Top Ten Worst Big Brother Players

Don't agree with the list? Vote for an existing item you think should be ranked higher or if you are a logged in, add a new item for others to vote on or create your own version of this list.

The Top Ten

1
Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
Asking to go on the block? Asking to be evicted? Thinking he would have some kind of "special power" and get back in the house? I don't even know where to begin. He never played the game
As described below, Kaysar is a completely overrated player both strategically and competitively, but Lawon made a mistake that no other contestant ever would or could make. Not only did he ask to be evicted due to delusions of a 'special power', but he consequently allowed Rachel, the eventual winner, to stay in the game. If he hadn't made that huge error, he himself wouldn't have won, but a fellow newbie may well have!
Kaysar is overrated, but Lawon's easily the worst player ever. Not only did he want to be evicted because he thought he would come back with a "special power"- when he got his chance to return, he lost the competition that would send him back into the House by a huge margin.
More comments about Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13

2Kaysar Ridha- 10th place- Big Brother 6 and 7
I agree, he is so overrated. CBS made him appear to be an amazing player, due to his "mysterious" nature. This was just because he was a by nature quite person, and they made him look as though he was an amazing person who conquered Eric in season 6... In season 7 against Will the doctor, they showed just how poorly he played the game, particularly by not going after the Doctor and Mike Boogie. Both seasons he was too trustworthy, which lost him the game very quickly in both.
He made way too many strategic moves that hurt him. He was voted out fourth by making stupid moves, voted back in by America, then made another stupid deal, and was voted right back out next. In All-Stars, he made some more stupid moves, and went home fifth. He entered the house three times, and never even made it to the jury once.
Kaysar was just completely clueless. He had the chance to play Big Brother 6 TWICE, and he still completely screwed up his chances. The Friendship Alliance played him for a fool, and he believed every single word they said! And his all-star stint was no better!
More comments about Kaysar Ridha- 10th place- Big Brother 6 and 7

3Kathy Hillis- 8th place- Big Brother 12
She was so dumb it was no wonder this texan was not the first to go I was in shock when she lasted until 8th place.
She's been a police officer for 20 years and she is probably the most weakest houseguest she failed at ever challenge my cat could do better than her told britney she was the weakest player ever and she made it that obvious she was the saboteour idiot
Oh, she bombed every competition. She sacrificed herself to being a have-not.

lassidoggy

More comments about Kathy Hillis- 8th place- Big Brother 12

4Mike Dutz- 11th place- Big Brother 8
He was told if he tried to make Dick, the current HOH lose the veto challenge, he'd be on the block, but he did it anyway, and he was put on the block, and sent home.

5Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14
He was the H.O.H. in week one, and got himself evicted week 2. He didn't make any solid deals in his time as HOH. And instead of being allies with the best player in the game (frank) he puts him on the block without having the votes. He freaked out at frank before the eviction ceremony which basicaly turned the house against him. And he evicted himself before the point of view which he would have a pretty solid chance of winning... Just an allaround bad player
Russell would be ashamed
This hothead deserved an early exit.
More comments about Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14

6Adam Poch - 3rd place - Big Brother 13
If there was a book titled "How to win 500 thousand dollars on Big Brother" I'd expect the author to be Dan from BB10 or Will Kirby. If there was a book titled "How to win 25 thousand dollars on Big Brother" I'd expect the author to be Jeff from BB11. If there was a book titled "How to win 50 thousand dollars on Big Brother" I'd expect the author to be Adam Poch. He was the ultimate floater and butt-kisser. He seemed so sure he'd be asked back for all-stars on finale I felt embarrassed for the guy. I'm sure America can't wait to watch him float and butt-kiss and try to collect his 50k this time.
As one of the biggest floaters in Big Brother history, his gameplay was very similar to Zach from Big Brother 8. During season 13 former HG Matt Hoffman quipped "Can we just write Adam a check for 50 thousand dollars now!? " figuring that everyone wanted to take him to the final 2. Yet Adam botched his chances of getting to the final 2 when he told Rachel he'd vote for her if she evicted him! Laugh out loud. He didn't even do that!
The person who was evicted the first week played a 100 timers more harder than Adam did the whole season. When Adam enter the house he should of hidden in a closet and not come out untill the final week. At least then his time on BB would have been more enjoyable to watch. Then he had the nerve at the seaon finale to say that he should be on the next BB all-stars, that will be the day when Janelle and Mike Boggie play the floater game.
More comments about Adam Poch - 3rd place - Big Brother 13

7Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15
Her biggest mistakes in this game was opening her mouth and letting the absolutely most evil person to ever play the game (Amanda) to control her nominations.
Absolutely horrible. Racist remarks, quickly making her an enemy of most of the house.
The arrogance and racism made the entire season's cast focused on bullying (not gameplay). It was a total removal from the game.
More comments about Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15

8Jessie Godderz - 10th place - Big Brother 10, 9th place - Big Brother 11
It was America's fault jesse went out twice, though I do agree that he played badly season 10. He was running the house until CBS handed jeff a coup de ta which is the only reason he was sent to JURY.
Of course I would vote for jessie because he is hot.
He's so full of himself
More comments about Jessie Godderz - 10th place - Big Brother 10, 9th place - Big Brother 11

9Justin Sebik - Big Brother 2
Psychopath! This guy is a total psychopath. How in the hell is he not on here yet? He was really creepy the entire time he was on the show. He constantly threatened houseguests with violence and held a knife up to Krista's throat.
He's crazy. He got himself kicked out of the house! If he played with the rules he would have done way better even though he's still creepy. Instead he wanted to threaten his way to the top, how is he not ranked the top most horrible player?
5%? - Only because only the real and long term fans can fully appreciate his one blunder. We expected Hantz to be an a-hole. Hope you are doing well Justin.

10Jase Wirey - 10th place - Big Brother 5, 12th place - Big Brother 7
Tried to win everything at the very start of Big Brother 5, which puts a huge target on your back. Acted cocky and annoying when he was in power, and had a creepy power bro-mance with Scott, making him an even bigger target. Loved his face when he realized Nakomis was getting rid of him. Somehow he was voted back into the All-Star house, and again won the first co-HoH. Jumped from side to side, and when Kaysar told his S6 was putting him up, he freaked out instead of trying to get votes to stay.

koenbertens


The Contenders

11Chelsia Hart- 8th place- Big Brother 9
Her strategy was horrible cussing at people and cause her own alliance to drop in numbers. She definitely made James look really bad in the end.
Her strategy was just to yell at people all the time.
Repulsive behavior... She was the definition of skank

12Jessie Kowalski - 10th place - Big Brother 15
She annoyed the whole house week 1 then when she had the most beautiful spot in the game until she tried to take Amanda out knowing she didn;t have the numbers to do that which turned everyone against her then when she gets nominated she turns the house into drama central then she got evicted dum player she always thought she was better than everyone else she's horrible
I love Jessie. But she didn't even have a gameplay. And when she tried a big move she couldn't even execute it. She had potential but she threw it all away quick.

BladedCrypt

Almost got herself evicted Week 1 was useless for the next 4 weeks then tried to make a huge move which got her evicted shortly after ony won 1 competition because Judd let her win

13Chima Simone - 8th Place - Big Brother 11
Chima should be high in this list because she was dumb enough to disobey the Big Brother rules and not wear her microphone. She had been throughout the game disobeying rules like not going to the diary room when asked and not wearing her microphone. The night before the veto comp, Big Brother set out a mini golf game to practice for the upcoming veto comp. Chima had put a big enough target on her back that at that point she was pretty much feeling defeated, so she took her microphone and tossed it in the pool. When they asked her to get a new mic and wear it, she refused and got herself expelled from the game.

14Frankie Grande - Season 16
Plays the exact same game as ANDY therefore I hope someone in that house gets him outta there I hate this guy

htoutlaws2012

Honestly I think Frankie is a nice guy but does not know how to play the game well. But he still brings some entertaining value to the show

15Dustin Erikstrup - 9th place - Big Brother 8

Volunteered himself to be a pawn against Dick when Daniele was removed from the block, when it wasn't even sure he had the votes and there had been swing votes all season. The best part was his face when he realized he has backdoored himself. When he won HoH, he acted all high and mighty, and annoyed a lot of people with his arrogance. Took both prizes in a veto competition and angered a lot of people. Too confident.

koenbertens


16Scott Long - 11th place - Big Brother 5

Tried to win lots of competitions from the start, making him a big target. Part of his strategy was telling people he had lots of money, which was a terrible plan because it makes people think you don't need the money at the end of the game.

koenbertens


17Devin Shepherd - Season 16
This guy is a combo version of Amanda and Jeremy from BB15 aka bully. All he talks about is being loyal, having integrity, and doing this game for his daughter. And plays the gentle giant role when he clearly isn't. Created an all-everyone alliance with half the house and thinks he's running the ship.
Why isn't his good buddy Zach on here. Sure Devin was paranoid, a bully and made a big alliance way too early, I think he played a good game and if he changed his attitude as well as his strategy he would have made it really far but he was still considered a big physical threat. This alliance that was made was basically the moving company again. Instead of getting moved out, it got blown up.
Hands down worst player ever! When the Chenbot asked him to rate his HOH run in week two, he gave himself a 4 out of 10. Which was way to generous. I would rank it a 1 out of 10. He formed an 8 person alliance in week one, then in week two when he was in power he put up a member (Zach). Worst move ever! Of course the other members are going to keep him. Furthermore, who wouldn't turn on him when he can't even stay loyal for 2 weeks.
More comments about Devin Shepherd - Season 16

18Kent Blackwelder- 7th place- Big Brother 2

He thought he was good, but he just stayed in as long as Will let him, and make the stupid mistake of thinking he ran the show and acting like it, which made everyone want to prove him wrong, which they did by eliminating him.


19Elissa Slater - 6th place - Big Brother 15
Only survived first 3 evictions because of the horrible mvp twist, cries about it when the mvp is in America's hands, then floats and rides Helen's coattails till helen was evicted, then wins hoh and doesn't nominate the power couple together, then decides she wants to keep the most hated person in bb history thus making herself equally hated, the getting the boot right after
Did nothing. I mean absolutely nothing!
She was not the M.V.P. she was the worst player ever
More comments about Elissa Slater - 6th place - Big Brother 15

20Mike Lubinski- 14th place- Big Brother 5

He made alliances with so many different people, without even trying to be secretive about it. When he was nominated, he decided to get into fights with the people with the power, and tried to get Diane, and only Diane to save him, because apparently one vote out of ten is enough to keep you in the game.


21Joey Van Pelt - Season 16
Telling the Bomb Squad that you have an all girl alliance. Now your on the block!
Tried to create an all girl alliance with seven other girls!

22Andy Herren - Big Brother 15
Just an all around nasty person. His constant spewing of hatred is almost unbearable...must have extremely low self esteem along with a total lack of self awareness as most things he says about others are qualities he possesses. Gross, nasty "human"...using that word loosely. He will look back at the season and cringe at himself...I can hardly watch him without being embarrassed for him. Nice job, DONKEY!
Almost single handedly made BB15 the worst season in history. He was a major part of the exits of all the interesting players (Helen, Amanda, Elissa). From a game perspective he's not one of the worst, but from an entertainment perspective, he's been atrocious.
If it looks like a rat, makes noise like a rat, it is a rat! If he's asked back for a future all-stars I pray the HOH in the first week makes sure he's out!
More comments about Andy Herren - Big Brother 15

23Marcellas Reynolds- 5th place- Big Brother 3
He won POV and left himself on the block after being nominated? huh... does not make an iota of sense.
He let Danielle talk him into backstabbing anyone she wanted him to, and then when she got Jason to put him up on the block, he was suprised, and claimed that they should never have messed with him, and that he will get them back, but when he had his chance, by winning the veto that could've saved him from the block, he chose not to use it, and he was sent home.
All I got to say is why would you not use the veto? Most dumbest move ever on Big Brother history. I truly think he is the worst player in Big Brother history. I don't see why he was in Big Brother 7 All-Stars. He didn't deserve to be there. He won it and he should have used it.
More comments about Marcellas Reynolds- 5th place- Big Brother 3

24Danielle Murphree - 3rd place - Big Brother 14
She didn't make any of her own decisions. She only did what Dan told her to do.
She is the REAL reason why Shane got evicted. She molested Shane, ew!
She came across as completely psychotic. I hope she gets help.
More comments about Danielle Murphree - 3rd place - Big Brother 14

25Bryan Ollie- 6th place- Big Brother 10
When all of his allies had either betrayed him, or were out, he had the power to win HOH, because it was an endurance challenge, and the more you wanted it, the better a chance you had to win. He was in the last two of that challenge, and made a deal, and asked for his own safety, the safety of his one semi-friend left Michelle, the ability to choose one of the two nominations, and the veto replacement, had it been used. He really thought that the deal would be honored, and he gave up the challenge, and Michelle was eliminated, followed right by Ollie himself.

26Brian Hart - 13th Place - Big Brother 10
Made way to many alliances on the first day and was ultimately taken down week one by Ollie and Jerry.
Are you the one looking for good girlfriend make out with

27Jordan Lloyd - 1st place - Big Brother 11, 4th place - Big Brother 13
Big Brother's ultimate coat-tail rider. Former HGs will be the first to tell you that Jordan winning her season was a freak accident and Jordan openly admits she had no idea what she was doing in her first season. She won her season by riding Jeff's coat-tails, sucking at competitions, being perceived as clueless, being nice to everyone, and (crucially) taking someone everyone hated with her to the final 2. She finished 4th in season 13 by riding Jeff and Rachel's coat-tails. The houseguests in season 13 openly had contempt for her ability to win competitions and she only won one HOH by making a lucky golf put. If Porsche hadn't won the veto in final 4 and for positioning reasons in the final 3 choosing to evict her, Jordan probably would have won again (shivers).

merrimac

Jordan is the weakest player ever. She didn't do ANYTHING... And I mean ANYTHING, yet she whined about Porsche and Kahlia not doing anything. In season 13 she only won HoH once and that was because Brendon and Jeff let her win. She isn't even as nice as she seems to be.. It's like an optical illusion, look closer and you'll see the truth
Disagree. Jordan's strategy was golden, she hid behind a bigger target in Jeff right up until he got evicted and then she won competitions, although I do agree that Natalie should of won. But Jordan I think deserved final 3 in s13
More comments about Jordan Lloyd - 1st place - Big Brother 11, 4th place - Big Brother 13

28Rachel Plencer- 8th place- Big Brother 6
Oh hell no, Rachel is a goddess
She won HOH, and found a secret clue in the very beginning, which made her seem like she'd be great, but then she just said, "vote me out" with her actions, and her attacks at other people. She just rode coattails, and said at the very end that the coattail riding was a good strategy, which shows why she didn't last very long.

29Amanda Zuckerman - 7th Place - Big Brother 15
Please move her up on the list. Why did no one care that she was producer Allison's good FRIEND?! Being a controlling personality can certainly work in a game, but the whining when things didn't go her way jsut made me sorry for everyone who knows her in real life.
The Nastiest Bitch to ever be on a reality show
Why is she not # 1 or at least on top ten on this list?
More comments about Amanda Zuckerman - 7th Place - Big Brother 15

30Jeff Schroeder - 5th place Big Brother 11
Using the good old, "Shut up, or I'll beat you" intimidation that surprisingly worked well, we can see how arrogance and an empty head stopped him from doing too good.
Definitely the most over rated HouseGuest in Big Brother history. I have absolutely no idea what the BB cat ladies and casual fans see in him
One of the biggest, nastiest bullies in BB history. Got a golden edit from CBS that still didn't mask his aggressive self entitlement from everyone who wasn't distracted by his showmance with Jordan.
More comments about Jeff Schroeder - 5th place Big Brother 11

31Keith Henderson - 13th place - Big Brother 13

Yay I added this item laugh out loud Anyway, his strategy was to alienate his only allies

His strategy was to basically copy the Brigade, and when that failed, he betrayed his partner Porsche, leading to his eviction Week 1. He also seemed to think calling out Kalia and Shelly was a good way to get their votes? Think again.


32Brendon Villegas - 6th place - Big Brother 12
Basically Kaysar 2.0... Showed his cards way too early both times (mostly with competitions), and got evicted 3 times in 12 months. The only difference between them is Brendon actually made jury.
He basically got evicted, trying to get evicted just to save his "fiance".
He was voted back in in bb13 after getting evicted.

33Rachel Reilly - 9th Place - Big Brother 12, 1st Place - Big Brother 13
Rachel is super annoying and won because she had (insert annoying voice) Bren-dan! Protecting her. Sorry Rachel fans. She is a horrible payer.
So mean and nasty. Only won because of that god awful RIG of a twist that paired people back up and then gave her a Veto comp the producers tailer made for her.
She won just because she's popular with the producers. Every single twist in BB13 was planted just so she should win.
More comments about Rachel Reilly - 9th Place - Big Brother 12, 1st Place - Big Brother 13

34GinaMarie Zimmerman - Big Brother 15
Her comments to Candice before her eviction are awful
She is so crazy over Nick, who was evicted weeks ago, and has a shrine devoted to him. She is also very poor when it comes to strategy, just following Aaryn's commands.
Disgusting, hateful, racist pig. Psychotic AND dumb as a bag of rocks to boot.
More comments about GinaMarie Zimmerman - Big Brother 15

35Lydia Tavera - 7th place - Big Brother 11
She didn't have much game; she was blinded by Jessie the whole time and asked people to vote her out just to be with Jessie.
She is so crazy she act like an animal after the power of veto just because
Jessie was out and she was a sour loser after Jordan took the point of view from
Her

36Mike "Boogie" Mallin - 6th, Winner and 10th place- Big Brother 2, All Stars, and 14
I agree, he really did ride Dr. Will's coat tail. I need someone to let me know what he has done that was great?

bigbrother

He road dr. Wills coat tails

37Joe Arvin - 6th Place - Big Brother 14
The worst player ever in the house all he did was sit and watch the drama. He would always float on Shane because the fact he couldn't do anything good in the house
Oh that phantom headbutt

38Erika Landin - 4th place - Big Brother 4, runner up - Big Brother All Stars

39Natalie Cunial - 5th Place - Big Brother 9
Had the chance to save all of her alliance member's but made a deal with James which ended up getting her 'boyfriend'. And also tried to play both sides of the house, which is the worst game move ever, and then getting betrayed by her alliance member's *facepalm*. Love ya girl, but you really could have used your brain.

40Jen Johnson - 8th Place - Big Brother 8

41Neil Garcia - 15th Place - Big Brother 9

42Helen Kim - 9th Place - Big Brother 15
"It's too soon to get rid of Amanda."

After she was able to get rid of Jeremy in week 2, she was nothing more but a foolish player trapped in Andy's web. Annoying as hell!

43Matt Hoffman - 7th Place - Big Brother 12

44Jenn Arroyo - 5th Place - Big Brother 14
Won the point of view, stupidly used it on Dan, CLAIMED she made a "big move" (yet Dan was the one that really did it for her), then gets taken out by him two weeks later.
Big Move Jenn City! She was mostly there for comic relief and was vacationing. Shes one of the biggest floaters in BB history!

45Jeremy McGuire - 14th Place - Big Brother 15

46Victoria Rafaeli - Big Brother 16
All she says how beautiful she is.
She's giving me floater vibes! Half the time I forget she's even in the house unless she is bitching about girls wearing her bathing suits and headbands.

47Paola Shea - Big Brother 16
All parts of her game suck

48Enzo Palumbo - 3rd Place - Season 12
He was a huge floater

49Janelle Pierzina- 3rd place- Big Brother 6
Good competitor...terrible at strategy. Still don't understand how she was such a fan favorite in BB6. She was so annoying and displayed similar qualities of many other hated HGs in history. Season 7 and 14 she was much better and I was semi a fan of her's. But I disliked her in Season 6 and overall she is a very overrated player in history.
She won a lot of competitions but in season 7 Dr Will could make her do anything he wanted.
She should've known what strategies would've worked for her, but just let everyone tell her what to do, even when it was bad for her. If it weren't for Erika waking her up in the top four in All Stars, Will Kirby would've won Big Brother twice.
More comments about Janelle Pierzina- 3rd place- Big Brother 6

50Will Kirby - Winner - Big Brother 2, 4th place - All Stars
I Just voted for him because he's not even close to being the worst player ever.
He is the best player ever to play the game. When he was nominated he told the house guests that he hated everyone and no one voted against him
I think he is too overrated

51Dan Gheesling - Runner Up - Big Brother 14
He is the second best player to play the game
Haha I just wanted to see his name his amazing
His jury management was awful. He is so overrated, yes his game was flashy. But losing in a 6-1 blowout with no one in the f4 he could beat in the end is not a god-tier game. Also he had three lifelines.

52Mispelling Joshuah - 7th place - Big Brother 9
He basically didn't know what show he was on.
I dislike with a passion so so much

53Jameka Cameron - 4th Place - Big Brother 8
She gave up thousands of dollars, a trip to Barbados, and took MULTIPLE punishments all so that she could win veto to save house guests that weren't in her alliance. Why? Because it was "god's will"... Not to mention she was completely useless in the game.

Comments About This List

Featured Lists
Popular Lists
New Lists

Top Remixes of This List

BladedCrypt

htoutlaws2012

mateonacho13

cambrick1

kormo

see more...

Posts About This List

List Info

This list was created 5 years, 189 days ago and has been voted on over 900 times. This top ten list has been remixed 6 times.

Updated Tuesday, July 22, 2014


List Error Reporting

See an item on this list that's misspelled, duplicated, or doesn't belong? Let us know. Click here to report the error.