Top 10 Worst Warrior Cat Characters

Me: And the winner for dumbest mouse brained fox-heart of all time...Tigerstar!
Tigerstar: Thank you, thank you. And perhaps our little Firestar here *waves his tail at Firestar who's in the audience* will win the most mouse-brained and weak leader ever award.
Firestar: *Growls*
Me: Knock it of Tigerstar.
Tigerstar: You're almost just as weak as Firestar, Firemist, if that's even POSSIBLE.
Me: Well that's just sad 'cause if the Faded Dark Forest EVER hears that you've been beaten in battle by some weak female Firestar, they'll NEVER let you hear the end of it.
Tigerstar: Is that a challenge?
Me: Duh.
Tigerstar: *Yowls and throws himself at me*
Me: *Kicks him away and slashes his muzzle* You can't forget that FIRESTAR is the reason you're in the Faded Dark Forest. And soon, you'll have to join the Faded Faded Dark Forest because of ME.
Firestar: Yeah! *Fires (oh, no pun intended) a blow a that sends Tigerstar skidding*
Me: Well I guess he won't be ...more

Tigerstar truly is one character I love to hate.

From his terrible treatment of Ravenpaw, to the innocent warriors he's killed, he deserves to be number one on this list.

And yes, I can already hear the fangirls and boys screaming "he's just misunderstood' but that doesn't excuse what he's done. You wouldn't forgive Hitler if he had a tragic, heart-breaking story would you?

Decides, even if you try to say that his evil roots stem from his training in the Dark Forest and Thistleclaw, remember that he wasn't forced into anything. He chose his own path, just like Crookedstar, Ivypool and Bramblestar did. (and they turned out reasonably good cats)

I LOVE TIGERSTAR. The top comment is cringy and stupid. He actually has character development and is a great antagonist, is strong, and though evil, loves his kits and mate, making it a little confusing. Y'all just love Firestar, and I admit I do too, but you only read the first series. Tigerstar is amazing.

I can't bel that bluestar picked raven paw to be Tigerstar's apprentice Tigerstar wanted to kill him and the whole hurting tiny/scourge was dumb Tigerstar is not loyal seriously he killed redtail, swiftpaw, brindleface, runningwind and then making it so it looked like it was whitethrohgt. and somehow he became shadow clan leader. And the whole creating TigerClan was pretty stupid and he said that he and leopardstar lead it and he ended up just pushing her to the side. he also tried to make stonefur kill graystripe's kits when stonefur didn't he made Blackfoot do it. And he technically killed himself when he harmed tiny because tiny held a grudge changed his name to scourge then came back and killed Tigerstar. The most annoying part is he doesn't stay dead.

At first she loved Stormkit as a mother should, but then when his jaw became crooked she didn't care about him anymore and changed his name to Crookedkit and for what? To make him even more embarrassed about his jaw even more? I mean what kind of mother does that? She only pampered him in the beginning because he was a good looking kit and when he wasn't anymore she just neglected him. He became a pretty good warrior later on but his mother still neglected him because he wasn't pretty enough, I mean come on! I think being a good warrior is much more important than what they look like!

What the Erins said or ' Weird Warrior Cats Facts' I found out Rainflower was abused as a kit. That makes her an even WORSE character! Why abuse your own kit if you've been abused yourself! She only things she cares about is looks. I am GLAD Shellheart broke up with her! She doesn't deserve his love, or anyone's love for that matter! Is it also wrong that I sorta laughed when she died in, 'Crookedstar's Promise? I was actually really happy she was killed off, but not happy that others that Crookedstar loved. She renamed her kit because of his looks. WE should rename her something more nasty. How would you like a taste of your own medicine,Rainflower?

I honestly think that Rainflower never deserved to love. I mean, it was well known that warrior queens loved their kits MORE THAN THE WORLD! They would sacrifice their lives for their precious kits, just like what Silverstream did, dying to give birth to her children. Queens even pushed to have a code, because they didn't want their children to go through the horrors of the world at a young age. And then to have a mother turn down her kit, just because of his physical scars, is just cold hearted. Rainflower then added to his internal scars, turning her back to him in times of need, when his own clan seemed to cast him out. Crookedkit didn't even know what had happened to him, and it only adds more to the pain. She then demanded for him to be renamed Crookedkit! Did she even realize how much this must have broken his heart?! Rainflower is truly an evil soul, who does not deserve to love.

Dearest Rainflower, You caused Crookedstar to take Mapleshade promise. Only to make you proud of him again. Rainflower, Crookedstar could have been the father of a wise cat named Whitestorm if things had worked out. But you would never approve. Perhaps your other son would live to see his grand son become deputy. You needed to work on your motherly love. Sincerely, Bluestar. - A note from Bluestar to Rainflower.

Had his personality tossed aside for the sake of plot. Does anyone really think he'd possess anyone like that if they hadn't taken it away? Seriously, he may have threatened her kits. But he never came off as a cat who would do that.
The only reason they threw him in was to appease the crowd. Seriously, it'd be considered 'bad' if the impostor had been someone else.

Ashfur is himself, I absolutely hate it when people compare him to other cats, I mean like, guess what? He's not a reincarnation of Thrushpelt, and so even though he COULD'VE been like him, he chose not to, and then he's not like Mapleshade since not only did she also love too much, but she also despised two of the clans. Also, my point wouldn't be that "he loved too much" even though that's partly true. He tried to let Squirrelflight know how much she hurt him when she straight out said "I don't love you". She could've said it from the beginning that all she wanted was a friend, and then Ashfur could've been more aware of it before it became a solid thought that he loved her. Ashfur thought that the only way to make her feel the same loss he felt was to take her loved ones away. At least he didn't kill any of the cats though he tried to, so it's not as bad as Mapleshade's case, in which she DID murder a cat, more specifically, a medicine cat.

I really don't like him AT ALL, PERIOD. You could tell Squirrelflight just wanted a friend while she was waiting for Brambleclaw to come back. Look guys we all have to face the ugly truth that Ashfur sucks! I don't hate him I just think that he was stupid to get in the way of real love to have Squirrelflight to himself. Especially if Jayfeather Hollyleaf and Lionblaze were her kits he would of killed them, then Brambleclaw then Firestar Sandstorm Leafpool. And anyone close to her so that she could suffer what he went through? Squirrelflight never loved him he was just a friend. I'm glad Hollyleaf killed him before he COULD do something evil.

Sorry not trying to be snappy just saying my opinion!

Poor Ashfur. I don't know why people HATE him so much if Scourge's behavior is acceptable just because he got bullied. To be honest, Ashfur's behavior isn't entirely his fault (not saying what he did is acceptable though). His mother died, his dad doesn't even talk to him, his sister barely interacted with him, thanks to weirdo Dustpelt. Brambleclaw was busy, and Squirrelflight is the main source of his obsession, making it impossible for him to avoid her. And without support, he has this heavy weight of obsession, slowly sapping his sanity. And the last straw is Brambleclaw. He snapped, and tried to kill them. Still not saying his behavior is acceptable, and he didn't love Squirrelflight. It's just obsession.

Ok, ok, ok. Let's be fair! I don't like Millie and I am a gray x silver shipper but I want this to be a fair debate between myself and myself.
1. The tunnels
After blossom fall came home from being trapped in the tunnels Millie snapped at blossom fall saying briar light could do better. Yeh I know Millie is obsessed and always worried but I think it's the same with every parent with a disabled son/daughter. I know this because of my family. Millie does over worry about briar light but I do think blossom fall just needs to get a grip. It's also the style Erin's have written this. Usually warriors don't spend much time with their parents which is why this plot confuses me. I think Millie's words from the tunnel incident were inexcusable though!

1.Why is everyone so upset that she never took a warrior name!? Daisy and Brook didn't, so why should Millie have to?
2. Why does everyone say she's a"Silverstream replacement"? Does that mean Leafpool is a "Feathertail replacement"?
3.If there is a reason to hate Millie, this is it. But wouldn't you be upset if one of your children was hurt by a tree? And yelling at Blossomfall was NOT right, but Millie was heartbroken! And it says in the Warriors Wiki that she wanted to spend time with all of her kits and not just Briar.
4. Hating Millie just because Graystripe was with Silverstream first is childish. Graystripe never said he hated your precious Silverstream, and he needed to move on sometime.

2. Millie's name. No cat knows this strange she cat who just appears at a gathering with gray stripe. She stands back a bit and let's the cats greet gray stripe. She seems like a good cat who makes an effort to be a warrior. Hunts, fights, then had three kits which you all know who they are. I think lots of people were bothered when fire star gave her a warrior name and she refused. That one sentence changed my view a lot in terms of her commitment to thunder clan. Unlike being a kitty pet being in a clan basically means your life is serving your clan and if you can't commit yourself enough to change your name then it's a bit- I can't find the word. Ever since then cats would always know that see used to be a kitty pet. Aaaa! I know it's her choice but it's just easier to go with the crowd especially being new and different. She he stubborn and causes a lot of disruption to her ceremony.

Millie is not a cat to be hated on at all. In fact, she is one of the most loyal warriors and mates out there. She bore beautiful kits, was kind and sweet to her mate and Clanmates, was determined to leave her own life just for her mate's safety, happiness, and devotion. She saved Graystripe's life and never thought of her past life once when she joined ThunderClan. The only dislikeable feature she has is how she became way overprotected of one of her kits, which I don't blame because one, I'd probably go crazy if my kit were paralyzed in a tragic event and needed a little extra help, and two, her other kits were adults, so they could care for themselves just fine. Millie may not have shown it, but she still loves and cares deeply about all of her kits, and she is really proud of them. You can't dislike her because she became mates with Graystripe. She made him happy and knew that he needed love in his life again after losing his mate and being lonely for so long. Just because she did ...more

Hollyleaf is the best warrior ever! I'm not stupid- I know about all the bad things she did, but you are missing the point of the part where she came back. Not many cats would have the courage to came back when there is a chance that no body would like them and they wouldn't be accepted. But Hollyleaf did because she was determined to do the right thing even after she had done the wrong thing. She admitted her mistakes and apologized for everything and wanted nothing but forgiveness. Most importantly she realized that all she really needed was right there all along- her family including leafpool loved her and Hollyleaf did all she could to shoe she lobed them back

Hollyleaf was always one of my least favorites. Everyone's hating on Dovewing so much, but in my opinion she was a good cat. She used her powers to save the clan from the falling tree, and the beavers. While she was doing that, Hollyleaf was hiding in the tunnels because she was too scared to face the fact that she broke the warrior code. Obsessing over some code was plain annoying. Squirrelflight cared for her like a mother. But then Hollyleaf decides to be a brush-off and say you're a pathetic liar. And then, when she finally admits she kills Ashfur, the clan is like, "don't worry, you did us a favor, he was evil." The other cats didn't even know if she was telling the truth or not. They just went along with everything. She didn't even have to kill Ashfur! She killed him so he wouldn't betray their secret but then tells it during a gathering anyways?! That doesn't make any sense. So for all of you that hate Dovewing, look at Hollyleaf. She is 100 times worse!

I'll admit, there are some things I like about her, but when it comes down to it she did a lot of terrible, cowardly things, and her story wasn't even completely resolved as Brambleclaw lied for her and made Ashfur's death seem like an accident. It wasn't - Jayfeather saw her memories of stalking him and biting into his throat! She also had flashbacks about the same thing in her novella. So I don't believe she's fully redeemed as long as her Clan thinks she didn't even do it on purpose, which she totally did. Also, she wasn't "cast out," she CHOSE to leave because she couldn't face up to everything she did to her Clan. She abandoned her brothers during the most trying time they had faced up until that point, leaving them to deal with the aftermath of what she'd done. And she only came back because Lionblaze saw her. She also had a SCARY over-the-top obsession with the Warrior code; she scared her brothers several times with her intensity. People claim she was "just being loyal" but no ...more

She may not be as evil as some of the others on this list (she isn't a villain at all), but her character development was unbelievably sloppy. At first, I sort of did like her, although her constant obsessing over the Warrior code was a little annoying. But after she discovered the whole thing about Squirrelflight not being her real mother, her behavior grew quite stupid, to say the least. Even the other characters pointed it out: why the heck would she kill Ashfur to keep a secret, then reveal the secret herself? And after she returned from the underground caves, her personality did a total one-eighty. She went from whiny, fanatical zero to sad, lonely hero far too quickly to be realistic. Overall, she had a lot of potential as a character, but lazy writing ruined her. Perhaps she would have made a fascinating villain, however.

I understand where people are coming from when they say he wasn't evil, just arrogant, and it wasn't his fault Tigerstar become evil. But it was. In Bluestar's Prophecy, Bluestar sees some of his training sessions with Tigerstar, and Tigerstar wants a clean session, and Thistleclaw keeps pushing him in the wrong direction. And as a cat as young as he is, he is easily influenced easily. Besides, no one could've though he was that important if Bluestar chased him out of StarClan, and no one went looking for him. He also fought for the Dark Forest in the Great Battle.

Thistleclaw never really did anything. He followed warrior code, he was very loyal, and wanted to defend his clan. Tigerkit was born cruel and would turn out the same with or without him as a mentor. Tigerpaw attacked Tiny himself, Thistleclaw didn't tell him to attack him and he didn't attack him himself. Bluefur was the one to break the warrior code, and she hated him from the start with little to no reason. He had his mate killed, and his kit taken away from him. And when he finally went to starclan and was happy for several moons, Bluestar can rushing in and chased him off to the Darkforest.

I personally did not believe he was such a bad cat till I read Spottedleaf's Heart. To be honest, I thought he was ferocious and violent cat, very ambitious and rebellious, but not anymore than that. Here's why:

Thistleclaw is NOT to blame for Tigerstar's actions in my opinion. Thistleclaw trained him to be ferocious and strong, but it was Tigerstar who had dark ambitions of ruling the whole forest with pure blooded cats and make himself king of literally the whole forest. Proof: his idea of pure blooded cats and his execution of all of them came from his deep hatred for his father turned kittypet. Also, his desire to become king of everything comes from a deep narcissism that Tigerstar had since his childhood.

Thistleclaw was a bad cat. He was violent, did not listen to anyone but himself, and he was arrogant and jealous. But he did not do anything wrong. He did not commit any crime. He trained Tigerstar to be ferocious, but any cat who is ferocious is not necessarily ...more

Thistleclaw should be first because Tigerstar might have been good without Thistleclaw. And I think Bluestar lost 3 of her lifes because of him. I think without Thistleclaw two cats wont be evil. In fact one of them might have never been born. (I'm talking about Tigerstar and Hawkfrost) And without Thistleclaw Scourge probably would have never went to the forest. Heck Scourge wont even be evil. The only good thing that he did was having Whitestorm with Snowfur. I personally love Whitestorm.

This one was bad from the beginning. Sure, he felt depressed and alone, and very angry. I can appreciate that. The thing is, dude, he needed to learn to move on with his life. Lizardstripe hates you? Your siblings reject you? Well, you have the elders, the medicine cats and your deputy/leader who would happily care for you.

You were given chance after chance to do good, but you end up being one of the most evil cats ever known. You killed loyal warriors, including your father, in order to satisfy your ambitions. Your thirst for blood doesn't even end there. You kill kits, expand territory, expel WindClan. Then, when your finally stopped and even given a chance to redeem yourself, with cats who would actively defend you, you still screw up.

I'm sorry, you might have been an interesting character, but you're the greatest sociopath the Clans have ever known.

He's filled with hatred and rage.

I believe he trained kits to death because they represented his foster siblings for him. I think he ruthlessly murdered them to unleash all his rage and hatred on them.

I believe he also banished Yellowfang and tried to ruin her life because she represented Lizardstripe.

You remember when Brokenkit was born, Yellowfang saw an angry expression on that kit? It's because Brokenstar is literally rage fusioned in a cat. All he does is because of his rage and hatred and violent, brutal, savage ways of expressing it.

Another thing about Brokenstar. It's his lack of concern for anything. He doesn't care of his clan starves, he doesn't care of the elders die, he doesn't care about the kits, he doesn't care about anyone. That's because he's so blinded by hatred and anger that his only purpose is to torture and kill.

I think Brokenstar never wanted to rule his clan or the forest for the sake of being leader. No. I think he ...more

Brokenstar really had a hard life. He was hated on, neglected, teased and insulted by his adopted mom, siblings and Clanmates. He started off being a tiny helpless kitten who was the target of a lot of anger. He was mistreated and had to grow up not knowing who his real mother was, just like his father had. Not only that, Raggedstar spolied him and teached him to be cruel and ruthless from a very young age. I think that he just snapped at some point and believed that by wounding his Clanmates he would earn their respect. When he started abusing him apprentice, a lot of cats looked up to him and he started doing it more to other cats. He was evil and insane, but there was a good reason to it.

Okay, but seriously. How is Hollyleaf in front of Brokenstar? I've never finished reading Yellowfang's Secret, but hear me out. He killed his father for no reason other than to become leader. He also had many chances to reform, but he threw those away. Brokenstar may have been scarred, but he had Yellowfang who was always there for him, and then he just betrays her trust and blames the death of kits on her. What's worse is when he takes refuge in Thunderclan, he leads a bunch of evil cats to attack the camp, refusing to have some good in him.

This is annoying. You guys don't appreciate the best villains. In my opinion, cats who held a grudge through almost their entire life aren't that impressing. This is proof Scourge is not mentally strong, nor is he the most intelligent cat. I'm not saying he is stupid, but let's think about it: Let go of your past. What happened, happened. Don't let it change you. Don't put all the blame on Tigerstar, Socks and Ruby. Scourge could've let go of the memories, but no... he didn't! Everyone, he is NOT the strongest cat, either, physically. come on, he is a tiny cat. The only reason he beat Tigerstar is because Tigerstar fell. There was no air action. Plus, he had dog teeth attached to his claws.
By the way, "revengeful" is not a word. The correct term is "vengeful".

To be honest, I don't think Scourge was evil. He only murdered two cats, both were evil, he did try to kill Firestar, and Bone killed Whitestorm, but his cats need food, and the forest would've had great amount of resources. He shouldn't have invaded and try to take over, but he was doing it for the good of his clan. He seemed like a good leader, and he also seemed to be a prodigy. The only thing that I did not like about his whole story is that he lied his way through, he said he killed dogs, but he only scared away one, the rest of the dog teeth are from his clan cats that always brought him bones.
Anyways, he was supposed to be a villain, but with the knowledge of his story, I can see he was doing everything for his sake and his clan, he's not completely evil.

Guy's. Let me get this straight. Scourge overreacted. How would you react, or literally anyone else in the real life world, if you got bullied, people tricked you, hated you, you wanted revenge, you went out, changed your name, and wanted to join the warriors and get away from everything. NO HARM DONE! He was destroyed and ALMOST killed by Tigerstar (Tigerpaw at the time) And he wanted revenge. He was working with Tigerstar unknown to him that that was his killer (almost) he remembers, and once Tigerstar betrays, he attacks. GUYS Scourge was defending himself, and he wanted revenge. SO WOULD I! Right? Now he went into battle because he wanted the forest to himself. Well, again, he wanted revenge. He made it fair and square. He shouldn't of died. He wasn't a villain. JUST because he ended a cats life. Geez guys. Seriously?

Listen up, you Firestar loving kitty pets, because I have something very important to tell you. Scourge had a similar childhood to Firestar, even both having a similar encounter with the clans. Even fighting a thunderclan patrol after exploring. The only difference between their stories at this point is, and listen very closely, idiotic Firestar lovers, everyone loved Firestar wherever he went, his family, his friend, and even a random cat from a clan he only joined later loved him, and there was some stupid prophecy saying that fire would save the clans. Scourge? Everyone hated him, teased him for being small and weak, making him angry. The thunderclan cats who came almost killed him! Some of you may think that he was being overdramatic, but if someone teased you, laughed at you, and almost murdered you, would you forget anytime soon?

Yep. Firestar is a moron. Can I vote for this cat right here 200 times? This isn't the most EVIL Warrior Cats list, this is the WORST Warrior Cats list. As in, "poorly developed" and "way too OP." I mean, SCOURGE has more character development than this guy, and he's in one book and a manga. I'm not counting his first appearance in Bluestar's Prophecy because he gets like half a page. Meanwhile, Firestar gets a whole arc that is only his viewpoint, is in all of the books after up to Dawn Of The Clans (which is really before), and has his own super edition. Your winner of the 2003-forever Worst Warrior Cat competition: FIRESTAR! Give him a paw everybody! He wins everything else, let's let him have this.

Firestar was actually a well written protagonist... at first. He had an uphill battle as an outsider, but he proved that he had a place in the Clan through hard work. While I admit that the prophecy was a bit cliche, Firestar never pretended he was superior to everyone else because of it (a BIG problem I had with the Three), and every mistake he made had consequences both tangible and emotional. He was chosen by StarClan because he deserved it, but never let some prophesied greatness keep him from learning lessons. That's what kept him from crossing the line into Gary Stu-dom: he wasn't invincible. He screwed up, he and his loved ones suffered, but he moved on and grew as a character. It was only through faith in StarClan that he survived the fight with Scourge, capping his character arc brilliantly.
And then, the second arc happened. Then the third. Firestar become boring, and worse, irritating. His peace-seeking antics continued, but with no cost. Characters stopped calling him ...more

He is the epitome of Gary Stu. "Eh...He's not perfect...Eh...He was naive...Eh...He made some mistakes...Eh..." Yeah, that much won't stop him from being initially labeled a Gary Stu. I think the Erins forgot that it was acceptable for a protagonist to be, well, imperfect.
Anyway, though I don't hate him for being in the spotlight, I was genuinely disappointed to find out that he was the mysterious fourth cat. Not those truly deserving, I.E., Ivypool or Hollyleaf.
He has done so much to make people hate him, but the writers make a poor attempt to justify his obnoxious actions. Heck, he has no backbone! The only reason that his actions are remotely justifiable is the fact that he is the original protagonist.
Oh, well. At least he was a good character in the 1-5 books. Afterwards, his likability was demolished by the writers' awful attempt at making a flawless, courageous, noble, and virtuous character.

He's way too OP, with too much attention. Fire star gets many more books to himself than anyone else, and is in more major prophecies than anyone else. Did you ever think about his story of entering thunderclan? I thought about it, and he's really just called to the clans randomly, because he has orange fur and a 'warrior's spirit,' whatever that means, and he seems to just suddenly be a good hunter and fighter the moment he enters the clan. Has he ever done something even slightly bad that hurt the clans even the smallest bit? Not that I am aware of, because he is pure and perfect and an undeveloped character and saves the day and is loved by Starclan and I could go on and on and on, but I won't anymore because I don't want to waste any more time on this ridiculous character.

Listen: some people will hate me, and I don't give a F... Bone is the most loyal cat of all the series. He depended on Scourge. If Scourge wasn't evil (I know he is not very evil for me), Bone wouldn't be. He was just following his best friend blindly. He obeys to Scourge at everything. He is also very strong. He killed Whitestorm, a very powerful senior warrior. Bone is one of my favorites forever! Everybody loves Scourge, saying thta he was misunderstood, bullied, which is true. But Bone? Everybody hates him! Because? He killed a noble warrior. How the Dark Forest would he know that Whitestorm was "so important? " Really people? You don't make any sense and you just look for the actions the cat did before, not the cat itself. Ridiculous. And the worse? Your "amazing Scourge" couldn't do all of his plans without Bone... Think about it, and hate me, I don't care.

Bone is the best cat ever!
He's extremely loyal to Scourge and will do anything he says
I personally love all villains and antagonists
Tigerstar, Brokenstar, Scourge,...etc
They all have terrible pasts that made them villains but still most people like the " heros " or the " good guys " just because they got the prophecy and spotlight.
Tigerstar wouldn't have been evil if it weren't for Thistleclaw. Brokenstar was unwanted by RainFlower. Scourge was bullied and made evil by Socks and Ruby
They just misunderstood by ALMOST everyone,

I can put aside that Bone killed Whitestorm. Sure, I was deeply affected by his death but Bone was, in my opinion, the most loyal cat. He was just following Scourge, even when it came to killing. If he had been a clan cat I'd bet everyone would love him. Heck, even in the Ultimate Guide, on Bone's page it says "No cat could have doubted Bone's loyalty to his cruel leader, and perhaps it is a tragedy that he never had the chance to live the life of a true Clan warrior" Do I need to explain?

We didn't get very much info about Bone, so I don't see why he should be on this list. Yes, he killed Whitestorm, but we all knew it would happen in the end! We would never have a Whitestar. If anything, he is a pretty good cat for staying loyal to his "clan" and fighting alongside Scourge.
So, I can see the mixed emotions about Bone, but he is just another loyal plot character in the end and we shouldn't hate him.

Throughout several books (before The Prophecies Begin) she was repeatedly snappish and rude, and I think that she shouldn't have tried to give her kits away like that. Oakheart literally volunteered to join Thunderclan, and there were also several other alternative, and better ways that could have gone.

Where do I even star with her? I have three big problems with her.

1) She ignored Fireheart when he came to her to speak about Tigerclaw's abuse. The worst thing an authority figure could do to an abuse victim, is to dismiss them. It's hard enough for a victim to speak out about abuse but WORSE when a figure of authority, puts their own feelings before the concerns of other's. Fireheart tried to tell her that Tigerclaw killed Redtail and was even going after Ravenpaw, but Bluestar would hear none of it. It's unfathomable.

2) Her whole breakdown was just annoying. Throughout the whole arch, I was just literally hoping for her to be killed off. Her only purpose at that point, was to cause trouble by starting fights with other clans and leaving Fireheart to step up in her place. She was so utterly useless. So frustrating of a character, that I wanted her DEAD.

3) Erin Hunter went to say that Thistleclaw went to starclan (because he did give Tigerstar one of his nine ...more

There are many Bluestar lovers who hate Bluestar haters, so they are haters too and do not say that haters are stupid. But Bluestar lovers, you don't like brave Swiftpaw, poor Brightheart or cute Snowkit, YOU DON'T LIKE THEM?
There are many Bluestar lovers who wants DEATH of us (Bluestar haters) and they say that we hate Bluestar and love Scourge, Thistlclaw or Tigerstar but that is LIE!
I hate Brokenstar, Darkstripe and Tigerstar but I like Scourge because he killed Tigerstar. LOGIC.
Bluestar was O. K. In first few books but then she went mad, stupid and crazy. She was O. K. again when she dies, too late for her.

I really don't like Bluestar. She certainly was, at times, a brave and valiant leader, but at other times, she was pointlessly cruel and aggressive. Yes, she was in a poor mental state for much of her leadership, but her utter neglect toward her Clan at this time was inexcusable. Fireheart basically had to run the whole clan. One thing that always stuck with me was Bluestar highlighting Brightpaw's injury that wouldn't even have happened if it weren't for her by naming her Lostface. This is borderline abusive and destroys the entire purpose of a leader. Also, while I agree Thistleclaw was a big scumbag, especially in Spottedleaf's Heart, I think Bluestar was hurtful toward her sister in the way she complained about their relationship which Snowfur was obviously dedicated to. She painted Thistleclaw as a villain and a murderer, which was way worse than the actual situation. People seem to forget about these things when addressing Bluestat, and honor her as an amazing leader, when, ...more

I think I can understand why people get mad for chasing stormkit to the gorge but if you read goosefeather's curse... (SPOILER WARNING) It clearly states he had the power to see the future so he must have known if crookedstar broke his jaw he would have fallen in love with willowbreeze,silverstream would have been born and feathertail would've saved the clans now lemme tell you this? what would have happened if he never broke his jaw? the tribes would be doomed!

Okay Guys maybe he is the fault of Stormkit/Crookedstar but!

While others commonly medicine cats must philosophize first once felt five thousand years about the meaning of a dream, he knows immediately what it means.

Poor Crookedstar and Bluestar. If he never existed, maybe the two of them might not have suffered. His stupidity killed Bluestar's mom, and Crookedstar wouldn't have a ungrateful mom.

God I hate him, he was a stupid cat, and he made Stormkit break his jaw. He never did anything good as a medicine cat either, and he had that stupid omen that killed Moonflower.

Mapleshade's the WORST. She's sooo overrated. I mean, so what if you're the first female villain? Many queens have their kits taken, and Mapleshade doesn't have a "good" reason for murdering those cats. Tigerclawstar succeeded a bunch more, with his evil plans and everything. He killed so many more cats. Mapleshade killed only a few(I can't remember exactly). People say she haunts apple dusk's line, but I think she really only "haunted" Crookedstar's family, or it was just a coincidence. Either way, Mapleshade's way to overrated, for some cat who barely makes it into the main series.

I think Mapleshade was a mother looking for revenge over her children's death, but she turned evil, and does not deserve forgiveness. Her story was sad, she mated with a enemy, and suffered the price. I think it was wrong for her clan to throw out her kits, or her in the first place. Cats should be able to love who they truly think is best for them. Mapleshade was betrayed by her mate, and her kits were drowned. She was broken hearted, but her choice is where she went wrong. The clans broke her, she turned to killing. She killed three cats, one for each of her dead kits. She thought this was the only way to avenge her kits deaths. She had no heart anymore. She then went on to making Thunderclan and Riverclan pay. She manipulated cats to turn against their kin, their clan. She was truly evil in the end, her innocence and love torn apart by her mate, her trust torn by her clan, and her heart torn by her kits' deaths. I do not think Mapleshade deserves any pity though, it was her choice ...more

Okay. Ruined Crookedstar's life. Pretty much had Thistleclaw train Tigerstar to be evil. Basically responsible for 50+ deaths. If she wasn't in the books, then most of Crookedstar's family wouldn't have died, Scourge wouldn't have come, lots of cat's wouldn't be dead, Firestar could have lived longer (possibly), etc. etc. Oh, and Spottedleaf. I'm not even going to say anything more than that.

"I'm going to make you pay for every blessing StarClan gave you! And every blessing you stole from me! "
"You have made me a promise, and I will make sure you keep it! "
Though, she wasn't really evil, she pretty much took the wrong path, and made other cats pay for it.
"Can you imagine what it feels like? To be rejected twice? To be a loner when all you tried to do was love? "

I feel incredibly bad for Maple shade, she was a mate of a River clan warrior, then when she had kits in thunder clan and she had told them... they kicked her out... when she tried to get to River clan clan camp by going through the river (This all happened in leaf bare) her kits were washed away. When she got to River clan camp, her mate already had a NEW mate... then they sent her away, she lived a life as rouge... and was starved to death... her river clan mate was Shell heart's father, Shell heart's kit was Crooked star... so that's why when she entered the Dark forest, she set out for revenge on river clan with Crooked star... then got revenge on thunder clan by corrupting Thistle claw and Tiger star... that's why I feel bad for Maple shade... - Night blossom

Hawkheart had no real need to kill Moonflower. She was destroying his herbs, so he of course had the right to attack her, but he didn't have to kill her. Lionblaze killed Russetfur, yes, but he was GUILTY about it. He hadn't meant to kill her, and he was shocked when he found she was dead. Hollyleaf was guilty about killing Ashfur. She did it on purpose, but she was GUILTY. Was Hawkheart guilty even a little bit? It doesn't appear so. The book says NOTHING about Hawkheart appearing to feel any sort of guilt after killing Moonflower, and he even taunts poor Bluepaw afterward and says that "she deserved to die." Later, he calls her a "kit-warrior" at the Gathering. I wouldn't say that Hawkfrost is EVIL, exactly, I just really don't like him. And it's too bad... I liked him in Yellowfang's Secret. He was nice then. But I hate him now. That's my opinion.

So if you are a medicine cat, your clanmates are battling against a another clan, and a cat attacks your store. You know the rival clan started it for no reason clearly, and your herb store is precious for healing the cats injured in battle. You attack them. Yes, it's harsh to kill, but Hawkheart doesn't even really qualify as a villain. Yeah, he killed a cat, but does it make him evil? No. It was defense, not like Tigerstar's way of killing. And I was really only sad not because of the character getting killed, but because of Bluepaw's reaction. (There, not the whole nine yards one. )

You know I never like Bluestar but Hawkheart had a perfectly good reason to kill Moonflower and if anything you should all blame it on Goosefeather since he told them to battle windclan. Also there is nothing in the medicine cat code that tells us that Medicine cats can't kill another cat. I mean they do have to defend themselves which can also mean killing. Also another he went to starclan and I find that justified since he was doing what he was suppose to do. He also mentor Barkface who was a pretty good medicine cat and no one gives enough love to him...

People show favoritism for Moonflower. I'm not saying that's a bad thing. I, too, liked Moonflower as a character. But perhaps you need to think logically. Hawkheart is a medicine cat of Windclan. His clan is being attacked for, as far as the Windclan cats know, no plain reason. A Thunderclan warrior is barging into the medicine cat den. All of the precious herbs could be destroyed. Hawkheart killed Moonflower, yes, but he had a reason(He did finish her off without it needing self-defense that I'll say). Defense for his Clan is the first rule of the warrior code he wouldn't let a Thunderclan warrior smash all his herbs for pure pity that he needs to keep the peace. I agree, he needn't have killed Moonflower, but things happen. Hawkheart killed Moonflower, but that doesn't make him a villain nor a cat that should be considered evil. Although, it is ultimately one's choice.

I don't understand how Spottedleaf is terrible. She isn't a Mary Sue, she's just described as beautiful. That's all, really. And I don't think she would've gotten in the way of Firestar and Sandstorm because of these 2 reasons:
1. She is a medicine cat. Spottedleaf doesn't seem like the medicine cat that would take a mate. And I'm pretty sure Firestar is smart enough to realize that SHE WON'T TAKE HIM.

2. She's dead. Firestar isn't that stupid.

Also, since when did she only like Firestar because he was in a prophecy? She never said that directly, so you'll never know. She acted as more of a guide for Firestar than a disturbance between FirexSand. If Cinderpelt didn't get hit by a monster and became a warrior instead, I think that Cinderpelt would've been more of a rival to Sandstorm for Firestar's love! Not hating on her, though.

I think Spottedleaf is snotty and is super obsessed with Firestar (definitely not like Ashfur thank god). Ok, she likes him, so? She is just...a cat. A plain ol' cat and not like the super warriors

- Spiritstar Of LightingClan

She's clearly the worst written character in the series. Her only trait was being a pointless love interest, and that's ALL she did. I see a lot of people complaining about how people don't like her, and that's fine, you have your opinions, but I'm entitled to mine and so is everyone else.
This isn't a list for most evil, just the worst. If she wasn't in the story at all, not that much would actually change in the story. She had no major impact on the story itself. Anyone could have done any of the minor things she did(like receiving the prophesy). She had no character development, no actual flaws, and was only there for unneeded and unimportant drama with Firestar, and minor, unnecessary cameos in the rest of the series. She is by far the least interesting character to read about(in my opinion). I truly don't like her character in the slightest, but I respect that some people do.

OMG she is the worst!
Spottedleaf may be a pretty cat, but geez, leave Firestar alone! He doesn't love you, and he never will! Not only that, but Spottedleaf is a HUGE mary-sue! In Spottedleaf's heart, she knew SO much about being a medicine cat, even though she had no training whatsoever. When she died, it was basically like she was still here, because she would not stop bothering Firestar. She'd show up in his dreams and be like: "hey something's gonna happen" and then he'd be like: "what?" and she'd be like "byyyye." Like, geez! Also, she ruined Leafpool's, and more importantly, Squirrelflight's life by not being clear about the whole Crowfeather or Clan situation.
She is an overrated, sickly-sweet smelling, stalking, PLEASE GET A LIFE cat.

I HATE Squirrelflight! She was so rude and stubbon towards Brambleclaw at the star of the new prophecy. She picked fights with everyone over tiny things! For some unknown reason Stormfur had a crush on her for a while! She broke up with Brambleclaw only because he was TALKING to his BROTHER then Ashfur fell in love with her and she stabbed him in the back, came crawling back to Brambleclaw, stabbed him in the back by pretending that he was Jayfeather, Hollyleaf and Lionblaze's dad. Then Hollyleaf murderd Ashfur and almost died trying to escape ThunderClan and you know what? Squirrelflight became deputy!

How can you hate Squirrelflight? She let Ashfur down

As gently as possible and she didn't cheat on Bramblestar or anything. She's fiery and intelligent and bright and energetic and loyal and strong and adventurous and determined and brave and she truly did love Bramblestar. She didn't stab him in the back; she was just being loyal to Leafpool and keeping her secret. SHE NEVER PLAYED WITH ASHFUR'S FEELINGS; IT WAS ASHFUR'S FAULT WHEN HE DECIDED TO HATE HER. She wanted to be friends with him and never tried to maniuplate him! She doesn't pick fights with everybody- she stands up for herself and others and was a fantastic foster mother to Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf. So what if she was

Stubborn and rude as an apprentice? She matured and anyway lots of awesome cats like Sandstorm were also rather mean as apprentices. Seriously, Squirrelflight is one of the coolest she-cats. And she never mated with Ashfur. It's his fault he feels like he has to kill his exes' father ...more

Squirrelflight.. What can I say about her.. Ok she is a bit rude to people and say like "You are such a mouse-brained cat" to basically everyone, even Brambleclaw. But I also like her because she let Ashfur down. She chose Brambleclaw instead. And she even had the courage to say that Lionblaze, Jayfeather, and Hollyleaf weren't her kits at the gathering!

Started off as clan nuisance then became a bit rude to bramble claw because he bossed her around a lot. She matured a lot as others have said and was just keeping leaf pools secrets. I think bramble claw was a bit stupid when he chose her for deputy. It's annoying about the whole kit problem though then she finally has some. She is a Mary Sue as some comments prove bellow

Dovewing is a spoiled brat and Mary Sue. Honestly, I hate her more than anyone else in the series. Think she's not a Mary Sue? Well, let's check the facts. First of all, she has this power, of which should've been Hollyleaf's, but ended up being this little brat's instead. Second of all, THREE tom cats were after her in the series. Really, THREE. It's a very common trait in Mary Sues to have numerous characters have interest in them romantically, a trait of which she possesses. Aside from that, she has color-changing eyes, need I say more? She thinks she's the best cat in the world and superior to Ivypool, of whom I feel sorry for due to her bratty little sister. And in the end, guess what? She gets everything she wants.

Why is Dovewing on the list? I love Dovewing! Dovewing is not a Mary Sue. Many people say she's incompetent, whiny, etc, etc . . . and then they call her a Mary Sue, either before or after, it doesn't matter. PeOpLe, a Mary Sue is the definition of perfect. Incompetent and whiny are NOT the definition of perfect. Sure, she takes the spot of Hollyleaf, bUt I mEaN, that's not really HER fault, that's the AUTHORS' fault. She can be annoying sometimes, but overall, she's a good cat. She lost her powers after the mountains (or something, I don't know) and she was despairing over it, but she'd had had them her whole life and she found it hard to work without them. Like you have your arm for your whole life, and then suddenly it isn't there anymore. Then what do you do? NOT despair over it? '
And Dovewing is not a brat! She cares about others, despite them being from other Clans. "Brats" don't do that. "Brats" aren't kind. "Brats" will not constantly try to solve problems between them and ...more

Yeah I always found that some part of me really didn't like her character. Heck I like her sister Ivypool more because she actually took the biggest risks just to help protect the clans. Dovewing didn't use her powers as best as she could with being one of the cats from the prophecy. She overshadows Ivypool too much and always like to seem as if she's doing things right even though she'll go breaking the code with Tigerheart. And I dislike how she treats a sweet tom like Bumblestripe who actually cares deeply about her. But anyway there's just so much to dislike about her character.

Holly leaf and ivy pool were practically the forth cat. It annoys me because lion blazes power isn't used to protect the clan but to protect himself in the battle. There are cats who fought just as hard as lion blaze but they died. It's kinda unfair. Jay feather did all the hard work for the power of three. Interpreted dreams but I think half the time he was just being nosey. Dove wing is the worst. She didn't help anyone. She says "I hear um coming", and that's it while ivy pool found out a lot more by risking her life in the dark forest. Holly leaf also risked her life and saved ivy pool

Spoiler Alert*

In a Vision of Shadows book 2, "Thunder and Shadow" I believe he just plain turned into a drama queen/king. When he lost a life to the rogues, he acted like everyone was a traitor. Tallstar made a mistake. Mudclaw would have been a much better leader in the long run. I think many former leaders made bad decisions. Firestar should have kept Graystripe as deputy or chose Brackenfur or even Ashfur, because Brambleclaw only became leader because of Tigerstar and "second chances". Blackstar too. Rowanstar just sits there and watches his clan crumble. I honestly want ShadowClan to fall at this point; I didn't used too but with everything going on I think that's what should happen. Anyway, I'm ranting! You got my point!

I honestly don't know why he is on here. He's not a jerk; he needs to prove his loyalty to his clan. After the huge skirmish with Mudclaw, he needs to be a jerk to Thunderclan. I actually applaud him for doing that as it helps cats no longer question his loyalty since everyone always knew he liked Thunderclan cats. They are from two different clans. Get over it, people.

Onewhisker is lovable. I might dislike Onestar, but remember that he went through a lot of stress and guilt when he had to cut ties with Firestar. Everyone thought WindClan was weak because they allied with ThunderClan and some cats think Onestar didn't deserve his leadership. That is a reason to cut ties, but he didn't have to literally attack.

I loved Onewhisker. I loved his character, and I loved Windclan too so I admired him for his humility. Then suddenly he acted all out of character and started doing random stuff. "Let's go attack Thunderclan for no apparent reason, it'll make us look strong! " Mentally ill Bluestar, Murdering Hollyleaf, and Crazy Ashfur take their places beside Onestar.

Definitely my least favorite character. What does Darkstripe even do: nothing. He's just Tigerstar's shadow, and doesn't really do anything. He also tried to poison Sorrelkit (Sorreltail), who's one of my favorite characters! He also couldn't even kill a cat (Stonefur). Blackfoot had to do it for him (thank StarClan that Blackstar went "sane" after that)!

I love Darkstripe! He's cowardly, stupid, and the worst villain ever, and that's why I love him. I feel like he deserves more credit. Everyone hates him because he's useless and pointless, but that's only because Tigerstar, Brokenstar, Darktail, Mapleshade etc were all given a lot of story and he was just pushed aside! He's my #8 favourite character, and I feel like he's super underrated! -FeirceheartOfThunderClan

Ugh there is something creepy about Darkstripe. The way he dotes on Tigerstar and how the book hints strongly that he loves Tigerstar. How he fed Sorrelkit deathberries and the way he acts. He had no mate and he is always getting under Hawkfrost and Tigerstars feet in the Dark Forest, seemingly lusting after them. He's just wrong, so wrong.

Darkstrips a cowered. He acts all: I'm the best and all. When Tigerstar is winning. And when Tigerstar is found out or wronged, he goes to: oh! I never knew your bad Tigerstar! You betrayed me! Then when Tigerstar goes back up, he acts like: oh you losers. Look I'm Tigerstar ally and I do everything to help him!

I don't really know why Leafpool is on this list... She is one of my favourite characters, but I'm trying really hard not to be prejudiced.
If I'm being honest, Leafpool made a LOT of mistakes in her life. Running away with Crowfeather, having kits, lying to her clan. But in my opinion, she's made up for this- at least a little bit. Now she's a loyal ThunderClan medicine cat (Or so we think). She also is very caring and helps whenever she can, even for cats in other clans. Leafpool is definitely not a Mary Sue, but I do not necessarily think that she is "evil" or "bad" enough to be on this list. I'm sure not many people will agree with me on this, though.

It took me way too long to find her on the list. Still don't like how she got to be a medicine cat a second time and hardly anyone is mad at her while her kids are looked at awkwardly because their parents shouldn't have gotten together. I also found it very insensitive of her when she gave Jayfeather his warrior name. "I'll give my child a permanent reminder that his father is from another clan. That's exactly what he needs! " Also, her personality annoys me. "'STARCLAN, HELP US! ' Leafpool pleaded, for the 50th time."
Between her and real jackasses like Rainflower and Breezepelt, who do I think is worse? Definitely not Leafpool. But I really, really dislike how she is painted in a completely good light and never scorned by anyone other than her kits and her Crowfeather's kits, who eventually either get shafted or forgive her anyway

Leafpool is a very boring cat. Her only purpose was to serve as a viewpoint of clan life, while her sister is off on an adventure to find Midnight the badger. She has no personality other than just being a standard healer. Seemingly out of nowhere, she falls for a cat from another Clan, whom she basically JUST MET. Together they run off and bang. She later returns and pushes her childen onto her sister to raise. Let's be honest here, she had zero personality or interesting moments until she gets knocked up by a cat she barely knew. I see her as a typical, hormonal teenager, who let her sexual emotions get in the way. I do not pitty or sympathize with her rash choices, in the slightest. As for her decision to lie about her kits and force them onto her sister, that's another stupid choice. First of all, her father is the CLAN LEADER. I highly doubt that Firestar would simply exile his own daughter, when he understood how much it hurt Yellowfang to give up her own kits. Also it would be ...more

Leafpool. Is. An. Idiot. I'm actually making a comic about this, and so far I have 3 issues and 2 others planned. I hate her so much! She's a bad medicine cat, and let Honeyfern die, while saying "stay back! " and not letting her family be near her in her last moments. Then there's the whole Crowfeather thing. She just couldn't help herself, could she? Then she went and had kits. "Oh no, I had kits! Well, it's not my fault, and there's NO WAY I could have NOT gotten pregnant." Then she's SO OBVIOUS about it, and then she admits it and quits her dream job. People make mistakes, Leafpool, maybe none as bad as yours, but now you're just showing them that you're a pathetic little wimpy cat. Sure, she gets punished, but that doesn't make it better. Also, in Leafpool's Wish, she literally ONLY uses Whitepaw to do apprentice tasks. Poor Whitepaw. And she can be a jerk to her sister. Squirrelflight: Okay, Jaypaw, once you've finished, you can get something from the fresh-kill pile. Leafpool: ...more