Most Overrated Rock Ballads

And it's a awful cover of a good ballad

Indeed it is. Just listen he sings "Oh Beth what can I do". Sounds like he has a cough.

It's a terrible cheesy song. I hate everything about it. I've never understood why so many people like it... Incredibly overrated.

The Unforgiven is on the same album, and I personally think that song is the better ballad.

In Fact this might be their worst ballad because almost all the other ones are better

It is not Metallicas best song and its not even their best ballad

Most Overrated Song on Vol 4 its not very good

I guess I can agree with this but it's still a very good song nonetheless.

This is the greatest song of all time so no

Anything that gets praise off this album is overrated and this was the best song on that awful album at best the song is medicore

Its only overrated on TTT's list. Usually this songs is not on every list of best rock ballads. At least not in top 10.

Even if it is one of their only good songs still its overrated

Oh yes this one is also very overrated

Why out of all the songs on Death Magnetic this one gets the most praise