Top 10 Sexiest Male Survivor Contestants

The Top Ten
Marcus Lehman (Gabon)

Charlie was infatuated with him, and I could see why. I wish those two had gotten together. Marcus had a calm confidence and a brilliant body.

Malcolm Freberg (Philippines, Caramoan, Game Changers) Malcolm's first appearance was during Season 25, Survivor: Philippines. He managed to emerge, along with eventual winner Denise Stapley, from the ruins of the Matsing tribe to go deep into the game. In the end, despite winning a chance at the Final Immunity Challenge, he was unable to perform and was... read more

He is cute, but I wish that he didn't keep his mustache. He didn't look cute like that.

J. T. Thomas (Tocantins, Heroes vs Villains)

I'd do anything to be stranded on an island with him! I love his cute accent.

Nick Stanbury (Panama)

He didn't come onto my radar until he got voted off. His speech was so touching, and then looking back, that body - whoa, what can you say? He's the whole package.

Charlie Herschel (Gabon)
Brandon Quinton (Africa)
Colby Donaldson (The Australian Outback) Colby made a memorable appearance on Season 2, Survivor: The Australian Outback, becoming one of the most popular male contestants of the early seasons. He went all the way to the end, where, in a controversial move, he chose to vote out Keith Famie and take Tina Wesson to the finale. Tina ultimately... read more

The fact that he does not court or exploit female attention makes him even sexier. His self-confidence, integrity, and maturity don't make him boring. They make him amazing. All that, and a smile to knock your panties off!

That torso is just amazing, plus the charisma he possesses. However, his back is his best asset - so hot.

He is so HOT! Definitely more than Brendan! Why is Brendan number one? Are you kidding me?! Brendan pales in comparison to Mr. Colby Donaldson!

Brendan Synnott (Tocantins)

He was already absolutely gorgeous on day one but just got hotter and hotter as the days went by. Absolutely drool-worthy. On top of that, he has a great personality, which is also a huge turn-on.

It was a shame he got eliminated but still super cute! I'd get with him ANYTIME!

Those eyes just make me melt, plus that muscled body - love the pecs.

Ozzy Lusth (Cook Islands) Oscar "Ozzy" Lusth is a reality television star best known for his appearances on the reality show Survivor.

He first competed in Season 13, Survivor: Cook Islands, where he finished as the runner-up to Yul Kwon in a 5-4 jury vote. The season was notable for its initial division of tribes by... read more

In Cook Islands, this boy was looking good. He was so cute I couldn't help but root for him.

Why is he so far down?! He was the cutest boy and also the sweetest! It is a shame he didn't win!

Adam Gentry (Cook Islands)

Omg, Adam is like the perfect package. Really muscular, tan, blonde hair, beautiful eyes and face, and SUPER tall! I would pay to have my way with him.

As he got deeper into the game, I got to see more of his personality, and he was really lovable and cute.

The Newcomers

? Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)
? Billy Garcia (Cook Islands)
The Contenders
Aras Baskauskas (Panama)

If I looked at his brother and him side by side, which I have, I would never in history have thought they were brothers. Why is Aras so much hotter?

He was super cute and a loving character!

The most likable guy from all of them. And he is the cutest too.

Yul Kwon (Cook Islands)
Tom Westmann (Palau) Tom Westman is a Sole Survivor of the series Survivor. He competed on Survivor: Palau and Heroes vs. Villains.

There's something so hot about a guy like that building things in the middle of a hot, sticky jungle. I would live in a crappy hut and eat sea snakes (or shark) with him any day, even if Probst was watching. Hee!

What turns me on about this man is the fact that he just cannot be beaten. He is so strong. Love it.

Ethan Zohn (Africa, All Stars)

I did not like him in Africa, but in the All Stars season, his muscles were popping out so much I couldn't resist. Plus, that hair and amazing soul - Jenna, you are a lucky girl.

All Stars was his hottie breakout, like a breakout of acne, but he had no acne. I can't believe Rob M. made fun of his hair. It makes him look cuter.

Jeff Wilson (Palau)

He has the most votes of the people I voted for and only has 12th place? Below JEFF VARNER? The voters here are nuts, except for J.T. in the top 4!

Jolanda referred to him as Hercules, and he was just that. I'm glad he appeared in the gay magazine DNA. His body proved that he was as strong as an ox.

Eddie Fox (Caramoan)

Darn, he was so hot but got blindsided. He was so cute. I wish he would have been asked back.

He and Andrea should have gotten together! That would have been a great couple. Eddie is so hot.

Is he single? If not, I will easily take him! I like sexy guys.

Mike Skupin (Australia)

Another real man. That body is just magnificent.

Spencer Bledsoe (Cagayan)

I can't believe Spencer is this far down! He's so sexy, hot, and handsome - ugh.

Andrew Savage (Pearl Islands)

I love his confidence as well as those defined, muscular calves. His strength in that weight-holding challenge was a major turn-on.

Todd Herzog (China)
Benry Henry (Nicaragua)
Joe Anglim (Worlds Apart)
Rob Mariano (Marquesas) Robert Carlo "Rob" Mariano, known by the nickname Boston Rob, is an American television personality widely known for appearing on several reality shows... read more

Rob Mariano is my celebrity crush. I am not joking. He is so cute! I know he is not coming back, but he still is the hottest Survivor contestant (male).

Jonathan Penner (Cook Islands) Jonathan Penner, or "Penner" as he is commonly known, made his debut on Season 13, Survivor: Cook Islands. His decision to flip from the Rarotonga tribe to join the Aitu Four alliance caused a major shift in the game. However, he was later betrayed by his new allies and became a member of the jury... read more
Spencer Duhm (Tocantins)
8Load More
PSearch List