Top 10 Most Overrated Disney Movies

WaltDisneytoptens1937

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Finding Dory

The Plot is overrated and the Jones are forgettable, its not a bad film, but not as good as finding nemo though

Look, It's A Good Film, But NOT AS Good As Finding Nemo, The Plot Is My Biggest Problem, With It, oh And If I Get Thumbs Down, It Means You're Butthurt - VideoGamefan5

This One Gets A Score Of 89/100 At Most - VideoGamefan5

Am I Done Yet?

Yeah But Sorry, A Carbon Copied Plot Can't Equal A Good Plot, This Film Is Good, But Just Saying - VideoGamefan5

V 6 Comments
22 Mulan

Some of the songs are good, but other than that I feel the only reason this movie has gotten so much more popular now is mostly because of PC culture. I guess I'm one of the few people out there who watches movies to hear a good story, good characters, and good dialogue. Yeah, there's some of that here, but it's mostly overshadowed by how much they're trying to push feminism onto kids. I'm not saying I'm for or against feminism, but the general concept of a family movie (especially a Disney movie) fueled mostly with the objective of pushing a political movement I find absolutely absurd. Like I said before, I don't hate everything about it. But the sudden uprising of third-wave feminism that has made this movie way more popular than it's content really merits, then I can't help but consider this the most overrated Disney movie ever. (also, curse you whoever wrote "I'll Make a Man Out of You". I'll never get that song out of my head as long as I live.)

How about doing a little more research on the source material, the poem/legend this was based on? It wasn't about Mulan proving herself or finally doing something right, it was her simply doing what she had to. Family honor and feminism had nothing to do with it. Had Disney stuck closer to the original source, the movie would have been a lot more worthy of the praise every things it "needs".

Too much emphasis on sexism, heroine whines about her lot in life early on and ONLY thinks to do something about it when her father is summoned to war, heroine spends most of the movie out over being discovered, annoying sidekick who was later reincarnated as the even more annoying Donkey from the "Shrek" franchise.

And people not shutting up about how great or how perfect this movie supposedly is puts it out of "underrated" territory.

Nowhere near as complex and nuanced as people make it out to be. It's like a B-Grade Ghibli film. About as complex as a rice crispy treat.

V 19 Comments
23 Fantasia 2000
24 Inside Out

Absolute torture for me to see Disney carbon copy every single movie they make and re-texture it. When I saw it, it was boring, stupid, filled with cliches, and was mind-numbing. Move this up into the top 5. This never deserved the recognition it got. This was the reason why I didn't see Zootopia. I knew they would carbon copy it again. And when did see it a month after it hit the films, It was. Same for Inside Out and Frozen.

The whole thing is just pretty boring. Little people get sucked up and lost somewhere in a random kid's brain and try to get back the the control panel

Overrated? Yep. Bad soundtrack (no classical songs; it is meant for an older audience after all), unfunny humor, and it just seems like Sadness could have attempted suicide.

So boring

V 7 Comments
25 Atlantis: The Lost Empire

While it's not the best Disney movie I really don't think people even know what overrated actually means

It's Not Overrated, I Barely Hear Anyone Talk About It - VideoGamefan5

Lol this isn't even overrated its underrated if anything god this website sucks at choices

Another cheap ripoff of Treasure Island - Hypercube

V 1 Comment
26 Hercules

This is actually an underrated movie - hurjelert

In my opinion, this is one the most underrated Disney movies. It has the best soundtrack(tied with some but never better than.) Meg is unique. No other Disney princess can come close to her sass level. (I love them, but I love Meg just as much.) The villain is my favorite Disney villain ever. He is sassy too. Hercules is sweet, clumsy, and determined. I love this movie. Plus, with "That's Phil's boy" this movie is magical. Also, Meg (who is actually a princess) isn't an official Disney princess. She marries Hercules(I checked there was a spin off thing where it is revealed they got married officially). Hercules is the son of the King of the gods. So, I'd say this is so underrated Meg never got her rightful title as an official Disney princess.

This is one of my favourite Disney movies,first of James woods as Hades was perfect! I liked the characters and as a person who usually find that main female character extremely annoying I loved Meg and she became one of my favourite Disney characters ever. The songs were beautiful and the movie has one of my favourite soundtracks out of all the Disney movies. Honestly I think this movies doesn't get enough praise. So why is it on most overrated Disney movies, last time I checked it was pretty underrated...

Actually really underrated and buried under other more popular Disney films, sadly. - punyraisin

V 15 Comments
27 Brave

I don't understand why people hate this film. It's a visually stunning film, which is different for Pixar (though for Cars they did well with landscapes too). I love the history and culture behind the piece. People didn't like the plot story with the mother turning into a bear, but if you read ANY sort of fairy tale from ANY culture, there are a lot of stories of similar things. This isn't a "new" idea that made Pixar to be a bad storyteller. For a story taking place in ancient Scotland, it was a powerful story about "mending the bond torn by pride" between a mother and daughter. I liked Frozen for doing something similar, but with sisters. But why does Pixar get hate and Frozen doesn't? Seriously people, I don't understand you! The only negative thing about the film is the abundance of boob jokes about Mottie (or whatever the maid's name is). That's pretty much it. I place it up with Incredibles and Finding Nemo.

Brave should be number two next to frozen. Wreck - it - Ralph is not overrated at all. It is underrated. Tangled is underrated too. But brave us too overrated

Other than the fact it won the Oscar over Wreck it Ralph, this is actually underrated - 445956

Why Do So Many People Hate This Movie? - VideoGamefan5

V 4 Comments
28 Tarzan

Why is this on this list, Tarzan is so underrated not overrated, the story is nice and a bit sad. The sound track it one of the most beautiful I've ever heard in a Disney movie, it may actually be my favourite. I liked the characters a lot to. Why is this on this list?

Why Is This Here, Sure The Songs Suck, But The film itself is Very fun And Exciting - VideoGamefan5

29 101 Dalmatians

Hello, shouldn't this belong in the "Underrated" section.

It's kinda Underrated - VideoGamefan5

This isn't overrated at all, it's a great movie and amazing.

I'm not sure how it's underrated also, it's been a successful franchise and critics gave it a 98% on Rotten Tomatoes, and the majority of people I've seen online and in real life love it. - SailorSedna

30 Beauty and the Beast (2017)

The best thing about the original Disney 'Belle' was that she was both strong and gentle, in a world that mostly tells girls they have to choose. This Belle chose strong, and no one even noticed her totally different character under all the shiny rococo madness. Not to mention the other 20 wonderful things they took from the original and botched.

Better than stinkin La La Land. I liked the songs in this one and actually gave a crap about what was happening - DCfnaf

While I would watch this over La La Land comparing it to the original, I think it is in a way an overrated comparison. - htoutlaws2012

31 The Incredibles

The Movie Is Awesome, But The Fans Need To Calm Down About Cars Getting A Sequel First, HELL, Has Anyone Even HEARD That Toy Story 4 and the Incredibles 2 Switched Release Dates? - VideoGamefan5

I love this and so happy there making a incredibles 2

Why the ruck is this here I love this movie and the SECOUND movie has jack jack as a bad boy I think

Ugh... no! no! A thousand times no. Watch it once, and it will change your mind of how great it really is. - htoutlaws2012

V 1 Comment
32 Alice In Wonderland (2010)

The original 1951 version is way better (yeah, I just said that). This needs to be in the top 5s. The character design is just boring.

I prefer this over the original actually, funny how their both next to each other. - htoutlaws2012

I Have No Clue - VideoGamefan5

33 Cinderella III: A Twist in Time

What's so bad about this movie? It was way better than Cinderella 2 in my opinion

34 Lady and the Tramp

This is my favorite Disney movie

We are Siamese if you please

Pretty good actually

Pretty Good To Be Honest - VideoGamefan5

V 1 Comment
35 Moana

As much as I love this movie, I am aware that it rather borrows elements from Frozen.

Overrated, But Still An Amazing Movie - VideoGamefan5

It's fine for what it did, I ended up seeing this like once, and yeah it consisted of almost mostly music I'd say Zootopia by far was better than this. - htoutlaws2012

95% On RT, This Film Is Great But Overrated - VideoGamefan5

V 1 Comment
36 Monsters University

Much better than the stupid Inc!

Monsters inc was better without this dumb sequel

37 Camp Rock

Oh Look!, Another Teen Disney Channel Film! - VideoGamefan5

38 Captain America: Civil War

I don't consider this a Disney movie, even though Disney owns Marvel. - SmashPrincess

It's The Quality Film That Rivals DC - VideoGamefan5

Worst MCU movie. The movie is too overrated.

39 The Black Cauldron

For all people whine about how Eilonwy should be an official Disney Princess, how this is such an underrated gem, that there may be a reason, any reason at all, it's so "underrated" never even crosses their minds.

This one of my favorite Disney movies. Just a warning though, this isn't a kids movie so I don't suggest to let your kid watch it till 13 maybe.

The absolute worst Disney movie EVER. Gave my kids nightmares!

40 Bolt

Miley Cyrus was in it. Need I say more?

As a dog lover it's hard for me to hate any movie about an owner and their dog. But this movie just isn't that good

NO!, This Movie Is Underrated - VideoGamefan5

Never liked this film. I liked the idea of it, but I guess I hated the side characters and the overall storyline that I never once saw it in a positive light.

P.S... The dog wouldn't ever think he could actually bark sonic waves because that would be done in post production of whatever T.V. show he was on. Either this dog is stupid or just drugged all the time.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Most Overrated Disney Animated Movies Top 10 Disney Movies that are Good but Overrated Top 10 Most Overrated Disney Movies of the 21st Century Best Disney Animated Movies Top 10 Best Disney Movies

List Stats

1,000 votes
158 listings
3 years, 275 days old

Top Remixes (35)

1. Frozen
2. Alice in Wonderland
3. Cinderella
htoutlaws2012
1. Fantasia
2. James and the Giant Peach
3. The Nightmare Before Christmas
Disney1994
1. Mulan
2. Lilo & Stitch
3. Toy Story 3
traveling_elusive_prncss85295

WRemix
View All 35

Posts

Movie Musical Reviews- #4: The Little Mermaid
Elric-san
Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P