Top Ten Warrior Cat Villains
I love the murder mystery in the first few books. I love how his betrayal drives Bluestar insane. I love that he becomes leader of Shadowclan. I love that he starved and released a pack of ravenous dogs into Thunderclan camp. I love the plot twist where he dies at the hands of Scourge. But I also don’t really like the twist. Tigerstar was built up over a series of six books causing so much pain and death to his own and other clans only to be suddenly murdered. If you’re going to have him die at some point then why build him up as a threat so much? And while I kind of get the lesson of him biting off more than he can chew with recruiting Bloodclan, I was really wanting him to settle his revenge on Firestar. It kind of felt like a plot twist for the sake of a plot twist.
Tigerstar killed SO MANY innocent cats and torn them to pieces. Why did Mapleshade have to lay out his destiny like this? Why did he have to live but his sisters die? Offense taken, tigerstar fans!
WOW Tigerstar is an ass. He killed so many cats. His mentor was evil, and Tigerstar then grew to be even worse. the buildup to his battle with Firestar in the Darkest-oh wait edgy cat beat Firestar to it. But then, we get it in The Last Hope. He takes Firestar's final life, and Firestar takes Tigerstar's second life, and frees the forest from him. Tigerstar was a cool character to read about, and he was one of the reasons as to why I love the first series. Not because he was a cold hearted serial killer, but because of how he kept the plot moving. If it weren't for him, none of the first, second, third, or fourth arcs would've happened when you come to think of it. Bluestar would have no reason to let Rusty into the clan, since there wouldn't be a prophecy about Rusty, since there would be no villain. Then Rusty wouldn't become Firestar, Leafpool and Squirrelflight wouldn't be born, and Jay or Lion wouldn't have been born. Cloudtail wouldn't be given to Firestar to become a warrior, ...more
I don't even have to say anything to say how bad Tigerstar is. Without him, all of these cats would not have died: (both directly and indirectly)
Spottedleaf (second time)
Hawkfrost (well Hawkfrost deserved to die)
Did I mention Bluestar and Firestar!
Tadpole--If he hadn't broken the warrior code and had kits with Sasha then Tadpole wouldn't have lived, or died. Calls others half-blood, disloyal, traitor, yet doesn't kill his own kits, Bramblestar and Tawnypelt, Sasha, Mothwing and Hawkfrost, the Dark Forest Cats, and most of all HIMSELF! Just wow, Tigerstar. If he existed in real life I would go up to him, pick him up, tie him up with nylon ropes, and leave him like that to slowly be strangled or starve to death.
If you have read Warriors: The Ultimate Guide, you would know that Tigerstar scorned the StarClan cats' advice ...more
HAWKFROST WAS MANIPULATED! He killed himself indirectly also :3.
He was the true evilest villain. Tigerstar was ambitious and vengeful, but Brockenstar was just plain evil!
I theorize that he was actually a psychopathic leader. Reason: he killed kits for no logical reason (for a villain), lost 8 of his lives right away to the joy of their power, and destroyed his own clan for fun. He reminds me of Nero (a historical psychopathic ruler) who killed he own pregnate wife with a nonsensical reason, set his capital on fire with his own hands, and was eventaully killed by other government officals because he was destroying the empire. See the similarity?
Brokenstar is just pure, concentrated evil. He killed kits because he just wanted to! This cat would do anything for power, including killing or diving out an entire clan!
Kit murderer, kills Ferncloud, drives WindClan out of their territory, kills his own father!? Even if my father is evil, I wouldn't kill him. Killing him would make me as bad as him. But seriously, I also think he's kind of a coward. Too scared to admit that you killed Mintkit and Marigoldkit, eh? Blame Yellowfang (fifth favorite character ever), hmm?
Brokenstar, Brokenstar... What to say about him? He let kittens fight. Guess that's all I have to say. He is cruel and not even his DrAmAtiC past can excuse that.
I hate him! If It wasn't for Thistleclaw, Scourge wouldn't be evil, and neither would Tigerstar! The riverclan patrol that killed him is the greatest hero (well, actually Jay's Wing is the hero for creating the tribe so they knew about dreams and could make the clans and save warriors from being all about dumb aincients who barely know or do anything but that is totally unrelated!)!
Thistleclaw shouldn't be here! Sure, he killed a cat or two, but he hated Bluefur! But even when she became Bluestar, he stayed loyal to her and the warrior code. I don't believe he should be here. If I could choose a REAL evil cat to remove from this list, I'd choose Thistleclaw!
Firestar ACTUALLY would've lived longer if it weren't for this guy! train tigerstar, tell him to kill tiny/scourge, scourge kills firestar for the first time, Darn cat! (I actually would feel horrible and want to get revenge if my mate died too)
He recieves brutal training from Silverhawk and Shredtail. He approves of Tigerstar's choice to kill Tiny. He learns the death blow. He teaches Tigerstar power. He died as he lived...attacking a RiverClan patrol. Ends up in the Dark Forest.
He threatened to bring Sorreltail to Leopardstar, planned to take over ThunderClan territory, was going to kill Firestar when Bramblestar stopped him and saved Firestar, killing him. (Go Bramblestar!) Trains countless cats to go to the Dark side. Is a Dark Forest cat. Isn't that enough to prove that he's evil?
I don't know if Hawkfrost really deserve to be in the top ten villains. He just did all of this for his father, because he never had a good family. And then he regretted most of it.
Hawkfrost is also my favourite villan, but I am a Hollyleaf fan so I will run after you with a pitch fork!
At first I liked Hawkfrost but then he turned evil because of stupid Tigerstar and he started plotting with Ashfur and tried to get rid of Stormfur and Brook and he KILLED Hollyleaf, she was amazing. I think that he could have been a good cat and he did used to be really nice, like (even though it was the wrong thing to do) helping Mothwing become a medicine cat and when he was a kit he was so cute and innocent and was heartbroken when Tadpole died and he also tried to kill Firestar which was completely wrong but he did it for his brother. I wish he could have ended up like Bramblestar and not his dad (I think he was cute with Ivypool too, until he tried to kill her. )
On my opinion, Scourge is one of the best villains. He had a cool (and realistic) past and did much evil things. He tried to take other the clans and the forest, and I guess the best thing is, that he's not the big muscular warrior, others show, but a small cat.
I think he is the reincarnation of evil but still he is so awesome! Scourge can be clever and treacherous. He agreed to help Tigerstar to earn territory and then kill Tigerstar himself. I wish he lived longer... I think Scourge is the best cat in Warriors
Ruby and Socks shaped out his personality. He ran away, was almost killed, “fought" off a dog, killed a rogue, becomes eviler, refuses to feed Ruby and Socks and sends them away, kills Tigerstar, taking away all nine lives at once, killed Firestar for the first time, and Firestar comes back and kills him.
Scourge is my favourite character! I love everything about him! (Probs because he's small like me self... lol) I have a small theory though. Did Firestar kill or murder him? Scourge has a collar studded with teeth protecting his neck, which was where Firestar bit him and supposedly kill him. My logic here is that there's a high chance he was probably buried alive in the thought he was dead, but only unconscious. But ya, what I'm tryna say here is... I HATE FIRESTAR! and love Scourge because he is the most awesome character ever and the only one who made the Darkest Hour interesting by killing Tigerstar #Deserved it.
Let's face it. Dark forest cats have hearts
1. Mapleshade grifeing her kits
2. Tigerstar releafed Golden flower and his kits are safe.
3. Hawkfrost caring for Shasa and Nothing
4. Thisleclaw loving Spottedleaf
Honestly, Appledusk was meant to be the worst villain. Why? I have a lot of answers:
1. Caused Mapleshade to go to the Dark forest
2. Which caused Thisleclaw to become aggressive
3. Which caused Tigerstar to go to the Dark forest
4. Which caused Hawkfrost to also go to the Dark forest
5. Which caused Antpelts death
6. Which caused the Great battle
7. Which caused LOTS of deaths.
Can we make this the most popular comment and like if you aggre with me? If you did, May Starclan light your path!
Reasons Mapleshade needs to be #1.
She succeed in her goal (making the cats of the clans miserable)
She trained cats in the dark forest
Her training cats in the dark forest creates some of the biggest villains in the series.
She was Bluestar if everything went wrong.
MAKE HER HIGHER UP NOW! I WANT HER NUMBER ONE.
Ps. Please stop voting for her be she killed Spottedleaf the second time.
I think Mapleshade is the worst because she CONVINCED cats to be evil and plotted it all from her spot in the dark forest, however, she was only angry at her mate (Appledusk of thunderclan) and riverclan. Her mate blamed her for drowning their kits in the river and riverclan thought of her as a traitor for having a mate in another clan. Thunderclan did not accept her. Thank you!
I love Mapleshade because she represents female gender. Female villains should be more common. I think in my opinion that Mapleshade deserves more. She is the best to me *snuggles Mapleshade*
Its just my opinion, but Sol is one of the worst characters. Of course, he is cool, but I hate him. Has its reasons. But he is a true villain and tried to destroy the clans.
Like the authors said: you don't need to kill with your own hands/paws. The worst villians are those that make others do it for them. That is Sol's style of villain.
Sol is a non-warrior, but a lobbyist. He "kills" Blackstar by using his mouth and brain. By the way, if you have read SkyClan and the Stranger, you will know why Sol wants to kill Warrior Code and the Clans. He is a selfish cat too. He wants to kill the Warrior Code, all because he wants to be a warrior. How selfish he is! Anyway, in his case, we learn one thing: Beware the people who tries to persuade you, because they might have plans to beat you without fighting. Non warriors are more dangerous than warriors.
Sol is my favorite! He is my bad boy! First, he acts innocent, then manipulates the three, then convinces Blackfoot to team up with him to destroy StarClan, then he MAKES A FREAKING WAR THIS GUY IS CRAZY!
He 's way too obsessed with Squirrelflight. He would've killed four cats. (Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, Jayfeather, Firestar.) He helped Hawkfrost set the fox-trap for Firestar, and was going to kill Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather. I was glad when Hollyleaf killed him. I was furious when he ended up in StarClan when Mapleshade didn't. He deserves to rot in the Dark Forest for all eternity!
Ashfur doesn't deserve to be here. He's kind, brave, deserving, and loving. A little too loving that is. Squirrelflight is the evil one! She's an idiot to love Brambleclaw instead of Ashfur. I can just imagine the kits they would've had!
I can see how some may think Ash is evil, but he was just jealous. Because of Brambleclaw, two of the cats on this list, who just happen to be my favorites, were somehow badly affected by Brambleclaw. Ashfur deserved Squirrelflight.
Honestly, I'm half and half with him. Yes, his lover DID leave him, but he reacted by trying to kill Firestar (who I honestly don't like), Squirrelflight, Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze. He tried to kick out his own CLANMATE, and was planning to ruin Squirrelflight's life. I don't know why people see him as the "good guy" in this. Also, when Hollyleaf killed him, WHY do they make her look evil? SHE WAS HORRIFIED. SHE KILLED HER OWN CLANMATE, SURE. But seriously, they always make Squirrelflight look like the villain when they're just trying to make the REAL ONE look innocent! Compared to Hollyleaf, WHO ONCE AGAIN KILLED ONE CAT, AND didn't TRY TO KILL 5, he's the true monster.
If it weren't for Clawface Spottedleaf would still be alive! Spottedleaf is such an innocent cat and I absolutely ship Firestar and Spottedleaf so just- just- DIE CLAWFACE.
Can people quit voting for him because he killed Spottedleaf. He did other stuff to. Just because he killed her doesn’t mean he is instantly the most evil cat ever. Think about it. If she never died then she wouldn’t have been able to appear in Firestar’s dreams and give him prophecies and stuff.
Spottedleaf is my favorite! How darew he's not 1st! HE KILLED HER! He was like... Brokenstar's BEST ALLIE! Excuse me, but if I WERE YOU... I would 100% put him on #1 for villans! How dare you kill Spottedleaf! Oh, you wretched cat!
Honestly, I don't care for him. He was only killing Spottedleaf either out of leader's orders, or because he WAS under Brokenstar's influence. And, if he was following orders, that's fine. Killing, yes it's a crime, but according to the code, leader's word is law, and you have to follow it. Besides, he never came back and murdered even more cats, RIGHT? I just think he might've been following orders, which is fine. End of story.
Traitor! Mean to Firestar when he arrived. Knows about Tigerstar's plan to destroy ThunderClan and doesn't do anything. Takes Bramblestar and Tawnypelt to meet Tigerstar. Tries to take Bramblestar and Tawnypelt to ShadowClan while the dogs attack. Meets up with Blackstar and feeds Sorreltail deathberries. Exiled and happily tries to kill Stonefur. Blackfoot helps him. Volunteers eagerly to kill Feathertail and Stormfur. Is ashamed when Tigerstar refuses, claiming that he was so nearly beaten by a prisoner. He's ashamed by that. When a cat is going to kill Firestar, he throws the tortoiseshell she-cat off and told Firestar that he wouldn't let him get killed by her, and that he wanted to kill him. Attacks with the Dark Forest in the Last Hope.
I just don't like Darkstripe. But he is a good villain. He just creeps around Tigerstar, and when he died, he just changed sides to kill Firestar! No one understands.
Really quite a good villain. He was a self serving coward. And I mean that as a compliment. I like being called a coward. And self/serving.
This guy is not a villain, but a perverted creep. He acts all perverted and like a pedo, and is always saying, "Oooh, no one can beat Hawkfrost, ooh," as if he's a sexual predator eating to pounce. He is alway tailing under Tigerstar's paws, listening to everything he says, and seems happy when Tigerstar's scolds him! He also lacks any taste of possible loyalty nor morality! He left ThunderClan for TigerClan, and right after Tigerstar became slaughtered by Scourge, he just went ahead and joined BloodClan. He also says creepy things in a lusty way, towards Hawkfrost and Tigerstar! No wonder they yell at him do much! He creeps the poor guys out! Plus, he fed and kit DEATHBERRIES just because he was caught PLOTTING with Blackfoot, a ShadowClan warrior! Ugh, it's just something about this guy that gives me the creeps. He just has BLIND loyalty, and follows anyone who offers an invitation.
Ok, I absolutely hate him. I thank those apprentices for getting revenge for Whitestorm. But I still need MY revenge! - Whitefeather
I don't really like Bone. However, we can say he's very strong to live a life eating garbage and fighting other cats and dogs for the territory. He was killed by apprentices, but they were a lot of apprentices. And when everybody jumps on you, what do you do? You fall down on the ground, while the apprentices try to kill you. Yes. Apprentices. It's a bit embarrassing, but Bone was strong enough to kill Whitestorm, a senior warrior.
I don't care for Bone. Like I said on the Clawface one, he was just following orders. Put yourself in the character's shoes (more like paws) and see why they do what they do. Bone killed under clear instructions from his leader, and there was a war going on between the clans, so it would be understandable if you had to resort to killing.
I vote Bone, I agree, vote Bone if you want pity for Whitestorm, I never noticed Whitestorm until he was made deputy, but when he was killed, I was so sad, R.I.P
Whitestorm, happy hunting in Starclan
Think of it this way: In the mountains, Sharptooth was the warrior cat. The Tribe was the rabbits, birds, mice, voles, etc. Prey. Fine, let's try roleplay. You are a mountain lion. You see a huge group of prey, just waiting to be eaten. They have flesh and fur. They're prey. Merely prey, who puts up a small struggle but nonetheless prey. Then, there's a bunch of tiny, miserable excuses for life. What do you choose? That's what I thought. Technically, Sharptooth is not a villain- just a larger version of the warrior cats! What else can he do, take pity on his own food, plain as a fish out of water, practically on his dinner plate!
-Silverfrost of RiverClan
Guys, I personally do not think of Sharptooth as a villain. He was merely a mountain lion trying to survive. Mountain lions count cats as prey and what do the warriors do when they see prey? They catch it for their clan. It's no different for Sharptooth; put yourself in the character's shoes and think of why they do the things they do.
Ahem, aren't mountain lions cats too? The way I see it, mountain lions (like Sharptooth) are basically cannibals that eat the species descended from them. Just saying, *shrugs and walks off*.
I don't give a fudgesicle about him/her. If you were in his/her shoes, and you NEEDED food, and the closest options were cats, I think you would choose to eat first. It's just survival. Sure he did "kill" Feathertail, but she did it out of protecting the tribe. Isn't that enough? I know, I know, most of you support Featherpaw or Crowtail or whatever it is, but like I said, SURVIVAL. You need food, or you die. Period.
Sharptooth is a mountain lion. He is trying to survive, just like the Tribe. In this case, Sharpy is the predator. The Tribe were, how we'd say this in scientific terms, outcompeted. Sharptooth won, until he was outcompeted. He's not a villain. He's trying to survive, like the Tribe, like the Clans, like you and me.
Another roleplay: Your Clan is in the middle of battle. You are a medicine cat. A rival cat is desperately trying to diminish YOUR herbs RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU. What do you do? Although he might have been a little harsh with the killing, think of Lionblaze! Did he mean to kill Russetfur? No! I'm sure Hawkheart didn't mean to kill Bluestar's mother. You sympathize Lionblaze, but not Hawkheart! Really?! What kind of people are you?! What are you supposed to do, watch a rival destroy your herbs?!
-Silverfrost of RiverClan
HawkHeart was low to kill Moonflower, he's a medicine cat, and medicine cats shouldn't kill cats! And either way he could have let her go but he KILLED her, I don't see him as a Villain but simply a annoying cat who did things in the past that annoy people. True, he was only defending his clan, but killed Moonflower was very unnecessary, and cruel for a medicine cat.
Oh my GOD! Hawkheart wasn’t a bad guy and should NOT be considered a villain. He was a loyal medicine cat and really cared for his clan! He was very kind to Yellowfang and it is even told in Yellowfang’s secret that he had trained as a warrior before becoming a medicine cat. Moonflower was in the wrong for mucking around the medicine den, as she should have known that he was a trained warrior. He saved his clan from dying to diseases like greencough in the future! You all wouldn’t have batted an eye if the warrior who died was Patchpaw or some minor character!
Hawkheart was never evil. He never had any bad intentions, and he was never a villian. You never know he could have killed Moonflower by accident. And he only killed one cat. Do you know how many cats your beloved Bluestar probably killed? Firestar? Yeah, no reply. Hawkheart is not a villian! He was a medicine cat, for StarClan's sake!
This rabitt has fox dung for brains. To attack Longtail, one of my favorite warriors, and make him blind. That's just not cool. It's the thing that only a mouse-brained fool would do.
- Longtail happened to be my favourite cat in the entire series. He may have been a jerk to young Firestar, but who could blame him? Clearly the whole battle wasn't even that horrible if Bluestar didn't end it, and she also didn't punish Longtail for it.
I personally think Firestar was far overrated, especially if he managed to defeat Longtail, a trained warrior, right as soon as he leaves his Twolegs. It isn't logical.
I must've spent at least five minutes laughing at these comments. As soon as I saw the title, I instantly voted for it. That rabbit destroyed Longtail! My poor baby never hunted another mouse again.
Speaking about mice, Mousefur's is just as evil. True, had she not been so worried over old prey anyway, Longtail would more than likely be alive. But, if that mouse hadn't existed, Mousefur wouldn't have been so worried and there would not have been something to crush Longtail!
*** VOTE FOR THE RABBIT THAT HURT LONGTAIL! ***
Lol 😂! Longtail was one of my favorite cats. Sure he was a jerk to Firepaw but can you blame him? I would do the same! And he clearly won the fight between him and Firepaw. Bluestar said “This cat has lost his twoleg collar in a battle for honor.” (Or something like that) Yeah he lost the rope of same that hung around his neck. So great.
What would you guys do if someone was trying to eat you? I’d totally fight back. Everyone teaches you that you run, hide or fight when someone try’s to hurt you. Now the rabbit couldn’t run, or hide so that leaves fight. You can’t blame the rabbit!
He isn't evil, he was just ordered by Tigerstar. I don't believe that he carries evilness in his heart, he is one of my favourite cats in the entire series.
So I think he wasn’t truly EVIL per say, but was definitely a villain. You could say Tigerstar wasn’t evil because he was under the influence of Thistleclaw, but we all think he’s a villain. I think Blackfoot was a really complicated character and enjoyed one who maybe didn’t want to do what he was doing and found ways to become better later on.
Guys. Are characters not allowed to develop over time? When he killed Stonefur, he was acting under orders, and I seriously doubt Tigerstar would have cared if Blackfoot had objections. He probably would have been killed himself if he had objected. If you're going to hate him for killing a cat, then you may as well hate Firestar or Graystripe too, because they've killed cats. You CANNOT ignore the fact that when Blackstar became leader of Shadowclan, they had given up all hope. He made them great again. He made them strong again. He wasn't the first cat to be manipulated by Sol, nor the last. Don't forget, the clans still thought Sol had predicted the eclipse, something not even Starclan had forseen. It was a poor judgement to let him into Shadowclan, but Blackstar realized his mistakes, and he helped to drive Sol out upon realizing the clans had been tricked. He certainly isn't evil, and he belongs in Starclan.
Blackfoot killed cats in cold blood, became a rogue for a short amount of time, and got tricked out of his beliefs by a loner who he barely knew, yet despite all this, he's my favorite tied with Whiestorm. While he isn't completely justified, he has legit character development and assisted Firestar in many ways. Who knows what would've happened to ThunderClan hadn't he decided to help them against WindClan and RiverClan? He is also extremely loyal to his clan. Did Tallstar not develop after learning his mistakes? Did Bluestar? Honestly, you people look at the bad much more often than the good. He is the guy who restored ShadowClan. He is the guy who saved ThunderClan's hide from WindClan. HE is the guy who killed Redwillow. Without him, who knows what would've happened to ShadowClan and ThunderClan? He was a bit persistent, and a bit aggressive, but nowhere near evil. He has legit redemption, which is something I allow with open arm- paws and nowhere near as bad as many take him for.
When I rank a side villain above main series villians. I think they need more good ones like Willy. Ones that actually DO damage by their OWN evil ambitions.
He killed those poor baby chicks, made Ravenpaw and Barley, leave the game, took advantage of their generosity, and was just a rude, traitor after all.
He set the Twolegs against Barley and Ravenpaw when they were trying to help! He brought some of BloodClan into the farm, while posing as a helpless loner!
He sounds like something a dog left behind. "Come her Max and willie! " Don't you think?
Manipultive, vengeful. He said he was glad that Hollyleaf was dead, and that it was Lionblaze's turn to die. Fight's alongside the Dark Forest in the Great Battle. Get's better in Crowfeather's Trial.
I like Breezepelt, mainly because he tried to kill Jayfeather (I REALLY don't like him), but also because of his past. I love villains like these, because it gives understandable backstories that show why they became what they are. Crowfeather chose to hate him, thus Breezie (that's his name from now on don't judge me) tries to impress him, probably at no matter the costs. I personally think that the reason he is what he is is because of a father that loathes his very existance. He is a very interesting character to me, with a not too over-the-top story (*cough cough Mapleshade cough cough*) and that's why I like him. Also, I know he trained with Brokenstar, but look at it like this: what he wanted was to make his CLAN strong and not underestimated by the other clans again. To me, that isn't a sin.
Okay seriously, he CHOSE to try and kill his own clanmates! And side with the bad guys! In a vision of shadows though, he was like, “cats who followed dark tail can’t” be trusted! And like, everyone looked at him and was like, your t(e last one to talk about trust!
Breezepelt was easily manipulated by the Dark Forest cats because can you really blame him? Crowfeather was being a terrible father to him and to make things worst, he finds out that he has half-siblings in ThunderClan. I actually like him and I kinda wish that he would get along with his half-brothers in the next series (wish is very unlikely to happen) and I wish that Crowfeather would become a much better father.
How was Goosefeather evil? Is it because he had that omen that ended up killing Moonflower? No, that was unexpected. Goosefeather didn't know Moonflower was going to die, and he didn't even kill her. Hawkheart did. If you read Goosefeather's Curse, you'll see why the way he acts. He's pretty underrated, honestly. He seems like an interesting character. His novella explains that he had a special gift to connect with other Starclan cats in the past, seeming like it's a curse. Sorry, but he shouldn't be here.
Goosefeather was CURSED! That's why the book is called Goosefeather's Curse. Cloudberry took him in as her apprentice. Hawkheart killed Moonflower, not Goosefeather's. He isn't the type of cat that would kill his good littermate. (Brambleclaw is a totally different story) Goosefeather tried to help his clan when he KNEW they would starve. He even told Doestar about the kittypets attacking Squirrelwhisker's patrol. He also knew that Swiftpaw (later Swiftbreeze) was over by the sunningrocks when she went missing. How does that make him evil?
How is this cat evil? He had no reason to be on here. He interrupted an omen wrong but so did every other cat. The fourth cat prophecy was interrupted wrong. The three though it might be Hollylead or Ivypool. they didn't find out Firestar was the fourth cat until he died saving his clan, does that make Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Dovewing evil? No! Of course not.
Goosefeather was never intended to be evil and never will be.
You see, Goosefeather was REALLY determined to be a medicine cat, so he switched to a medicine cat in the middle of being a warrior apprentice. I think he was just trying too hard. Anyway, why would he kill Moonflower on purpose; she was his sister!
Ok, you gotta admit, he could have been a better father. He could have noticed all of what to love about Moonflower. But, at least he was loyal to his clan, right?
I don't like him. Moonflower loved him when she was a KIT. Then, they have kits and he's all " forget what's-her-face and my kits! I'm gonna go hang with Dappletail."
When Moonflower dies: "wait, who are you? Oh, you're my kit! Wait what's-her-face died? Oh well, sorry. "
In star clan: " I'm so sorry my precious Bluestar! I should've protected your mother! I never loved Dappletail" then she comes: "hi my love... No I was just thinking of you... No they mean nothing to me! "
See, he's a no-good, lying jerk-face!
Stormtail was a terrible father (much more than Crowfeather), a terrible mate (much more than Crowfeather), and a cheater (much more than Crowfeather. Why am I comparing him to Crowfeather? I have no idea) but he was loyal to his clan and was (kinda) there for Bluestar when Snowfur died (KINDA).
Dappletail could be his mother (along with the white kit with blue eyes who was deaf and mentioned by Dappletail when talking about one of her kits from a previous litter) as the books always mention her having kits. The erins confirmed that Patchpet was Greystripes father so it is possible for cats to retire to the elders den soon after having kits. Although I am not sure about Stormtail.
Guys.. He is Evil+Evil+Evil+Evil times 100. He was so cruel when he did not cure sick prisoners, did not fed them well, and when he ordered Needletail to kill Violetpaw! Also, he destroyed riverclan, and shadowclan. How can this guy not be 1? He is scary. One time, I said I rather join the kin than bloodclan, I was wrong. You should join BLOODCLAN. Darktail is scary... So scary... even better at thinking something cruel than Tigerstar. Scourge allow his littermates to eat at least for once. Tigerstar wasn't that evil too. Brokenstar.. Well he is evil, but so does darktail or even more. He deserves first place.
Why is Darktail not #1? First of all, he completely took over ShadowClan and RiverClan and drove out SkyClan from their old territory. What did Tigerstar do? He became leader of ShadowClan, then was killed abrutly by Scourge. Darktail punished cats for simply not agreeing with him, while Tigerstar did follow a few of the rules, like waiting to become deputy before ambushing Bluestar. After reading this, we can ALL agree that Darktail caused WAY more damage to the Clans and is the MOST EVIL warrior cat.
Darktail is a truly villain. And he would admit it. At least I guess. I mean, though he had a DrAmAtIc past, he tried to destroy the clans with his FaMiLy. But he's kinda cool though xD
Why is this guy not number 1? In my opinion, he is the most bloodthirsty power hungry scary villain in the entire world! Even more scary than Voldemort!
Not all villians kill. Just as much damage can be done with words. People (cats) that INTENTIONALLY use their words to DESTROY others are villians too. If it's not intential, they aren't villians.
For example, Longtail does want to make Rusty/Firepaw feel bad, but he could not bring himself to go as far because he doesn't really want to hurt others. Also, Millie does her negative statements out of her own stability. Both are antaganists, but not villians.
Rainflower is a villain.
Well...Yes, she's one of the worst parents in the series and I do not feel any sympathy for her. Literally, she said THIS: "Who cares? He will never be better than you." (Rainflower to Oakheart about Crookedjaw)
Only a horrible, cruel mother says that. Die, Rainflower!
Gold digger! She told Oakheart that he was better than crookedpaw just because crookedpaw wasn’t exactly picture perfect! What kind of mom does that? A horrrible one.
I do think Rainflower's actions were bad, but she was different. She was trying to stop loving Crookedstar, so that if he died, it wouldn't affect her. She changed his name so she'd forget about Stormkit. It's not that she didn't love him, she was just trying to prevent being hurt(Emotionally). If she were emotionally hurt, it could lead to WORSE things. Such as Ashfur, since he didn't get the love he was looking for, and every other cat was out of his age ranks, he threatened to kill many cats, leading the Hollyleaf leaving, and Lioblaze and Jayfeather hating Leafpool and Squirrelflight, but that's beside the point. The truth is that she was trying to shelter herself from the pain that would've been inflicted. - Whitesplash
Oh Clear sky! He was so brutal in first 3 books of DOC, but anyway he became nice cute cat~ I love him :) I love him in both ways, villain and good guy! Clear Sky was super mean when he was villain, not feeding Jackdaw's Cry lol (Did I spelled right?). But he was so cutie when he was good guy in fourth book! I LOVE him
Clear Sky was totally a antagonist for the first couple of Dawn of the Clans books. I think he was totally unreasonable but I totally understand why, which is why he’s one of my favorite villains.
Why is clear sky not the first most evil. THERE WOULDN'T BE EVIL IN THE CLANS IF IT WEREN'T FOR HIM.
List of some of the bad things he did.
1 Throw out his little brother cause he was injured. 2 Murder the mother of some helpless kits, and lie to them. 3 Murder a kittypet. 4 not want his own son. 5 caused many cats to kill each other. 6 Created boundaries 7 lied all the time. 8 hate his whole family. 9 Try to kill his brother, and basically tried to kill everyone. 10 tried to justify and say everything he was doing was right. 11 Throw out some of his most loyal followers because of injury. 12 Try to teach litte, cute kits harsh, battle moves. 13 lie to everyone. 14 super duper mean and demanding. 15 only cares about himself. That is just some of the things he did. HE is also the reason clans were divided, and they aren't all living in peace. I HATE your GUTS CLEAR SKY!
I really hate it when people say that clear sky was evil
First off he was the first skyclan leader how can he be evil?
Second he was blinded by fear of his cats starving
Would YOU like to see your sister/brother starve?!?!
Third everyone concentrate on the BAD things he did
No body ever remember that he saved Gray wing kit!
And he changed. In the first battle if he was really evil he Would have killed Gray wing because evil cats don't care WHO they harm but in the end clear sky is a good cat and he should not be anywhere near this list.
Clear Sky was a villain, at least for the first 3 Books. Not because he's evil. He's a villain.
I really wish we could’ve seen more of Snowtuft! There was only on or two scenes with him and they didn’t even list him in the clans when he was alive! I need more snowtuft
This cat is evil because he is in the Darkforest, isn't a good argument. We don't even know why he's their, which is sad because we can say he was their for killing one cat like every other cat who is alive/was alive.
Snowtuft is in the Dark Forest so that makes him a villain. Some other non-Dark Forest'ers are villains higher than Snowtuft here so I'm wondering why he's all the way down here.
Snowtuft really is a good Dark Forest warrior. He trained. He helped. He stayed loyal. All that matters, right?
You terror! You changed poor tiny/scourge's life!
Look at it this way.
If Ruby hadn't left him out, made him want to prove himself, then tell him that unwanted kits get thrown in the river, scourge/tiny would have been a kittypet, and nothing bad concerning Scourge would have ever happened!
Technically, if she didn't do what she did, Scrouge would've never formed BloodClan and some other cat would have to kill Tigerstar nine times because the forest cats don't have dog teeth as claws to rip out nine lives at once. So, she indirectly saved the forest.
If it weren't for her rumor, 'Unwanted kits get thrown in the river!' Scourge would've never become evil. It's a fact...
Any vote that went to Scourge should have gone to Ruby. Ruby created Scourge as a villain.
He and Silverhawk trained Thistleclaw.Thistleclaw turned Tigerclaw evil.It wasn’t Mapleshade who created the evil chain it was Shredtail and Silverhawk!
He was in the Dark Forest which is bad enough!
I hate how he left that hideous scar on Snowtuft. He's an old atupid jerk.
I agree with Russthewolf.