Top Ten Mario Characters that Need More Development
Maybe different-colored Toads could at least have distinct strengths and personalities. Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time and Bowser's Inside Story featured a few more interesting examples, but they were only present for a fairly short time. There's no reason not to expand such individual traits to other Mario games as well.
I really love Toad, but I'll admit that he barely has any reason to be in every Mario RPG. Make each color a bit more varied in style. Green Toads could be faster, Blue Toads stronger, Red Toads smarter, etc. Or simply give him different clothes.
Replace half of the Toads with Toadette. Toadette specifically could benefit from having her own game. Maybe Mario could rescue her for Toad, as Bowser learns of the Super Crown's powers and thinks Toadette would be an easier target. She could send letters for help.
It's sad that she's becoming the new Rosalina. At least Rosalina wasn't a damsel in distress and had a huge backstory. Toadette is bland, and she's often portrayed as a damsel.
Like Toad, Toadette hasn't shown anything that stands out from the other characters, despite becoming a part of the main cast.
Mario's character is in the same vein as most of Nintendo's protagonists. He's heroic, bland, and wants to stop the evil person. He's just the same as Link and Kirby.
Give him an anger streak or make him a bit more nonchalant. In Bowser's Fury, he didn't want to help Jr. and wasn't fazed by Bowser's yelling.
Ironically, Mario is probably the most underdeveloped character, because all I know about him is that he likes to jump... a lot.
I wish there were more games where she's playable and has a major part in the story that isn't centered around being saved by Mario. Thousand-Year Door, Super Paper Mario, and Super Princess Peach (all of these games are considered spin-offs) showed that Princess Peach has potential. However, we don't see this in the main Mario titles, which is kind of disappointing.
Despite being the main girl, Peach is almost a bland character. The only thing we typically see is the classic princess who gets kidnapped by a monster and is saved by a plumber. Nintendo should focus on other things, like exploring her powers or creating another game like Super Princess Peach.
Daisy debuted in Super Mario Land in 1989, after few other appearances she disappeared for nine years until she was brought back in Mario Tennis (2000).
Daisy... read more
She's a tomboy who is sporty and sassy... even though Peach is also sporty and sassy just as often. Her only real character trait is being a tomboy and loud. Mario Strikers 3 could probably help, as that was when she had her most defined characterization.
They should kill her off in Luigi's Mansion 3 so she can finally develop into something different than Peach 2.0, and so they can finally stop forcing her into everything.
Now, I know that being a tomboy is rare for a princess. Tomboy princesses like Daisy, Alena, and Lucina aren't very common in video games. Still, we need to learn more about Daisy's life in Sarasaland.
Pauline was the first lady not only of Mario games but for Nintendo in general. Despite this, today she's too bland and unoriginal. Originally, she was called the Lady and represented a real lady without any particular traits. She was only kidnapped over and over by Donkey Kong and never really shown a personality.
Yup. We know nothing about her because Peach, Daisy, and Rosalina are all in the spotlight more.
Put him at #1 now. This guy needs a story behind him. Why is he here, what does he want, and what is he even capable of?
He's part of the main cast, but we don't know anything about him - probably because he was created to be Wario's tennis partner.
Duh! He's been in nothing other than spinoffs, and he's basically a poor man's version of Wario.
Nintendo didn't even fully confirm the gender. Enough said.
We know a lot about his background, but can he just get a unique personality or something?
Bowser Jr. did get a lot of character development in Super Mario Sunshine, and we know his character motivation, so he doesn't really need to be on this list.
I thought Bowser Jr. was cool, but I just realized Nintendo is making him the 8th Koopaling. We need to see more unique things from him.
Bowser's Fury is on the right track to making him a more enjoyable character to talk about.
Why do so many people on this site hate Rosalina so much?
I knew those Rosalina haters would come here. Idiots.
Here's why: Baby Daisy was created as filler, just like Baby Rosalina, and this isn't helpful for character development. However, unlike Baby Rosalina, she doesn't damage Daisy's character. In fact, she basically confirms that Daisy knew Luigi and Peach since they were babies (as hinted in Mario Super Sluggers), so we can definitely expand on that.
She was just thrown into Mario Kart 8 without any background or buildup. If Nintendo made another game where Peach was playable and she could use this form, then we might be able to see what potential it actually has.
Make her an evil Peach. I don't know.
I hate Diddy Kong. They should give Candy Kong a chance - he always gets in the games, and it's not fair.
Make him a goofy villain who will still crush you if you underestimate him. He'd be similar to how he was characterized in the Mario & Luigi series.
A weird example, but he hasn't appeared since the DS era and deserves to be a Wario antagonist sometime, considering he captured him.