Top 10 Reasons Why Dovewing is Better Than Ivypool (Warriors)

The Top Ten
1 She has powers

This is StarClan's fault but it still makes her chapters much more exciting than Ivypool's boring ones. Dovewing fans should take over the 'Why Ivypool is better than Dovewing' list so that it's the opposite. Dovewing is really cool though. - Moonstar of ThunderClan

Dovewing really isn't responsible for this. Ivypool is a jealous monster.

Yes, but does that make her better than other cats in the series?

2 She isn't dumb

I don't care if the Wiki says that Ivypool is "intelligent" because nothing on the Wiki is true! Calling Ivypool "intelligent" is a very long stretch. She thought the Dark Forest was good, and you have to have no brain to think that.

Dovewing is actually smart. She did way more spying than Ivypool ever did in her life! Plus, she actually has a brain!

- Laurel

This is thoroughly ridiculous. Ivypool isn't dumb. Neither is Dovewing. They just had a few arguments, that's all.

I don't know why people are STILL comparing Ivypool and Dovewing. One time I hated Ivypool. That turned out useless. Besides, they're both good characters. Yes, I respect your opinions, but still.

-Dovestar of FrostClan

3 She loved Ivypool/paw even when Ivypaw pushed her away

Ivypool is stupid. All she wanted was to be much better than her sister and be better at everything just because she's a jealous monster. Ivypool lovers whine that Dovewing whines too much, while Dovewing lovers see the positives in all the warrior cats and also see the negatives. That's why Dovewing fans aren't brainless Ivypool fans!

Ivypool broke her sister's heart more than once. Even if Dovewing whines, she has good reasons for it, while Ivypool mopes about being 'underrated'. Everyone pampers her all the time, and she got two - not one, two - apprentices when she was a young warrior! - Moonstar of ThunderClan

4 She doesn't get jealous easily

This is so true! Dovewing always saw the good in her sister, and Ivypool has little to no good in her at all. Dovewing wouldn't be jealous at all! Dovewing probably has one of the most tragic lives of any warrior cat ever!

Idiotpoop gets pampered and two apprentices when she was a young warrior, for StarClan's sake! Idiotpoop also envied her sister! - Moonstar of ThunderClan

This is 100 percent true. I can't think of one time where Dovewing got jealous. She's happy with what she has and she doesn't envy other cats because they have something she doesn't, unlike some other cat we know (cough cough Idiotpoop cough cough) -FierceheartOfThunderClan

5 She didn't make Firestar lose a life

I hate Ivypool for making Firestar lose a life. It was terrible.

6 Dovewing did something in the first book in OoTS, unlike Ivypool

Ivypool is useless! She should dig a deep well in the ground and live down there until she comes to her senses that I don't think she has! The only thing Idiotpoop is good at is driving people insane during her boring, useless chapters! She's not even one of the Three and she cannot do anything helpful! - Moonstar of ThunderClan

What if Dovewing did not have her power? She wouldn't know about the beavers and even if someone did, wouldn't be able to go with the others on the quest!

Ivypool is useless. The whole point of her is to drive everyone out of their minds.

7 Ivypool could be replaced, while Dovewing cannot

Ivypool could be replaced with an atom, a kit, or anything bad. Also, if she went to eat trash, it would be cannibalism (eating the same thing that you are).

- Laurel

Ivypool could be replaced by air. Ivypool is just as stupid as trash.

8 ThunderClan owes Dovewing more

They pamper Ivypool and treat her like she saved everyone and is the best cat ever, but really, she did nothing. She just yelled at other cats when they asked her what was going on in the Dark Forest, while Dovewing was listening with her super hearing.

- Laurel

Yes! They treat Ivypool like royalty, pamper her and adore her because she "saved them all," she gets two apprentices when she's still a young warrior, and they pay no attention to Dovewing! No wonder she (spoilers) left to go to ShadowClan! ThunderClan treated her like trash! -FierceheartOfThunderClan

9 Ivypool was a terrible spy

She was. All she did was sit there, do everything they said, and kill some poor guy twice.

All she does in the books is whine, complain, be rude, kill cats, and repeat. And then when someone asks her what's going on, she'll just say, "NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS" and ignore that cat for the rest of the day or continue to act like they said some horrible swear word to her!

- Laurel

Yeah! All she did was learn how to fight the Clans and believe she could save everyone by herself! This cat is such a mouse-brained fool! She should have been called Ivyfool. I'm just going to call her Ivyfool. She's so stupid!

All she did was kill poor Antpelt by ripping him open just to prove herself that she was a Dark Forest warrior! - Moonstar of ThunderClan

10 Ivypool didn't believe Dovewing when Dovewing said that something was blocking the lake, but turned into a jealous brat when Dovewing got chosen to check it out

Exactly. If she didn't believe that something was blocking the lake, why would she care who went to check it out? She should've been happy that she didn't have to go.

Also, she could've at least been happy for Dovepaw instead of just ignoring her and turning into a sour jealous brat while she was gone. -FierceheartOfThunderClan

The Contenders
11 Ivypool is rude to Dovewing, but Dovewing is actually a great sister
12 Dovewing made Shadowsight
13 Ivypool got Hollyleaf killed
14 Dovewing wanted Ivypool in the prophecy
15 Dovewing is kinder and doesn't want to start war
16 Dovewing has 0 flaws
17 Ivypool never listens
18 Dovewing whines because her life is stressful while Ivypool complains about not being pampered enough
19 Ivypool acted like she could save everyone during the battle with the Dark Forest but barely did anything while Dovewing listened to the Dark Forest
20 Without Dovewing confronting her Ivypool could've easily turned evil
21 Dovewing kept her personality
22 Dovewing never wanted to have powers
BAdd New Item