Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters

There are lots of scary looking creepy pasta characters out there.

Here are the top ten...

The Top Ten

1 Jeff The Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

Jeff the Killer is without a doubt THE scariest Creepy Pasta character. He climbs through your window at night, stands beside your bed, waits until your wake up, when you do wake up he smiles at you with the most horrifying face ever, says, "GO TO SLEEP" and kills you with his knife. ULTRA MEGA SCARY!

Wait if Jeff has no eyelids, then what would pepper spray do to him. Also if you don't blink for that long your vision gets REALLY blurry so unless Jeff uses eye drops every minute or so, then he can't see, also what would protect him from getting his eyes poked out. This is one flawed character swimming in the garbage section of the creepy pasta website known as "crappy pastas". 3/10 Bad

Jeff is pretty scary to look at, I'll admit. He sneaks into your room at night, waits for you to wake up, and tells you to "Go to sleep" before stabbing you to death. That's pretty creepy, but he's not the scariest. I think Jeff only wins because of his fangirls. I mean, I love Jeff, but...how can a psychotic KILLER have fangirls?! What?! That doesn't make sense to me. Someone PLEASE tell me how he has fangirls. Anyway, his story isn't really that scary either, but eh. Jeff is pretty cool. As a fellow 'pasta, I will say that Jeff is scary, but not the scariest. Sorry, fangirls, but that's that. Oh yeah, and I CAN BE SCARY TOO, JEFFERY!

"Well Jeff he is the most popular creepypasta I ever known"

"He scary me every time I see his face and Jane want to kill Jeff someday"

"Well Jeff is my favorite creepypasta and he is my the best killer"

If Jeff try to kill me I would fight him and knock him out "mahahaaha"

"Just kidding I would be friend with him"

"Just is my fifth favorite creepypasta and I love him

2 Slender Man

There is no one more chilling than the Slender Man. Jeff is known for his murderous tendencies and slit open mouth smile, but his face displays his intentions. You have a chance. He's not all that different from any other serial killer psychopath, hm? I'm bipolar; I'm not always in control of my own mind. Delusions of grandeur and fantasy dance under my eyelids, just waiting for me to blink. The Slender Man likes that for he likes to play. Why do you think he prefers children best? He loves their imagination. But he'll take older children and even adults if he feels they have that vital energy of a child, an imagination innocent in theory but just wild enough to see the dark depths of the world. Isn't being imprisoned by your own mind far scarier than physical imprisonment. With Jeff, he kills you but Slender Man? He plays with you like his own personal golden fiddle. When he comes for you, will he go easy, killing you outright? Or will he take his time, enjoy his prey's beautiful ...more

Tall and smexy

There is a game called slenderman and slenderman the arrval

Slenderman goes around and stalks people, has no face and has tentacles, is as tall as the trees, and he kills children. He is a scary dude. He can get into people's minds and can be watching at all times. Slenderman truly is terrifying! This probably my exact reasoning for loving him. I'll tell you what though. Slender is DEFINITELY an eerie creature, but he is truly TERRIFYING when he's mad! This coming from one of his proxies. Don't tell him I said that! Yes, Slender, you are absolutely a scary creature.

3 Eyeless Jack

I say Eyeless jack is the scariest creepypasta for 3 reasons; 1: He cuts open your body and eats kidneys while you sleep, 2: He is anonymous having it where no one knows his true face and the only thing you can look at his is deep, black, eye sockets 3: Jeff the Killer has become a lover from fan girls :/

"Eyeless Jack is is my first favorite creepypasta but he scary me a lot"

"He is like a brother to me"

"I wish I can see his face and meet him"

Well eyeless jack is one of my favorite creepypasta I love him so much I wish I can see his face and I wish he was my friend

I love eyeless jack and I understand his story, he's amazing and wonderful in many ways, that's why I love him with all my heart, he may be a creepypasta and he may not be real but I still love him, its weird I know but I can't help it..he's changed me, and I'm happy, I think of him when I get sad and he always seem to cheer me up. I wish...that I could be apart of the creepypasta group but many people say their not real and to let it go but I can't so I won't.

4 The Rake

Loves his shiny skin

My bud hey amigo - laughingjackLJ

so cool

I like to rake leaves. It is very boring. Why is this known as creepy? Maybe when you get slugs on you from rolling in the leaves, but whatever.

5 Laughing Jack

I think laughing jack is hot and scary at the same time. - iileah_2

He is my most favorite creepypasta,as in out of the males. He is so cute

I think that laughing jack is scary but cool at the same time.

Loves candy

6 Ticci Toby

Ticci Toby is a pretty scary character, I guess. He has a story that I can kinda relate to and he kills people with hatchets! That's pretty cool. I think of Toby as my Creepypasta brother. I absolutely love his story and his design. But will someone PLEASE tell me where the heck the waffles thing comes from? What the heck? Ticci Toby is truly an awesome Creepypasta.

If you think toby is cute say I

Ticci Toby is awesome. He had the guts to stand up to his father(even if it was to kill) and his mom backed out on him. How's that for messed up? Even if he wasn't born with killer instincts, between abuse, neglect, and bullying, did he even really have a chance? His life was messed up from the beginning, but add everything together, and it's heartbreaking. He's a lovable character though, and his favorite is waffles. Ticci Toby is my favorite proxy as a whole.

Ticci Toby is just like me. He always has his tics. I also have this problem with the tics, especially when I am angry

7 Smile Dog (Picture) "Smile Dog" is a story about a cursed image file. The image shows a large German Shepard or Husky dog that is smiling.

I love him because smile dog is smile dog

The picture made it to where I can't look at a dog the same way ever again.

He always tried to bite me maybe because I had treats in my back pocket for him when he was good (at killing) - laughingjackLJ

Seriously smile dog gives me nightmares just looking at it

8 Bloody Painter

Loves to paint

Awesome cute

I love Bloody painter. He is adorable and even though he kills I still like him

Bloody painter is so hot he's cute to love bloody painter

9 Happy Appy

His theme song is AWESOME

He was always talking to me I ignored him sometimes - laughingjackLJ

It bootiful just look at its face

Just creepy I would not that apple at my house

10 Smile Dog "Smile Dog" is a story about a cursed image file. The image shows a large German Shepard or Husky dog that is smiling.

Teens and younger looking at the picture of the smiling husky will have nightmares. I don't advise looking at it unless you are 100% sure that you love horror pictures and movies and can handle this. The minute I saw that picture I turned away. That picture is scary. (Yes, I am not that into creepy pictures) This is a picture, you will not forget for a very long time.

I love dogs but this dog is my faverrete cause he's very scary

Smile dog dakes you go insane

Smile dog is my favorite creepy pasta. he is cute! (although some may not agree) I don't know why there's two pictures of him though.

The Newcomers

? Skull Trooper

The Contenders

11 Mr. Bear (1999)

Ok um Mr bear is the name of my childhood toy

Illegal Mr bear

LOL HE IS ADORABLE! HE IS NOT SCARY LOL

First I Didn’t Know The Story So I Looked It Up And It Was Amazing

12 The Girl in The Photograph

I just about wrote 100 creepy pasta girls and I know that she is in that list

I didn't EVEN KNOW HE HAD A SISTER!?!

She's Jeff the Killer's sister

It's just she cares for creepypastas Like Jeff The Killer But not for us humans

13 Zalgo Zalgo is an Internet legend about an ominous entity believed to cause insanity, death and destruction of the world, similar to the creature Cthulhu created by H.P. Lovecraft in the 1920s. Zalgo is often associated with scrambled text on webpages and photos of people whose eyes and mouth have been covered ...read more.

He was always making us do stuff - laughingjackLJ

I like zalgo

I don,t what i.n doing

He is cute and adorable but he has no halo

14 Rap Rat

We always called him small - laughingjackLJ

Not even scary to me - Janethekiller

Rape rat

If the daije a djew scare jioewq

15 BEN Drowned BEN Drowned is a creepypasta character created by Jadusable. BEN is said to have died by drowing and haunts a Majora's Mask cartridge.

He plays games with you and kinda will help you out

Cool I wish that he was my friend

He reminds me of my cousin.

Ben's story is heartbreaking and he is one of my favourite creepypasta's.

16 Abounded by Disney Mickey Mouse Costume

Suicide Mouse is better :/ - Carlitooooo

So scary I got nightmares for a week

That thing is really creepy. What could be under the costume? What we only know, is that it was abandoned by Disney... and by God - hansoharrigen

To me he is the scariest because I grew up loving Mickey Mouse. When I heard of ABD I was tempted to read his story. That made me super scared of him so he's by far the scariest

17 Tails Doll

Tails Doll is my favorite, but a little scary...

Tailsdoll is horrifying

Ummm I don't know about u guys but this tails doll thing is one hell of a monster it waits for u in the dark for u to come out of your room and go to the bath room like what guys but he's not as creepy as sonic exe sorry tails doll fans

What a crepy character. He is scary.. image if he was at ya home ready to kill ya

18 Seed Eater

He was one of eyeless jack's best friends - laughingjackLJ

This is by far my favorite! Reminds me of a Wendigo!

Seed Eater is so cute! - EclipseOnyx

Oh, Eyeless Jack eats your kidneys? How about the Seed Eater eats your children.

19 Mother's Call

She was our mother (obviously) - laughingjackLJ

I've seen this one on reddit once. It's REALLY good

I have no idea for what the heck it is but I love it!

Some of the scariest creepy pastas let your mind do the work, a WONDERFUL example of this is Mothers Call. I have only read it once but I get chills from just thinking about it. What was in the kitchen? Was it a kidnapper? Was it a monster? Was it a spirit? We don't know and that's why it's so scary.

20 sonic.exe Sonic EXE., also known as Sonic exe, is an alleged cursed version and format of the classic game Sonic The Hedgehog. The original story is about a teenage boy named Tommy or simply Tom who suffers supernatural delusions and hallucinations.

He was always mean to masky - laughingjackLJ

Sonic rocks

Scarier than Tails doll.

He’s so cool and creepy! I LOVE IT!

21 Ben Statue

I never really liked him hehe he was mean to me and sonic.exe - laughingjackLJ

I love BEN Drowned

If you play majora's mask and have read BEN DROWNED you will agree it should be in the top 10

Isn't it also known as the statue of Elegy?

22 Hoodie

Hoodie is one of my faveretes cause he is so cool I wear hoodies he wears hoodies and I like his background story

I'm not gay but I love him as a best friend - laughingjackLJ

I love hoodie

He isn't a creepypasta

23 Sally Williams

She's adorable! I wish I was her sister. I am half creepypasta the day before I hurt a kid and pulled his eye out of its socket

I love her despite what happened to her... Bit she's a cutie but forever trapped 8 years old...

Sally didn't deserve what happened to her and I wish I could see her, for real

I am happy she killed the people that hurt her she didn't deserve it she IS my sister!

24 Mr. Widemouth

He always tried to eat jeff - laughingjackLJ

Who be that?

Generally, I like Mr. Widemouth's story more than any of the character based creepypastas. It may be because it was one of the first stories I listened to, but damn, it still gets me thinking about the ending, all these years later. If I had've met him, I would've died by just tripping on him, before he even managed to say a word, knowing myself. Wonder if he would've been impressed with himself or unamused by me...

Heard the story and I've loved it ever since
How could you not love a game loving furby friend uwu

25 Masky

Masky is very cool

Again I'm not gay but he's so nice - laughingjackLJ

Ugh he is so hot! Tim can u not be sexy?

Masky is a clam guy and doesn't annoy any of the Creepypasta characters and made by Marble Hornets

26 The Sandman

He.. always kept to himself - laughingjackLJ

I kind of felt sorry for the for mr. Sandman

This dude scares the hell outta me oops ff

Damn scary.. NIGHTMARE FUEL

27 Clockwork

"Clockwork is my second favorite creepypasta"

"I like her color eyes and hair color remind me of sally"

"My favorite part is when is said your time is up"

She is a badass

I love Clockwork, because of her Clock-Eye.

She always was just wrong - laughingjackLJ

28 Homicidal Liu/Sully

Out of the 2 brothers he is the only one I can stand.

She also kept to herself - laughingjackLJ

I like his background story more than anyother creepypastas story

He is my favorite character in creepypasta with ticci Toby and Ben Drowned

29 The Smiling Man

We never understood what he was saying - laughingjackLJ

He' real creepy..

I saw him in my dream when I was 4.

Go die smiling man

30 Jason the Toymaker

He was pretty cool - laughingjackLJ

yes cool

The fact that Jason tricks his young victims into being their friend is rather terrifying. Not only that but the fact that Jason will do just about anything to get what he wants even if it means killing an entire family. His demonic form is down right horrifying as well, since his toys also change into their demonic forms makes it even more creepy. Above all, Jason has to be one of the scariest and yet, most interesting Creepypasta characters there is.

HOLY POOP WHY IS HE NOT WITHIN 10

31 Momo

She may be creepy but she is cute

We never liked her because she just stared to kill not to any hard work like us - laughingjackLJ

Literally we got in trouble at school for this

We like em big.
We like em chunky.
We like em round.
We like em funky.

32 W. D. Gaster

Yes I remember gaster then under tale creators paid him to be in the game - laughingjackLJ

He is in undertale not creepypasta

Is this a crossover from Undertale?

What WHY IS HE HERE HE AIN'T NO CREEPYPASTA! Although...he is sometimes horrifying...hm...mixed feelings here

33 Pinkamena Diane Pie

Pinkamena is actually pinkie pie

She is really scary

She was... cool - laughingjackLJ

Cupcakes is amazing, if you ever want to listen to a continued version of Cupcakes, listen to Muffins by Reitanna Seishin on YouTube

34 Lavender Town Pokémon

I listened to this with my friend and its stuck in my head

Wow so scary

We went there once, lanender town ash came with us evreywhere - laughingjackLJ

I'm 11 and I listened to it...am I gunna die?.-.

35 Puppeteer

He's my favourite creepypasta well out of the males. I watched I eat pasta for breakfast and has rlly adorable

he's cool - CrystalRS

He can be your friend to...

I love this guy.

36 Herobrine

I love herobrine he is my favorite

I like herobrine but I have dreams about him and he is destroying my family but I stopped him with the diamond sword.

Something about an elusive game-haunting spirit that doesn't really straight up kill you but just stalks and watches you from afar is deeply unnerving

I stg no one has watched the 2018 stream of minecraft in december that the developers DECLARED THAT HEROBRINE WAS JUST A MYTH?

37 The Grieving

This is a lost epsiode creepypasta based off the cartoon the Amazing World Of Gumball. It basically revolves around the gruesome deaths of Anais and Darwin

What is it?

38 Jane Everlasting

I personally like Jane because she continuously tries to kill Jeff and it's really funny but cute

I love jane! But I have heard that people ship her and jeff not that I don't like it but doesn't Jane want to kill Jeff before when jeff was not a killer she and Jeff where in love or something

I love this gal! She should be in the top ten not down here! But I thought she was Jane the killer, not Jane Everlasting.

I love her!

39 Sexual Offenderman

What is that name I'm scared he gonna touch my no no square

I'm a weirdo but I love him

what!

I love him with all my heart, even if he kills me!

40 Red

wow

He’s so snazzyyy

Because I like the color red

This story is so Amazing 9000/10

41 Funtime Foxy

Funtime foxy is a girl she has a really coo jumpscare! I like her!

One of my most favorite fnaf characters,but how is she a creepypasta.

I had no idea she was a creepy pasta this is amazing!

She's not a creepypasta she just creeps people out so most likely yeah but if you check her blueprints she can mimic voices that's most likely why. - LaylaHangedLH

She is my favorite animotronic and I didn't know she is a creepypasta I guess I learn something new everyday!

42 Zero

Best one ever

Love this story

yes

Awesome

43 Sally

The sally is cute girl to me

My friends call me Sally I don't know Why though they think I would be the perfect example of her especially because I have a teddy bear just like her the same name and all

I love her!

Sally is really nice I like her the most

44 Lost Silver

Lost silver is very cool he's a cool ghost

I don't know whos this

Lost silver is one I think is actually true because it happened to more than one person and there's profe that it happened just like the Ben drowned and I personally believe in all of them and before you people start beating me down I have my own beliefs based on true facts about them all...so unless you want to test whether or not my BARK is worse than my BITE I suggest you sit down and check the facts yourself... otherwise you most certainly will see that my BITE is worse than my BARK. - AlphaWolf1

He has no arms and legs

45 Jack the Ripper

Jack the Ripper may not be a creepypasta but there is a creepypasta based on the Jack the Ripper game. - Ilovestephanie

He is NOT a creepypasta. He is real. Honestly it is fascinating to learn about how he killed his victims

Grell. Is. The. Best. Pasta.

He is not a creepypasta he actually is a serial killer.

46 Chara Chara is a character in the game Undertale by Toby "Radiation" Fox who is one of the seven people to fall to the Underground prior to the fall of the player character. Her name can be changed by the player and will be assumed as the player character, until the Pacifist Route when Asriel asks for the ...read more.

Chara is kinda cute killer

She is from my favorite game undertale

She is proudly the first creepypasta or something. I took a quiz who is your creepypasta dad and Jeff the killer is MiNE DO ALL OF YALL HER MEH

She is NOT a creepy pasta. - DinoLover4242

47 The Smiling Girl

Never heard of here

I never seen this creepypasta

Never heard about her - Janethekiller

Never heard bout her

48 Mario

It's a me, Mario!

why is Mario a Creepypasta?

Also, he's my Idol. - CrystalRS

Scares the crap outta me. I've got an irrational fear of italians...

Not a creepypasta - TotalEscapeTheIsland

Oh, I get it, it's the (mario) the music box thing, huh?

49 BRVR

I love BRVR, I think its kawaii -w-

Never heard of it.

He is like a creepy torn up pikachu

I've looked into BVRV. Personally I feel sorry for him.

50 Frank (Donnie Darko)

Oh my god. The creepiest rabbit ever. I'm surprised nobody thought of him.

I love frank. The reason I'm scared of rabbits

He's so adorable

So same So creepyyy!

8Load More
PSearch List