Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters

The Contenders: Page 3

41 Chara Chara Chara is from the video game "Undertale" and serves as the unseen narrator in the pacifist, neutral, and genocide routes. They are the evil protagonist in the genocide route, along with Frisk and Flowey. They are unseen in any other route, despite being the narrator. They crash your game when you reply more.

Chara is a creepypasta for me. She kills everyone actually and because she is a creepypasta its because she kill everyone in 1 world using a knife to kill everyone, and her creepy face at the end, the enjoinment to kill everyone, and has the power to Reset timelines to beat her victim/enemy.

Chara is very creepy if you've ever played or seen someone play Undertale. She has no mercy and is FILLED WITH DETERMINATION ask she can never truly die. Also the fact that she is really just a spirit/ghost makes her even scarier.

Chara I like her she's cool I mean she is scary but I think she's nice don't know why though if she kills every one


V 6 Comments
42 Lost Silver

Lost silver is one I think is actually true because it happened to more than one person and there's profe that it happened just like the Ben drowned and I personally believe in all of them and before you people start beating me down I have my own beliefs based on true facts about them unless you want to test whether or not my BARK is worse than my BITE I suggest you sit down and check the facts yourself... otherwise you most certainly will see that my BITE is worse than my BARK. - AlphaWolf1

While it may be a pokemon creepypasta, I believe that this story is rather creepy. Don't play Silver after this.

The drawings of him are quite cute and his legs and arms are gone so...

Lost silver is my fave Creepypasta

V 1 Comment
43 The Rugrats Theory

This will definitely ruin your childhood.

I never even heard of it

Ok what

44 Judge Angels

If I had to date any female creapypasta character it would be this girl

She the best creepypasta R.I.P I miss her even bloody painter misses her she was the best

This girl is psycho

She was born with unusual pitch-black eyes (which caused her a traumatizing childhood thanks to her father) and fights with a giant bladed sword.

She kills her victims by giving them "trials" to see if their innocent or guilty *always guilty cough cough*

She's got a lot of mental problems, claiming to be the "final judge" and thinks shes all righteous (which is so ironic being as she murders people) but yanno... she's crazy so let the girl believe

She's also the girlfriend of "Bloody Painter"

45 Funtime Foxy Funtime Foxy

I'm more of a Bonnie fan but if I just had to pick it, though it's not a creepypasta,

I like him but I don't class him as a creepypasta.

This is not a creepypasta

"This should be in FNAF, not creepypasta"

V 1 Comment
46 Homicidal Liu/Sully

He is just great, his story was sad but I like that he would always support jeff, a real brotherly figure

FiRst of all he's my second favorite one. He's like totally so handsome and hawwt. His eyes are like so pretty and his hair is also pretty like it's like mine but different color. Uhm by the way he is older than Jeff and Jeff is the youngest. LIU is really pretty even though he has scars. His story was sad and people who don't know him should read his story.

Homicidal Liu is one of my favorites because his story links to Jeff's story

He's pretty damn fun to cosplay

V 6 Comments
47 Nightmare Ally

I've read her story and I felt sorry for er to tell the truth.

She in my nightmare😅 ha I don't have dreams

49 The Weeper

I don't know much about him, but his name seems pretty coolio. I am trying to make a creepypasta character. somone give me a name and ill create his character by the name. Thanks.

50 Sexual Offenderman

If he were real he would be the easiest not to die by: Don't take the rose. But at the same time who said he wouldn't pull a Slender and stalk you and badger you until your sanity slowly disintegrates and you end up ending yourself?

He stalks women and they end up dead. What all can I say?

I laugh at this one!

Offenderman is scary I mean like he rapes people and just gives you a rose and if you run you can't get away from him cause he would just keep catching you tell you take the rose and you better hope you took the right one or if you where able to get away from him than you are lucky and hope you don't run into him again.

V 6 Comments
51 Sally

Sally can be scary if you don't play with her but she's is just so cute I mean come on she's was murder by her uncle like come on she's was just a little kid

Sad child hood and horrible life is what I think but she is cool in a creepy way though

She is an awesome dead child

Sally is the best creepypasta character she is cute As hell and really cool. Like ger cause she killer her uncle

V 7 Comments
52 Mario
53 Dr. Andonuts (Radiation's Halloween Hack)

He ain't scary he just says u are going to die here lol worst creepy pasta ever he sucks

54 Destiny The Killer

Who exactly is our boyfriend? - EAR2121

Destiney...YUCK! She tries to kiss my boyfriend.

She us on Quotev. com. Click this link to this girls page and go on published. She makes great creepypastas. quotev. com/truth2betold

55 The Nurse Ann

I think that The Nurse Ann should get a higher rank I mean 62 more like 15 at least! With out her a lot of people would still be hurt shes the nurse! She is totally cool, killer cool!

She's really cool and her weapon is kinda like what I would want, her story was cool

She is awesome! I like her. Her weopon is a mini chainsaw. I feel sorry for her to. Shes 24 and she's been single for 24 years! It's cool how she was put together.

I ment to put 56 instead of 62

V 2 Comments
56 Mereana Mordegard Glesgorv V 2 Comments
57 Ennard Ennard

HE. IS. SCAAARRY! He wants your skin!


58 The Surgeon V 1 Comment
59 Funtime Freddy Funtime Freddy
60 Grey Man
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Gaming Creepypasta Characters Top 10 Scariest Female Creepypasta Characters Top 10 Scariest Anime Characters Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 4 Characters Top 10 Creepypasta Characters

List StatsUpdated 24 Sep 2017

3,000 votes
92 listings
4 years, 104 days old

Top Remixes (8)

1. BEN Drowned
2. Frank (Donnie Darko)
3. Hoodie
1. Eyeless Jack
2. The Rake
3. Squidward (Squidward's Suicide)
1. Slender Man
2. Smile Dog (Picture)
3. The Rake

View All 8


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.