Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players

These are some of the big brother players that don't get enough credit for some of the moves they made. I set aside how I personally felt about them and completely focused on game play and strategy. Comment on what you think.

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Lawon Exum (Big Brother 13)

He's better than Dan, Will, and Derrick combined together.

By far is the greatest player of all time

The goat in my opinion


V 2 Comments
22 Candice Stewart (Big Brother 15)

She figured out the moving company alliance in under a week and she's the one of the main reasons why Nick left the second week.

23 Helen Kim (Big Brother 15)

She and Amanda controlled that whole house in the beginning of the game! Helen is super under appreciated. I hope she comes back for another season

She dominated that whole house

24 Britney Haynes (Big Brother 14) Britney Haynes (Big Brother 14)

I love her. Amazing social game and proved that she could win competitions. Although her flaw in BB12 was not seeing the Brigade. In BB14, however, she had a good read on the house, which is eventually what led the master of the game to send her out. Honestly, who really could have won against Dan's funeral?

25 Steve Moses (Big Brother 17)

He is so underrated. Many people refer to him as a floater but he isn't. His strategy was to be under the radar, look weak and make the others believe that they could use him. His strategy worked as Vanessa brought him into Scamper Squad. For the first 5 weeks the bigger personalities like Jace, Davonne, Jeff, Audrey and Jason were evicted so Steve was smart to stay out of the way. He threw comps when he didn't need to win, but won when he had to and nominated power players like Jackie and Austwins and evicted Vanessa. Even though he was under the radar for most of the game he made some good moves early on. In week one he formed a small alliance with Jace and Austin, he formed the Rock stars alliance with Johnny Mac and in week 2 he aligned with Vanessa and this helped him get into scamper Squad. He started to play more aggressively near the end winning 3 of the last 4 Hoh's, taking a shot at Austwins and evicting Vanessa. So he played a really good game. However, his moves were very ...more

Steve is very underrated. The thing about Steve is that he won when he needed to and wasn't a competition threat. Steve was a smart player and the Jury gave him credit for sending Vanessa out. Liz wouldn't have done that. So Steve definitely didn't float.

26 Andy Herren (Big Brother 15) Andy Herren (Big Brother 15)
27 Lisa Donahue (Big Brother 3)

Take her off this list immediately. She had no place winning over Danielle. She has a bitter/stupid jury to thank, but she never should have won nor should she have made it as far as she did. Thanks, Big Brother, for only inventing sequester after this fluke.

28 Jackie Ibarra (Big Brother 17)

Had Steve targeted the sixth sense rather then Jackie during the Double eviction Jackie already had her spot in the final 3

I honestly feel like she should be higher, people criticized her as being a coaster in the game which is only because the show edited her to be that way, she had a good read on the house such as when she saw through Shelli's lie about Jason and was one of the few people to see Vanessa's game but if it wasn't for Steve, she would have gone MUCH farther.

29 Ian Terry (Big Brother 14)

Obviously underrated

30 Spencer Clawson (Big Brother 15) Spencer Clawson (Big Brother 15)
31 Diane Henry (Big Brother 5) Diane Henry (Big Brother 5) Diane Nicole Henry is an American model most known for coming in third on Big Brother 5, a reality TV show broadcast by CBS in 2004.
32 Rachel Reilly (Big Brother 12 & 13) Rachel Reilly (Big Brother 12 & 13) Rachel Eileen Reilly Villegas is an American television personality, a talk show host, an actress, and a reality show participant.

This girl is the definition of a fighter. Everyone in the beginning saw her as a target and she made it into the jury but in Big Brother 13, she WON and she was a target the minute she walked in the door because everyone saw how she played. Even though she has a bad social game, she truly deserved to win the prize.

33 Frankie Grande (Big Brother 17) Frankie Grande (Big Brother 17) Frank James Michael Grande Marchione (born January 24, 1983), usually credited as Frankie Grande or Frankie J. Grande, is an American dancer, musical theatre actor and singer, producer, TV host and YouTube personality. He is the older half-brother of singer and actress Ariana Grande. V 1 Comment
34 Michelle Costa (Big Brother 10)
35 Andrew Gordon (Big Brother 12)
36 Devin Shepherd (Big Brother 16) Devin Shepherd (Big Brother 16)

Obviously the best player of all time

37 Nicole Nilson Schaffrich (Big Brother 2)
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists