Most Evil Warrior Cats
He was always vicious from when he was a kit, and on his conquest for power many people died, and then when he was in power. The first one was Redtail which was totally unfair! Redtail didn't do anything wrong! Next I think was Runningwind. He straight up killed her, only because she was from Thunderclan, the clan that exiled him for leading an attack on the camp, which is a GOOD reason. Then from his dog plan he got Swiftpaw killed which wasn't entirely his fault, but the dogs shouldn't have been there. Then he murdered Brindleface only so the dogs could get a taste for cat blood! Then Bluestar died stopping the pack HE unleashed from getting to the Thunderclan camp. And he ordered Stonefur's death! And that's just from The Prophecy's Begin.
Tiger was the first villain ever introduced in the series. He was also one of the best. I feel they just did him so dirty with his Dark Forest persona. That part of him just seemed so much less horrifying and scary, he completely lost a lot that made him a good villain.-Fallen from before StarClan
His mentor made him evil, but he is VERY evil! He killed Redtail, I think Firestar but I'm not sure, He attacked Bluestar (I think) and almost tried to kill his own apprentice!
Tigerstar is evil. No doubt about it! He technically killed his own son by leading a pack of wolves in TC territory! Your ambition ruined your life bro. I hate you. Literally was with Sasha and Goldenflower! That's not how love works yo. He killed like tons of cats! So many I can't even count them all! Honestly, I didn't really want Firestar to kill him though so his soul would fade forever because I thought it would be cool if Goldenflower turned evil and wanted revenge on Tigerstar or som. I don't know. Anyway, he was evil, and you all know it!
-FerretTail of RC
Broken is just a psycho. He trained literal CHILDREN to fight in war, getting many of them killed. And his Dark Forest persona was great too! He just didn't have any children to torcher so he chose to torcher the clan cats instead.-Fallen from before StarClan
Of course, most people think Tigerstar is the most evil. But we never got to know what MADE Brokenstar evil. If he was born pure evil, Then he is probably definitely more evil than Tigerstar. But, at least Tigerstar never tried to train kits and send them to battle at a young age. At least Tigerstar didn't exile his mother and refer to her as a rogue. I mean, he didn't know she was his mother, but doing so left Runningnose to be the Medicine cat, a cat who can't cure his own cold. He also steals kits, even though it's completely unnessary. He was the cause of young Badgerpaw's death, and the deaths of so many countless cats, from all over the clans. Yellowfang was right to feed him deathberries. If any cat is the most ruthless, evil, heartless, and souless cat, it's Brokenstar.
I am about to go into a rant on how much I hate this guy.
Brokenstar is the mouse brained son of Yellowfang. He gave her a bad rep because he would train kits at like 3 moons old and except them to win. He killed like 30 cats and is the ugliest cat anyway (besides Rock ofc) and thank StarClan Yellowfang killed him by feeding him deathberries because she was probably tired of dealing with her mentally messed up son. She also killed his spirit. Brokenstar's favorite thing to do was to kill kits and innocent cats.
I just hate Brokenstar for what he did!he nearly wiped out a hole generation of Shadowclan-cats! If you read the books you can only find 2 warriors from Brokenstar's time! Think about how many kits their are born in 1 green leaf and then you take away all those kits except for 2. that's how many kits Brokenstar killed in one year. But it doesn't end there, Brokenstar is leader for quite a few years. So you can add A LOT OF OTHER KITS TO! He called the killed kits weak, HE WAS THE WEAK ONE! He only killed defencelessness kits and innocent cats with a practically (for Shadowclan at that time) unbeatable army of warriors. I love Yellowfang for killing him not once, not twice but three times! HE DESERVES TO FEEL ALL THE PAIN THOSE POOR SHADOWCLAN QEENS FELT BACK THEN!
Scourge was powerful, no doubt about it. His past was also sad, how he had trauma with both the clans and his own kin! Honestly I want him to meet Jake, I feel he would freak that his half-brother is the great Firestar.-Fallen from before StarClan
He was bullied for being a runt. So he decided to show them who's boss! He ran away and became one of the Most Evil Cat EVER! I was sad when he died… I wanted to see if he went to Starclan or the Dark forest. He didn't go to Starclan because He was Evil and With the dark forest.. He didn't go there either. I know suprising right. It's because he didn't believe that it was true.
Why would you mouse brains put scourge on here. If you read his backstory you'll probably think twice about putting him on the list. SPOILER: he didn't kill White storm, Bone did. Yes he did just take all of tiger stars lives. But tiger claw chased him away when he was only a tiny kit! Tiger star deserves to die he would have killed firestar and taken over the whole forest and killed every cat who tried to stop him. Oh and we can't forget that he had tried to destroy thunder clan with a pack of dogs. He was the reason blue star died. He killed red tail and tried to kill firestar multiple times and he tried to kill blue star.
A lot of people don't like and I don't like him either, but if you read his backstory you tend to get more pity for him than hate. He was treated terribly by his littermates, he almost got murdered when he was a kit, and he was raised by outsiders. Sure he was still a bad cat but the only love he must of felt is when every twoleg place cat made him leader. That is my defense of him being not as bad as you think but don't get me wrong he is still a bad cat. When people say he wanted the best for his cat that is not true. Take Bone for example. If Scourge's deputy got sick then he would have left him to die. That's all I got. He is not evil but still bad. I don't hate nor love him. I just pity him.
I guess Hawkfrost CAN be counted as a villain, since he secretly trained as a Dark Forest warrior and supported his evil father, Tigerstar.
Hawk was kind of a side villain when he was alive, but I feel he became his own cat once he reached the Dark Forest. I feel he really cared for Ivy and even might have loved her, and felt so hurt when she betrayed him.-Fallen from before StarClan
Hawkfrost was kinda like a litter puppet. But his relationship with Mothwing and later Ivypool showed how cunning he really was.
Feathertail saw that he was becoming his father. But if he turned on RiverClan... I mean, let's take a trip down memory lane. Hawk was chasing a moss ball and fell in the river. Moth was pretty dang traumatized, and Hawk was holding on to life's edge. Feathertail. She saved him. How could Hawk ever turn on him? Also, the reason why he's probably so strong is because his mentor was Leopardstar.
I have some sympathy for her, but not much. Yes, she should have felt hurt by ThunderClan exiling her, but she also caused that. She acted like Apple was her's to own, not as a lover or a secret mate. Yeah, she's allowed to feel jealous towards Reed loving Apple, but she just acted like she OWNED him and he shouldn't be able to live without her approving everything he does. Oh and yes, I hate Apple and Reed very much. Apple cheated on Maple, sure, but she just acted like she owned him, it just feels wrong.-Fallen from before StarClan
Mapleshade really deserves #1. Though, if she had not met Appledusk she would not have became evil, but she did and she killed cats, Ravenwing, Appledusk (Trying to kill Reedshine) and poisoned Frecklewish with a snake. Because her kits died? They drowned in the river (though they were gotten to the other side and not rushed to some place of the river), so she kills cats? Evil cat, and then she killed Spottedleaf (spirit life; I've never liked that tortoiseshell sweet-smelling medicine cat but I still think It is evil for her to kill Spottedleaf) when Spottedleaf was defending Sandstorm. That made her more(?) evil, I think.
She killed three or more cats by herself and is everyone forgetting that the reason lil' Tiger killed those cats was mostly because of her? (And other Dark Forest warriors) And I forgot to mention, Crookedstar too. Besides, who was the one to train and make an army of the Dark Forest? You must be thinking, 'Maybe Brokenstar or Tigerstar? They're evil', but no! Mapleshade did. I can't even believe that Darkstripe got a higher rank than her! Darkstripe is a coward, and as far as I know, he hasn't killed that many cats. Maybe one or two, or even not at all. She deserves better than this. Honestly, I wish that she saved her kits and went to StarClan, but well, that's not happening. Might as well stick up for her to be the evilest villain. Also, I know I might sound weird 'cause I'm switching sides now, but I thank her for killing Spottedleaf. Spottedleaf was around too long. I mean, come on, I think she's more of a stalker than a lovely lost love. Anyway, she DESERVES more than this. She ...more
Mapleshade totally deserves to be number 1. She killed at least four cats by herself, possibly more, and killed many others through Tigerstar, Scourge (because of what Tigerpaw(star) did to him, and through all the other Dark Forest cats during the Great Battle. She made Crookedstar leave his mother to die, lured Twolegs toward Willowbreeze, and manipulated so many cats. She what she wanted, and she knew how to get it. Tigerstar only got any power because Mapleshade was instructing him. She's more evil than any other cat in the books. She is more worthy of the top spot than any of these other villains.
He was probably the most successful villain. He almost destroyed the clans, no other cats had been able to do that. I kind of am impressed, and I no I might get some hate for this, but I think Onestar needed to go he was such a good cat at the beginning but once he became leader he changed in a bad way.
I think he's one or the most evil villains in the ENTIRE series. First, he almost wipes out Skyclan and claims he and his rouges are them. Next, he goes to the lake and takes over Shadowclan, and destroys Riverclan and doesn't BURY their dead clanmates. Then, there's the great battle all over again but WORSE. And then makes Windclan leave the battle. He's my favorite villain. -Hazelspring of Riverclan.
Darktail is EVIL! Tigerstar took over Shadowclan and Riverclan, but he made them join forces. Darktail took over both those clans too, but just destroyed them both! He destroyed Skyclan, but then, when he found out Onestar wasn't there, he just abandoned the territory he took, just to find his father. But then he kept PRISONERS! He basically tricked kitty pets into joining them, tricked half of Shadowclan into joining him, and drowned any cat who did the simplest act of disagreeing with him. He didn't get defeated until all 5 clans worked together to drive him out. Tigerstar was killed by a rouge. Brokenstar was killed by a medicine cat! Mapleshade died of wounds from an apprentice! SERIOUSLY! He is the NUMBER 1 villain of the warrior series.
Yes, finally Darktail is in top ten. He should have been introduced earlier in the series, because tons of people have zoned out of the books by AVOS. (If you ask me they should have turned POT and OOTS into one arc and have AVOS as the fourth. But he was a great villain as leader of the rogues, and his obsession with Violetshine was creepy. He was the focus of half of AVOS, more than scrouge, who only appeared in one book, not counting the manga. Also he needs a novella, if Mapleshade and Tigerstar get one, so does he.
Tbh, Darkstripe is mouse-brained. Thinking Tigerstar will always win? Yo, are you blind to see that your friend, Tigerstar, is pure evil? And you follow him. Wow. In the fight against BloodClan, you chose to fight Firestar. Like, bro, What! Also, you were a spy and just blurted everything out to Tigerstar. How annoying can you get, dude?
-HollyShine Of RiverClan
Darkstripe is pure evil. He stayed in ThunderClan to spy on them and then he reported to Tigerstar all of the things they did. This guy is just plain old EVIL.
This kind of cat is not the most evil but I don't like him duh ALSO I saw someone post that Darkstripe killed Needle but NO It is darktail Actually so you can start developing new hatred(?) toward DarkTAIl and DarkSTRIPE
He wasn't that bad but I do think that he wasn't a good cat either SPOILER!. For one he was on Tigerstar's side when they attacked the camp. Second of all, he left his clan and fought Firestar when BloodClan attacked.
Sol used his words, not his claws to win fights. He convinced nearly the entire of ShadowClan to abandon StarClan, that's got to count for something.-Fallen from before StarClan
Sol.. He is very convincing. (Spoilers!) In Book 5 in Omen Of Stars. He convinced some Thunderclan cats that Windclan said they are weak and they need a lot of help. He is also a little backstabbing Monster. This is also apart of #5 Omen Of Stars. He was working with Windclan when Lionblaze let him back into the Camp.
Honestly, he seemed like a nice guy at first, but after that, he's all tricky. I think the basic reason I literally hate him is because he tricks everyone with his words.
This cat can use his tounge! He is very dangerous in his own way, and although he isn't a great fighter, he literally convinced the ShadowClan to drop their believe with WORDS.
Thistleclaw created Tigerstar in a way. It was written in the stars that Tigerstar would be evil, but Thistleclaw focused on battle a lot, and he got him to attack Scourge (then Tiny) which kind of created Scourge. So in summary, if Thistleclaw didn't exist, a lot of villains wouldn't.
Okay, settle down... this is going to take a while...
For one, Thistleclaw did not make Tigerstar evil, Goosefeather saw evil in Tigerstar when he was still a kit. He was simply an evil cat, nothing to do with Thistleclaw.
Also, it's not Bluestar's fault Thistleclaw was evil. Your girlfriend's sister not liking you doesn't give you the right to turn against everyone that loves you, everyone you grew up with. Bluestar also didn't chase Thistleclaw into the dark forest. That was a joke the authors made up.
Thistleclaw had no reason to be evil. He trained in the Dark Forest in Spottedleaf's Heart and chose to stay there. Don't make the excuse that he lost his mate and sister. Look at Crookedstar, he lost his mother, his father, his mate, his kits, and his brother. And yet he still stayed loyal to the end.
Why, Thistleclaw, I don't get all the ambitions to have power in warrior books! The bad guys never get the actual power, so I always wonder what they were gonna do. I feel bad for Bluestar for having to deal with Thistleclaw in her early days of leader.
Thistleclaw is a strong cat. He Works in the Dark Forest with Mapleshade, Ashfur, Hawkfrost, And Tigerstar. He is a great Warrior! I give him #5 On the Rank
I just finished reading into the wild (Great book) seriously HE KILLED Spottedleaf!And he took frostfur's kits (but luckily graypaw and firepaw got the kits back)
Think of it this way- NIGHTSTAR, leader of ShadowClan is Clawface's brother. Also does anyone else think it's weird that when he was an apprentice he was named Clawpaw? How did he mess up his face?
Clawface brakes into thunderclan camp.
Clawface tries to steal babies.
Spottedleaf tries to stop him.
Claw face takes the babies.
Thunderclan gets the babies back.
WHY CLAWFACE? Spottedleaf was my first favorite cat when I was new to the series. Then, he came in and murdered her. Sorry not sorry!
Bone is loyal to Scourge and Only Scourge Other then his clan. But then again he was literally like Scourge's Slave. And I think if he chose to not join Bloodclan he could have been so much more.
Bone made me yeet the book(Darkest hour I think) across the room when he killed whitestorm, I mean what the heck he's sooooo evil and is scrouge's loyal partner. He made me feel better when the apprentices karma'd him by killing him for revenge. Good thing erin killed him.
Bone is pure evil! He literally collected claws from cats and teeth from dogs. He deserves to be in dark forest for his bloody actions, Maple shade killed to avenge her kittens. Bone doesn't deserve to be in StarClan. He died because of apps so he can learn his gory actions from the past.
Bone was so cruel. Bad deeds: Following scourge as his second in command, nearly killing barley and his sister violet, killing whitestorm, and killing many other cats. Bone deserved to die in the paws of the apprentices.
In my opinion, One Eye should be closer to the #1 spot. He's far more evil then Clawface or Darkstripe, that's for sure. He killed Tom when he was defending his kit, whom he also tried to kill. He was partially the reason why Petal died, indeed leaving Birch and Alder without their mother. He banished Clear Sky from his group, and marked an eye on the cat's paws, claiming them his. Kind of like a slave in my opinion. He was greedy for power and the control over Clear Sky's cats.
Clawface killed Spottedleaf and was one of Brokenstar's followers. That's bad, but not as bad as what One Eye did. Darkstripe wasn't technically "evil". Though, he did feed Sorrelkit deathberries and betrayed his Clan.
Even Bone. He was Scourge's dirty follower and killed Whitestorm, but we don't know if he killed anyone else. I think One Eye was much worse. And no offense, but people think these cats should be in the top 5 because they killed their favorite character(s).
I hate this cat so much. (Spoilers)
First, he attacks Mouse Ear, then he attacks the cats when they go get the Blazing Star, and a kit! Hey dum dum, Pebble Heart was saving your life. they should have just let him eat the sick bird. Then he attacks Sparrow Fur, then kills Tom when he tried to save his kit! Then he kicks Clear Sky out of his own camp and territory and traps Sparrow Fur so he can kill her later >:(
After that, he stops the cats from getting more Blazing Star so they can save Holly, a cat expecting kits. And when Acorn Fur tries to save them, he most likely tried to attack her after. Then he uses his daughter, Star Flower to learn how the good cats will attack. He deserved to die!
He's in Dawn of the Clans, so most of you don't know him. But he's so evil, that he kicked Clear Sky out of his own clan, killed Tom, nearly killed Sparrow Fur, and put his mark of a single eye on innocent cats, making Snake betray his group and made Petal die, leaving Birch and Alder without a mother. And, thanks to his daughter, Thunder, Cloud Spots, Pink Eyes, Lightning Tail, and someone else I don't remember left to create a new group. So, if you think he is something to forget, then I'll make his dead spirit haunt you in your dreams.
One Eye is a beast. He probably had the sickness to some extent, and that he's the reason the sickness got to Petal, Birch, and Alder! And he didn't even seem prepared to help end the sickness if he even knew the actual cure in the first place!
I hate Clear Sky so much! He basically hogged Bright Stream from Gray Wing, and then accidentally got her killed! Then, he hogged Storm from Gray Wing, and accidentally got HER killed too!
He also killed Rainswept Flower, and her last memory was of his DAMN STINKY breath in her face going "I'm nOt GreeDy I'm JuSt StrOnG!"
And yknow what? He didn't even apologize afterwards! He just decided to hog Star Flower from his son, Thunder, who by the way, he REJECTED when he was a kit!
And when Frost got a burn on his leg, Clear Sky chased him out of the camp and left him their for the animals to feast on!
And when his little brother, Jagged Peak, fell from a tree and hurt himself, he KICKED HIM OUT!
And her even killed a whole bunch of innocent kits because he felt like it!
I don't know HOW Clear Sky is people's favorite cat, I hate him!1
Huh, this guy killed a lot. I was like "Who is Clear Sky" and searched in fandom. Then I saw his killed victims and the "I'm not greedy, I'm just strong" one. Telling that at the face of a person who you, like, was just about to murder? Chill. I know, this guy lost 2 mates, but you can't be "mkay, I lost my girls who were my brother's crush, maybe I will turn a monster and kill a bunch of innocent kits and steal my son's gf". Crookedstar lost everyone except for Stormfur and his kits, but he was kind and is many ppls' favorite. I haven't read DotC, but I guess I know it all now. So I can yell "I think Clear Sky isn't a good guy" proudly.
I find it hard to forgive Clear sky. He kicks out his own brother He leaves his son. And kills a bunch of cats because of "territory" and so called "danger". The only danger was Clear sky himself. Clear sky knew he was doing something bad but he kept in going until he got caught red handed (or red pawed). I don't like Clear sky and I'm sure I'm not the only one
Clear Sky is a jerk. he is plain out rude and he literally kicked his brother out of his territory. he wanted more territory and kicked his clanmates out when they needed him most. Take Frost for example, when Frost got that burn on his leg, he tried to show Clear Sky that he was worthy but of course, Clear Sky didn't care and kicked Frost out of his camp and left him there to rot. Clear Sky also took Star flower from Thunder. He also kicked his OWN BROTHER out when he fell from a tree. He is also very stupid and greedy. He just takes as much land as he can. Not to mention he also almost killed two kits when he killed their mother and lied to them about it. Even when Gray Wing helped him in the fire, he still didn't care and still was hostel to his brother. He also rejected his own son. I could name bad things about him all day.
Hate her she loved Nettletail but then was jealous of Rain because Nettletail loved him but after Darktail told her to KILL Nettletail and she was very loyal to Darktail so she killed her. I mean she killed her own love!
Sleekwhisker was awful. Just a horrid nightmare. I mean she was the first cat to volunteer in joining Darktail. And THEN she stole Yarrowleafs kits! I don't even know why she wanted to stay with Nettle and Raven! I mean, Nettle was prepared to KILL his own kits, and I am sure that Sleekwhisker eventually had kit with Nettle. She's just SOOOOOO awful! And I'm sure if she ever DID have kits she wouldn't even care about what happens to them!
Horrible cat. I hate her for what she did to Needletail, and for literally joining Darktail without a reason. She literally gave herself a warrior name.
She's so evil. First as Sleekpaw she joins Darktail's rogues and plots against the clans. Then she gave herself a warrior name and turned Violetpaw in for trying to put Darktail to sleep, then helps Darktail drown Needletail for Voiletpaw's punishment. Then, she goes to SkyClan and begs for sanctuary with Yarrowleaf. Then she puts Yarrowleaf to sleep, steals her kits, and betrays the clans.
I hate Ashfur. Like bro don't tell the whole four clans a secert about Squirrelflight. Do u want your clan to fall apart? Also, just because Squirrelflight loved you for like half a moon, and then became mates with Brambleclaw, doesn't mean like you had to threaten "her kits". Lastly, he was a terrible mentor to Lionblaze, and he was always in a bad mood. So, I HATE ASHFUR!
(SPOILERS FOR TBC)
Okay so this guy was like a side villain for the first books in the series. But ever since the Broken Code rolled around he has become so much more, well, EXISTING. This guy literally trapped StarClan and took over the Dark Forest, that's gotta count for something.
I LOVE ASHFUR. Stupid Hollyleaf killed to to 'protect' the secret, then let it out herself! I have a feeling she wanted to do that so she could make horrible things happen to Leafpool who gave her whole life for those kits. I hope she's on the hated warrior cats list. Ashfur was heartbroken! He truly loved Squirrelflight and she basically dumped him like that. How harsh! Ashfur had suffered enough already with his mom being killed by dogs and I remember his sister got sick a few times so he had her to worry about as well.
My point is that Ashfur is a great warrior and is always overlooked and underestimated. He should not be on this list.
I think Ashfur is misunderstood. With Squirrelflight.. He only started that fire because he loved her but she didn't love him back. Back just think if Squirrelflight just chose Ashfur then the whole Fire wouldn't have started
For the one who said that he killed Scrouge so he is bad, don't kill me, but Scrouge was 6 years or something according to the wiki. Not 6 moons. Just years. And, if you say that Firestar killed many villians so he is evil, Feathertail is evil because she killed Sharptooth. Longtail is evil since he killed a random Dark Forest tom. Gray Wing is evil-he killed One Eye. See? Maybe being evil could be good if they are evil.
When you think about it, Firestar is evil. DON'T YELL AT ME YET! He killed an apprentice. It was a young apprentice too, or knowledge shows that. And a tiny apprentice. HE LOOKED LIKE A KIT, WE KNOW THAT MUCH. Firestar murdered him with a cold heart. You may wonder who I'm talking about. Scourge. Yup, he was a young apprentice with no battle experience that killed Tigerstar... GARY STU! I still think that is just on how he fights and other than that, he has no points where he's a gary stu. Firestar is the worst!
What you're the worst. Firestar is my favorite I need you to die now ok bye cause you will die and go to dark forest Firestar is not a villain he never killed anyone unless they were evil. I hate you. He had a good reason to kill Scourge even though I love Scourge. Whoever put this on, GO DIE IN A HOLE
Nope, I don't see this. Just to get this straight, FIRESTAR IS NOT A VILLAIN! Whoever thought of this should be sent to the Dark Forests. Sure, he got mad at Bramblestar and Squirrelflight, but IT WAS A PROPHECY. Why can't you understand that? He was told that his daughter and his enemy's son would DESTROY THE CLANS. He had all of his rights to freak out. He saved the forest, like, a million times, and sacrificed a ton of his lives for OTHER CATS. Why do you put so much thought on the few small things that he did wrong? Focus on the other, humongous, things that he did to save ALL the clans, not just his own. HE IS FRICKIN' AMAZING!
Snowtuft was in Omen of the Stars. He almost killed Ivypool.
No one likes a bully. Socks is too easy of a character to hate- along with Ruby-, and I seriously do not like him. Although Scourge did bad things, it probably wouldn't be as bad if his siblings didn't bully him. Just like with Thistleclaw and Tigerstar, it wasn't Thistleclaw's fault entirely, but he definitely didn't help.
Okay, people, Ruby is nineteen here. Socks did everything beside her. So if ruby is a culprit, so is socks.
He also made Scourge/Tiny run away from home and became evil!
Socks was part of what made Scourge what he was.
Him to Smokepaw in the ShadowClan camp ruins: I'm not going to let you die!
Him to Smokepaw who fell from the cliff: He's dead already! We r not going to save him!
Now don't get me wrong. He was partly right here, and even that I hated him for killing Stonefur, it was mousebrained Tigerstar who ordered Blackfoot. I mean, he isn't the most evil one.
Is everyone just going to vote for someone because they killed a cat?
That means Lionblaze should be on this list.
Back off! I care about him! I hate Firestar!
I don't care if he killed Stonefur.
Why does everyone hate him for killing Stonefur.
We barely know him!
Nobody screamed over Russetfur's death like that.
And you can't just say,
"I won't kill Stonefur because I don't wanna."
And your leader is Tigerstar!
And Sol? Does anyone hate Berrynose and Poppyfrost for believing that Sol rescued their kits?
And is not believing in StarClan necessarily a bad thing?
-Iceshard of ShadowClan, proud fan of Blackstar
I hate how everyone was just fine with him being leader when he supported Brokenstar and was one of the reasons why Stonefur died.
Appledusk was not evil! He had every right to blame Mapleshade for the death of his kits, because it was her fault. It was her fault for trying to take them across a river during a storm, when she could have easily just went through Fourtrees. He even admitted to his leader that he had broken the code, and proved himself loyal to his Clan. He wasn't a jerk for rejecting the cat that caused the death of his kits, and there's nothing wrong with him taking on another mate. He risked his life defending Reedshine, and stayed loyal to his Clan. Yes, he didn't get punished like Mapleshade did. But he was NOT evil, and Mapleshade deserved what she got.
This guy is a jerk! He cheated on Mapleshade, and blamed her for their kits drowning, when they were trying to get to RiverClan. He said he loved Mapleshade, and then turned around and backstabbed her!
He rejected Mapleshade when he said that he loved no one else but her...
THEN Mapleshade went into RiverClan and caught him cheating on her and rejected her in front of everybody!
he CHEATED on mapleshade with reedshine while she had 3 KITS! and when mapleshade tried to be with him, appledusk REFUSED to love her mapleshade was still morning the loss of her 3 DEAD kits he is the main reson mapleshade turned insain . Appledusk needs to be in the darkforest with mapleshade he is the MAIN reson 3 cats are DEAD .
RAINFLOWER IS THE WORST CAT WHO EVER EXISTED! It's really hard to find someone who would stand up for this cat, and for a good reason. Rainflower hated Crookedstar because he broke his jaw, he wasn't in control of that! People call Mapleshade the only female warrior cats villain, but they've forgotten about Rainflower, so Rainflower, don't say you've never won anything, you've won the worst mother ever award.
I'm surprised that Crookedstar never turned evil. She's Lizardstripe of RiverClan, at least Brokenstar was not Lizardstripe's real kit. She never deserves Crookedstar and Oakheart. Fade away Rainflower!
Rainflower was by far the worst parent in the entire series. She disowned her own son, favored her other son, and basically neglected Crookedstar for his whole life until she died. I'm quite glad she died, and I'm glad she didn't give Crookedstar a life. Though I hope she tried to make amends with him when he died and joined StarClan. The worst thing a mother could do to her child is neglect it and make them feel like s/he isn't going to do well in life.
No words for how horrible she is. Shell heart was right to leave her, Shellheart, Crookedstar and Oakheart deserved so much better.
I hate Pinestar. he is half of the reason Tigerstar is like this. He was so scared that he would lose his last life that he gave up his life, left his clan, mate, and kits, and became a KITTYPET. He also technically killed Moonflower.
Actually, Pinestar was encouraged by Goosefeather, who began panicking in the middle of camp, surrounded by warriors, saying that WindClan would destroy them and they needed to attack WindClan first. The ThunderClan warriors agreed enthusiastically, and Pinestar was basically forced to go by his own warriors. He was also told by StarClan in Goosefeather's Curse that he should always listen to his medicine cat. The only thing that Pinestar did wrong was leave his Clan to become a kittypet, which caused his son Tigerstar to want to prove that he wasn't a soft kittypet like his father. But all in all, he wasn't an evil cat, only made a few mistakes during his time as leader.
If he hadn't left thunderclan, Tigerclaw wouldn't have felt he had to prove that he wasn't like him, and would've not been so ambitious. He wouldn't have let Thistleclaw twist his mind, and he wouldn't have attacked Scourge. Scourge and Tigerclaw could've both been good cats...
Pinestar basically killed Moonflower! Of course he's evil! He made his clan raid the medicine cat supplies! Hawkheart used that fact to kill Moonflower!
Slash... Slash..! Slash..! SLASH! I HATE THIS FRICKING CAT! He kidnaps Star Flower, starves her when she is expecting kits, steals prey from all the groups making them starve, telling them that they have to starve to save Star Flower (not literally) tells Frog that he doesn't get any prey because he didn't steal enough prey, only gives the good prey to his best friends, doesn't lift a single claw to help his cats when Red Claw accidentally leads dogs into the camp, kidnaps Black Ear because he is Gray Wing's son who he somehow hates now, almost lets the KIT get hit by a monster and then...! I'm done ranting on this cat. There is too much for me to say. NEXT!
He is vicious, he kidnapped Star flower. and when the dogs attacked he didn't lift a claw to help.
Slash really should be higher up, after what he pulled with kidnapping star flower and totally starving his group
Slash worked with bone
She did ally with Tigerstar because she was afraid he would kill her (I think). She also probably didn't want her territory taken away although it did any ways.
Leopardstar isn't evil, just kind of strict... In a way. She just wants what's best for her clan... I think.. I don't really know much about her...
What your saying Sandstorm22... here is what I have to say
She was afraid to tell Stonefur not to kill Featherkit and Stormkit and let Blackfoot kill him because she saw that Tigerstar would kill anyone who disagreed with him in the past.
And she did not send greystripe away! Greystripe just knew he was loyal to ThunderClan!
Leapordstar didn't tell stonefur not to kill graystripes kits when tigerstar told him to and sent graystripe away.
People hates Hawkheart only because that he killed Moonflower. If Spottedleaf was in WindClan, born more earlier, was meddie in there and killed Moonflower, would you hate Spottedleaf? It was Goosefeather who sent Moonflower to death. Oh yes, this is against a code. He's a codebreaker, now I can't defend him anymore. Kick this guy out, Ashfur and Hollyleaf!
Hawkheart did what was right and defended his clan. Also, don't pull that "he could have gathered more herbs in the future" crap on me. At the time of the battle, it seems that leaf bare was happening (or already started). So, if Hawkheart were to let Moonflower steal Windclan's herbs, it would have weakened or killed many warriors or kits and would have caused many things in the future to be different. Let's be honest here. Would we have cared as much if it were a side character that had died instead? Sure some people would have been sad but we wouldn't have cried and cried. Also, in Yellowfang's secret, it says that Hawkheart was trained as a warrior before choosing the life of a medicine cat. His instincts to protect his clan would have kicked in, like when Yellowfang jumped into the rat fight in the Carrionplace. I feel like Bluestar's Prophecy was meant to portray Hawkheart as a bad guy. In all of the other books he is just seen as a grumpy but admired cat. He was very kind to ...more
He isn't evil. He was defending his herb storage. Every cat knew that Hawkheart was a warrior-turned-medicine cat, so she shouldn't have even risked going into that den to destroy the herbs, knowing Hawkheart was a formerly feared warrior of WindClan. Besides, he's a nice cat. He was really nice to Yellowfang when she became a warrior-turned-medicine cat. He went to Starclan anyways, he did no wrong.
Hawkheart IS EVIL! And I don't think it says anywhere that he went to STARCLAN! And it's against the warrior code to kill! To the person who said he trained as a warrior first, it doesn't matter! It is still against the warrior code to kill, warrior or not. You could have wounded her badly, but not killed her! He is also pretty rude.