Most Overrated Sonic Couples

The Top Ten
1 Sonamy (Sonic x Amy)

I think the reason this is so overrated is because people base most of their ideas off the oversexualized fan art of them and other weird things like that. Sonic may love Amy, but not like that. He has proven countless times he doesn't have feelings for her and literally just wants to be friends, and, honestly, I can see why. Amy may be the pretty girl, but that's all I think people really focus on. Amy Rose is obsessive, whiny, and clingy. This ship just doesn't work and that's period.

It's so overrated, it's EVERYWHERE! And the fanbrats are just as bad as this shipping, they will NEVER get together, if they did, it would make sonic a pedophile, Amy is 12, sonic is 15, and if he was "so shy" how come he NEVER confessed his love for her when there alone? Bull. And the fantbrats hate on sally just because they ship sonamy, call me immature if you want, but this couple overrated, and it's sadly not enough for the sonamy fans for people to not like it, seriously, they bash sally and every picture I see of these two sally would be crying on the ground, or making her look immature, it's annoying, so yeah it's overrated, sorry sonamy fans but it's true, stop making pictures of sally look like a baby, it's just immature, sorry if this is a long comment, it's just my opinion.

Just because Sonic does nice things for Amy, such as saving her from a robot kidnapping her... twice, and took some shell bracelet thing from her, doesn't mean these two are cute together. Because if you actually look at it with context, SONIC DOESN'T LOVE AMY! Sure, he probably likes her as a friend, but that's all. For that matter, Sonic probably just sees Amy as like his little sister or something. Nothing more. So if there were to be a sudden confession scene from Sega and Sonic Team, it'd be a friend-zone confession.

I hate how people just like this shipping because it's cute, you can't just like a shipping because it's cute! And there not even cute together, and he doesn't want Amy as a girlfriend, he likes as a friend. And stop using sonic and Amy scenes as "hints" for sonamy in sonic X and sonic boom, those series suck Amway, and there not even Conan.

2 Shadamy (Shadow x Amy)

This couple don't make sense! Amy loves Sonic not Shadow! And before you say Silver is Amy and Shadow's son that proofs that Shadamy is a cannon couple! Silver has gray hair Rouge has white hair Shadow has black hair black and white make grey! And before you say Silver's eyes are yellow Rouge has green/blue eyes and Shadow has red eyes so Shadamy makes more sense! Amy has green eyes Shadow has red those colors don't make yellow and Amy has pink hair pink and black don't make grey! Shadow thinks Amy is a nonsense Amy loves Sonic and none else! Shadouge makes whey more sense than shadamy I HATE shadamy because it makes no sense I'm sorry for my language but I'm tiered of this couple! And sorry if I have bad English.

I actually don’t mind Sonamy, I find it cute and endearing, but Shadamy is one of the worst couples I’ve seen, and if u think Sonamy is more overrated than this that you clearly haven’t been active in the fandom. Shadamy is EVERYWHERE and it makes 0 sense! This is coming from someone who used to ship this as their OTP—no! They way they make both for the characters look is too unlike their characters! Shadow is all mushy and lustful and Amy is overly sexual. NO! Shadow is calm, collected, and doesn’t do romance. Amy is cheery, cute, and loves her hero, Sonic. I only shipped it a while ago because I thought silver was their kid. But the fandom has grossed me out so much—I simply can’t even come close to shipping it. Amy and Shadow have little to no moments, and if better ship Shadow and his red eyeliner than Shadamy. You here that, fanbrats? Your ship will NEVER happen!

Agreed People make it seem like they known each other since birth but in reality they haven't said over 60 or 70 words to each other. Plus Amy is in love with sonic and I don't think Its gonna change anytime soon and there is no "shadamy" moments in the games or shows "archie doesn't count" So it doesn't make sence. I like both of these characters but them as a couple is just BLAH!

This couple is thr most overrated piece of crap out there! There is no evidence, their personalities clash, and they aren't even friends! I swear people ship Amy with everyone now and practically idolize her! They don't like each other in anyway, they barely even speak to each other, and its just unbearingly unrealistic!

3 Tailsmo (Tails x Cosmo)

If Cosmo died, then Tails has no choice but to be with Zooey or alone as far as shipping goes. Cream doesn't deserve to be in a relationship.

This should not be on this list Tails loved her people come on

She died. It was cute before though.

4 Shadouge (Shadow x Rouge)

There are absolutely no hints from Shadow's side. Shadow is a loner and the definition of nonromantic. He shouldn't be shipped with anyone. Also, the "hints" from Rouge's side are very subjective. It's nothing special. I'd sooner ship Sonouge, seeing as he subtly flirted with her once. Besides, Rouge does have a canon crush on Knuckles.

So true. They are just partners, and Rouge just has a deep respect for him. Its nothing romantic.

This pairing is so boring and has no appeal at all. It should be #1. And the fans are despicable.

They aren't even in a romantic relationship! Shadaria and Knuxouge are WAAY better than this monstrosity!

5 Sonaze (Sonic x Blaze)

Not even in a romantic relationship. Save "Sonic and Blaze" ships for sonamy and silvaze!

And it also has little support

There are no romantic hints.

Sonaze? I strongly prefer Sonaisy.

6 Silvamy (Silver x Amy)

ONLY FOR SONAZE! (As my other comment, waste your time making sonamy and silvaze more popular with your fanfic and fanart instead of wasting your time on this junk)

Shadamy makes no sense? B s. In the game shadow was introduced in, Amy was the one to convince shadow to not destroy earth, not sonic or rouge. Just amy. Of course it doesn't matter because it won't happen but still...

However, this ship makes completely no sense and Amy just hugged silver because she again mistook him for sonic.

Kill me now. Why is this a ship? Amy felt betrayed after he tried to kill Sonic so there is a lack of trust. Also, they didn't have any chemistry.

Amy accidentally hugged Silver. Now apparently they are a couple.

7 Taiream (Tails x Cream)

This couple is horrible, deal with it. Thus, deserves to be on the list and never be taken off. Why do people think Cream should be in a relationship? She is too young and it's better to leave her hanging. (You don't need to be in a relationship to be happy, I mean not everyone does)

Tails rocks, but Cream sucks. There I said it.

A horrible abomination of a couple. Tails and Cream never shown any romantic feelings towards each other in
any of the games, comics or shows, so this "ship" isn't canon, never existed nor even
happened. Screw the fact that Tails and Cream complemented on their
gear in Sonic Free Riders, it was only general interaction, not a
romantic moment. I'm sure Sonic and Tails would say the same to
each other if they liked each other's gear. Also, it's shippers tend to bash on Cosmo from Sonic X and Zooey from Sonic Boom too much just because they think they get in the way of their precious shipping and prefer Tails with Cream. (I prefer Tails with Zooey) Also, knowing how horribly some fans treat Cream, it's better that she isn't in a relationship at all.

TAKE IT OFF THE LIST. THIS COUPLES ARE NOT HORRIBLE AT ALL. HOW COULD YOU SAY THAT! Ignorant people treated Cream so bad for no reason at all and she deserve better treatment. Tails also. Tails and Cream are so much better for each other in every category. I LOVE TAILS AND I LOVE CREAM! Tails should have Cream as his apprentice. DON'T JUMP TO CONCLUSIONS. Haters should LEAVE CREAM ALONE BECAUSE SHE'S NOT EVEN BOTHERING ANYONE AT ALL. I support Tails and Cream. You can't leave Cream hanging. it's like people want Cream to live all alone and not let her have any relationship with anyone at all. That really makes me feel sad. Please people give Tails and Cream a chance. This should not be on this list at all. Please take it off the list.

Cream is better off dead than in a relationship. There I said it.

8 Sonally (Sonic x Sally)

EW! Khanally and Sonamy! Forever!

9 Minash (Mina x Ash)

Ew. Just ew. Even though it LOOKS cute, just no!

10 Manmina (Manic x Mina)

So fake not even a couple

The Contenders
11 Sonicorn (Sonic x Sally Acorn)

Why is this on this list? It's doesn't even have many fans

12 Shadikal (Shadow x Tikal)

This couple is just nasty!

Highly unrealistic.

13 Knuckouge (Knuckles x Rouge)

Is it wrong that I can’t decide between Shadouge and Knuxouge? I like both, but I think Sega was hinting more at Knuxouge. Shadow may like Rouge, and Rouge may like Shadow, but it may be extremely hard, even impossible, for Shadow to love like that again, considering all the trauma he’s gotten from the death of Maria.
Anyways, Knuckles and Rouge are meant to be together.

Actually, I highly disagree with this. He blushes and has a hard time saying that he cares for her. This couple is canon. In Rouge's biography, it says she has a crush on knuckles and has a deep regard for him. This couplr is the most logical and backed up.

Rouge flirts with everone. It's only different for shadow because she has GUNINE INTEREST FOR SHADOW HIMSELF, not a rare Jewel or infomation on how to get them. She never uses her 'feminine charm' on shadow, but just uses that on knucklehead and everybody else she can to get what she wants

Rouge is trying to trick Knuckles into marrying her just so that she can steal the Master Emerald!

14 Creamy (Cream x Charmy)

Why? A person lied on Answers (the website) saying she talked to Sonic X director and he said real ships were:
Chaream/ Creamy

15 Sonails (Sonic x Tails)

Since when Sonic was a pedophile? (Sonic is 15 and Miles A.K.A the real name of Tails is 8)

What is this popular monstrosity? THAT IS SOOO GROSS!

Um, since WHEN was sonic p*do?!

16 Sonadow (Sonic x Shadow)

HOLY CRAP the brats who think this ship is reasonable is horrible the fanart is revolting

The most disgusting ship ever

The fan(girls) just overestimate this one. -_-

Why is this so popular? YOU NEED A GAY SHIP, SHIP INFINITE x GADGET!
(But please, instead do straight ships.)

17 SonDash (Sonic x Rainbow Dash)

They never even met and even if they did, they would compete with each other. Not love each other romantically...

18 Sonette (Sonic x Bowsette)

I really want to see this happen, I love sonic and Bowsette is really sexy

The best meme couple.

19 Sonicream (Sonic x Cream)

Sonic is creams big bro

They are just friends

Kill me. Why. Vomit.

Cream is like 6 or 8! Sonic is not a pedo!

20 Tailsouge (Tails x Rouge)

For the last time, people Rouge is 18 years old and Tails is 8 years old. So this ship is pedophilia and pedophilia is sick and wrong.

21 Sonuli (Sonic x Fuli)

I hate TLG and I am seriously praying in front of a cross hoping that the crazy shippers of The Lion Guard fandom would never pair Sonic up with Fuli. SonicxRainbow Dash is bad enough, SonicxFuli would be much worse.

Someone on DeviantArt drew a fanart of this (Fuli VS Sonic the Hedgehog), even if it's a rivalry, it still sucks.

22 Shadula (Shadow x Nebula)

I hate Shadula I like her art the but she makes Shadow seam like a cupcake, the first time Shadow meets Nebula he know her for 2 seconds and she remind hem of Mara Shadla is crap

Oh you mean gothnebula, I love her story's but she makes Shadow seam like Sonic their for I HATE shadula!

23 Shadugar (Shadow x Sugar)
24 Sonosy (Sonic x Rosy)
25 Sonouge (Sonic x Rouge)

Shadouge forever!

8Load More
PSearch List