Most Evil Warrior Cats

The Top Ten
Tigerstar Tigerstar is a villain in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. Son of Leopardfoot and Pinestar, former mate of Goldenflower and Sasha, and father of Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, and Tadpole. This brown tabby cat almost causes the downfall of the clans. But is killed, firstly by Scourge, more.

Okay, Tigerstar, we get it, your evil. We also understand that you hate Firestar because he was part of your exile. We definitely understand that you want your revenge on Firestar, but CHILL! What's the point of recruiting countless cats to kill off the clans who did absolutely NOTHING to you. Oh, and don't EVEN blame it on anyone else, Tigerstar. You chose the path that led you to where you are now. This is why your trapped in the dark forest and why Firestar killed you.

Okay, ONE Tigerstar shut it and deal with life your an overgrown kit no one can deal with your sad situation your a FRICKIN BULLY, I hate you SO much like ok, ok, you don't like Firestar. PS: I thought you were a good little kit till I saw how Thistleclaw trained you, then an explosion happened and all the GOOD molicules in your brain blew up,. So only bad one's were left. I agree with Skycloud, BUT something I never understood is, why on the freaking earth did StarClan give him his 9 lives?! " Because they wanna make things INTERESTING" Hmm, okay! Was it interesting for our dear Stonefur? Nope. We'll just get his opinion on Tigerstar in StarClan. I'm super annoyed cause no one did ANYTHING. NOTHING to deserve your absurd cruel treatment. AND OH HAWKFROST, evil runs in the family.


Honestly, I think Tigerstar wasn't that evil. True he did murder many cats to go rise in power. But he gave his son 2 chances. Also maybe the reason why he was evil because he was influenced by Thistleclaw being his mentor and Mapleshade helping him go into power in Shadow Clan. Tigerstar is just a warrior who just wants power and pure-blooded warriors. Nothing more.

Tigerstar is definitely the most evil cat ever. He was willing and wanted to kill his own leader so he could control the forest. The most frustrating thing about it is he pretended to be all nice and loyal and it drove me INSANE that Bluestar actually trusted him and that Fireheart and Graystripe were the only ones who knew the dark truth. Everybody trusted Tigerstar before he led the attack, even Bluestar refused to accept the fact that Tigerstar betrayed her. She was shaken to the core and, because of Tigerstar, she was mentally unstable until her death. And all of that was for nothing after Fireheart drove him out because he regained all his popularity in ShadowClan and became leader there! And for a while, all the Clans except ThunderClan trusted him.
I'm glad Scrouge killed him he deserved a death as awful as that.

Brokenstar Brokenstar is a villain character from the Warrior Cats series. He is a dark brown tabby tom with a bent tail and orange eyes. Brokenstar was a former Shadowclan leader and a member of the Dark Forest. His mother is Yellowfang and his father is Raggedstar.

Of course, most people think Tigerstar is the most evil. But we never got to know what MADE Brokenstar evil. If he was born pure evil, Then he is probably definitely more evil than Tigerstar. But, at least Tigerstar never tried to train kits and send them to battle at a young age. At least Tigerstar didn't exile his mother and refer to her as a rogue. I mean, he didn't know she was his mother, but doing so left Runningnose to be the Medicine cat, a cat who can't cure his own cold. He also steals kits, even though it's completely unnessary. He was the cause of young Badgerpaw's death, and the deaths of so many countless cats, from all over the clans. Yellowfang was right to feed him deathberries. If any cat is the most ruthless, evil, heartless, and souless cat, it's Brokenstar.

We get that Brokenstar is evil, but I feel like part of it is Lizardstripe's fault. She didn't want another kit, but WHO says you NEGLECT the kit? But overall, Brokenstar was a total piece of fox dung. I mean, who trains kits at like, 3 moons, trains hem so ard that they DIE, chases out another clan, trains cats to KILL, starved their own clan, and stole kits from another clan. I mean, that's a little too much. Look at all the other characters who never knew their parents! Their fine! They never turned evil (Well, y'know, other than Tigerstar, but that's a separate story)

He is my favorite character so far. He should be the evilest because he was born evil. Sure Lizardstripe was his foster mother but he still killed his father and he knew. He is heartless to not caring about other cats. I feel bad for him though because he died stupidly 2 times. The only problem with him he is too evil. If he did of little compassion I would've liked him more.

Brokenstar is C R A Z Y! He tried to train kits to fight. He was the cause of many kits deaths. And when two kits were found in the woods, he blamed Yellowfang, the medicine cat for murder! And he kicked his own mother out of the clan even if he didn't know she was his mother, but still.

Scourge Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series . He's the leader of BloodClan . He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin . One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth .

I thought he was cool. The way he killed Tigerstar just seemed like it really fit him. I also think it's funny that cats thought the dog tooth on his collar was a trophy for killing a dog but in reality he was trying to rip his collar off with a dog tooth but instead the tooth got stuck.

Alright, testing, testing. I HATE SCOURGE. I mean with Ruby & Socks hadn't bullied him he wouldn't be this way but they did! Who wears dog teeth as a trophy! And his progress is made of lies " The only way to survive is too lie" He says! Okay two, TIGERSTAR GOT KILLED BY HIM, so thanks for that y'know. I cracked up when Firestar killed him. But I was watching my old friend from StarClan then.


Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series . He's the leader of BloodClan . He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin . One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth .

Scourge wasn't evil, he was doing what wa right to survive, he was only defending himself, Tigerstar, HIMSELF, challenged Scourge, when Scourge defended himself by killing Tigerstar, Firestar attacked him and he defended himself and attacked Firestar! He was only rude to Ruby and Socks for treating him the way they were when he was a kittypet. There, my point proved.

Hawkfrost Hawkfrost is a villain character from the Warriors series. Hawkfrost is a brown tabby tom with ice-blue eyes. Hawkfrost was a former Riverclan warrior and member of the Dark Forest.

Hawkfrost was power hungry from the start. When the all the clans but Riverclan were weakened due to twolegs, Hawkfrost wanted to claim the land for his own clan. He never liked Mistyfoot (Mistystar) and wanted to replace her as deputy. Honestly, Hawkfrost, where in the name of all the warriors in StarClan is your brain? Why reclaim land that has no use? Why try over and over again to get Stormfur and Brook out of RiverClan? Why try to kill Firestar (See book 6 in The New Prophecy)? Why train more cats in the dark forest and attack the clans? Honestly, Hawkfrost, if you were patient, you could have achieved what you wanted. But nah, your mouse-brained. This is why Brambleclaw killed you twice.

HE is just sooo terrible! I really don't knwo why he decided to follow his father! althought I found out hawkfrost did regret following his father.

I love Hawkfrost and think he should be 1st, though, is he really evil? Most of what I’ve read was him being manipulated by Tigerstar and his past, from the death of Tadpole to the distrust of Leafpaw (Leafpool) for being Tigerstar’s son, yet I’ve never seen Brambleclaw being judged for who his father was

Don't send me hate- but I actually think of Hawkfrost as a cat who was persuaded into evil- I feel like he never wanted to be apart of it but was forced to by Tigerstar

Mapleshade Mapleshade is a character in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. She is a tortoiseshell she-cat with a white tail and mistakenly described as ginger-and-white.

Mapleshade totally deserves to be number 1. She killed at least four cats by herself, possibly more, and killed many others through Tigerstar, Scourge (because of what Tigerpaw(star) did to him, and through all the other Dark Forest cats during the Great Battle. She made Crookedstar leave his mother to die, lured Twolegs toward Willowbreeze, and manipulated so many cats. She what she wanted, and she knew how to get it. Tigerstar only got any power because Mapleshade was instructing him. She’s more evil than any other cat in the books. She is more worthy of the top spot than any of these other villains.

As much as I love her, you gotta admit she was pretty twisted. I've only read up to Omen of the Stars, but she sounds pretty evil. She tried to kill Sandstorm and ended up killing Spottedleaf again. Mapleshade isn't the most evil, but she definitely isn't undeserving of the dark forest.

I'm trying to stay calm... I can't take it anymore! SERIOUSLY? Driving her out? What about Graystripe and Silverstream? Bluestar knew he was in love with a Riverclan cat, and didn't vanished him! But Mapleshade? Let me take a moment to make a trantrum... Ok I'm back. Not to mention they drove out her kits! Thunderclan is evil, like if you agree. It's against the Warrior Code to not harm a kit, EVEN IF IT'S FROM A DIFFERENT

I feel sorry for Mapleshade just a little bit. I mean, she was kicked out of Thunderclan for mating with a Riverclan cat and was forced out of Riverclan because her mate blamed her for drowning the kits. Then again, she manipulated Crookedstar to get revenge.


This kind of cat is not the most evil but I don't like him duh ALSO I saw someone post that Darkstripe killed Needle but NO It is darktail Actually so you can start developing new hatred(?) toward DarkTAIl and DarkSTRIPE

One of the most hated cats. He doesn't even try to lead! He is a coward! He just sucks. He is a villain, though no more than tigerstar.

He wasn't that bad but I do think that he wasn't a good cat either SPOILER!. For one he was on Tigerstar's side when they attacked the camp. Second of all, he left his clan and fought Firestar when BloodClan attacked.

*SPOILERS! * When I read the part where Darkstripe killed Needletail I threw the book across the room (thank goodness it didn't break... it was a library book 0,0) I know it seems mean, but I really hate him...


Darktail is the best villain that you could ask for! He's super smart and cruel. Darktail isn't the out front mean cat like Tigerstar but he's alarmingly calm. The creepiest villain in my opinion is the ones who give the calm threats with malice.

He played everything as smart as anyone could. He drowned so many cats and drove out SkyClan. He killed Onestar and captured almost all of RiverClan and took over ShadowClan. Also why are people voting for cats just because they killed their favorite character.

Darktail is EVIL! Tigerstar took over Shadowclan and Riverclan, but he made them join forces. Darktail took over both those clans too, but just destroyed them both! He destroyed Skyclan, but then, when he found out Onestar wasn't there, he just abandoned the territory he took, just to find his father. But then he kept PRISONERS! He basically tricked kitty pets into joining them, tricked half of Shadowclan into joining him, and drowned any cat who did the simplest act of disagreeing with him. He didn't get defeated until all 5 clans worked together to drive him out. Tigerstar was killed by a rouge. Brokenstar was killed by a medicine cat! Mapleshade died of wounds from an apprentice! SERIOUSLY! He is the NUMBER 1 villain of the warrior series.

Yes, finally Darktail is in top ten. He should have been introduced earlier in the series, because tons of people have zoned out of the books by AVOS. (If you ask me they should have turned POT and OOTS into one arc and have AVOS as the fourth. But he was a great villain as leader of the rogues, and his obsession with Violetshine was creepy. He was the focus of half of AVOS, more than scrouge, who only appeared in one book, not counting the manga. Also he needs a novella, if Mapleshade and Tigerstar get one, so does he.


Thistleclaw was the cat who taught Tigerstar the meaning of cruelty. But you've gotta admit, the whole cause of him turning evil was Snowfur dying. If she didn't die, then he wouldn't be evil. He's not as bad as Mapleshade. He's about equal. They both lost what they loved and ended up turning evil over it.

In Crookedstar's promise we found out that Thistleclaw was training in the dark forest. He convinced his apprentice, the soon to be Tigerstar to never be soft on any cat. He also tried to get Bluefur to stay away from Whitekit.

I mean..he's not too bad, but he trains in the dark forset! I simply I hate him bc bluefur was trying to keep to the warrior code, she can't even go near her sisters kit! -treewhisker

Okay, settle down... this is going to take a while...

For one, Thistleclaw did not make Tigerstar evil, Goosefeather saw evil in Tigerstar when he was still a kit. He was simply an evil cat, nothing to do with Thistleclaw.
Also, it's not Bluestar's fault Thistleclaw was evil. Your girlfriend's sister not liking you doesn't give you the right to turn against everyone that loves you, everyone you grew up with. Bluestar also didn't chase Thistleclaw into the dark forest. That was a joke the authors made up.
Thistleclaw had no reason to be evil. He trained in the Dark Forest in Spottedleaf's Heart and chose to stay there. Don't make the excuse that he lost his mate and sister. Look at Crookedstar, he lost his mother, his father, his mate, his kits, and his brother. And yet he still stayed loyal to the end.


Sol nobody wants you here. First, you flip ShadowClan upside down and they don't believe in StarClan anymore, then you leave and come back, stir up some trouble between ThunderClan and WindClan, so that they'd go against eachother. Sol, do me a huge favor, and go find a hole to die in.

Sol is ok.. I mean, he stopped shadow clan in believing in StarClan, and that’s when we have a problem. Not to mention he caused a few deaths.

Sol stole Leafstar's kits! Just to prove he can be a warrior! He totally can, but breaking the warrior code is not a way to show it! Who agrees with me?!

If you read sky clan comics you'll understand this persons opinion he was a kittypet once named Harry and one of leaf stars kits were named after him but at the end of the first comic he says his name is Sol it was a big shocker but I totally understood the cat looked exactly like him! I've never read the other two comics but if you've read eclipse and long shadows you find out he was banished from sky clan and wanted revenge for every clan and the warriorcode! And he also made Blackstar believe that starclan was just a bunch of dead cats! :-O how could he! But seriously after Jayfeathers, lionblaze,tiger heart, flametail, made a fake starclan sign, Blackstar believed only because real starclan cats came to make a big finally! Blackstar then vanished sol and he was never seen again until the forgotten warrior! :-/ Sol just keeps on coming! He actually made thunderclan believe he saves two kits from a creature! But it wasn't him who did it -)! SPOILER : it was actually hollyleaf! She ...more


He killed Spottedleaf in cold blood for Frostfur's kit, followed Brokentail(Star), I'm extremely glad that he got killed by Graystripe( Fire & Ice). Probably not believing in StarClan because he would either be in StarClan or the Dark Forest, but no, they don't mention him at ALL. He's the evilest guy ever, SPOTTEDLEAF


Clawface. Killed. Spottedleaf.

He's legit evil. Why is he never mentioned in the dark forest? How is he not mentioned in StarClan or the Dark Forest? Does he not believe in StarClan? *Gasp*


Clawface brakes into thunderclan camp.
Clawface tries to steal babies.
Spottedleaf tries to stop him.
Spottedleaf dies.
Claw face takes the babies.
Thunderclan gets the babies back.

I hate him because he killed Sppotedleaf and when Firepaw tried to kill him in ShadowClan camp Whitestorm said that warriors don't kill, and I was really mad because Whitestorm stopped him. SO I THINK THAT HE DESERVED TO DIE

The Contenders

Bone is pure evil! He literally collected claws from cats and teeth from dogs. He deserves to be in dark forest for his bloody actions, Maple shade killed to avenge her kittens. Bone doesn’t deserve to be in StarClan. He died because of apps so he can learn his gory actions from the past.

He nearly killed Violet and Barley! He also killed Whitestorm! WHY WHITESTORM?! He is legit the Cat Of Cruel! He so doesn't deserve to be in StarClan! Also, HE FOLLOWED SCOURGE!, I hate, hate, hate him.


Bone was so cruel. Bad deeds: Following scourge as his second in command, nearly killing barley and his sister violet, killing whitestorm, and killing many other cats. Bone deserved to die in the paws of the apprentices.

Killer of Whitestorm. Whitestorm was the best. Even in the darkest times, he was calm. He was loyal. Then a craphill came in and killed him. Bone deserved to die under the apprentices paws.

Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He's mates with Sandstorm and has 2 kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. He was formerly a kittypet named Rusty.

Nope, I don't see this. Just to get this straight, FIRESTAR IS NOT A VILLAIN! Whoever thought of this should be sent to the Dark Forests. Sure, he got mad at Bramblestar and Squirrelflight, but IT WAS A PROPHECY. Why can't you understand that? He was told that his daughter and his enemy's son would DESTROY THE CLANS. He had all of his rights to freak out. He saved the forest, like, a million times, and sacrificed a ton of his lives for OTHER CATS. Why do you put so much thought on the few small things that he did wrong? Focus on the other, humongous, things that he did to save ALL the clans, not just his own. HE IS FRICKIN' AMAZING!

GAWD FIRESTAR AIn't NO villain. by the way he was only mean to Sqiurelflight and Brambleclaw in Moonlight because HONESTLY, "Fire and Tiger will destroy the Clans" OF COURSE HE'S GONNA FREAK OUT. THE CLANS THAT HE WORK SO HARD TO PROTECT. how doesn't getting scared that somecat is going to destroy your home make you EVIL? Firestar is literally the bravest, most noble cat in the Warrior series. It doesn't make sence that people see the leader of ThunderClan, who literally stopped Tigerstar from slaughtering everyone, be evil, like BRUH.

Every body. Let's make it clear. Even though Fire was kind of a goody-goody stuck u I'm-so-great interfering furball, HE IS NOT EVIL HE IS A HERO NO MATTER HOW HE CAN BE ANNOYING

What the heck! Does the person that made this have a brain!?! And so sorry if anyone found that part mean :) He's a hero. I can't believe it!

One Eye

He was so cruel for killing Tom when he was just defending his daughter. Also why was he going all out on battling a kit which he shouldn't really be fighting anyway.

He was one of the worst villains ever. He took over the whole forest and tried to kill a kit. He killed Tom because he was trying to defend his kit. He slashed his mark into every cats paw pads and used his daughter to get information from Thunder. He was EVIL through and through.

In my opinion, One Eye should be closer to the #1 spot. He's far more evil then Clawface or Darkstripe, that's for sure. He killed Tom when he was defending his kit, whom he also tried to kill. He was partially the reason why Petal died, indeed leaving Birch and Alder without their mother. He banished Clear Sky from his group, and marked an eye on the cat's paws, claiming them his. Kind of like a slave in my opinion. He was greedy for power and the control over Clear Sky's cats.
Clawface killed Spottedleaf and was one of Brokenstar's followers. That's bad, but not as bad as what One Eye did. Darkstripe wasn't technically "evil". Though, he did feed Sorrelkit deathberries and betrayed his Clan.
Even Bone. He was Scourge's dirty follower and killed Whitestorm, but we don't know if he killed anyone else. I think One Eye was much worse. And no offense, but people think these cats should be in the top 5 because they killed their favorite character(s).

He's in Dawn of the Clans, so most of you don't know him. But he's so evil, that he kicked Clear Sky out of his own clan, killed Tom, nearly killed Sparrow Fur, and put his mark of a single eye on innocent cats, making Snake betray his group and made Petal die, leaving Birch and Alder without a mother. And, thanks to his daughter, Thunder, Cloud Spots, Pink Eyes, Lightning Tail, and someone else I don't remember left to create a new group. So, if you think he is something to forget, then I'll make his dead spirit haunt you in your dreams.


She's so evil. First as Sleekpaw she joins Darktail's rogues and plots against the clans. Then she gave herself a warrior name and turned Violetpaw in for trying to put Darktail to sleep, then helps Darktail drown Needletail for Voiletpaw's punishment. Then, she goes to SkyClan and begs for sanctuary with Yarrowleaf. Then she puts Yarrowleaf to sleep, steals her kits, and betrays the clans.

I have sympathy for this cat. She was born during a time when all of the apprentices were rebellious, and she went through a lot.

Sleekwhisker helped Darktail, who also drowned the other cats!

I thought she had completely changed when she went to join SkyClan. WRONG!

Clear Sky

I hate Clear Sky so much! I mean, he kicked out Jagged Peak and Frost, he was so mean to his own son AND to Storm, his own mate. And poor Falling Feather and Quick Water. I'm only on the third book but I feel sorry for them. And I don't care if he gets any kind of redemption, I will still hate him! How does any cat in his camp even like him?! Without him, the mountain cats would all live in peace! I think Gray Wing should never have given him a second chance. And I mean, why does he care so much about stupid boundaries?

I HATE Clear Sky! When Jagged Peak fell out of a tree and got injured, the stupid furball kicked him out! Jagged Peak is his own little brother that he kicked out! Clear Sky also basically took over the forest and kicked out of killed cats who were already living there before him! He wouldn't take his OWN son in his camp until Thunder grew older and Clear Sky took him. Then he kicked him out (basically Thunder left)! He almost killed two kittens! He is only cared about boundaries and stronger cats! He doesn't care about them when they're injured or weak! Clear Sky (I think) said that he doesn't have any brother or something like that..! He kicks out injured cats! He's just a stupid and I mean STUPID FURBALL! But on behalf, he was just afraid of losing someone he moves and he became greedy. But still..

People say he changes after Path of Stars, but that's not true. Moth Flights Vision comes after Path of Stars, and Clear Sky denies WindClans access to herbs on his territory. Because of his arrogance, Micah was killed. And oh, I forgot to mention that he murdered Misty, the mother of two kits. And Bumble, an innocent kittypet. Oh, and he exiled cats, not just any cats, but his own brother. And every cat he had as his mate, they were stolen. Gray Wing loved Bright Stream, Clear Sky got to be her mate. Gray Wing loved Storm, Clear Sky got her. Thunder loved Star Flower, and you know who got her. Also, after he murdered Misty he was about to kill her newborn kits! And Rainswept Flower, one of my favorites, was killed by him! His last words to her were : "I'm not greedy. I'm just strong." And when his mother, Quiet Rain, came to visit him, I enjoyed seeing her saying all those things to Clear Sky. Oh, and also Clear Sky rejected his son and tried to kill is brother. He is horrible and ...more

Too strict about his stupid boundaries. He doesn’t even let medicine cats get herbs! And don’t forget he rejected Thunder and killed Misty and was about to kill her two defenseless kits.


Snowtuft was in Omen of the Stars. He almost killed Ivypool.

Snowtuft was an evil lier

Snowtuft just seems.. cool

stop it just stop


No one likes a bully. Socks is too easy of a character to hate- along with Ruby-, and I seriously do not like him. Although Scourge did bad things, it probably wouldn't be as bad if his siblings didn't bully him. Just like with Thistleclaw and Tigerstar, it wasn't Thistleclaw's fault entirely, but he definitely didn't help.


Okay, people, Ruby is nineteen here. Socks did everything beside her. So if ruby is a culprit, so is socks.

He also made Scourge/Tiny run away from home and became evil!

he always agreed with ruby, witched made scourge evil!


I hate how everyone was just fine with him being leader when he supported Brokenstar and was one of the reasons why Stonefur died.

Get Blackstar off this list now or consequences happen. He was frightened when he killed Stormfur! I mean, what would you have done if you were being tortured with decisions by a cat like Tigerstar?! I cried when I found out he was dead. Now get him off the list.

Not evil. Just a bit devastated, he only believed Sol bc he thought starclan wasn’t watching over him. Thanks to Flamepaw Dawnpaw and Tigerpaw, plus Hollyleaf Lionblaze and Jayfeather. They made him believe in starclan after setting a fake sign that turned into a real sign. He’s honestly one of my favorites.

I AM HERE TO SAY THAT BLACK IS NOT villain. 'K he Killed Stone which I liked him and was quite upset when he died. But Black suck as warriors not leader.


Ashfur needs to cry himself a river, build a bridge, and get over it! Just because squirrelflight rejected him for Brambleclaw doesn't mean he should try to kill Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf. This guy is just being oversensitive. But I still think death wasn't the only way to shut him up and not tell the secret

I LOVE ASHFUR. Stupid Hollyleaf killed to to ‘protect’ the secret, then let it out herself! I have a feeling she wanted to do that so she could make horrible things happen to Leafpool who gave her whole life for those kits. I hope she’s on the hated warrior cats list. Ashfur was heartbroken! He truly loved Squirrelflight and she basically dumped him like that. How harsh! Ashfur had suffered enough already with his mom being killed by dogs and I remember his sister got sick a few times so he had her to worry about as well.
My point is that Ashfur is a great warrior and is always overlooked and underestimated. He should not be on this list.

Ashfur tried to kills three cats from his own clan all because Squrrielflight would not be his mate. Then now he steals Bramblestars body tried to kill the real Bramblestar kit. He sent like the whole Thunderclan into exile and almost killed Tigerstar's the 2 kit.

I mean Ashfur had quite a sad life really. He wanted to be Sqiurelflight’s mate but she went with Bramblestar. Then, to get revenge, he said he would kill her kits which weren’t really her kits. I actually think he should of went to the place of no stars though I do fell quite sorry for him.


He was part of the reason Mapleshade was so vengeful. I don' like him or Reedshine. I know Reedshine didn't do anything wrong but she was still annoying. He cheated on both of them. But he has a cool name, I'll give him that.

What I am gonna say is that he is loser, sucker, traitor, and cold heart dude. I hope he goes to dark forest and suck. Poor mapleshade, poor kits. He chose to turn his back on mapleshade because he is just a coward!

yes! Appledusk is a huge jerk. He could have saved Mapleshades kits but he let them drown because he liked Reedshine (My least favorite character) So he is pretty much evil.

He is the reason mapleshade went nuts and also the reason several other cats died. He deserves to be called evil


Rainflower didn't really love Crookedkit after his accident. She completely ignored him and paid attention to only Oakheart. If Rainflower had simply been kinder Mapleshade wouldn't have caused the deaths of so many cats

I literally was crying when I read about her. She was a horrible, disgusting mother to Crookedkit when she should have cared for him and cared ABOUT HIS LIFE. I feel like screaming when I think about the cruelty she treated her PERMANENTLY INJURED kit with and need to walk away so bye.

MEAN Crockedstar (hint I can't spell) would not hurt siverstrem or her kits (fethertail & stormfur) Rainflower= mean, no heart I had to look up how to spell heart-Eve p.s. Firestar is not evil SCREW the list

I hate that she hurt crookedkit! renaming crooked kit was very sad. (I cryed 4 times of the part in crookedstars promise) -treewhisker


It was evil of him to just take Starflower to his camp and then let her starve when she was expecting kits and he starved other cats and when te dogs attacked he didn't even help fight them off and he said that his cats were all so weak and not betle-fit

He is vicious, he kidnapped Star flower. and when the dogs attacked he didn't lift a claw to help.

This guy needs to be closer to the #10 spot

He is just plain evil...


If he hadn't left thunderclan, Tigerclaw wouldn't have felt he had to prove that he wasn't like him, and would've not been so ambitious. He wouldn't have let Thistleclaw twist his mind, and he wouldn't have attacked Scourge. Scourge and Tigerclaw could've both been good cats...


Actually, Pinestar was encouraged by Goosefeather, who began panicking in the middle of camp, surrounded by warriors, saying that WindClan would destroy them and they needed to attack WindClan first. The ThunderClan warriors agreed enthusiastically, and Pinestar was basically forced to go by his own warriors. He was also told by StarClan in Goosefeather's Curse that he should always listen to his medicine cat. The only thing that Pinestar did wrong was leave his Clan to become a kittypet, which caused his son Tigerstar to want to prove that he wasn't a soft kittypet like his father. But all in all, he wasn't an evil cat, only made a few mistakes during his time as leader.

Pinestar basically killed Moonflower! Of course he's evil! He made his clan raid the medicine cat supplies! Hawkheart used that fact to kill Moonflower!

Uh... Pinestar isn't really evil... But maybe he caused some of Tigerstar's fury



now I don't like leopardstar at all because I read a shadow in riverclan and when there was the flashback tigerstar told stonefur to kill featherpaw and stormpaw but he begged leopard star to do somehting but she said ( he is your leader stonefur do as he says ) and when he refused darkstripe and blackfoot killed him!

She did ally with Tigerstar because she was afraid he would kill her (I think). She also probably didn’t want her territory taken away although it did any ways.

Leopardstar isn't evil, just kind of strict... In a way. She just wants what's best for her clan... I think.. I don't really know much about her...

Leapordstar didn't tell stonefur not to kill graystripes kits when tigerstar told him to and sent graystripe away.


Hawkheart IS EVIL! And I don't think it says anywhere that he went to STARCLAN! And it's against the warrior code to kill! To the person who said he trained as a warrior first, it doesn't matter! It is still against the warrior code to kill, warrior or not. You could have wounded her badly, but not killed her! He is also pretty rude.

I HATE Hawkheart! He should be so much higher on this list! Cats shouldn't kill. Even if he was defending his herbs, he didn't have to KILL Moonflower. It isn't ok to ask Goosefeather if he killed someone, even if he was joking. Also, he was rude at Featherpaw's ceremony I think. And is was Shrewpaw's fault as much as Moonpaw's for arguing. And he was super rude to Bluestar when she was an apprentice.

I HATE HAWKHEART, he killed Moonflower without mercy! Next time can the medicine cat stick to helping cat's heal? Also ya guys he's PRETTY rude I must say

He isn't evil. He was defending his herb storage. Every cat knew that Hawkheart was a warrior-turned-medicine cat, so she shouldn't have even risked going into that den to destroy the herbs, knowing Hawkheart was a formerly feared warrior of WindClan. Besides, he's a nice cat. He was really nice to Yellowfang when she became a warrior-turned-medicine cat. He went to Starclan anyways, he did no wrong.

8Load More
PSearch List