Top Ten Warrior Cat Villains 

Alright! I have like billions and trillions of reasons why I HATE Tigerstar. Who wouldn't hate him? He killed a bunch of cats! I think Stonefur died in one of the saddest ways. He protected Feathertail and Stormfur. (Tysm Stonefur) Anyways, he also tried manipulating Brambleclaw/star into taking over the forest with Hawkfrost! (Stupid Hawkfrost fell for it right away). I was so happy when Brambleclaw killed Hawkfrost. Hawkfrost was like really REALLY annoying! Tigerstar is TERRIBLE! He killed so many cats I can't even count all because there are so many! Even though Tigerstar died in a bad way, at least he's dead!

Tigerstar is DEFINITELY a villain! He killed Redtail, had Stonefur murdered, killed Firestar, tried to kill Bluestar, killed Brindleface, I could go on and on and on. He shouldn't be one on this list because that sits with Diseasepelt all the way, but still! Ya, I get he just hated his father for leaving him and had to grow up with no family, but that doesn't give him an excuse to kill a bunch of cats! I hate Tigerstar!

He's an interesting villain. He may be strong and power-hungry, but he's got an ok head on his shoulders, he made sure that no-one would rat him out, because no one would ever believe that Redtail would have killed Oakheart, and honestly, would anyone plan to have another cat risk their neck going into enemy territory to figure what REALLY happened at the battle of Sunningrocks. He even came back after death to kill Firestar, and they had an epic batlle, during which both cats died (although techinically Firestar killed him and then died of his wounds). He definitely isn't as smart as Sol though, because he never fully prepares for another cat being ready to face him except for Firestar, so Scourge killed him.

Ok guys this guy he just no no first of all he treats Firestar/paw,heart,rusty very badly tries to kill blue star and leads an attack of rouges on his own clan! I seriously can't believe him.

Okay, I don't HATE Brokenstar. I mean, he was abused as a kit, his sister's both died, his mother left him with a so-called excuse for a mother, and then he was killed by his own mother TWICE! That's kind of hard to live with. I don't agree with the things he's done or with him becoming evil and stuff, but I can't say I hate him because I don't.

Brokenstar was just a villain for the sake of being a villain. He was horrible. He caused the death of MANY kits, children, MANY. He never stopped. He forced the Dark Forest trainees to fight with him. One of them refused to, and he got killed. Brokenstar showed the rest of the trainees that if they didn't kill their family and friends, he would kill them. He got spoiled by his father, he banished his own mother, killed his own nieces and blamed it on his mother, killed Ferncloud who was trying to protect Brightheart and the kits, etc.

The thing about Brokenstar is that, he legitimately barely has any reason to be evil. People like Thistleclaw and Tigerstar had understandable motives and tragic backstories, Brokenstar was a villain just for the fun of it. Sure Brokenstar's parents were neglectful but Brokenstar was basically destined to be evil from the start. That to me, is enough to propel him to the top 3. Onto the stuff he did, he murdered his father and attempted to murder his mother, he basically made his whole clan suffer, and kicked out WindClan.

He is one very twisted cat he needs help like right now kinda help he scares me when I first read about him I had a nightmare about him he's scary and needs help ASAP.

I don't just hate Thistleclaw because I love Bluestar. I don't love Bluestar so I can't use that as an excuse. And I don't just him because he's a villain either. To be honest, I don't really even KNOW why I hate him. He's just annoying in my opinion and he's kind of a jerk to Ivypaw/pool throughout her training. He's only in a few books though so I don't think he should be at three on the list. He should be around ten or eleven, not three.

Not to undermine Tigerstar or Scourge or any other villains on the list, but Thistleclaw is probably the most important villain on the list. I'd say if Thistleclaw never went insane, a multitude of things would have never took place. Tigerstar might have actually been good and Firestar would have never come. Thistleclaw basically created Firestar's obstacles. He pushed Tigerstar to be his worst and caused Scourge to seek revenge. He also had a tragic backstory of his love interest, Snowfur, dying. His character is really looked into and well developed. His motives are actually understandable and his impact is seen all throughout the series. By far the most impactful villain of Warriors and my personal favorite.

I don't think Thistleclaw should be on this list. Yeah, he was with the dark forest, but only because he wanted to impress his clan. And he only turned evil because Spottedleaf turned him down (read Spottedleaf's heart)

See, now this was the cat that corrupted Tigerstar you know? Feel like that kinda makes you evil to have caused the evil in the most evil cat out there.

Ahh what a dumbass. when yo dad evil and dead yo NOT supposed to follow him into evil-dead-land. Bur I don't know why he so high on this list. Anyway I like name an design. But nono kill holly leaf. Ma favorite villain tho

I HATE this cat he attempted to kill Firestar in hopes that his half brother Brambleclaw would become leader of Thunderclan I mean come on talk about just I can't even say it cause I hate him so much!

Did anyone read Tigerstar and Sasha Return To The Woods? Yeah, at first I liked Hawkfrost but then he turned evil because of stupid Tigerstar and starte dplotting Ashfur and tried to get rid of Stormfur and Brook and he KILLED Hollyleaf, He threatend Sorreltail to Leopardstar.

I know all the Hollyleaf fans are going to run towards me with fir and pitchforks but I'm going to be honest. I was glad to have Hollyleaf dead. I just don't like her. But I was sad when Hawkfrost died. He is my favorite villain in ANY book. Hmm. Lets see what he did. He tried to kill Firestar so Brambleclaw could be leader, Plotted with Mudclaw from Wind Clan, Killed Hollyleaf, And used his SISTER as a medicine cat to make up a sign to get rid of Stormfur And Brook. Wow. He tried his best to follow in his fathers footsteps and succeeded. I will always like you Hawkfrost

I feel bad for him, he was bullied so much as a kit. Tigerstar totally deserved being killed like that, and Firestar shouldn't have killed Scourge (not that I'm saying Firestar is a bad cat, because he isn't

I truly think Scourge's action speak for himself. Who becomes a serial killer just for what? Being mildly bullied? Getting nearly killed, but what lucky enough to survive? I never even saw ONCE Scourge talking to his mama about how his littermate's behaviors affect him. Did he even ask if it was true that unwanted kits are thrown in the river? NO! He then runs away, get scarred by Tigerpaw, and was saved by Bluefur. And then he repays the very cat who saved him by becoming a serial killer and launches attacks to the forest, causing cats, noble like Whitestorm, to die. Really? This is worse than Tigerstar, who had a bad influence in his life.

He is, in my opinion, OK. I guess, WOO HOO for killing Tigerstar (because that evil murderer deserved to die. Seriously, if I was in Warriors and Redtail didn't die, I would have a MAJOR crush on him, so I don't like Tigerstar AT ALL) but he tried to kill Firestar and take over the forest... so, yeah, he's cool, but should probably be lower on the list. He isn't all that special. I mean, he only appears in ONE book (not including mangas, super editions, novellas, and field guides), so I guess he's just a low profile. Meh. He's a brutal killer, because he tried to kill Barley's sister Violet! (Luckily, she survived. But what surprised me was that it was Barley's brothers that had joined BloodClan were ordered to do it and didn't even PROTEST! Like, dudes, she's your SISTER, for crying out loud! ) But, just to be clear, he's definitely a villain, and TOTALLY deserves to be on this list. Just saying'.

Tigerstar, Brokenstar And Thistleclaw are ahead. Wow. So, Thistleclaw broke a couple of peoples hearts and stuff, and trained in the dark forest. So what? Scourge didn't even believe in the dark forest. Aww, Brokenstar was sad because he didn't have a mommy! And Tigerstar... Tigerstar was KILLED by this guy. A guy 10x smaller than him. You might say he had dog's claws on, that's true, it's not cheating, it's just he actually had a good lot of brain between his ears. He knew he'd lose to a cat 10x bigger than him. Smart, backstabbing, Scourge. Most evil cat right here!

Okay, Mapleshade is 100% the most evil cat. Why?

She murdered the three cats she hated most in her lifetime; Ravenwing, Frecklewish and Appledusk, and she succeeded unlike all the other villains. Once she died, she made Tigerstar and Thistleclaw evil, and those two made many more cats evil. She killed so many cats through her puppet cats (Tigerstar, Thistleclaw etc) and she made the Dark Forest rise. She's really evil not just because she murdered so many cats, but because she succeeded.

She's my favorite villain. She has such a tragic story, but even that doesn't justify her actions. Most of the time I don't know wether to feel sorry for her because three of her kits died, she got kicked out of her clan, her boyfriend abandoned her last minute for another cat(hey apple dusk, if you wanted to become mates with a thunderclan cat you should have at least stood by her in the end!) Or hate her for killing all those cats. She's a great evil character.

MAPLESHADE!This girl is ma favorite villain and my favorite cat! She is one of the only female villains, but she rocks it. She is one of the oldest villains and her spirit is still alive even after the end of the Broken Code! She went through hardship in her life. She was cast out by her clan and when she was crossing the river the cats of RiverClan actually broke the warrior code! The code says all cats shall help a kit in need, even if the kit is from another clan. They helped her and didn't save her kits! Then they refused to give her shelter! Her mate dumped her! I think Ravenwing, Frekcklewish, and Appledusk totally deserved her vengeance. I'm glad that they died. Oak star exiled kits! Even when she was in the Dark Forest she remained a powerful force. She was super menacing. She made Thistleclaw and Tigerclaw who they were. I was sad that Spottedleaf died, but to be honest I was sick of her. In the battle in the Last Hope she was awesome! And in the battle in a Light In The Mist ...more

Ok, Mapleshade was a terrible cat, but an amazing villain. I like how her motivations were different from the other villains, but I hate how everyone acts like she is innocent. People defend her saying she acted out of grief, but that's no excuse to kill three cats. It was her fault for being mates with Appledusk. When everyone assumed the father was Birchface, she never tried to correct them, she just went along with it. Ravenwing was only doing his job by telling the truth to the Clan. And while Oakstar shouldn't have exiled Mapleshade's kits, he was acting out of grief as well! She pretended to be mates with his dead son, so of course he would be mad. And it was Mapleshade's fault the kits died, she tried to make them cross a river during a storm! People complain that Frecklewish watched and didn't do a single thing, but Mapleshade betrayed her brother's legacy, and saving her kits wasn't the first thing on her mind. And yes, Appledusk was a jerk for mating with Reedshine, but he ...more

In my opinion, Sol isn't dangerous because he's strong, or reckless, he's extremely manipulative. Imagine if Sol was able to control Tigerstar, his brute force combined with Sol's ability to control cats, Firestar might not have been able to stop him from taking over the forest.

I LOVE Sol! At least, I DID before he tried to convince Leafpool's kits to take over the forest. Then he became another Tigerstar. Sol was unique before the last 10 chapters of Sunrise. He was the way I play Plague Inc.: Start harmless until I've infected everyone, then strike! Sol could have harmed nobody until he was an influence, then bend their judgements to make his life better. Still, if not for the turnaround, I'd wish he wasn't on the list, because I agree largely with what he says. "Why should dead cats control the living? Why can't all cats learn to use herbs? Why can't you choose your own destiny? " And he's completely right. He was so interesting because he was in my head too. I knew he was a villain because I spoil things for myself, but I believed him and what he said. He also raised the questions of "Is he really a villain? " He was best as a villain who caused destruction to others around him, but used his hypnotic voice to keep cats bending over backwards for him. He ...more

All I can say is I love this cat he is just in the top five of my favorite Warrior cats I love him so much he's so cute and adorable don't judge on my preference of cats please I just have a weird preference in tom cats.

Sol is smart and thinking, ever since SkyClan banned him he has planned to avenge all clans, his character developement is great, I suspect he is the best villain ever, he's smart enough to make other cats do his dirty work!

He is my favorite villain, not because I think he doesn't deserve hate, not because I think he did the right thing, but because the scenes with him in it were so INTERESTING. The infamous fire scene is definitely my favorite, but he also plotted with Hawkfrost to kill Firestar, took over Bramblestar's body, and kidnapped Squirrelflight to the dark forest, as well as many other things. I really hope the truth about what he did when cats called him clanmate comes to light soon, and he gets an interesting and suspenseful death.

A) "his only fault was to attempt murder too much"
B) I would be upset if my crush dumped me for someone else. But I wouldn't try to murder their family. And it doesn't count as being dumped if they were never together. Squirrelflight thought they were just friends. She told him that.
C) to those of you saying he didn't kill any of the cats he tried to: Would he be more evil if Brambleclaw didn't dig the stick out of the ground? Would he be more evil if he was stronger and Lionblaze wasn't invincible? Would he be more evil if Squirrelflight didn't confesse that they weren't her kits? Other cats actions shouldn't affect how evil he is.

This boy has got to learn that he is still loved by Squirrelflight even if she has a mate that isn't him if she didn't love him why did she cry when he was killed this boy has problems that where caused because he didn't let anyone explain what was going on jeez he needs to listen for once!

First off, Ashfur tricks StarClan to let him in (Squirrelflight's Hope). He comes down because of his jealousy of Bramblestar and Squirrelflight, taking over his body and making him sick. He tricks Shadowsight to make Bramblestar go into the cold, getting him frostbite and making him die. Ashfur is the worst villain. ever.

Honestly, I don't care for him. He was only killing Spottedleaf either out of leader's orders, or because he WAS under Brokenstar's influence. And, if he was following orders, that's fine. Killing, yes it's a crime, but according to the code, leader's word is law, and you have to follow it. Besides, he never came back and murdered even more cats, RIGHT? I just think he might've been following orders, which is fine. End of story.

Can people quit voting for him because he killed Spottedleaf. He did other stuff to. Just because he killed her doesn't mean he is instantly the most evil cat ever. Think about it. If she never died then she wouldn't have been able to appear in Firestar's dreams and give him prophecies and stuff.

I love Spottedleaf and she is my life but I feel bad because I really like Yellowfang and Clawface's mate is Yellowfang's sister, Rowanberry, who I love, and Clawface's son died, no matter how bad Clawface is, I feel bad he returns home and his mate says, "our poor son died." I mean seriously have a heart

I personally feel terrible for him. He didn't have a chance for character redemption unlike Blackstar, and is the only villain I'd consider "Good". He's not a horrible cat unlike Brokenstar, he just did everything his leader did. He was actually really good in Tigerclaw's fury and Yellowfang's secret

I don't really like Bone. However, we can say he's very strong to live a life eating garbage and fighting other cats and dogs for the territory. He was killed by apprentices, but they were a lot of apprentices. And when everybody jumps on you, what do you do? You fall down on the ground, while the apprentices try to kill you. Yes. Apprentices. It's a bit embarrassing, but Bone was strong enough to kill Whitestorm, a senior warrior.

I don't care for Bone. Like I said on the Clawface one, he was just following orders. Put yourself in the character's shoes (more like paws) and see why they do what they do. Bone killed under clear instructions from his leader, and there was a war going on between the clans, so it would be understandable if you had to resort to killing.

His death was the funniest in the books and I'm glad he's dead he killed whitestorm I can picture the apprentices charging him and firestar just watching and staring on like wtw? YAY bone is dead bone is dead bone is dead is what the apprentices said after they killed him and before bone died one of the apprentices said "Hello! My name is Sootpaw, you killed my father, PREPARE TO DIE! " (I know he was still a kit but one of the apprentices was his son and I can't remember his name so I'm going with sootfur/paw)

I vote Bone, I agree, vote Bone if you want pity for Whitestorm, I never noticed Whitestorm until he was made deputy, but when he was killed, I was so sad, R.I.P
Whitestorm, happy hunting in Starclan

Hawkbutt is the dumbest laziest most fox hearted BRAT! He killed Moonflower when Bluepaw was only a appearance for like 3 days! I mean, what is your problem Hawkbutt? But even though Hawkbutt killed Moonflower and all, I don't blame Goosfeather for her death. But still Goosefeather was Moonflower's littermate! Whatever, enough of Goosefeather! I hate how Hawkbutt calls Bluepaw a kit! I mean, how come he couldn't at least call all the appearances kits!? I hate Hawkbuts guts!

Just because he killed someone doesn't mean he's evil. It's been a while since I read bluestar prophecy, but he was defending the herb storage, and even if medicine cats aren't supposed to kill he shouldn't be deemed evil for doing that.

I think Hawkheart had a good reason to do what he did (herbs are important) but I don't think he should have killed Moonflower. Maybe injured her but not killed.

Ok, I know, I know he is not necessarily a real villain. But he is evil, I think anyone who kills a cat is evil. He didn't even have a good reason it was just because she was stealing his herbs... which the whole clan was trying to do What are you going to do now Hawkheart, kill all of ThunderClan? Also, I know you could argue that Gray Wing killed Fox, Tall Shadow killed Fircone, Jackdaw's Cry, and Falling Feather both killed each other and all of that, but they weren't trying to kill each other they were just either trying to defend themselves or someone else. Also, I hate how Hawkheart kills Moonflower right in front of poor Bluestar/Bluepaw and he didn't even care...

Ok this makes me mad. Longtail gets BLINDED because of a RABBIT! Erin should've done better. I wouldn't be so mad if he got blinded in battle or born blind like Jayfeather. When I first saw a drawing of Longtail, I thought he got injured in battle. But it was a RABBIT!

- Longtail happened to be my favourite cat in the entire series. He may have been a jerk to young Firestar, but who could blame him? Clearly the whole battle wasn't even that horrible if Bluestar didn't end it, and she also didn't punish Longtail for it.
I personally think Firestar was far overrated, especially if he managed to defeat Longtail, a trained warrior, right as soon as he leaves his Twolegs. It isn't logical.
I must've spent at least five minutes laughing at these comments. As soon as I saw the title, I instantly voted for it. That rabbit destroyed Longtail! My poor baby never hunted another mouse again.
Speaking about mice, Mousefur's is just as evil. True, had she not been so worried over old prey anyway, Longtail would more than likely be alive. But, if that mouse hadn't existed, Mousefur wouldn't have been so worried and there would not have been something to crush Longtail!
*** VOTE FOR THE RABBIT THAT HURT LONGTAIL! ***

What would you guys do if someone was trying to eat you? I'd totally fight back. Everyone teaches you that you run, hide or fight when someone try's to hurt you. Now the rabbit couldn't run, or hide so that leaves fight. You can't blame the rabbit!

Wow I so agree with this although the rabbit isn't technically a villain because it was just trying to survive and wasn't planning anything sinister. But I hate it, Longtail was a great character, he redeemed himself as well.

If I had to describe Diseasepelt in five words, this is what they would be; Arrogant piece of fox dung. Done. Don't even try to make me change my mind by saying "Oh it's Crowfeather's fault!" or "Oh it's all Crowfeather!" Because it's NOT! Diseasepelt thinks it's okay to try and kill his half-siblings AND a pregnant she-cat AND betray his Clan all because his father hates him. What sense does that make? Killing Crowfeather would make sense, but Hollyleaf? Jayfeather, Lionblaze, Poppyfrost? Not okay, Diseasepelt. Third worst cat in Warriors.

Don't blame Breezepelt for doing what he did! His father didn't care a bit about him until Crowfeather's Trial. His parents fought all the time which was also a terrible influence.

Poor Breezepelt...Seeing A traitorous father pick an ice cream for a mate (I just take Leafpool for an ice cream XD) and leave your mother...Breezepelt, go ahead, kill your father.


I'm just kidding. *sigh* You deserve a better father so you won't go to the dark forest. Please don't!

I feel sorry for Breezepelt! Personally, I think it's all Crowfeather's fault! He becomes mates with Nightcloud, doesn't love her but still stays with her?! That makes her suffer! And he established such hatred between Breezepelt and his Half-siblings! I'm sorry that Breezepelt had to live THIS life. His Father could have at least pretended to love him!

Guys. Are characters not allowed to develop over time? When he killed Stonefur, he was acting under orders, and I seriously doubt Tigerstar would have cared if Blackfoot had objections. He probably would have been killed himself if he had objected. If you're going to hate him for killing a cat, then you may as well hate Firestar or Graystripe too, because they've killed cats. You CANNOT ignore the fact that when Blackstar became leader of Shadowclan, they had given up all hope. He made them great again. He made them strong again. He wasn't the first cat to be manipulated by Sol, nor the last. Don't forget, the clans still thought Sol had predicted the eclipse, something not even Starclan had forseen. It was a poor judgement to let him into Shadowclan, but Blackstar realized his mistakes, and he helped to drive Sol out upon realizing the clans had been tricked. He certainly isn't evil, and he belongs in Starclan.

First, I hated Blackfoot/Blackstar when he killed Stonefur. He was a BIT of an villain that time, I guess. But as I moved into the series, I began to reflect about it more. Blackstar was being hostile BUT cooperative and VERY RARELY passive. I gained respect for Blackstar and ShadowClan. I also believe that he was scared of rebelling against Tigerstar and /had/ to kill Stonefur. He deserves to be in StarClan.
Did he kill Stonefur because he wanted to?
No.
Did he follow Brokenstar because he wanted to?
No.
Did he fought with no mercy because he wanted to? (Into the Wild raid)
No.
Did he get manipulated by Sol because he wanted to?
No.
Did he feel guilty about killing Stonefur
YES!
Does he deserve to be leader?
YES!
Does he deserve to be a StarClan cat?
YES!
I was happy ever since I read Bramblestar's Storm, because ol' Black went to StarClan, killed by a storm. He deserves to be in StarClan! That's my opinion.

Okay, Blackfoot WAS bad before, killing Stonefur. But can you really blame him? He was appointed deputy by Brokenstar only to be exiled by following his leader's orders (not Brokenstar's fault that his father chose him as deputy). Then again, he was following orders when killing Stonefur but that was either out of loyalty or out of cowardice.
But later on in the series, he changes and actually becomes a great leader in the end.

So I think he wasn't truly EVIL per say, but was definitely a villain. You could say Tigerstar wasn't evil because he was under the influence of Thistleclaw, but we all think he's a villain. I think Blackfoot was a really complicated character and enjoyed one who maybe didn't want to do what he was doing and found ways to become better later on.

I CAN't believe that Darktail is just ranked 20! He is the most evil cats in the whole Warriors series( except Bramblestar's impostor ). He took over rebuilt Skyclan's camp and made Shadowclan to his stupid Kin. Darktail also treated prisoners badly, and gave a very poor prey after the prisoners had to say some stupid swear. And he killed POOR Needletail, Violetpaw's foster sister and a friend. I was glad when Onestar drowned him to death like he did.

Guys.. He is Evil+Evil+Evil+Evil times 100. He was so cruel when he did not cure sick prisoners, did not fed them well, and when he ordered Needletail to kill Violetpaw! Also, he destroyed riverclan, and shadowclan. How can this guy not be 1? He is scary. One time, I said I rather join the kin than bloodclan, I was wrong. You should join BLOODCLAN. Darktail is scary... So scary... even better at thinking something cruel than Tigerstar. Scourge allow his littermates to eat at least for once. Tigerstar wasn't that evil too. Brokenstar.. Well he is evil, but so does darktail or even more. He deserves first place.

I like to think of Darktail as Scourge 2.0, and I enjoyed Scourge as a villain. But right from the start, he's more of a Breezepelt 2.0 than a Scourge 2.0. But that's not his fault.

Why is Darktail not #1? First of all, he completely took over ShadowClan and RiverClan and drove out SkyClan from their old territory. What did Tigerstar do? He became leader of ShadowClan, then was killed abrutly by Scourge. Darktail punished cats for simply not agreeing with him, while Tigerstar did follow a few of the rules, like waiting to become deputy before ambushing Bluestar. After reading this, we can ALL agree that Darktail caused WAY more damage to the Clans and is the MOST EVIL warrior cat.

How was Goosefeather evil? Is it because he had that omen that ended up killing Moonflower? No, that was unexpected. Goosefeather didn't know Moonflower was going to die, and he didn't even kill her. Hawkheart did. If you read Goosefeather's Curse, you'll see why the way he acts. He's pretty underrated, honestly. He seems like an interesting character. His novella explains that he had a special gift to connect with other Starclan cats in the past, seeming like it's a curse. Sorry, but he shouldn't be here.

Goosefeather was CURSED! That's why the book is called Goosefeather's Curse. Cloudberry took him in as her apprentice. Hawkheart killed Moonflower, not Goosefeather's. He isn't the type of cat that would kill his good littermate. (Brambleclaw is a totally different story) Goosefeather tried to help his clan when he KNEW they would starve. He even told Doestar about the kittypets attacking Squirrelwhisker's patrol. He also knew that Swiftpaw (later Swiftbreeze) was over by the sunningrocks when she went missing. How does that make him evil?

How is this cat evil? He had no reason to be on here. He interrupted an omen wrong but so did every other cat. The fourth cat prophecy was interrupted wrong. The three though it might be Hollylead or Ivypool. they didn't find out Firestar was the fourth cat until he died saving his clan, does that make Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Dovewing evil? No! Of course not.

Goosefeather was never intended to be evil and never will be.

He is not bad! Why do you think that? He was trying to prove he wasn't some lazy fur-ball! Hr was super sad too that Moonflower died!

I hated her SO MUCH after what she did to Stormkit, like seriously! I mean it's not like the WHOLE CLAN stares at him weirdly but his own freaking mother wants to rename him CROOKEDKIT. And when she whispered to Oakheart at his ceremony that Crookedkit would never be as good as her! All she cares about is that her kits are handsome,She is my most hated cat ever.Crookedstar deserved a better kithood

Probably the character I hate the most, because I felt so much empathy for Crookedstar. She's a emotionnal and verbal abuser, and a hypocrite and narcissic too.

I do think Rainflower's actions were bad, but she was different. She was trying to stop loving Crookedstar, so that if he died, it wouldn't affect her. She changed his name so she'd forget about Stormkit. It's not that she didn't love him, she was just trying to prevent being hurt(Emotionally). If she were emotionally hurt, it could lead to WORSE things. Such as Ashfur, since he didn't get the love he was looking for, and every other cat was out of his age ranks, he threatened to kill many cats, leading the Hollyleaf leaving, and Lioblaze and Jayfeather hating Leafpool and Squirrelflight, but that's beside the point. The truth is that she was trying to shelter herself from the pain that would've been inflicted. - Whitesplash

Not all villians kill. Just as much damage can be done with words. People (cats) that INTENTIONALLY use their words to DESTROY others are villians too. If it's not intential, they aren't villians.

For example, Longtail does want to make Rusty/Firepaw feel bad, but he could not bring himself to go as far because he doesn't really want to hurt others. Also, Millie does her negative statements out of her own stability. Both are antaganists, but not villians.

Rainflower is a villain.

I don't like him. Moonflower loved him when she was a KIT. Then, they have kits and he's all " forget what's-her-face and my kits! I'm gonna go hang with Dappletail."
When Moonflower dies: "wait, who are you? Oh, you're my kit! Wait what's-her-face died? Oh well, sorry. "
In star clan: " I'm so sorry my precious Bluestar! I should've protected your mother! I never loved Dappletail" then she comes: "hi my love... No I was just thinking of you... No they mean nothing to me! "
See, he's a no-good, lying jerk-face!

To be honest I like stormtail. He was head over heels for moonflower, then realized a little too late that she wasn't the one for him. I don't think he's a total jerk, I mean he was pretty ignorant but he didn't know what to do because he loved dappletail. I feel bad that the fandom shows him pure hatred.

Stormtail was a terrible father (much more than Crowfeather), a terrible mate (much more than Crowfeather), and a cheater (much more than Crowfeather. Why am I comparing him to Crowfeather? I have no idea) but he was loyal to his clan and was (kinda) there for Bluestar when Snowfur died (KINDA).

Dappletail could be his mother (along with the white kit with blue eyes who was deaf and mentioned by Dappletail when talking about one of her kits from a previous litter) as the books always mention her having kits. The erins confirmed that Patchpet was Greystripes father so it is possible for cats to retire to the elders den soon after having kits. Although I am not sure about Stormtail.

Clear Sky is an arrogant selfish stupid lying bossy ruthless pushy mean cruel nasty fox-hearted mouse-brained irresponsible BRAT! He killed Misty, pushed out Jagged Peak, left Frost to DIE, and the two worst things he did; He killed Rainswept Flower and rejected Thunder TWICE! Not only did I love both of those cats, but Thunder is his SON! He loves his litter with Star Flower SO MUCH, but Storm and two of his first litter die and he's just like "Oh, well my son might die just like the rest of the cats I care about but he reminds of me of my dead mate so I'm sending him off to my brother who I also hate because I don't want to take care of him!" And then a few moons later he kills Rainswept Flower because she... oh wait, she did NOTHING! He's completely lost his mind, and I will always hate him, nothing he does will make me change my mind.

I'LL SAY IT AGAIN Clear Sky is a selfish arrogant lying stupid demanding irresponsible bossy pushy ruthless lazy mean cruel nasty entitled self-absorbed BRAT! My god I'm so tried of people saying he's such a "gentleman". When HE'S NOT! He's extremely disrespectful of women! I mean he literally murdered many women assaulted many more and treated a few like shi!

NO Clear Sky KNEW EXACTLY what he was doing and he KNEW it was wrong but he still did it anyway! It was his fault his mates died! And he WASN'T blinded by fear of starvation! Also Duskstorm DON'T EVER TRY TO PUT ME IN HIS PAWS! If I acted like him I'd go to jail and everyone would hate me! Also yes I wouldn't like it to see my sister starve BUT I wouldn't turn into a CRAZY SERIAL KILLER! My god I'm so tried of people praying him and calling him a so call "gentleman" well in reality he's nothing but a criminal and a villain! Also I DID remember that he saved Gray Wing's son but that doesn't mean he's a hero nor I do have to like him! It's just like Voldemort from Harry Potter (by the way spoilers for Harry Potter in case you haven't read the books or seen the movies) he killed Harry's parents Lily Potter and James Potter but he didn't kill Harry but no one calls him a hero! So why does Clear Sky get a free pass?!?! He feels very little remorse about his actions he's a selfish arrogant ...more

I hate Clear Sky! Why is Clear Sky not the first most evil? I really hate it when people say that Clear Sky is evil oh Clear Sky! Ok, Clear Sky was evil but SKYSTAR wasn't he was one of the cats who invented the warrior code! He also invented SkyClan! Clear Sky=evil Skystar=better than evil.

This is the cat that invented scourge! If she had just been nice to him, Tiny would not have become SCOURGE the evil tom, but he would have stayed as Tiny, the nice kit!

You terror! You changed poor tiny/scourge's life!
Look at it this way.
If Ruby hadn't left him out, made him want to prove himself, then tell him that unwanted kits get thrown in the river, scourge/tiny would have been a kittypet, and nothing bad concerning Scourge would have ever happened!

Technically, if she didn't do what she did, Scrouge would've never formed BloodClan and some other cat would have to kill Tigerstar nine times because the forest cats don't have dog teeth as claws to rip out nine lives at once. So, she indirectly saved the forest.

If it wasn't for her, Scourge would be happily purring alongside a kind human right now, instead of evil and dead.

This cat is evil because he is in the Darkforest, isn't a good argument. We don't even know why he's their, which is sad because we can say he was their for killing one cat like every other cat who is alive/was alive.

Snowtuft is in the Dark Forest so that makes him a villain. Some other non-Dark Forest'ers are villains higher than Snowtuft here so I'm wondering why he's all the way down here.

I really wish we could've seen more of Snowtuft! There was only on or two scenes with him and they didn't even list him in the clans when he was alive! I need more snowtuft

Can't say much 'bout this guy, but he's evil of course.
But these stories with "he is the soul of Snowkit" are just bull. But bulls are cute. Lol.