw would have. Everyone is always 'Tallstar is so wise and farsighted.' But this was stupider than Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and Jayfeather looking for the foxes as kits. I hate Tallstar, RID to him.(Rest In Despair)
When Tallstar dies he makes Onewhisker his deputy because he gets a vision that Onestar will be a fair leader and ally with Firestar. But he was wrong. I can't stand that sad look on Mudclaw's face in the manga when Onewhisker is made deputy...it looks so sad..
I love Tallstar but I was mad and sad, just make Mudclaw leader, I think Mudclaw was very sad, he really wanted to be leader, well... Onewhisker is leader now.
OH MY GOODNESS GRACIOUS STORM'S DEATH WAS SO SAD GRAY WING LOVED HER AND SHE CHOSE CLEAR SKY AS HER MATE BUT STILL AND THUNDER GREW UP WITHOUT HIS REAL FATHER AND NO MOTHER THOUGH GRAY WING WAS A GREAT FOSTER FATHER AND STILL WHERE IS GRAY WING NOW? HE DIED FROM ASTHMA AND HE ISN'T HERE? I HAVE A COMPLAINT BUT BACK TO STORM SO THIS IS WHAT SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED
Gray Wing dug through the rubble till his paws hurt. he could see a small shape moving under. "One of the kits is alive!" he yowled as he dug harder. Turtle Tail peeked over the rubble and started helping Gray Wing. He noticed a gray tail flicking under a rock. "Storm!" he yowled and dug more. Storm sat up coughing and gagging until she spit out dirt. "Let's get you and your kits to Cloud Spots and Dappled Pelt!" Gray Wing Turtle Tail and Storm raced away each carrying one of storm's three kits.
Also I gave Thunder's unnamed siblings names Thunder had a sister named Cloud and a brother named ...more
Her death was very sad, but I think I saw someone who said that they wanted her to be Thunder/Thunderstars mate, Thunder is her son, so...
I think it was really sad when storm died because she was mates with Clearsky, who was devastated and Graywing had a crush on her! She never got to name her kits too ;-;
It's so sad how Graywing was in love with her but she chose CLEARSHY INSTEAD like SERIOUSLY!?! :( then she DIED and Thunder was all alone because Clearsky didn't take care of him, Graywing was a great foster dad towards him but STILL!
~ Sugarstar from SugarClan
Brokenstar - or Brokentail when he was taken in by ThunderClan - is a very sad death, but it was a quick death of death berries. He was ignorant to the end, but we all know he was just not loved as much as he could have been. He didn't know who his mother was till his last moments too. - Blackmoon/star, Warrior of PebbleClan and Leader of NightClan
He was only evil because he was evil because he never got love :<. Yes, sent kits to fight, but still to all the good cats think of what life would be like having no love :<
I litteraly HATE Brokenstar! I was so happy when he died. Sorry Brokenstar lovers. I would have never cried. And yet I didn't. Please don't take this offensive it's my opinon. I agree only thing sad was his mother did not love him when she found out he was the cat with blood on his paws. AND killed him because of that.
In my opinion, one of the saddest deaths. Yes, he was evil, and he sent kits off to fight, but he did it because his mother never loved him. In fact, she killed him TWICE! He was my favorite. RIP Brokenstar.
I've loved Mousefur since Into The Wild, she was such a good character, and Longtail x Mousefur is REAL. I love them both so much, and at least she can be with Longtail in Starclan <3
I was so sad when she died, even though Erin Hunter only wrote a sentence or two of her death. I think she should have lived on, being the only cat that lived from the middle of Bluestar's Prophecy to the end of The Last Hope. She was grumpy, but that made her character more interesting and sad. <3 you Mousefur!
Mousefur was cranky, but always the most loyal cat in her clan she loved and cared for Longtail and she fought like all of starclan only to be killed by a stupid stupid dark forest weirdo R.I.P. mousefur!
She was brutally murdered by a dark forest tom. She was so smart and brave... I miss her.