Top 10 Best Pop-Tarts Flavors

The Top Ten
1 Brown Sugar Cinnamon

Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon has been critically acclaimed twice in my lifetime. It's simply nothing short of amazing, and if I could, I would eat this every day. Please take some time to retrospectively admire and wonder about the magnificent ramifications this Pop-Tart has had on your life.

The impact this single flavor of greatness has had on my life is phenomenal. I'm consistently astounded by the flavor-packed taste of the Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tart. After eating my first one, I will never eat any other flavor again. It's impossible to go back to strawberry after experiencing the power of this Pop-Tart.

I will forever be a die-hard Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tart enthusiast from birth till death. Nothing will separate me from these breathtaking pastries. Nothing!

2 S'mores

I'm going left to right, I'm going right to left, I'm going right to left, I'm going left to right. I'm gonna take a bite. I'm going left to right, I'm going left to right, I'm going right to left for that s'mores flavor!

Especially at night... Oh yeah! I also had it with the Hershey's brand ice cream brownie with fudge and brownie pieces in between. The whole combo was really good!

S'mores are definitely the best with gooey chocolate and marshmallow filling, and their delicious, soft/crunchy granola shell! They rock!

3 Hot Fudge Sundae

You can bring this to a party or away game. It is still the best one by far. If you think Brown Sugar Cinnamon is better, get some help. You are sick.

Hot Fudge Sundae is my favorite Pop-Tart flavor! Well, all my Pop Picks (as I call them) come really close to each other. Confetti Party Mix is delicious, and I'm not kidding. Also, have you ever taken a bite of Chocolate Fudge? Well, I pity you if you haven't! But overall, Hot Fudge Sundae is looking hot. Never. Ever. Miss. This. Flavor. If. You. See. It. I'll see to it if you do!

You have never known true pleasure until you are alone in a dark room with a raging thunderstorm outside, consuming a toasted Hot Fudge Sundae Pop-Tart (good not toasted as well).

4 Cookies & Creme

I found these in the store a couple of months ago, and the first thing I said was, "Wow! This looks so good! I bet it tastes awesome!" It wasn't too long after that when I finally tried it, and I was right! I absolutely loved it, and it was definitely the best Pop-Tart flavor I've ever had!

I don't understand how some people's favorites are brown sugar cinnamon and strawberry. There are so many flavors that are way better, like cookies and creme. So good. My favorite, though, is peanut butter, but these are close behind.

5 Strawberry

There is nothing better than the good old original strawberry Pop-Tart. I personally hate flavors that are more on the dessert side. I prefer the fruity flavors. In my opinion, strawberry is the best fruity flavor, making it my number one.

I love frosted strawberry! But cinnamon has to be my second favorite. It used to be number one, but strawberry is better! So much better! The frosting on this one is better too. The frosting on the cinnamon melts too quickly in the toaster. Definitely better.

I really love strawberry-flavored Pop-Tarts because they have a little sweet and a little sour. They are so tasty and quick to eat if you are on the go, just like any other flavor of Pop-Tarts. I love strawberry the best, but cookies and cream is my second favorite flavor.

6 Chocolate Fudge

I loved the Cookies and Creme, but I've only had them a few times, and that was a long time ago. I can't even remember what they taste like anymore, so I'm voting for these because I still love them.

The best flavor possible for Pop-Tarts. It does not get any better. These are simply the best Pop-Tarts I have ever tasted. In fact, I am eating one at this very moment.

I haven't had many different flavors of Pop-Tarts, but out of the ones I've tried, these are probably the best. I love the filling and the crust on these ones.

7 Chocolate Chip

I don't like Pop-Tarts because of their fillings, but Chocolate Chip Pop-Tarts are the only exception. The moment I tried these, I knew I was hooked! It's terrible because I'm trying to limit my calorie intake, but I just can't help myself!

I first tried Strawberry, and honestly, I only ate the crust and the frosting on top, leaving me feeling sick from too much sugar. Chocolate Chip doesn't do that. I can eat the whole thing without feeling like I'm about to puke. Seriously underrated! My one and only favorite Pop-Tart for sure!

8 Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Seriously, I can barely stand any other Pop-Tart because this one is so much better than any of the other flavors I've had (and I've had almost all of the others). They taste delicious toasted or untoasted. You just can't go wrong. Best flavor by far.

The strawberry Pop-Tart is disgusting, simply horrible! The hot fudge sundae would be my second choice. Then the brown sugar, followed by the s'mores. You can't go wrong with cookie dough, though it does need a splash more.

The only good Pop-Tart flavor, in my opinion! I don't eat other Pop-Tarts anymore because this is the best!

9 Red Velvet Cupcake

Red velvet isn't my favorite flavor in general, but Red Velvet Pop-Tarts are the best! They are so delicious, and I even smear cream cheese on mine after I toast them. I think anyone and everyone would love these, but especially those red velvet lovers out there. You need to try these amazing masterpieces.

The best Pop-Tart ever, hands down! Please don't keep this a limited edition. When I buy, I must buy in bulk, at least 5 boxes. My friends steal them because they are so good, and I can't eat just one! My favorite!

10 Cinnamon Roll

These are the best ever. I do eat them every day when I can find them. The stores in my area couldn't keep them on the shelf. Wondering why they ever took them off?

These are the best without a doubt! Our Walmart in Spearfish, SD, used to sell them, but all of a sudden no longer. We can't buy them anywhere. Please engage a retailer near us so we can be happy again!

The Cinnamon Roll Pop-Tarts are by far the greatest tasting Pop-Tart of all time. It's breakfast, it's a snack, and it's also a dessert. It's the most versatile Pop-Tart out there. Who doesn't like versatility and options?

The Contenders
11 Rainbow Cookie Sandwich

Ok, this one? The cream filling is literally like vanilla icing, and the fact that it isn't completely frosted provides a perfect balance between the icing filling and chocolate drizzle frosting. By far the best Pop-Tart flavor!

By far the best Pop-Tart I've ever had! The filling inside is amazing and creamy, just like icing, and the outer part complements it perfectly. If you've never tried this, you're missing out. I eat at least one a day.

They should sell this one more often. It is definitely in the top three best Pop-Tarts!

12 Blueberry

I was at a five-star restaurant earlier today, and the server asked, "Would you like to see a dessert menu?" I literally could not think of anything else other than blueberry Pop-Tarts. Not the Nutella melted cake with chocolate truffle ice cream. Not the 24k shaved gold lemon tart. No! I told the server that I wanted the check so I could go to Target and buy Blueberry Pop-Tarts. And you know what? I started eating them before they made it to the checkout counter. So yes, I vote for blueberry.

This one is my favorite. It might have something to do with the fact that this was one of only three flavors that the store I got them from as a kid even sold. I never tried whatever the other two were. I like most kinds, but this one has always been the best.

13 Cherry

What is this delicious Pop-Tart flavor handcrafted by the gods themselves doing at number 13 on this list? I am ashamed of all of you who did not vote for this delectable treat. Eating these is like eating pure joy.

This was the first Pop-Tart flavor I ever tried as a kid, and they remain my favorite. These should be much higher on the list than they are right now.

Eating one right now, and I was like, "I wonder what the most popular Pop-Tart flavor is." I was mad when Frosted Cherry was not in the top 10.

14 Confetti Cupcake

It tastes like sweet, creamy cake batter! It's basically a more acceptable way of having a cupcake for breakfast. The funfetti sprinkles on top are also a nice touch. This should be in the top 10!

A dessert package. A cheap way to get a cake, and yet it tastes better than any cake you can ever taste. Amazing flavor.

I just ate one. So delicious! If you toast it well, it's pretty much a dessert. Confetti Cupcake Pop-Tarts are great.

15 Raspberry

The best Pop-Tart flavor ever. It's amazing toasted or at room temperature. I like most Pop-Tarts, except the fudge ones. Gross. But wow, how can these little pockets of perfection not be number one? About to go pop one in the toaster now.

This is definitely my favorite out of all the Pop-Tart flavors. Even though it is artificially flavored, it tastes like raspberry. This is also one of the first flavors. It is not one of the overly sweet ones.

It is surprisingly good. By the way, Chocolate Fudge is awful, and Strawberry should be number one.

16 Wildlicious Wild Berry

The wild berry is extra colorful and super fruity. I love the icing colors. I think it's the best of the fruit flavors. However, the quality of the outer crust has gone down over the years. Pop-Tarts used to taste even better.

This is the original Pop-Tart flavor. By far, it is the best flavor. Its colors are fascinating. The texture is crisp and clean.


Die-hard Pop-Tart Consumer

Wild Berry smashes out here. These are some of the greatest things I've ever had. My wife's boyfriend's kids love them!

17 Chocolate Peanut Butter

Okay, this is in my top five. It comes in a gold package, for crying out loud. It's not gross - it's amazing!

Come on, it's chocolate and peanut butter. You can't go wrong with that.

18 Chocolatey Strawberry
19 Blue Raspberry
20 Wild Cherry
21 Strawberry Milkshake

Ever since Pop-Tarts brought this flavor back, I don't want to eat any other flavors. They're just so good. I hope they don't take them away again.

These Pop-Tarts were my childhood, and they really were my all-time favorite. I hardly ever ate the other flavors.

These things were the bomb! I remember eating them frozen all the time. So good! Recently, I've been craving them badly and can't seem to find them anywhere.

22 Vanilla Milkshake

Viva La Vanilla Pop-Tarts! The greatest thing to happen since the founding of America. If these aren't brought back, I will die!

Delicious, especially when toasted!

23 Wild Berry

My daughter says, "I love these. Oh my God, they're so good."

24 Blueberry Muffin

These were our new favorite. The filling inside is so creamy, and they make the house smell so good when toasting. We are on our last box because I can no longer find them. I hope they will return someday.

It is clearly the best. I have never had Cinnamon Roll, but Blueberry Muffin is so good, I know that Cinnamon Roll can't beat it. I love Blueberry Muffin!

25 Pumpkin Pie

Easily the best flavor out there! I don't even like Pop-Tarts, but I love anything pumpkin, so this was an automatic win for me!

Really yummy and festive. Might be even better if I took the time to toast them!

I long for fall so I can have these again!

8Load More
PSearch List