Best Survivor: Caramoan Players

This is my rankings of my favorite players from Caramoan.

The Top Ten

1 Malcolm Freberg Malcolm Freberg

Even he's the first one who goes home in the "3 Amigos" he's been my favorite Survivor Player of ALL-TIME. - jerardagustin

He was awesome in this season! HE is BOSTON ROB... With better hair.

He's the guy that broke apart the Stealth R Us alliance by blindsiding the leader, Phillip.

Him an corinne were the only highlights of this awful season

2 John Cochran John Cochran John Martin Cochran, commonly referred to as simply Cochran, is an American reality television personality and television writer.

Get this guy tp 1st

Don't like him but how on earth he is behind Malcolm or anyone for this season is beyond me. By far the best player of Caramoan, anyone who says otherwise is retarded or insanely biased. - feisty37

Come on Cochran, has to be the #1 best!

Way better player than Macolm this season. These votes are embarassing.

3 Brenda Lowe

One of the most overrated female Survivors ever along with Ciera and Candice. - feisty37

My favorite girl out of the cast, Go Brenda! - jerardagustin

Smart, Strategic, and Beautiful

I give her an F. She sucks. - jhunk

1 Comment
4 Andrea Boehlke

She is so fierce

YAY <3 You watch Malcolm near the well so long that Malcolm didn't get the idol. HAHAA - jerardagustin

5 Reynold Toepfer

I'm rooting for him to go Finals and I want him to win. - jerardagustin

I really hope that he come back for another season

6 Eddie Fox

I want him and Malcolm to win but then when Malcolm was gone it was 6-0-0 and I was so disappointed to him because he vote Malcolm. Even he knows that Malcolm would go home he should have been stick to his allies. - jerardagustin

My favorite player if he made to the finals he would of won the ultimate underdog

Was bold and managed to survive a 6-person 7-person alliance for a long time


7 Dawn Meehan

She made it deep into the game and only lost to Cochran in my opinion because she back stabbed Brenda. However, that is what the game is about. She knew that she probably would not have beat Brenda if she went to the final 3 with her and she was also paranoid that she was the target. Not to take away too much from Cochran's win, but this was an extremely bitter jury if there ever was one. Dawn did what she had to do and also improved greatly from her first season.

Dawn meehan is the worst and ugliest player to ever pay survivor; actually, I take that back franscesca is the only person that is worse... she sucks

I STILL can't forgive Dawn for KO'ing Brenda. I was RAGED at her when Brenda tearfully left.

8 Erik Reichenbach Erik Reichenbach

Back in that Micronesia time, he turned out to be the worst Survivor player ever. When he came back here, everything changed. I support that. He only lost because of a medical evacuation. I

He's the victim of his own stupidity! This lovable moron stumbled his way to Final Five twice! That should be applauded!

He should have leave Stealth R Us and join the Amigos, but still he's a good player. - jerardagustin

Dang. In Micronesia he was underestimated and could've won if not for his immunity necklace

1 Comment
9 Phillip Sheppard Phillip Sheppard Phillip Sheppard is a United States Army veteran and the chief executive officer of a software company, who is best known for his appearances on the U.S.
10 Brandon Hantz Brandon Hantz

Weird O.O. on South Pacific, he played the religious guy and then on Caramoan, he was with the devil! Scary! Haha but still he is a GOOD PLAYER. - jerardagustin

The Contenders

11 Michael Snow
12 Laura Alexander

Sad That she leave early. - jerardagustin

13 Sherri Biethman
14 Shamar Thomas

The most idiotic player ever

15 Rob Mariano Rob Mariano Robert Carlo "Rob" Mariano, known by the nickname Boston Rob, is an American television personality, widely known for appearing in several reality shows, including Survivor, and The Amazing Race with his wife, Amber Mariano.
16 Hope Driskill

Like Laura too.. You leave earlier. - jerardagustin

17 Julia Landauer
18 Allie Pohevitz

Had a great game but an unfortunate downfall.

19 Heidi Stobel

Heidi was in The Amazon.

20 Corinne Kaplan
21 Francesca Hogi Francesca Hogi
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Survivor: Caramoan Contestants Best Survivor Players Best Survivor: Cambodia Players Top 10 Survivor: Cook Islands Players Best Survivor: All-Stars Players

List Stats

100 votes
21 listings
6 years, 178 days old

Top Remixes

1. Malcolm Freberg
2. Reynold Toepfer
3. Eddie Fox
1. John Cochran
2. Malcolm Freberg
3. Eddie Fox
1. John Cochran
2. Malcolm Freberg
3. Andrea Boehlke


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.