Best Hockey Players of All Time

Don't agree with the list? Vote for an existing item you think should be ranked higher or if you are a logged in, add a new item for others to vote on or create your own version of this list.

The Top Ten

1
Wayne Gretzky
Simplest choice ever THE GREAT ONE is easily number 1.
Anyone who does respect it should walk off the face of the world
grezkey is the best hockey player cause he scored 521 goals in a row
I visited Gretzky's restaurant in Toronto last year. There is a very special room with jusy a few tables and each of the four walls has a single portrait which seems to suggest that Wayne holds these players in high reverence. Gordie Howe; Bobby Hull; Maurice "Rocket" Richard; Bobby Orr. Thanks Wayne - great room!
[Newest]He has his own road in Edmonton he's so good
More comments about Wayne Gretzky

2Bobby Orr
Orr was the only player in the history of the NHL to win the Art Ross Trophy ( Scoring title ) and the Norris Trophy ( most valuable Defenseman ), in the same year! He did it TWICE!
Also the only player to make the nhl as a 18 year old rookie during the original six teams ( 1966/67 ). Plus he would fight his own battles, block shots, made the other superstars look like ordinary players. The only way that he was stopped was they chopped his knees out from under him. Played nine seasons on 1/2 a leg and rest guts.
Orr was harder to shadow than a forward like Hull but he still ranks with Hull & Howe as the most complete player in the era of original six team play. Gretzky was the best specialist in history in the style of a Magic Johnson in NBA as a play-maker & in his ability to be in the flow of play. I would like to have seen an Orr or Hull surrounded by a team like the 80's Oilers to see what they could have done to the record books! We did get a glimpse of that in 1976 with the Canada Cup.
Orr was the greatest hockey player he changed the game he was 14 trying out for the boston bruins just 14 he was the greatest player in the game.
[Newest]Bobby Orr is clearly the best but people are crap heads
More comments about Bobby Orr

3Mario Lemieux
his shortened career was the only thing that kept him from beating all of Gretzky's records. He's at least just as good.

BKAllmighty

For many reasons, Mario is better than Gretzky, but I think Orr is first, Mario second. I am not even sure I would put Gretzky third and the simple reason is that I think the greatest hockey player should be not just who has the best stats but should be based more on talent along with stats of course. So here are my reasons: Gretzky had far better talent around him for more years than Mario did. Of course the injuries to Mario, prevented him from breaking the records, Gretzky admits to this. Mario was more skilled and more physical, Gretzky admits this too. Many point out how many assists Gretzky had which is certainly amazing, but obviously he would not have had all of those assists if the people he passed too can't score. That is the case with lots of great passers... Not enough skilled scorers on their teams, so the passes don't amount to anything. Gretzky was lucky to have many great players around him. Also, Gretzky played in a much less physical environment, as history shows... His era did not allow as much physical play. And I can remember SO MANY times watching games where refs constantly favored Gretzky... Wouldn't let anybody near him and quick to blow the whistle etc... Mario was a great skater and much much stronger than Gretzky... Had to tolerate so much more physical play and did not get anywhere near the calls that Gretzky did either.
Simply the most skilled all around player who ever lived.
[Newest]He played with cancer!
More comments about Mario Lemieux

4Gordie Howe
Greatest athlete in hockey. Played into his fifties! He was given room to set records because he manhandled players - not because he was protected. When Howe had the puck it was special like when Mantle came to the plate.
Scotty Bowman. You know him? At a luncheon he was asked who the best was and without hesitation said Howe. In an era of 5 decades, he defined the all around player. He could score, he could defend, he could pass, he could skate. The Russians when just starting to take ice hockey seriously, used Howe as their model. As far as Gretsky goals, look at the number of goals scored when Howe played and the overall number per game was far lower than in Gretsky's time. So, based on the lower totals, Howe scored more goals based on overall production.
Howe had the unique ability to define how a game was to be played on any given night. Any style /speed his skill set allowed him to play any way the opponents wanted to play. Probably the one thing about Howe was that while he was the most dominant player he was not dynamic in the sense of the other great players. You had to watch him play over a period of time to witness how much bettor he was than his contemporaries. Their would be even a higher appreciation of his extraordinary skill set if there was video and or tape of him during his prime.
[Newest]He is the 2 best beside bobby Orr but he is king of hockey so you guys vote

5Sidney Crosby
He is a awesome player he can score goals he is awesome at hockey
In todays game, the best and for anyone calling him a baby if you knew anything about hockey, you would know how strong this man really is. Crosby is the hardest working hockey player on the ice and that is what seperates him from the rest. He's a superstar and a champion!
He's is amazing and way better than ovechkin! He's got the better stats and all! He is a boss!
[Newest]Sidney Crosby… used to be a crybaby USED too, not anymore Now he is a GREAT hockey player anyone who says he is a crybaby, you're wrong. Very wrong… very

More comments about Sidney Crosby

6Maurice Richard
Most people voting now never seen him play, so please go see some archives and just watch how he played and then you will see that he was the greatest
The most under rated player ever to have hit a Puck
Maurice Richard not only was an excellent player, but he had to endure the racism against the French-Canadians. He continually played brilliantly (like many others may have) BUT he also had another task; not letting the others get to him. It was a difficult time. Trust me, Richard should win, hands down, #1.
[Newest]Deserves to be rated #1

7Steve Yzerman
Steve Yzerman had something that Crosby will never have... Class! I will never say that Crosby isn't talented or doesn't deserve to be ranked high on this list but he can never be compared to Stevie, Wayne, Bobby or Gordie. I think a lot of people have voted based primarily on who currently on top and whos name they hear the most.
He belongs at 3 or 4... Not 8... He's the 2nd best player ever on the best team ever The Detroit Red Wings
Yzerman is much better than Crosby and Ovechkin. Neither of them belong on this list.
[Newest]Steve no way top 10 wasn't even the best player on his team

8Bobby Hull
Hockey's "Golden Age" according to the "Legends of Hockey" series was the 1960's. The "Original Six" era when Gordie Howe was still in his late prime and Bobby Orr was a spectacular rookie. Bobby Hull was named the "Player of the Decade" by the sporting press! I wish he had not jumped to the WHA in 1972 (his absolute prime) because he was on track to shatter all of Howe's records. His career even overlapped Gretzky's early career in the WHA and in the first game involving their respective teams, I read that Wayne's Mom said to Hull "don't you hurt my son! " During the 1972 Canada /Soviet series when Hull was not allowed to play for Canada I remember the billboards "To Russia with Hull" and how the NHL had almost lost the series due to their vendetta against Hull. The most dissapointment was expressed by the Russians themselves as Hull was the most idolized western player ever. During the 1976 Canada Cup the long awaited dream team was assembled and both Hull and Orr dominated the games and the Soviets were not a factor as they left their premier squad at home to allow for an excuse for what they knew would be a dominating performance by Canada. On the upside considering Hull's self demotion to the minors, every pro athlete in the modern era who signed a contract exceeding one million dollars per season should mail Mr. Hull a large cheque for paving the way to free agency and the obsene salaries that we see today in sports! Thanks for the memories Bobby!
Still the best analogy I ever heard was this: goal tending being equal, put same player at all five positions ^^ match this team against any other player at all five positions ^^ you soon expose weakness in almost all examples with the exception of ORR ^^ HULL. Simply put - the two most complete players ^^ would dominate in any era.
"The perfect mesomorph"--Time magazine, March 1, 1968. Had the fastest shot ever, his slap shot was clocked at 118.3 mph. His wrist shot was timed at 105.7 mph. And his backhand shot sailed along at only 96 mph. Fastest timed NHL skater ever at 29.7 mph with full hockey equipment on. The skates in those days were as heavy as lead weights. None of the modern players can touch those marks. Just think what Bobby Hull would do in todays game with the graphite sticks and lightweight skates that are now used. Not to mention the state of the art workout gyms that every NHL team has. Even though Hull had muscles growing out of muscles he never took steroids to get that way. And he was one of the most complete players ever. He didn't need a body guard to protect him.
[Newest]:-) :-) He's definitely definite definitely definitely the best he is super great.
More comments about Bobby Hull

9Alexander Ovechkin
I wouldn't say he's the best of all time, but definitely the best player right now. There's no one you can compare with him... He's just amazing
I think he's the LeBron James of the ice hockey

Flomania69

Will people ever top comparing Crosby and Ovechkin? They are both very talented players but hey aren't the same in how they are talented. Ove Is not the Lebron James of ice hockey. Sid isn't the greatest to ever live. They're very, very, skilled. Amazing players. Out of the two I would just have to go with Sid. Only because of how much hate he gets for bing such a talented player, he shocks me of what he can do with te puck, every time.. Don't hate Ove at all though, he amazes me every time he hits the ice. But they aren't the same in how they amaze me, they shouldn't be compared in how they play, they both play very differently.
Simply amazing, I can't list all of the achievements he's done but he is so much better then sidney crysbaby
[Newest]He should be where Crosby

10Patrick Roy
He is the best goalie ever to walk on this earth

Bigtime11

He should be higher no one played goalie has well has him
Patrick Roy had the skills and the comedy once he deked Wayne Gretzky when he came out of the net and crossed the red line
[Newest]WHAT A CAREER as a goalie! He is in the top 3 at least!

The Contenders

11Mark Messier
This list is idiotic, nobody still playing in the NHL should be in the top 30 except for maybe Martin Brodeur certainly not Sidney Crosby or Alex Ovechkin, How could any of these guys be rated above Mark messier2nd all time in scoring and perhaps the best 2 way player of all time...
8 and 87 are not better. He should be 5th. 2nd all time in points. He has a award named after him and is the best captain to put on a Jersey in any sport. Gave the Rangers a cup with some help but come on the Mouse is better then sid and the great 8. And the great 8 still has not won a cup.
The Moose, The Messiah or whatever you want to call him, was the best leader of all time. During the Oilers era, Gretz admits he wore the C but Mark lead the team to victory. Messier has to be in the top 3 or at least 5.
[Newest]He is second all time in points how do you pick 11 at least 6

12Phil Esposito
He was the heart and soul of Team Canada in the 1972 series with USSR. He was an outstanding center for the Bruins for 12 years and carried the team emotionally as well as with his on ice talent.

13Jean Belliveau
Jean Beliveau is too good of a player to be this far down. He should higher than Crosby and Ovechkin at the least. I don't think Crosby and Ovechkin deserve to be on this list, but Rocket Richard does.
No list of greats would be complete without Le Gros Bill.
He was a real gentleman and a great player. He is somebody all hockey players should strive to be like.

14Ray Bourque
Ray Bourque is the leading defencemen of all time, and 11th overall for all skaters points of all time (and that's as a defencemen)! Definitely one of the best.

15Peter Forsberg
Peter Forsberg at his best was the best player the world has ever seen, the most dominate in perhaps the most physical era of hockey.
A complete player with humongous stick control, skating speed that beats the most, great pass and checking capabilities
What could you say, one of the best, probably the best technique of all time. Huge scorer of the game. Great leader and role model
[Newest]He is is the best in history. Yes he is!

16Guy Lafleur
He is my choice. A dedicated player with great skills! He was a leader of the game, a comet-loke on skates and a sharp shooter. Every team mate he had became a best player with him
pppppppfff guy lafler was a fifehudered goal scorer and got at leest then a point every game you dont even need to say to ten

pz
Best player on the greatest team in North American team sports history period.6 50 goal seasons and the best combination of skating, shooting and passing ever.

17Jaromir Jagr
SImply the best, putting him behind OVY is just a poor joke. I would put him into same level as Lemiuoux
What?! The best European player all times in 15th place behind Ovechkin (yes, he is amazing, but he is still too young to compete Jagr), Sundin and Forsberg (okay, maybe it's equal with that guy)
Its a joke to put Jagr in 14th place. He is definitely on of the best player ever. To be behind Ovechkin and Crosby and Forsberg is purely fun
[Newest]He's the best player

18Martin Brodeur
Good goaltender, but he also had great defencemen in front of him, and played in a clutch and grab system that was accepted back then. Patrick Roy was a much better goalie. Just look at what he did in Montreal. Singlehandedly won cups for montreal.
Broad our just has mad skills but he's getting old so there wearing off
Martin Brodeur below Mario Lemieux? Ridiculous!

19Mats Sundin
Awesome player, great leader, playmaker, and a good scorer when needed. He wins the big games and always gives his all.
Mats never won a scoring title or a Stanley Cup. Consider that before you put him in the top 25, never mind top 10. Any of you Leaf fans hear of a guy named Joe Sakic? You should have heard of him because you chose Luke Richardson over Joe in the '87 draft.
He IS the best leaf ever! He was the team! Also, in my opinion was one of the most talented players to play the game.
[Newest]Sucked when he went to Vancouver

20Teemu Selanne
Last year one of his best seasons! And he will continue to play at least one more year.
It's amazing how he still can keep playing on such a high level - he must soon have some kind of record as a NHL pro in years. His dedication to icehockey is one of a kind. And it does not seem like anyone is going to break his rookie year record of 76 goals - and that was only a beginning.
Even if he is very old player, he can still keep playing at the same level. GREAT! ONE MORE YEAR!
[Newest]Best player in the world

Comments About This List

Featured Lists
Popular Lists
New Lists

Top Remixes of This List

nobody11

CMCassidy63

divoice

Nico87

julierestagnobonavita

see more...

Posts About This List

List Info

This list was created 9 years, 162 days ago and has been voted on over 9,000 times. This top ten list contains 173 items, has been remixed 47 times and has been blogged about 4 times.

Updated Monday, May 25, 2015


List Error Reporting

See an item on this list that's misspelled, duplicated, or doesn't belong? Let us know. Click here to report the error.