Best Survivor Players

The Contenders: Page 3

41 Sarah Lacina - 11th Place - Cagayan

She clearly played like a villain and voted out the whole jury while only Andrea realized how big of a threat she honestly was and was a part of every blindside. She is the reason why everyone was placed on the jury and in she never had any official votes thrown at her the whole game. She is definitely a game changer

She was included on every vote and and had no official votes against her the whole game which is really impressive. What got her out last time, staying in the middle, is what caused her to win this time.

Honestly, she could've been better off not relying on the Legacy Advantage. - isaaonrtdmtr

She won game changers and was in on every vote

42 Rafe Judkins - 3rd Place - Guatemala

Rafe should be before danni he played strategic and he was also good at individual challenges great player

Rafe made a dumb move telling Danni that she can pick anyone. Otherwise he would have been in the final 2 and probably WON!

Lol he still loses to Danni, and she wouldn't have taken him to ftc anyway.

43 Jane Bright - 6th Place - Nicaragua

Um, she's awesome and hilarious but not an all time great player. - dathriftshop

Never judge a book by it's cover, Jane is a living testimate to this because she looks like an old lady, but, she did really well in challenges.

44 Aras Baskauskas - Winner - Panama

Just like Stephen fishbach and abi, areas is one of my favorite survivor players, and ultimately my favorite winner of all times.

Aras is great strategist and manipulator but not with a flashy gameplay.

He would have won blood vs water too had tyson not been so after him

Yeah... Aras was hot. so very hot. and a great player, he made big moves while staying under the radar which is really difficult. he's one of those winners that were just so likeable in the end that no one could vote against him

V 2 Comments
45 Hayden Moss - 6th Place - Blood vs. Water

Hope he comes back in another season!

Represented big brother well!

He should be the one getting credit for that rock draw not that moron Ciera!

46 Natalie Anderson - Survivor San Juan Del Sur

She kicked butt! She hid in the shadows for so long and pretended she didn't even exist, until the one episode where she became the center and told everyone she was going to take revenge. Just amazing. Hands down, AMAZING!

One of a the most fun players to watch that I have ever seen on this show!

One of the most entertaining winners. She played perfectly after Jeremy's blindside.

She was definitely a lot more focused without Nadiya. - naFrovivuS

V 3 Comments
47 Kass McQuillen - 3rd Place - Cagayan

Kass figured out that she was not part of her alliance and flipped. If it wasn't for a final two or Tony, Kass wins Survivor

48 Ami Cusack - 6th Place - Survivor: Vanuatu

Extremely cunning. Strong physical player. Works well in alliances. A player that can easily take the bull by the horns or disappear into the shadows. By far one of the best to never win the game. She could win, but she can't let her heart get in the way of the game like it did the last 2 times she played.

First truly dominant female player in Survivor. Orchestrated the first powerful female alliance. Made a mistake at final 7 in agreeing to vote out Eliza rather than Chris (she would have cruised to a win otherwise). Strong physically, strong strategically, and underrated socially.

49 Frosti Zernow - 8th Place - Survivor: China V 1 Comment
50 Phillip Sheppard - Runner Up - Redemption Island Phillip Sheppard - Runner Up - Redemption Island Phillip Sheppard is a United States Army veteran and the chief executive officer of a software company, who is best known for his appearances on the U.S.

Phillip definitely redeemed himself in Caramoan. Was a pretty calm leader, and didn't act rudely towards anyone. However, he was still not really the greatest choice for a leader. - isaaonrtdmtr

Hilarious! He made me choke! - MatrixHog

In Redemption Island,yeah he was a terrible player and a floater of Boston Rob like every other Ometepians. But, in Caramoan he was an underrated strategist as he started up and led the Stealth R Us 2.0. And he made every single person on the favorites tribe feel included in the allliance giving them all nicknames. And he was also the one early on who decided who stays and who goes. If Malcolm hadn't used the idols, Phillip may have won the game.

51 Susie Smith - 2nd Place - Gabon

Most underrated player ever.

52 Deena Bennett - 8th Place - The Amazon V 1 Comment
53 Brian Heidik - Winner - Thailand

Brian invented the strategy Boston Rob used in All-Stars and won with in Redemption Island. Only, Brian was much more dominant than Rob. The other contestants weren't even aware of how manipulative he was - they thought he voted them out because they were scheming against him when really he had always planned on the stabbing them in the back. He won the most individual challenges - despite throwing several of them. Including the car challenge. He also won several of the team challenges by himself. He only won 4-3, because he only needed four votes to win. Obtaining the other votes would just be a waste of his time and energy.

Brian Heidik is the most villainous Survivor player to ever play the game. I view Jonny FairPlay more of a comedic punk of a villain and Russell Hantz is not a villain but a bully. Brian is a true villain because he played the game of Survivor with absolutely no emotion, voting out people was nothing personal to him it was just business. Brian is more dangerous than Russell and FairPlay because these two are very aggressive and open about who they want voted out giving the target time to scramble. Brian waited for the right time to strike and gave his targets a slow and painful death without being in real pain. He is so overdue for a second time but it is still not too late

The first player to use the strategy of aligning with multiple individuals and promising them they were going to the end. Played a very covert game while playing up to the camera. Was very modest at tribal council, playing to the jury's ego by telling them each that he voted for them because he thought they were plotting against him. Ultimately brought the biggest loud mouth, Clay, to the end. A very underrated player! - the_scream

How is he number 34? Brian and Kim played the two best winning games of all time, it's not even close.

V 8 Comments
54 Alexis Jones - 6th Place - Micronesia V 2 Comments
55 Natalie Bolton - 4th Place - Micronesia

Pulled off a big blindside with Jason, and with help from Cirie, pulled off the biggest blindside ever with Erik.

Incredibly underrated, how has she never had a second chance yet some people have been brought back 4 times?!

One of the greatest female survivors to not be an all-star. Also the original last fan standing.

One of the best one time players

56 Eliza Orlins - 4th Place - Vanuatu

An extremely underrated player, she deserves a lot more credit then she's given. Everyone wanted her gone since Day 1 and she lasted until the last episode, with only one immunity under her belt. She won around 2/3 of the reward challenges and was part of the all-female alliance that conquered the game, up until final 7 when Eliza turned against them and got LeAnn and then the ringleader, Ami, out. She was an entertaining player and made a really good underdog. One of my top favorites

Smart player what else can you say! She made an alliance got to the top 7 with them and voted out the leaders of it when needed if she won that immunity challenge she would've won Vanutau

57 Tai Trang - 3rd Place - Kaoh Rong
58 Shannon "Shambo" Waters - 6th Place - Samoa

The chicken lady! - naFrovivuS

Seriously number 42? She has the most potential of all the women in survivor to win but only got voted out because of Russells dark plan

59 Joe Anglim - 8th Place - Survivor Cambodia Joe Anglim - 8th Place - Survivor Cambodia

You know, Tina Wesson called this guy the best to have never won and I about fell off my chair when I heard that because he can't even make it through the Final 8

One of the biggest physical threats ever

He's the best player survivor ever had

He is so good at this game

V 3 Comments
60 Matty Whitmore - 4th- Gabon

Although he is generally not looked at as an all-star, he was the piece that held the weak foa foa tribe together. He was a fantastic challenger, and a great social player. He is without a doubt my favorite survivor to watch. He would have won, if he had defeated Bob in the sudden death challenge too.

Fang. Not Foa Foa.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Greatest Survivor Players Never to Win Smartest Survivor Players Best Survivor: Blood vs Water Players Best Male Survivor Players Best Survivor: Caramoan Players

List Stats

6,000 votes
139 listings
9 years, 238 days old

Top Remixes (51)

1. Parvati Shallow - Winner - Micronesia
2. Todd Herzog - Winner - China
3. Kimberly Spradlin - Winner - One World
1. Parvati Shallow - Winner - Micronesia
2. Rob Mariano - Runner Up - All Stars
3. Sandra Diaz-Twine - Winner - Pearl Islands
1. Rob Mariano - Runner Up - All Stars
2. Parvati Shallow - Winner - Micronesia
3. Russell Hantz - Runner Up - Samoa

View All 51


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.