Top 10 Worst Things About StarClan

1. They put Leafpool on trial

   Squirrelflight and Leafpool's trial was so unnecessary. StarClan judged both of them for the three, but what happened to Moth Flight? They trashed her. She judged Leafpool for having a mate outside her Clan (Crowfeather was never judged) and for having three kits, even though Moth Flight had four kits and a mate who was also from outside her Clan and a medicine cat.

   SQH is a hot mess. But this really makes me mad. They were considering sending her to the Dark Forest, too.

2. Innocent cats get sent to the Dark Forest

   Snowtuft, Frecklewish, and Juniperclaw were all sent into the Dark Forest.

   Snowtuft redeemed himself, so why does he deserve to be in the Dark Forest? Juniperclaw only poisoned SkyClan to save ShadowClan. Why does he belong in the Dark Forest? Frecklewish tried to save Mapleshade's kits until it was too late. Why the heck does she belong there?

   Frecklewish, for example.

3. Cats like Blizzardwing go to StarClan

   Ashfur, Blizzardwing, Skystar, and Onestar.

   Skystar is so rude. He killed a lot of cats. Blizzardwing just banished his mate for another mate. Onestar was once the sweetest, most lovable, and most adorable cat. During Mudclaw's rebellion, Onewhisker was horrified by what he would do. Then Onestar just hated Darkkit and made Darkkit become evil by not allowing him into his Clan.

   Ashfur is more evil than the Dark Forest itself. Why the heck does he get into StarClan while Frecklewish suffers in the Dark Forest?

   For the record, he cheated on his mate.

4. Nightstar didn't get his nine lives

   Nightstar, the leader who saved ShadowClan from Brokenstar.

   Heck, Brokenstar and Tigerstar have nine lives!

   I really think StarClan is evil.

   This is a symptom.

5. Few Clan cats question them

   Mothwing doubts them. Jayfeather definitely does, even if it doesn't show.

6. They act like gods

7. Every supernatural event is attributed to them

8. They are a cult

9. They offer no path for redemption

   ALiTM made me so angry. And not just because of Bristlefrost's death.

10. They choose who to talk with

    Shadowsight is proof. They can talk to Jayfeather, but not him?

    Shadowsight is never listened to.

The Newcomers
11. ?

    They are biased

12. ?

    They give vague prophecies that never mean what they say

The Contenders

13. They show poor judgment

14. They are responsible for getting many cats killed