Scariest Animatronics In Five Night's at Freddy's

Bonnie isn't scary he (and pretty much every other character that's in good condition) just acts creepy. Can you imagine SpongeBob or dora the explorer wandering around your house at night and trying to kill you? The animatronics are scary because they twist on how we believe they should act. They act in ways the human brain doesn't comprehend which makes them somewhat frightening but at the same time not. Bonnie perfectly examplifies that. This list should be called creepiest five nights at freddy's characters. We might have more candidates that fit the role that way.

The first time I saw him he was pretty scary but the more I followed the game I got accustomed to him and the rest. But yeah he does seem quite scary, I mean even the creator himself admitted he was scared of him. But there's still one question left unsolved... Why do people find it creepy that Bonnie has no eyebrows, or even anyone without them for that matter?

In the First FNAF Bonnie is scary mainly because of it's lack of eyebrows, but in the second game, the lack of the entire face is what makes Bonnie not as scary as say, Freddy (because that's who scares me most in the second game) I would like to imagine who Bonnie would look like if he had an actual face, probably a lot scarier than the original or the toy.

BONNIE IS A BOY

In my opinion, Foxy is by far the scariest of all the animatronics. He is fast, creepy, and he is always out to kill the nightguard. In joy of creation, he always creeps right behind you with his flashing white and red eyes. He is different from the other animatronics, which makes him even more deadlier. He does not go easy on you, as he forces you to check on him and his curtain in the first game in order to stop him from sprinting down the hall at an abnormal speed and then poking his creepy face into your office, letting out a earsplitting shriek. Never underestimate Foxy the Pirate, because he will just keep on surprising you...

Foxy is the only character that you can see moving. He comes out of the Pirate Cove and sprints to the West Hall. He is more difficult than the other animatronics because he moves very fast and when you see Foxy running down the West Hall, you have to close the door before it is too late. - TheCoolMinecraftApoclypse

What if wrong with loads of you people? It's so obvious that foxy is is trying to kill you in the second game! He's set to be friendlier on the first game because of the bite of 87 happening in the second game because the second game is a prequel! He leans in because he's been set to be friendlier which explains why he's not as nice when he kills you is because the bite of 87 had not yet happened! God damn it, some of you are dumb!

Because he's a pirate

Golden Freddy, you have to wear a mask. He can teleport in your office and he just stands there for like 4 seconds! It is said that if you see him, put on your mask/ look at the camera because he will go away. Oh yea, & when he attacks you, he crashes the game!

I think he is, by far, the scariest character in the first game. His dead-eyed appearance and the way he just appears in your office is really unnerving, and then that terrible distorted roaring sound when he's all up in your face...

Yeah, the way he appears in your office is terrifying. Especially because none of the other characters does that. (Except when they attack you) - timelordgaia

Golden Freddy not only crashes the game but he has the most terrifying laugh. You know why? Because he's possessed by the crying boy he chummed on in the "87 Bite". He's a rich and creepy character.

Crashes de game people

Though the other animatronics are all creepy in their own ways, mangle would have been scary even before he was ripped apart by toddlers. Now he's just a convoluted spider like thing, with two heads that is able to travel along the ceiling like a spider. Considering that his jumpscare is extremely unpredictable, it's a wonder how he is deemed less scary that bonnie and foxy.

It's basically a messed up spider. I hate spiders. The simple fact that they can go on walls, and possibly drop down onto your head terrifies me. And the only ruminants of his original body is its face, and it has the extra head!

Sure my first jump scare by Bonnie in fnaf 1 did make me and my brother scream, but Mangle has given me more heart attacks than any other. She has no timer for her jump scare, she can stick to the ceiling at 1 am and attack you at 4. Your almost never ready for it. And her design is straight up crazy. I always wanted a animatronic like this. I REALLY don't see why everyone is scared of Foxy, Mangle destroys Foxy in this list.

I do not think mangle/toy foxy is that scary yes she is token part and put back together incorrectly but that’s the stupid kids fault she would have been the same as the other toys but no it’s all the kids fault but mangle is still as beautiful as she was

In every game his jump scares are terrifying and always scare me. In the first game when the power goes out the screen goes dark, his face glows and his jingle is played. Then, if you're unlucky enough and just miss out on finishing the night, he will jump scare you! Also, he has another jump scare in the first game where he creeps in the office (when you're normally trying to find him or someone else) and then from behind gets in front of the night guard, eyeless (with just a tiny white dot) and jump scares you from really close up!

Freddy the Fazbear? Who the hell wrote this?

Out of all jump scares in the first game Freddys is scarier. It's so unexpected, not the power outage but from night three and onward. I HAVE figured out a strategy to keep him on the stage but there is no denying that I almost needed to buy a new pair of pants before I figured it out.

He is scary probably one of the scariest

Creepy...

Nightmare looks like a mix of shadow Freddy and shadow Bonnie with the body of golden Freddy

He is the " not so nice versing of Fred bear

Why did scott make this...

Look guys, he is by far the scariest. His creep qualities are second to none. Not even Nightmare Fredbear, who is second. Fred bear is not as scary only because he’s not black and doesn’t fit with the background (cause he’s yellow and yellow is bright) and in my opinion fredbear is more expected. NO ONE EXPECTS NIGHTMARE. And he’s always switching from one hall to another. All of the animatronics have lackluster creep ability compared to nightmare. DID I MENTION HIS VOICE IN ULTIMATE CUSTOM? Creepiest voice on the roster(even fredbear, who is second again). He stares at you from the right side like a demon, not the scariest appearance but still creepy and demonic. Definitely the scariest! “The sun fears me...”

Like golden freddy, but with teeth everywhere. Nightmare fuel!

I used to think all the characters were cute. But the rows of teeth kind of got to me. I really like all of the animatronics. Until I saw him on the internet... But I just love fnafs games. Great job Scott!

The Games Out Dude

Literally, look at his face(es)! He is a beastly killer and will smash your face! 🐻🐻🐻

She scares me I mean THREE ROWS OF TEETH WHAT THE HECK

HEY SHE GIVES ME NIGHTMARES THREE ROWS OF TEETH

She can sometimes cause me to stay awake at night for this reason:

She seemingly shares a link to the boys mother in a horrible way and these are the reasons why:

She is the only Nightmare Animatronic that carries equipment (a horrific cupcake that will maul you to death) The cupcake is food, Obviously

She goes in the kitchen where food is. Now FNaF4 is a Nightmare right? Why the hell would she go in the kitchen for, (yes it's a refrence to FNaF1 I understand however)

She is also the only female animatronic in FNaF4 excluding the halloween edition.

Heres what creeps me out: The mother in FNaF4 is not present at all. Mothers in a general sense will be the one who prepares food for the family. Mothers are naturing.

Nightmare Chica to me seems to be disturbingly smart in the fact that she takes the idea of what a caring mother will do for there chilid and transforms it into a upside-down representation of the boy's mother by offering him food ...more

Very well-said. I definitely agree with your views, and it really is disturbing seeing a formerly, seemingly welcoming and hospitable character/persona being twisted into such a horror. - SwiftFox777

This thing is scary as heck. I'm surprised he's not higher on the list. He scares me the most!

Dude this guy creepy as heck just look at his body

Nightmarionne has that grin that says: GOODBYE SUCKER.

This is like an upgraded puppet. I have a funko figure of it. It's so cool, but it cannot stand up.

Ennard is quite a scary character, especially based on the fact that he uses manipulation and impersonation so frequently to lure you into a false sense of security while he manipulates other animatronics. He is an amalgamation of everything bad and scary, and wants revenge and to escape. - SwiftFox777

It would make a better nightmare with a few changes because it did gave me so scared that I can't even stay outside in day light

Mad scary and it's ending gave me nightmares.

I don't know why, but Ennard never really scared me. I guess it's because I find his nose cute?
I really have no idea.

(The only thing scary about him is that he follows you home and he's hard to beat)

This version of Foxy wasn't all that disturbing to me until I found a fan made script of something he might say. Something along the lines of "You will feel pain and suffering for the rest of your pathetic life... both seconds of it." Creepy.

All those sharp, and pointy teeth. RETURN TO A PLUSHY!

He's so terrifying. The original foxy may be my favorite but the nightmare version is SCARY!

I love his pointy feet

I'm not scared of withered bonnie I just feel sorry for him/her. R.I.P face

He looks scarier WITH his face

Faceless Faceless FACELESS! And I did not put Springtrap and Toy Bonnie on here beacause they are BARLEY scary

I think he's scary because he has a rusty face and his jumpscar can be deserbing

He's a version of chucky, I mean, hand him a knife and it would be complete

He looks like he stares at you while you are asleep that's just wrong on so many levels

Plushtrap scares me. I'm like! Even though plush trap may be cute but he is so scary

He's adorable- not scary.

Mr funny guy

Think of the cutest thing in your childhood. A pet hamster, a teddy bear, your baby cousin... Now imagine them coming to life and trying to turn your veins into guitar strings. Now you see why Toy Bonnie's on this list?

Just... Look... Stare for ten minutes and tell me he isn't SCARY AS CRAP! - EchoTheKiller

He's kind cute, maybe even girly. He's a bit creepy, but nowhere near as creepy as old Bonnie.

He is my BABE.And when I mean babe I MEAN BABE! And his jump scare just says " I AM HOME HUG ME! "

He is very scary and sometimes he doesn't breath at all

The animatronic that kills me the most... I one was at the door, and I didn't hear breathing, so I shone the light, and just as I shone it Bonnie started breathing and killed me. I had my volume very high as well.

sum times

How the heck does nitemare bunnie even breath does he have lungs or sumthing

It's so scary when you crawl through the ballora gallery and when you see the light of the door you see ballora's legs go past. Oh, and her jumpscare is pretty terrifying as well.

Probably the creepiest she littaeraly creeps the @&$&$#%out of me

SHE IS SO MESSED UP

He destroyed other animatronics and killed night guard to kill more and more as purple guy

She doesn't even have one

She (just triggered a bunch of people) is the only one that actually scared the living daylights out of me. That opera singing bastard is terrifying! Oh and she said girls can wear bow ties. Just to let you know.

Just saying,it’s a boy cause Foxy’s a boy and all so...FUNTIME FOXY’S A BOY! WHY DO YALL THINK It's A GIRL!

Shadow Bonnie is the scariest for me because of the lack of defining facial and bodily features. I mean, she only has eyes and a mouth, which are colored bright white (lots of contrast). When you're looking around in a dark place, she can appear ANYWHERE.

In five nights at Freddy's 3 if you are playing on a iPhone once you finish the fourth night you play as shadow Bonnie and when you move you twitch which freaked me out so bad

The only one who has ever given me nightmares!

This thing is scary. I mean, it just crashes your game when it disappears.
(No jumpscares.) What is the truth of this thing? oOShadowbonnieOo
is a mystery.

Oh my god he is terrifying I mean None of these characters are too scary (for me) and this did not give me nightmares but he is still the creepiest

...Mommy? Daddy? Somebody?

His Hands Are Creepy

He's the least terrifying, I'm afraid.

Even the original BB is scarier. - KennyRulz244444

What the Dark Forest? Of course, she DOES kick butt on the Hunger Games simulator for some odd reason.

Who the heck added him to the list?! You can't even see him!

Why is this even here? - GentleTrouter

WHY THE HELL IS HE ON HERE NIGHT GUARDS ARE SCARY?

What why HE'S THE NIGHT GUARD WHY