Top 10 Biggest Anime Debates

When it comes to anime, fans have plenty to talk about - and sometimes argue over. Some debates feel like they've been around forever, popping up in every corner of the fandom, while others are fueled by newer series that shake things up.
The Top Ten
Dubs vs. Subs

I initially preferred dubbed because I A) didn't like having to listen to Japanese voice actors as I couldn't understand them, and B) well, that's just how I started watching anime. But over time, as you go deeper into the world of anime, you notice several things that make dubs utterly pointless, ridiculous, or frustrating.

The match-up of the subtitles to the dub is usually inaccurate, which I have to say can be funny, but you sometimes lose the essence of the subtlety in the original script.

Anime has a lot of emotion. The vast majority of the time, the emotion stems from the voice actors. For me, the best emotion is in Japanese voice actors.

Dubs sound utterly ridiculous sometimes. The girls' voices are far too high, and perhaps out of habit from being picky about voice actors, this makes me cringe and unable to focus and watch it properly.

Anime is Japanese and should be embraced that way. You also get to watch way more anime if you watch them in Japanese as they take ages sometimes to dub new anime. So, it's a win-win situation. But whatever floats your boat. Maybe it helps that I love reading too?

Naruto vs. Bleach vs. One Piece

I have never watched Bleach or One Piece since I have always been a die-hard Naruto fan, but I just want to say that if all three could amass so many fans, they must all be good anime. I don't think they should be compared, though. Each anime has its ups and downs.

I'm just going to say the ups of Naruto are that battles aren't just power battles. They're not that simple. The whole "jutsu" and "chakra" thing is very detailed and makes sense. The battles also have strategy, something I feel like many action anime lack.

The downs are that some people hate the fillers (although I don't. It's good to take a break from the main plot once in a while) and a few of the characters, especially Sakura and Karin. Although for Sakura, if she wasn't so crazy about Sasuke, people would have definitely liked her better.

Goku vs. Saitama

My opinion is that Saitama would win because he defeats everything in one punch, as the anime title implies. Goku wouldn't have a chance because he has to scream for a few episodes to become a Super Saiyan.

That said, it's pretty cool when watching, and it gets you hyped up for whatever is going to happen next. But if you look back on it, you kind of wonder why he needed to act constipated for a few episodes.

That's my take on it anyway. I hope it makes sense to people.

Goku would obviously win. His speed is comparable to those who could travel through universes in seconds, while his power is multi-universal. The biggest thing Saitama destroyed is part of the moon, but that is not even close to Goku's biggest feat.

Dragon Ball Z vs. Naruto vs. One Piece

DBZ is the worst to watch, in my opinion, but solos both verses. Naruto is good, just has a lot of filler, and OP is a masterpiece. As for standing in power between Naruto and OP, due to recent manga events for OP, the OP verse probably beats the Naruto verse.

I think Goku will win because he is faster than Naruto. Don't get me wrong, I still think it will be an amazing fight, but if you watch Jiren vs. Goku, you will see that if Naruto truly pushes Goku to his limit, he will go Ultra Instinct, then the match is over from there.

Death Note vs. Code Geass

As long as season three doesn't pull a "Psycho Pass 2" and screw everything up, Code Geass pulls ahead of Death Note due to it having the greatest ending of any show I've ever watched.

I would have to say Code Geass because it is an anime with both a great story and such loving characters. Well, that is what I think, so feel free to agree or disagree.

Code Geass is the perfect package. Though Death Note is very well made, it ends on a flat note.

Anime vs. Manga

I think it depends. For those older titles such as Fruits Basket or Sailor Moon, the manga is beautifully illustrated. But for something like Sword Art Online, Fairy Tail, Inu X Boku, Your Name (great movie by the way, you should watch it), and Attack on Titan, they are nicer in anime. Hearing the voices, the heartbreak, the happiness, the music... is more to which I would prefer.

I think you should watch the anime before reading the manga. This way, you will be able to get the voices of each character and see the colors. Manga is mostly in black and white.

It depends on which anime you watch or which manga you read.

Luffy vs. Naruto

To be honest, they both have their strengths and weaknesses because Naruto can just duplicate himself and trick Luffy. Or Luffy can play passive-aggressive and stay back a little while attacking Naruto.

Strength: Naruto. Speed: Naruto. Offense: Naruto. Defense: Naruto. Naruto defeats Luffy. And that's just Naruto with incomplete Kurama.

Luffy, at this point in the manga, beats Naruto due to Luffy's awakening. Also, don't forget the story isn't even over yet, so Luffy's power may still grow.

Anime vs. Cartoons

Cartoons are pictures that are drawn or animated, not real pictures taken. Anime, on the other hand, refers to 2D Japanese animations. Anime does fall under the category of cartoons, as it is hand-drawn. However, many cartoons, like How to Train Your Dragon, are 3D American animations and not Japanese, so they are not anime. But even if an anime is called a cartoon, it's not derogatory.

There are plenty of great cartoons with good characters, costumes, personalities, story, plot, voices, voice acting, animations, etc. And calling an anime a cartoon does not mean that it is aimed at children. There are many cartoons that are only for adults. Cartoons, while usually aimed at children, are just drawings that are not pictures of real-life things.

Shonen vs. Seinen

Seinen manga and anime are better than Shonen because, unlike Shonen, Seinen tells a dark and mature story that can sometimes be better than watching pirates on a boat being stupid.

I think shonen is better, although seinen is not far behind.

Pokémon vs. Digimon vs. Yu-Gi-Oh!

Personally, I think Digimon is better than Pokemon, not to be rude. First off, the first, second, and third seasons' characters do grow up mentally and physically. Second, in some seasons of Digimon, there are darker themes aimed towards older audiences. And third, it always changes up everything in each season, including the timeline, characters, stories, and even the whole Digital World!

I mean, I used to be a Pokemon fan, still am, too, but only for the card games, video games, and manga. Another thing, people think that Digimon is just a mere cheap copy of Pokemon, but if you actually don't judge a book by its cover, then you'll see how much different Pokemon and Digimon are! They first started in different years, one being in 1996/1997 (Tamagotchi Pet) and the other being in February of 1996 (Pokemon Red/Green), so both were released around the same time. Plus, Digimon is (no offense) millions more times complex, well, in a good way.

So that is my post about Pokemon vs. Digimon, and the conclusion is that I like Digimon more in every way!

The Newcomers

? Aho Girl vs. Sexy Saitama
? Black Clover vs. Fairy Tail
The Contenders
Sakura vs. Hinata

Hinata, and if you choose Sakura, then you're actually unreasonable. See, I didn't even capitalize the s in her name because she is less significant or something like that.

Hinata, no doubt. In beauty, intelligence, loyalty, strength, and just overall character development, she surpasses Sakura.

Sakura, both power and physical appearance. Fight me.

Goku vs. Superman

Don't get me wrong, I am a huge Dragon Ball fanatic, but this is such an unfair comparison.

Easily Goku. He can destroy multiverses.

Naruto vs. Goku

Goku wins in a fight. Naruto is the better written character.

Fan Service vs. No Fan Service

I personally like fan service. It can really help anime by appealing to the audience and actually giving unreasonably hated characters some appreciation from fans. Even though it can take over the story or just be shown too often, for some anime, like DxD for example, they're the main appeal and aspect of the anime. Anime that are not hentai but still have plenty of sex jokes or fan service have a genre, and it's called ecchi. Saying that the fan service in DxD is bad is like saying the gore and fights in Naruto are bad.

Tokyo Ghoul vs. Akame ga Kill

Akame Ga Kill will be my favorite anime due to different types of nostalgia.

Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) vs. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, of course. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood had actual plot structure and source material to go off of. Fullmetal Alchemist 2003 had ten or twelve unresolved plot points that are caused when you start running around with a plot like a chicken with its head cut off. (And no, Conqueror of Shamballa doesn't solve much anyhow.)

Both are great shows, but only one can be the best. Let the debates begin!

Yandere vs. Tsundere

I like tsundere more. Yandere generally just have their dere type as their entire personality and their love interest as their backstory and only character development. They often say, My world was grey and dull and I didn't have a reason to keep going, until I met them. Yandere can refer to people obsessed with violence or just crazy people in general, but my reasons for not liking them are the same.

But tsundere just means that they are defensive to the point of violence, get embarrassed easily, or won't admit their love. Even though it can be a big chunk of their character, they generally have a genuinely sad and sometimes very unique reason as to why they're always rejecting the other. This is just my preference. I'm also biased just because kuudere are my favorites and some are somewhat similar to tsundere.

Funimation vs. Viz Media vs. Bandai

The three best-known anime dub companies (sans the infamous 4Kids). People who enjoy English dubs will debate which company makes the best English dubs. This is also the debate over which is the best Dragon Ball dub.

Funimation and Viz Media are the best, and Bandai is just a wannabe anime company.

Killua Zoldyck vs. Rock Lee

Rock Lee wins, no debate. Killua cannot keep up with the power of the 8 gates.

Todoroki vs. Jojo

First of all, which Jojo? Second, if it's Jonathan, Joseph, or Jotaro, they would lose because they're just superhuman. The only Jojos that can beat Todoroki are Giorno and Jotaro (Eyes Of Heaven).

Lelouch vi Britannia vs. Light Yagami

Lelouch vi Britannia. As an anime, I prefer Death Note, but Light's acting is actually painful to watch. He is an idealist, and his philosophy that all criminals do not deserve to live is not justified, as fat Americans in front of a TV screen are way more disgusting.

Lelouch vi Britannia is portrayed in the show as a genius. He is unpredictable, good at lying/acting, and very amusing. His actions at the end of the show were the most shocking, as he was portrayed as a narcissist for the most part.

I can see that Lelouch is much less mentally stable, and his whining can get annoying, but it's just because unlike Light, he had an interesting backstory, which is one of the things that anime does better than any Hollywood movie/show.

Netero vs. Roshi
Chibi vs. the Real Thing

I absolutely love chibi! At first, I didn't know what they were, but when I clicked on it, I was captured by the cuteness. However, my love for chibi is not as much as the real thing. True, I enjoy looking at them, but I really like the real version too. However, if anyone else sees this, please say what you think! There can never be any wrong answers with this.

Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha vs. Puella Magi Madoka Magica

Puella Magi Madoka Magica! Honestly, the story is pretty good, and don't even get me started on Kyubey's design. He's just the most intriguing little devil.

I would go with MGLN. PMMM is the most overrated magical girl anime ever.

Angel Beats! vs. Clannad

Angel Beats, to me, had the far greater ending and overall felt more saddening and memorable throughout its progression. In my opinion, both of these short anime series are terrific and pull so hard at your heartstrings. It's a difficult choice in my eyes since both are so great at what they are trying to do, but Angel Beats just honestly made me feel something more. I recommend both shows highly, and they are very incredible masterpieces, so go give them a watch!

Both are really sad anime. Both are romances. Can't really decide which one is better.

8Load More
PSearch List