Top Ten Warrior Cats That Should Be Leaders


The Contenders: Page 5

81 Hawkfrost (Hawkstar) Hawkfrost (Hawkstar)

Hawkfrost is evil he ain't a good cat ;(

If tigerstar was not evil hawkfrost wouldn't be

You call murdering innocent cats and just being plain evil wonderful? What kind of a person are you?! - RiverClanRocks

Tigerstar must have completely taken away his conscience but, I believe, if Tadpole was alive and Tigerstar backed off he would be a decent cat, ambitious, but decent

He was only being loyal to his father! He was scared of being rejected after losing his mother already

V 9 Comments
82 Thistleclaw (Thistlestar)

Maybe if Bluefur left him and Snowfur alone, he would of thought she was okay and stayed good. He would of been a strong and brave leader. I wish he wasn't evil, he had so much potential.

No offense but he would have wanted to kill everyone besides he persuaded Tigerstar to be evil whom then persuaded Tiny/Scoure to be evil! So it was all Thaistleclaw it states in Bluestar's prophecy that he would destroy everyone if he became leader. ~Blizzardstar

Thistlekit was a cute kit. All he ever wanted as a kit was to became a apprentice and become a great warrior. He later devoloped feelings for Snowpaw (fur). When Snowfur died, he was so sad. If you read Crookedstar's promise, Crookedstar saw Thistleclaw training with Shredtail. My guess why Thistleclaw is acually there is:
He wanted everyone to be treated as fair as Snowfur so they all die
Or he wanted to be trained to be a better warrior so no other cats he liked ended up like Snowfur

V 4 Comments
83 Flintfang

He would've been a great leader of Shadowclan he wouldn't have trained all those kits to early or kill those kits whose's death he blamed Yellowfang.

V 1 Comment
84 Squrellflight (Squirellstar)

It's spelled Squirrelflight. When she first appeared, I immediately thought "this cat would be a horrible leader". But she has really matured and grown. I think she would make a fierce, strong and brave leader.

I think she deserves to be a leader. Loyal brave strong and fierce. But she was sadly put to shame by Hollyleaf at a gathering. She only did any rong out of loyalty to her clan and sister. She still loved her sisters kits as if they were her own. CURSE YOU HOLLYLEAF!

I would of got graystripe because he is so nice and loyal, BUT! Squirrelflight is honest, silly, has a sense of humor... I love her! If I were her, I would mate graystripe! Anyway, she would make an awesome leader! Go squirrelflight/paw!

Squirrelflight is my favorite character in warrior cats because she's so energetic,funny,much more!

V 9 Comments
85 Sorreltail

She's amazing! Way better than Firestar or HAWKFROST? Seriously?

She is a senior warrior, and a loving mother. She might be a good one, actually.

Sorreltail did die from injuries. She is also very powerful able to live through being fed deathberries by darkstripe and she had pinned darkstripe probably for return

V 1 Comment
86 Whitewing

She is kind and caring.

I ship Whitewing x leadership! Calmest warrior ever, would have been like a girl Firestar. She always looked after her daughters, I can see her doing the same for her clan mates. Just like Bumblestripe, she would like to talk instead of battle, and risk every life for her clan mates. When I was in elementary school, 2 of my friends and I played warrior tag, a game where we were one of our favorite warriors and when we were it we were bad warriors. I was Whitepaw when I was good, and I loved playing her.

87 Mistyfoot

She is loyal to Riverclan and helps Graystripe learn the news about his kits.

Umm... after Leopardstar died, Mistyfoot became her successor. How could you not know that?

She is a leader now.

Have u people even read the books? - tigerstar908

V 5 Comments
88 Berrynose

I think he talks back too much, and he brags a lot too.

I dislike him, he's alright at times, though sometimes he makes me cringe.

His rudeness would be too much for me

He would have been great Feathertail lover4571 🐱

89 Shellheart (Shellstar)

Shellheart is one of his son crookedstars biggest supporters. I guess he knew Hailstar will pick crookedjaw to be the next deputy so he became a elder. The other reason is that he is very old ( well he is probably 8-10 years old that is very old for a cat).

V 1 Comment
90 Cherryfoot (Cherrystar)

Not a thing - Frogjaw1996

91 Thrushpelt (Thrushstar)

He was so nice to Bluefur/Bluestar when she lost her kits, and he was always with her every step of the way! I think Thrushpelt/Thrushstar would be an awesome leader! Go Thrushstar!

V 2 Comments
92 Weaslefur (Weaslestar)

You mean Weaselfur? - Frogjaw1996

93 Pebblefoot (Pebblestar)
94 Mallownose (Mallowstar)
95 Patchfoot (Patchstar)

Patchfoot would have made an amazing kits.

96 Sparrowpelt (Sparrowstar)
97 Maggottail (Maggotstar)

Maggottail is super evil. He kinda is already a leader (in the dark forest). Also maggotstar is a weird name

He's a bad guy! Come on, you're practically saying that you want evil to win and the Clans to be destroyed!

What cruel mom would name their kit maggot? Does anyone know who his mother was?

I've heard somewhere that he took on the name maggottail as part of his pride. The story I heard was that he had a fox bite on his tail, survived, and changed his name because he was proud of surviving a fox bite. Probably fanon though - Talljake


V 4 Comments
98 Skywatcher (Skystar)

He would have been a great leader!

There already is a cat called Skystar... Clear Sky's new name

Only one left who believed in StarClan and did not become a kittypet

He should of been leader of SkyClan!
I'm very sad that he died!
He would make a fantastic leader!
Skystar1! Skystar forever!

V 3 Comments
99 Willowfrost

So basically she's a Mary Sue.


Mary Sue much? - TheEliteComet

Lol lol lmao

V 1 Comment
100 Sweetbriar (Sweetstar)

Isn't sweet paw named after her

Yes - Frogjaw1996

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Warrior Cats That Should Become Leaders Soon Warrior Cats Who Should Not Have Been Leaders Warrior Cats Who Should Be Clan Leader Instead of Dark Forest Cats Top Ten Warrior Cats Clan Leaders Top Ten Female Warrior Cats You Most Want to Become Leaders

List Stats

1,000 votes
131 listings
5 years, 272 days old

Top Remixes (14)

1. Ivypool
2. Whitestorm (Whitestar)
3. Graystripe (Graystar)
1. Mapleshade (Maplestar)
2. Hollyleaf (Hollystar)
3. Jayfeather (Jaystar)
1. Hollyleaf (Hollystar)
2. Brackenfur (Brackenstar)
3. Crowfeather (Crowstar)

View All 14


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.