Top 10 Warrior Cats with the Saddest Lives
Crookedstar was a RiverClan leader in the forest territories. He was born as Stormkit to Rainflower and Shellheart alongside his brother, Oakkit. Following an accident in which he broke his jaw, Stormkit was renamed Crookedkit at the request of Rainflower. She disowned him, leading to Crookedkit running away from the Clan. After returning, he was apprenticed as Crookedpaw to Cedarpelt. He was continually visited in his dreams by Mapleshade, who trained him and demanded he stay loyal to RiverClan above all else. ...read more.
1. I think what makes this book so sad is how he was rejected by his own mother for a horrible mistake he regretted so much he had to flee the Clan. Echomist was more of a mother to Crookedstar then Rainflower who couldn't admit how wrong she was about Crooked.
2. When Willowbreeze died I couldn't stop crying, she was a kind, loving cat that accepted Crooked and loved him. Crookedstar's excitement when he heard Willwbreeze was having his kits was so heartwarming and beautiful. When she died and Crooked went into the Dark Forest to kill Mapleshade I could really feel how heartbroken he was.
3. THE KITS! When the died along with their mother I for sure thought that Crookedstar would leave the Clans again.
4. This was just a heartwarming moment, I loved the scene where Oak and Crooked fought over Silverstream and how Crooked should be a better father. The book ended on a high note when Crooked promised to always take care of Silver.
1. He broke his jaw and then he was neglected by his mother. He was renamed to Crookedkit and he still had love and care to his mother even after she rejected him. She then died and Crookedstar was upset
2. He had then lost his father by lump in his stomach
3. Willowbreeze's death was the one that killed me. She died of greencough shortly after her kits were born and then she died. Crookedstar was furious and he went into the Dark Forest and tried to killed Mapleshade. He didn't succeed.
4. His two kits then died with their mother except for one, Silverkit, and Crookedstar was very protective of her.
5. His brother then died after a rockslide in a battle
6. THEN his daughter died while having kits and then its was over
All he had was his grandchildren.
He then lost his ninth life by greencough.
He didn't deserve all that. Sure Mapleshade trained him but no warrior cat should ever have to go through that. Even though I hated Ashfur, I felt so bad. Crookedstar is my favorite warrior cat. (Alongside Yellowfang)
Guys, seriously, Crookedstar's Promise is so much sadder than Bluestar's Prophecy. Crookedstar lost his mate, parents, kits, and leader, and also was underestimated because of a scar. Bluestar lost her mother at a young age, and her sister later on, and had to give up her kits. But Crookedstar didn't get to see two of his kits grow up. And what really makes Bluestar's Prophecy sad is that Bluestar won't stop mourning. I think CrookedStar's life is very sad. To have to watch everyone around you die, it's just heart-breaking.
Mapleshade is not what I would consider a 'bad character', but rather a broken character. Yeah, she made mistakes in her past, but who doesn't? What wrecked her life was the denial of her mate, Thunderclan's choice to exile her, and the choices made by many others who turned her away. Mapleshade was a desperate mother. And when her kits died, she lost everything. I don't agree with her actions, but people/cats need to acknowledge that her life was torn apart. Time and time again, she was rejected, turned away, banished. And just think, if Tigerheart was a fox-hearted fool, and the leader of Thunderclan was cruel, then this would have been Dovewing's fate too. A DESPERATE, AND BROKEN MOTHER.
-Birdcreek's Opinion :)
I really think Mapleshade should be in Starclan. I give credit to the person who gave me this idea, but think about it! She had a bad childhood. If she was exiled, and no cat called for her to stay or anything, that means her parents and siblings don't care about her or are dead. Which leads to a bad childhood. I watched a video on youtube and Bright Guardian Akira and Moonkitti really said that Mapleshade was always selfish, and they got that proof from when Mapleshade thought or said several times " Back off Reedshine! Appledusk is mine!" But they didn't look into the story. What really made Mapleshade evil and selfish? What I said about the bad childhood. If her parents and siblings were dead or if they didn't care about her, Mapleshade never learned to love. She was selfish becuase she thought Appledusk would always be the one to love her. This is Why she DESERVES Starclan. Thx for the person with this theory and Bright Guardian Akira is no longer active I think.
First of all, I think she only loved her kits way too much. And did all the things she did it was only for her very broken heart, and her kits...Okay, Thunder Clan should have accepted her, letting some kits and their mothers go away somewhere without any protection like, That's heartless in MY opinion! Raven Wing didn't care at all about those kits. Freckle Wish cared a lot for the kits, and all out of a sudden despised them. Surely forgetting the good moments with them. It's okay she had felt betrayed since she though it was her dead brother kits but, uh. They are only innocent kits who didn't deserve all those stares of every warrior, and hate. Apple dusk cheated on her, remplacing her with ReedShine and acussed her for his and her kits death. Non-sense if I'm being honest. That's why I vote for Maple Shade and think she should be #1.
She went insane after her kits died and killed who she believed were the culprits. Just like me when my friends steal my Smarties.
Poor Briarlight! She couldn't move her hind legs after being crushed by a tree. I found it rather rude that Jayfeather wouldn't take her under his paw. She always was so helpful and kind with him even though he was usually snappish.
(First off this is MY OPINION about her, do not hate me) Okay so first she was training, blah blah blah. tree falls down. Blah blah blah. Anyways Longtail ran down (sorry long tail) but she ran down knowing she probably wouldn't survive or return perfect. But still did it. I honor her for courage but still seriously. After that, (poor siblings) her mother babies her and Blossomfall gets YELLED at and she was hurt (both ways, mentally and physically). So her mom obvious doesn't care. Briarlight just watches her mom yell at Blossomfall. (I just finished Omen of Stars so I don't know about after). So mom only cares about her. So, image your a child, the only child breaks there leg and it's unfixable. The mom yells at you for being away for awhile and you have thorns in your foot and she doesn't care. That's why I like her siblings more. (Again please don't hate me :( its MY opinion)
Briarlights life is much more sadder than Bluestars and Ivypool's would ever be. She didn't have kits, Ivypool and Bluestar both found love and she couldn't walk properly from when she was an apprentice. She died young too, stuck in the Medicine Cat Den all her life doing exercises. Never out of camp living the life of a real warrior. I say put her higher on the list! If I was to make a cat come to life again like Cinderfur Briarlight would be my first choice!
OMG Briarlight, she had the hardest life, she broke her backbone and paralyzed her hind legs, by a tree!, all she could do was sit around in the medicine den, since jay feather wont mentor her, by the way I think she got reincarnated! I feel so bad for her, he dreams of being a warrior, CRUSHED and so is her backbone, her life sucked and honestly I think she should be #1, her life was the hardest.
Her life was FULL of death. She watched her mother get viscously murdered right after she became an apprentice. Her father didn't really care about her, and ran off with some other she-cat right after her mother was murdered. She watched her sister get hit and killed by a car, then had to raise her nephew, Whitestorm, and protect him from his evil father, Thistleclaw. She fell in love with Oakheart, from another clan and got pregnant. She was pretty much forced to give up her kits, or Thistleclaw would have become leader and most likely destroy the Clan. She had to bring her kits through a blizzard and Mosskit died and she had to burry her in the snow. She couldn't even watch the other two grow up because they were in RiverClan. Right after she dealt with losing her kits she immediately became deputy and soon leader and had to carry the weight of the Clan. Her best friend, Thrushpelt died, and she dealt with the guilt of never giving him the life he deserved. Tigerclaw's treachery and ...more
Her life was so sad! Her mother was killed by a medicine cat, Goosefeather (her uncle) tells her she's destined to lead Thunderclan, and that means giving up her kits, she couldn't be with her mate, her sister dies, one of her other kits die, and she has to live knowing her kits will never see her as their mother. On top of all of this, her father never payed attention to her, except for once when he comforted her, but that was ONCE, and he was just padding after a she-cat who was less than a year older then his kits!
As sunstar said, she suffered a lot for one cat, also like leafpool was abandoned by star clan, and also had to sacrifice for her children, it broke her apart, haunts her in her darkest times, I call that sad!
Her father completely ignored her as a kitten, but that was okay, because she still had her mother, who was proud of her. When she and her sisters became apprentices, she was forced into a battle and watched Moonflower, her mother, die in front of her. She was barely more than a kitten and was heartbroken. After a few moons of grief, she moved on and vowed to make Moonflower proud from StarClan. She became a warrior alongside her sister, whom she was very close too. Snowfur grew closer towards a warrior named Thistleclaw and they had a kit together. Whitekit. Bluefur, trying to spend some time with Snowfur, persuaded her to go on a walk. They bumped into some ShadowClan warriors, and while chasing them out of ThunderClan territory, Snowfur got hit by a car. Bluefur blamed herself deeply for her sister's death and thought she would never feel happiness again. Instead, she became Whitekit's foster mother and watched him become a warrior, guiding him all the way. Around that time, she ...more
Cinderpelt would've been a great warrior ngl. She twisted her hind leg and she couldn't walk very well. While she was an apprentice without her injury, Cinderpaw's dream to become a warrior, her feelings for Firestar...And all that was taken away after Tigerstar's trap nearly killed her (she was hit by a monster). She had to stop her warrior training and become a MEDICINE CAT. Firestar didn't know she had feelings for him so he went of with Sandstorm :(. Cinderpaw blamed herself for killing Silverstream, her mentor Yellowfang died in a fire.
Many moons later Cinderpelt was killed by a badger.
Cinderpelt is truly my favorite character. She could have turn into a great warrior if Tigerstar was killed earlier. She blames herself of Silverstream's death even though it is not her fault. And not long after she received her full name, her mentor Yellowfang died. It must have felt awful. Even when she received the omen that she will die soon, and don't have a medicine apprentice. She risks her life of saving Sorreltail and her kits. And a badger killed her. The worst creature ever is badgers.She died so young. I LOVE Cinderpelt.
I'm glad Cinderpelt got a new life as Cinderheart but she was too young to die. But she died doing what she loved. Helping and Saving her best friend.
She gave up everything she loved when the car crushed her leg. Her dreams of becoming a warrior, her love for Fireheart/star. She had a chance to become an amazing warrior and become his mate, and the monster took all of it away! Think about the pain she felt looking at Sandstorm and Firestar, knowing that it could've been her! Instead she had to hide her feelings and pretend that Firestar was nothing more than her leader and friend... Firestar didn't even know she loved him!
Scourge honestly did have a pretty sad life. If it wasn't for socks and ruby and tigerstar, scourge actually wouldn't be evil! Scourge somehow got a whole alley of cats to join this so called new clan called blood clan, and he became evil, and he was now born to fight, and kill. I fell sad.
-Silentwhispers the Riverclan medicine cat
Not gonna lie, Scourge did live a kind of sad life, he was bullied, was lied to by Ruby, ran away because of the lie, didn't have enough food, Ruby and Socks are so mean!
Uhm, I think Scourge is a Sociopath. Yes, Tigerpaw attacked him and they didn't let em into the clan, but he would have STILL been evil. He have a hunger for power like Tigerclaw/star. For all those people who say "oh, Baby scourge didn't do anything wrong.." and "It was all Socks and Ruby's fault" I'm not trying to bash your opinion, but for you thinking that think abour what he thought. he Thinks "I'll show them...I'LL SHOW THEM ALL" while he was still in Kitty-Pet place. So, he was evil BEFORE he left his home. He craves for power and blood lust. Is that normal? I think not.
But his kithood was sad, not like his whole life. Yup, getting bullied by his siblings is sad, but seriously guys, he was leader of one rogue group/BloodClan and had a enjoyable life until the Darkest Hour.
Yellowfang. She grew to love Raggedstar, only to have his kits in secret, due to medcine cat rules! Her two kits died, which omg this is going to make me cry, which she named Wishkit and Hopekit! Her third kit survived, only to turn on his mother and father. He killed Raggedstar and banished Yellowfang. Yellowfang in ThunderClan was grumpy, impatint but she fought enough battles for 9 lifetimes. She did two things before she died. She killed her own son to save the Clans, Brokenstar, by feeding him deathberries. She died of smoke enhaliton. And now StarClan says she has to do prohecys and deal with Jayfeather! Rest, Yellowfang, rest.
Oh yes. Yellowfang. One of the saddest life in the Warriors series. I mean literately, she lost Silverflame, her grandmother, as an apprentice, ability to feel every cats pain. Had feelings for Raggedpelt, but she realized that she needed to become a medicine cat, so they stopped hanging out together. She then had his kits and the two of them died. Only one survivor, Brokenkit. The biggest mistake of all. He was adopted to a very harsh and strick queen. He was treated poorly. When he became deputy, he murdered his own father to become leader. He trained kits to become warriors and fight battles WHEN THERE NO MORE THAN 4 MOONS! Yellowfang had to watch Raggedstar and Foxheart as they grew close, but Raggedstar had no care for Foxheart. Later on, Brokenstar murdered Yellowfang's younger siblings, Marigoldkit and Mintkit and lied to the Clan that Yellowfang killed them. She was exiled from ShadowClan and lived her life as a loner for a couple of days until she found Firepaw and was ...more
Yellowfang had a very sad life. First she was constantly teased by her denmates and often gets into arguments with her love Raggedstar. She had to give up her big dream of a warrior for a medicine cat because she bears the entire Clan's pain, and the clan teases her for being a medicine cat. Brokenstar is a horrible cat she have to protect and even though she protected him he exiled her, then she joined ThunderClan to be attacked by nearly everyone at first. Even though she lived happily in ThunderClan after becoming their medicine cat, she has to watch Brokenstar stay in ThunderClan and she have to kill her own son in front of herself. Then she dies in a fire trying to save some cats. I think even Crookedstar's life can't be sadder!
First' she loses Silverflame. This makes her very sad, and she is constantly teased and taunted by Foxheart. She loves Raggedstar, but Foxheart is always trying to make him her mate. She could feel the pain of other cats, so she had to give up her life-long dream of being a warrior. Raggedstar was devastated, and she accidentally had his kits. Two died, and Brokenstar was the only survivor. She had to give him up to Lizardstripe, who treated him poorly. She had to watch Brokenstar get bullied, and he rejected her after the bullying. She has to watch him become evil, and he exiles her from the clan for a crime she didn't commit. She goes to ThunderClan, and is accepted. She still has to deal with her son, and is forced to blind him. He dies at her paws, and she is left for only Firestar and Cinderpelt. She then dies a hero, and lives in StarClan.
Leafpool's life was so sad... The second saddest warrior life. Her life was better than Cinderpelt, at least she got Crowfeather. List of Leafpool's whole life:
1. Grew farther away from her sister
2. Fell in love with Crowfeather
3. Ran away with Crowfeather
4. Comes back to find Cinderpelt DEAD
5. Breaks up with Crowfeather and is devastated
6. Had Crowfeather's kits
7. Her kits didn't even know who their real mother & father were
8. Lied to her whole clan about them
9. Watched Crowfeather mate with Nightcloud and their son, Breezepelt
10. Exposed in front of the gathering that she was Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, & Lionblaze's mother
11. Her kits hated her.
12. Her daughter tries to kill her.
13. Her daughter "dies"
14. She couldn't be a medicine cat so turned into a warrior
15. Her kits forgave her and she was a medicine cat again, yet Hollyleaf dies.
There's a lot more though. I love Crowfeather, but Leafpool's pain started with him...
Oh, Leafpool! I don't understand how you could've managed. You sacrificed all you had. First your mate, then your kits, then your position as a medicine cat, and finally your life! And none of it was your fault. You were so brave to follow your heart. And then you lost your mentor, too. You felt that it was all your fault. Your heart broke. I understand, Leafpool, that it was terrible for you. Having your own kits hate you, seeing them grow up not knowing who you really were. And you loved them with all your heart! It must have cracked with despair. I understand, Leafpool, I do.
Lost everything...all in one day. Her kits hate her, and all she ever did was a sacrifice FOR them, had to refrain from embracing her reincarnated mentor, star clan stopped talking to her when she needed it most...SO SAD
Everyone is right, because she had the most saddest life a warrior cat could have. I love her so so much for keeping it all in her.
Breezepelt, I blamed him for his actions at first but then I looked at his parents...
Crowfeather neglected his duty as a father, one of the things I find hard to like about him.
Nightcloud, on the other hand, pampered her son. I mean, he was the last living of his litter (as far as I'm concerned) so she must be protective.
But Crowfeather just pisses me off. He didn't comfort Nightcloud when she was grieving or actually became a father to Breezepelt until he saw what his son had become.
Breezepelt was taught growing up that he didn't need Crowfeather, and that Crowfeather was just a piece of fox dung father.
He was visited by the Dark Forest, who became role models replacing the role model his father should have been.
Sure, he made mistakes, and is probably still shunned for them to this day. His mistake lead to a lot of problems, and that was when Crowfeather finally realized what he did wrong.
Breezepelt is to blame for his actions, ...more
I understand that he's done some bad things, but honestly, I blame crowfeather for all of his mistakes and how he turned out. I really love those AUs where Breezepelt gets sort of adopted by someone else! I love him.
Breezepelt's mother kept spoiling and pampering him, meanwhile, his father ignored him and pretty much never even showed a cent of care to his son(I mean, he might have cared, but at least he didn't show it). His parents are always fighting, and suddenly he's in the dark forest. And a lot after, he finds out that his father had a mate in another Clan and he has half-siblings in ThunderClan, and those half-siblings turn out to be the cats he hates most.
I. LOVE. BREEZE. Many find him to be a whiny pushover, but I see different. Just look at how Crow treated him! He acted like Breeze was just another cat, that is not anything like a real father. A real father would've actually been there for his kits, even if they didn't love their mate anymore. Damn even SPIDERLEG learned his lesson and at least tried to become a better father towards Rose and Toad. Then Crow was acting so scornful towards Breeze through his apprenticeship, CAUSING HIS DARK FOREST VISITS! That's right, Crow started the whole Breeze-hates-everyone thing! If Crow would've just maned up and became a father toward Breeze anything Breeze has done bad would be reversed. AND THEN Crow still acted scornful towards him after the Dark Forest attack, AND THEN TRIED TO OWN UP THEN? MAN I HATE CROW! Honestly Crow shouldn't have even tried to fix his relationship with Breeze, cause something like that has no way of being fixed. Heather is all Breeze needs, he no longer needs ...more
How the heck is he number 20 his life is so sad! So he has a crush on Bright Stream but then Oh no! She is expecting kits with Clear Sky. Then Clear Sky hates Gray Wing and after that becomes evil. Gray Wing falls in love with a rogue named Storm but... Of course that doesn't work out it's Gray Wing after all. Storm falls in love with CLEAR SKY! She has three kits but then she dies with her two kits and only one servives. So Gray Wing has to take care of Thunder cause Clear Sky regected his son. Now Turtle Tail comes back after her kittypet vacation carrying kits. There father later tries to steal them, and Turtle Tail gets hit by a car. So Gray Wing is left alone to take care of his mates kits. But of course the kits don't consider him as there father so Sparrow Fur just LEAVES! Later he falls in love with Slate and they have three kits but this time HIS mate doesn't die it was his turn!
Also I forget witch book Pebble Heart dies in.
Sorry for the spelling mistakes!
Gray Wing definitely has the saddest life (I don't remember much cause I haven't read Dawn Of The Clans in 293209320 million years) because first she has to leave the mountains to chase Jagged Peak, and then Turtle Tail (his mate) runs away to the twoleg place to live with Tom when they get settled. Later Gray Wing saves Clear Sky in a fire, giving him asthma for his whole life (sorry if this is not in chronological order) and when Turtle Tail comes back, she dies shortly after. Gray Wing than has to split with Turtletail's kits and Thunder to live in Tall Shadow's territory, and then Gray Wing makes a hard decision to leave all his friends in Shadowclan to live with Slate in Windclan. Gray Wing then finds his mother who dies a short amount of time later. After Slate gave birth, Gray Wing had a asthma attack that killed him and he barely got to know his kits. I haven't read dawn of the clans in 2 years, but I think that's what happens, and if you don't that's sad your a foxheart.
Seriously, he has to leave his mom, he likes Bright stream and Storm then Clear sky takes them as his mates! Then poor Turtle tail dies right when he realizes he really loved her, Clear sky goes insane and causes the great battle, he watches his mom die in front of him, and when he is finally happy he dies. that's one of the saddest lives to me. He should be mentioned more by the modern clans.
Every cat he loved became Clear Sky's mate. When he and Turtle Tail became mates she died saving her kits from their father Tom. He also lives with asthma after the fire in Thunder Rising coughing all the time and never getting to do what he wants. Oh I forgot he watched his mother Quiet Rain die in front of his eyes.
He had to become an elder early because a rabbit blinded him as he became a laughingstock of the fandom. He tried to impress mousefur but failed. He was hated by everyone's favorite character, Firestar. Everyone thought he was a traitor. He had to watch his friend die. He got one of the worst introductions is warriors readers seeing him as a bully. People have him when sandstorm was a bigger bully than him. Tigerclaw was his friend but was a traitor. Swiftpaw was denied being a warrior. He has to swallow up hid pride and beg fireheart to make his apprentice a warrior. Longtail's mentor was a traitor. One of his apprentices is a jerk. Longtail died getting fresh kill. This character needs a rest forever.
His life is the saddest of all to me, he lost his eyesight hunting a rabbit, got crushed by a tree and much more, not to mention the Erin's had said he was also as old as Mousefur so living that long with all the bad things that happened to him had to be pretty bad.
Blinded not even halfway through his life and joined the elders early and died because of a tree!
He is an underrated warrior. I blame the rabbit for his sad life.
I like Ivypool don't get me wrong, I love Ivypool but I think she overrated, and Dovewing is underrated. Her life wasn't that sad. Sure she went to the dark forest and risked her life, but after that she was well respected got a mate and lived a great life. Nothing compare to the others cats lower on this list if you ask me.
She was ignored and why? For being better than her Mary Sue sister? For being kick but? For being plain awesome? She was so spectacular that it was a shame she wasn't the prophecy cat, but honestly, I think I like her better as a non prophecy cat. It shows that cats can actually train for what they have without having dumb StarClan cat hovering over your headd.
She was overshadowed by her sister, and always felt like she was less than her. Dovewing even blames Ivypool and calls her a traitor when she founds out Ivypool was training in the dark forest! Ivypool didn't even know! Her story's a lot longer, but I'm afraid I don't have time to go on.
Ivypool needs more love! Everyone likes. Her mary-sue sister! It reminds me of high school. Like one sister is all cool and popular in the other sister isn't.
Her birth broke the warrior code, and she killed Ashfur in fear of him revealing the truth over her family. She lived in the tunnels for a while, before rejoining ThunderClan. Hollyleaf was slain by Hawkfrost and spent her last moments with her mother Leafpool saying her last words ”I couldn’t bear to… to leave without knowing my mother.” ...read more.
Hollyleaf's background is SO SAD. She never got a power and had to accept she wasn't part of the three, turns her BIRTH was breaking one of the things she loved the most, she was lied to about who her parents were, she killed a cat out of anger and got depressed out of it later and she finally forgave herself after and went back to the clans only to be KILLED a book after.
Hollyleaf, she was one of the most important cats to me. Like Ivypool, her siblings were part of the prophecy, and she thought she was too for a long time. She was lied to about her parents for a long time, and her birth was against the warrior code, which means so much to her. Later, she died without being able to celebrate victory with her brothers and clan. This is so sad
She was true role-model for the warrior cat series. She died bravely, she died with courage and she died knowing that she did Thunderclan proud. She died young. She didn't have a mate. She didn't even know her true family.
Se had to live in the tunnels for almost her entire life! When they finally found her, she only lived for about one book longer before she died.
She gets so much hate for liking firestar/heart! She's not a "Mary sue", I mean people call her OLD. Willowpelt and redtail, and tiger star weren't old same age As her, also she was manipulated by thistleClaw
Hey, I like spottedleaf I think she deserved more but, I hated her and firestar. When he had kids and a mate, she called him DARLING and oh fireheart felt her presence by sniffing herbs. Overall I think she's amazing it's mostly crusty rusty who made people think she was a Mary Sue. - squirrel'heart
SpottedLeaf's life was SO sad! She got hypnotized by ThistleClaw and witnessed him murdering a cat! And she had trusted him! She had been forced to become a medicine cat to get away from him and then she died so young! And she had to watch SandStorm and FireStar fall in love and go on missions together and travel to the lake together and she just had to live/die with it! Then she got killed by MapleShade and her spirit died! I love MapleShade but... GRR
She doesn't deserve to be here. Hate me all you want, but this is my opinion. Spottedleaf is a Mary-sue, don't believe me? She's so 'attractive' and has a 'strong connection' to StarClan, like, put some character in her! She's a good Med cat, kind, sweet, gentle. All these describes a Mary-sue. In NO way is her life sad. Firestar only like her because' she looked pretty and smelled nice. Feel free to try and change my mind but rest assure, I'm not.
She and her sister were abandoned as kits, and would have died if Alderheart and Needletail hadn't have found them. She was separated from her sister and forced to live in ShadowClan (I think, correct me if I'm wrong), which then proceeded to completely crumble and get taken over by rogues. She was abused, starved, scared into submission. Her foster mother wasn't very good to her. She had a very difficult relationship with Needletail, who was her only friend there. One of the most horrific scenes I have ever read in Warriors was when Violetpaw was drug out to the lake in the middle of the night (by was it Darktail? And one of his goons? ) and they almost drowned her until Needletail came to save her, and then they forced Violetpaw to watch as they drowned her only friend, which allowed her to escape as Needletail was murdered.
She had to grow up too fast! poor girl, had a horrible foster mother, felt all alone, was influenced by her...uhhh friend who kinda did the wrong thing, gets caught saving people, watches the evil guy drown her closest friend, lives with the sadness, sad.
I hate her, but her life was pretty sad. She got taken to a different Clan, separated from her only family member, her only friend got killed by Darktail, and yeah.
I was lowkey pissed off at ShadowClan. Like you take Violetshine away from her sister and than you don't even take good care of her. Stupid Pinenose!
Everybody hated ashfur because he nearly killed firestar. But nobody really thought about how much he suffered! Ashfur is totally rejected by squirrelflight, one of the biggest idiots in the series. Ashfur literally gave up everything for squirrelflight and then squirrelflight took brambleclaw as a mate (by the way, squirrek/bramble doesn't work at all). He suffered so much and he was killed by hollyleaf for loving squirrelflight. Poor ashfur nobody likes him
AshFur Is my FAVORITE character! He got dumped by someone he thought loved him, then killed by her foster kit! Then had to watch BrambleStar and Sqirrelflight gro closer and closer!
I don't know how old this list is, but ashfur took a turn for the worst. I would still like him and feel bad for him if he hadn't STOLEN BRAMBLESTAR'S BODY. He would have had my sympathy but he is just evil and obsessive. good job hollyleaf you killed a truly evil cat
Oh my gosh his life is too sad! His mother was killed by a viscous pack of dogs and his sister got sick a lot, then he finally found someone to love and she dumped him! Wow. Glad I got that out.
Tallstar's revenge was such a good book. While other good cats wanted revenge or wanted to kill throughout the books, no one turned themselves around quite like Tallstar.
Let's see. Hated by his father, not even noticed by his mother, laughed at by the other apprentices, and this is such a sad sad life
BOTH his parents rejected him! It seemed like Palebird basically forgot she had a son after she took another mate. Dawnstripe cared more about him than Palebird ever did.
Tallstar book was such such a good book, BOTH his parents rejected him! People his father was angry then died full with rage ssad sad. Lets see.
Bright heart was an apprentice when she got injured by a pack of dogs, and Swiftpaw died…. She became one eye blind, and one torn ear, but she survived! She got the horrible name Lostface, but luckily firestar changed that. Next bright heart practiced with cloud tail, and she became a warrior and she and cloud tail became mates and had kits….. but it was a pretty sad life
Brightheart. Well she does have a sad life. Luckily Firestar changed her name after the horrible name Lostface. At least she had family and friends!
I love bright heart and I hated how bluestar named her lost face, no cat should live like that. I loved how cloudtail was such a good mate, he panicked when she went with swiftpaw to get attacked by dogs. She is one of my favorite cats - squirrel'heart
Brightheart's life is kind of sad, she went with Swiftpaw because she didn't want him to go alone, ended up loosing Swiftpaw, became half blind and half deaf, and more (I think).
He lost his mate and his kits and couldn't live in his own home that's pretty self explanatory .
Poor hawkwing lost his kits and mateT_T I am SOO happy he managed to find his kits again!
Why did his mate and bro die!
Once I read Hawkwing's Journey I will see what I have to say about him
So underrated. His life was sad, lost every cat he loved to some sort of rockfall, forced to leave leafpool, has to mate with night cloud and live with the constant pain of knowing leaf pools still alive and without him, watches his son become well...his son. All because he was too sad to care for him! Plus his mother dies, he's acused of code breaking, his kids hate him, and leafpools dead SO...oh yeah, he has no friends and is lonely as an apprentice.
I know many people hate him for being difficult or even abusive sometimes though if you look deeper into him you'll understand why he is the way he is… Growing up as a kit, he was born to Deadfoot and Ashfoot - his father was the deputy of WindClan which would probably mean that they would have less time together. In his first major appearance in book Midnight, he is shown as stubborn and always being difficult - he always does the opposite of what he's told which results with everyone else in the group being annoyed with him. How ever uncooperative he may be, Feathertail always tries to understand him and in the end they get along very well. When he spends more time with Feathertail he experiences something he's never felt before, which was love. Later on in the book, The Tribe of Rushing Water was given a prophecy by The Tribe of Endless Hunting that a silver cat shall save them all from the Sharptooth. At first they think it's Stormfur though the prophecy actually meant ...more
He was always shy but he definitely had a ton of trauma. His crush dies, he gets a mate in another clan who sadly rejects him for her clan, then he watches his kits grow up not knowing of their kinship, takes a mate he does not love to prove loyalty, and has a kit who does not love him? I mean, this is depression!
How is he not #1? His parents died, Feathertail died, he tried to KILL HIMSELF over Feathertail, Leafpool left him, he was forced to have kits with Nightcloud to save his reputation, he never got to know three of his kits, three of his kits died (Breezepelt's littermates and Hollyleaf), and he cared about Nightcloud and Breezepelt and regretted ignoring them!
Is there anything sadder than that?
Squirrelflight had a hard life. She's undecided between Bramblestar & Ashfur, and when she chooses Bramblestar, Ashfur takes revenge by almost killing her sister's kits. She also lied to Bramblestar about their kits, and Bramblestar breaks up with her. Then her mate turns into Ashfur, and might lose Bramblestar. Poor Squirrelflight...
Honestly I don't think her life was that sad, but she's my favorite, so I mean like, why not vote for her?
Her mate died because of a greedy cat, sister died, parents died, one of her kits die.
Squirrelflight! I cannot believe she lost bramblestar like that! And two kits AND her sister! T_T I litteraly hate ashfur! If only I could just.. aargh! Poor squirrelflight she's one of my fave characters
Leopardstar watched her loyal and kind deputy get killed because of a stupid crush on Tigerstar! Stone fur was so nice I sobbed when he died, I wanted to close the book. He died a noble death.
He was just a cat loyal to his clan until Tigerstar came and made him try to kill an apprentice, leading him to be killed. It wasn't fair because wasn't the other prisoners a part of Riverclan and loyal.
I think that riverclan should have helped Stonefur. I also was mad that Leopardstar did nothing!
Stonefur is so underrated and forgotten?
Raven paw had to escape from thunderclan from the blood and power thirty tigerstar. Tigerstar was about to kill, him. I guess he had a better life with barely, but I could see him being a proud warrior too!
Oh ravenpaw, you were threatened by tigerstar and witnessed him kill red tail, still terrified, he runs off to live with barley. I'm so glad barley offered to take him in, if it wasn't for ravenpaw, tigerstar would've probably killed bluestar. - squirrel'heart
I honestly love ravenpaw, but after running away from his evil mentor, he lived a quite happy life with Barley. I mean, he caught a SNAKE and an ADDER!
He was forced to run away as his evil mentor was bloodthirsty and wanted to kill him. At least Ravenpaw gets company
I'm a massive fan of Jayfeather, let me just say! I think it's so sad he wanted to be a warrior but had to be up being a med cat! Also in the time before the Tribe Of Rushing Water, he truly loved Halfmoon so as that he cannot have kits or a mate in his own time. Also he could never be with half moon, so as he doesn't belonging that time, also he is always treated like a kit for being blind, which I find so sad!
I am such a big fan of Jayfeather, let me just say! It's so sad he wanted to be a warrior before being a medic cat! Like I cried when he died too! :(
Although I'm not a massive fan of Jayfeather (still like him though, just the series he was in I found boring) he had a sad life, he was blind his whole life and was treated like a child, really just sad to be honest that his dreams of being a warrior were crushed and then he also lost his powers.
Hmm no. He's just enjoying all the grumpiness(according to Alderheart), and come on, there's more things than losing your crush, sis and mother. Such as, losing your 2 brothers, both parents, two kits(one more after the death), and other tragic things happening. And yes that was Sorreltail.
Hm? What life? All I see is a child warrior that was killed by claws much to young.
He was too young. Living a Warrior life at an age where he should've been playing in the nursery
His life. Was no life. That's the sad part
The little kit died a innocent death...